Showing posts with label musing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label musing. Show all posts

Sunday, August 19, 2012

Competition in dancing

A friend of mine got upset after a recent dancing competition in which he or she failed to finish in the top three. (Lower placings are not announced on the night.)

I left this comment on his or her blog, which was well received, and as I find the topic interesting I reproduce it here along with an except of the original post.


Original post (excerpted):
When you're being judged, regardless of result, its really hard, excruciatingly hard not to take things personally. So, ultimately in a creative space, being judged is large a contradiction. How do you NOT take things personally? I'm guessing that you need to have enough self resolve, enough worthy self esteem and enough perspective that conditions and subjectivity explains the judgement.

If I don't have a goal, then I'm just messing around. And in this creative field, there certainly is space for faffing about. But my goal was to achieve. To be validated. Which is unfortunate because the nature of competition is to be validated by others. I certainly feel like I got the skills, but do others? Do my peers think the same? They can SAY I got the skills but in my book, it needs to translate. You are good and here is the evidence. Without my goals, I am merely faffing. I don't wanna faff. I wanna succeed. And if I faff about then in an amazingly absolute statement, I don't wanna be a part of it.

There seems to be too much out of my control. There are those who have so much natural talent, effort and time to continue to win and get the box ticked in their favour. Its an equation of variables. Sometimes, you don't have what it takes to win.

So: you competed, and expected validation in the form of a placing; it was not forthcoming. You feel rejected. But what have you failed at?

You have failed at only one thing: convincing the judges that you were one of the three leads who best demonstrated mastery of the criteria by which the event you danced in was assessed.

Succeeding at this task would not have made you "good at dancing". While it is true that it's practically impossible to win a dance event and not be "good at dancing" – which is why it works so well as a validator – it's eminently possible to be "good at (almost all) dancing" and suck at competing. So while I recognise the attraction of competition, I think you should be clear about what role it plays in your dancing.

Most people's goal in dancing is, I posit, to be as good as they can be – or, at least, to be good enough to do X. (X = have fun, dance at 200 bpm, do an aerial, whatever.) Most people don't enter dancing with the goal of being better than anyone else. However, trying to be better than someone else is one of the best ways of improving yourself – that's the point of competition in the swing dancing scene. The goal is not simply to be the best: it is to have become the best by improving. And good on competition for doing that.

I have a competitive personality. Board games, foot-races, mental puzzles, sport – subconsciously, I will want to win, even if I don't enter them with that purpose; and to win, I need to beat other people. For mainly that reason, I don't compete as a swing dancer: my goals as dancer are to be good enough to do X, and I don't want my satisfaction with my dancing to become something that relies on me beating other people. Even if that means I don't improve as quickly as others.

Do I want to be "good at dancing"? Absofuckinglutely. Does it feel awesome to be recognised as such in front of a crowd? Hell yeah. Are competitions the only form of validation? Fuck no. Do people come up to you and complement you on your dancing? Do follows seek you out for dances? Repeatedly? Do people watch you dance; hoot and/or cheer? More importantly, do you feel as though you can express yourself musically through the form of dance? Do you get those moments of 'flow'? Isn't that why you dance?

TL;DR
Competitions are great for making you better dancer, but to win you need to be better than other people. If your goal is to be a better dancer, but you can't handle being worse than other people (even if you're better than you used to be), reconsider competing and/or your attitude.

Monday, June 18, 2012

On being understood

I have a 300-word section on my Facebook in which I describe myself. This is unusual, as far as Facebook profiles I've seen go: most people don't fill the "About Me" section out at all; or if they do, it's perfunctory. When I befriend new people on the site I'll eagerly click through their profile to discover what fascinating mysteries might reveal themselves; as a rule, I am left wanting.

Having recently added a few dancers from my swing performance troupe to my Facebook, the topic of my lengthy profile came up briefly during a dinner. Later, I asked one of my new acquaintances what she thought of my profile: specifically, whether it reflected accurately her impression of me that she'd gleaned from real life. She gave me a considered answer, then asked, quite reasonably, "Why do you want to know?"

An excellent question, to which there are several answers; or, perhaps, an answer in several parts.

The primary answer is this: to be understood. 
People are multifaceted. Each of us has different sides to us, some of which are only revealed in particular circumstances. People who have known me for years in one context can be surprised by other aspects of my life or personality I consider such natural parts of my identity that their surprise baffles me. Things like that I can dance – not just swing dance, but clubbing-style dancing –; that I'm a footballer; that I love The Living End; or that I'm German. 

Reflecting upon these things, I decided to write a profile that would bring somebody familiar with one side of me up to speed with the most important other aspects necessary to understand me: my personality type, sense of humour, hobbies, etc.
Curiously, there's a paragraph in which I write about how I see myself – it's odd, in context, in quite a different tone to the rest. My dancing profile evaluator remarked on it, and as I was able to offer was that I had perhaps written it so that I might understand myself.

The search for understanding as a driver crystalised for me today when I read a piece by Martin McKenzie-Murray, a skilled speech-writer and blogger. 
“You’re born in a cage,” he said, “and you’ll stay in it because there’ll always be a gap between your experiences and the words you have to describe them. More, you’ll only ever be able to occupy one skull—you’ll never completely know what it’s like to think or feel like somebody else. But, you can enlarge that cage by developing ways to communicate and your confidence to do so. That starts with expanding your vocabulary. The strength—and intimacy—of your relationships in life will largely depend upon your ability to express yourself warmly and precisely.” (emphasis mine)

 That'd be it. Well, part of it. For his message had a coda: "It might not matter terribly, because few of us listen anyway."

How much of what I intend to convey arrives? And is the fault mine, or yours?

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Wish one is ALWAYS for more wishes

Last week I went to drinks celebrating the 5th birthday of the Centre for Policy Development, a very cool, creative think tank that sprang out of the policy development the New Matilda magazine was doing; you may remember I've written for NM now and again.

The CPD is run by Miriam Lyons, a fascinating woman well worth listening to, and at the birthday drinks I ended up with conversation with her parents. Lyons' mother, a psychologist, asked me the following question:
"If you had three wishes to change the world to help the environment, but that change had to occur through political processes, what would those wishes be?"

I found the question fascinating, and pondered it for a minute or two. Think about your own answers for a while, if you like. (You know it's a happening party when people stare into the middle distance rubbing their chins thoughtfully for a while.)
My first wish, I decided, was:
  1. Give the environment legal rights.
Once you treat the environment as a legal entity, and give it rights, any dealings with it then have to recognise those rights. Damage to the environment no longer becomes 'free', but instead requires restitution to someone (presumably the government) for infringing these rights. Okay, 'the environment' probably has de facto rights (via the government) in some sense already, and I don't know exactly what my system of rights would look like, but this is magic genie wishing at a party, remember?

I was pretty happy with this answer, and for a while I couldn't think of anything to do with my other two wishes. After a bit of needling from Lyons Senior, I decided that a framework for protecting the environment and some absolute standards probably wasn't enough; I'm protecting the environment for the sake of people, so there should be a relationship to people in my plan. Therefore, my second wish was to:
  1.  Give every person the right to a minimum amount of environmental quality.
'Environmental quality' is obviously fairly fuzzy, but it would cover things like clean air, water, land, biodiversity, etc. There are thousands of indicators of environmental quality, so I'd let my genie loose on that. (Or some applied statistics majors, whatever.)

Having now established a framework of sorts and a mandated supply of environmental quality, my economist brain decided the final piece of the puzzle was obvious: create demand for environmental quality. How, though? Creating demand, especially ingrained demand, is tough – it's often as much cultural as anything else, and creating or changing culture is a barrier I've never been able to surmount. In genie-party-land, however, I was able to get away with:
  1. Create an ingrained (cultural) demand for environmental quality, e.g. through education.
When it comes to affecting (or effecting) culture, I usually throw my hands up and look for a sociologist/psychologist/theologian/whatever to pass the question to; they invariably profess to not know the answer either – and I don't know I'd believe them if they claimed they did! But educating people to value the environment, e.g. through bush walks or family outings, seems to be a fairly effective method. It was certainly a good topic of further conversation.

We asked the same question of another researcher at the CPD, and the differences in our answers was fascinating: her first wish would be to "assassinate some people – clear the decks!" (Lest you get the wrong idea about the CPD, remember this was birthday drinks, and I don't think she took the question quite as seriously as I did.)
I've forgotten her second wish, unfortunately, but her third was to take over a large stake in the media to promote her message: "buy Channel 9", basically.

It's intriguing how differently people approach the question; I think I'll squirrel it away as a conversation starter. You have been warned.

Friday, March 23, 2012

Paying for organ donation

A friend asks: 
I did a piece last year on the economic benefits of paid organ donation schemes. I was just wondering if you had encountered this topic at all. I couldn't find an economic reason to oppose it.


I only just tossed off an answer, but I thought the topic interesting enough to preserve:

I haven't come across any studies of paid organ donation schemes, no.

The biggest economic problem I can think of is that it's paying people to do what 'right' anyway. If that sounds totally non-economisty, let me rephrase it: markets provide an extrinsic incentive, via payment. However, many – most – things also have an intrinsic value: "pride in your work"; "the satisfaction of a job well done"; the respect of others; the comfort of following your morals.* If you focus too strongly on extrinsic motivation – performance-related pay is a good example – you remove intrinsic motivation, and intrinsic motivation is a MUCH stronger force than extrinsic.

So a (possible) problem with paid organ donation schemes, depending on how they're set up, is that you may begin by supplementing your 'free' pool of donations with paid donations, but you end up having to pay everyone as payment becomes the prime motivator for donation.

Better, IMO, are non-monetary schemes to increase intrinsic motivation or overcome barriers to action: make organ donation opt-out, for example, rather than opt it. Marketing, awareness campaigns, stuff like that. Create a culture of giving, rather than a culture of 'pay me to do something good for other people'.

* Interesting side note: happiness studies have found people with strong (not strict; more, 'well-defined') moral codes are likelier to be happy than people with weak or no morals. The speculated reason is that acting in accordance with your morals lets you feel good about yourself (in addition to however good the activity makes you feel), while not having morals mean you get the benefit of the activity.

Monday, January 02, 2012

The fundamental question on asylum seekers

Australia's dog of a policy on asylum seekers – at least, those arriving by boat – appears set to be a continued topic of political discussion this year, so I'd like to echo the sentiments of Guy Rundle as expressed just before Christmas:

The Australian asylum seeker discussion is wrongly framed. As signatories to the Refugee Convention, we have a categorical moral imperative to allow any potential refugees that reach our shores to claim asylum; this is their right.
However, the policy debate revolves around whether we can "wholly negate someone’s rights (that we have explicitly promised them), in a situation where their life and freedom will be wholly annihilated indefinitely, all as a strategy for dissuading unknown future persons from making a possibly perilous journey.

By that definition we are using the 'deterrent' — the people locked up for years on Manus, Nauru, in Malaysia, or god knows where — as a means to a utilitarian end. It is a clear use of human beings in their totality, as means to other ends, and cannot in any sense ground a moral policy."

We are "negating the irreducible moral base with a utilitarian argument based on unknowable contingencies and outcomes that cannot be guaranteed".

Our role should be "to stand up for what we believe to be irreducibly right — right not by emotion, but by well-argued reason from fundamental principles, capable of debate — and seek to repeatedly make those issues clear as they are ceaselessly covered over by, well by notions like 'offshore processing'. Making those issues clear would be done by making clear the fundamental political question that no politician will put — are we going to stay within the Convention, or are we not? Surely anyone who wants an honest debate and decision would want that question to rise to the surface.

Either we stay with the Convention, and honour its obligations – and further obligations that arise from those — or we repudiate it. Putting the question thus is first of all, simply honest — but I suspect it would also make clear to people eager to impose desert prisons etc, exactly what they are repudiating, about themselves as much as anything.

That seems to be the only moral approach of any honest commentator from any side regarding the issue."

Our current discussion is not about how to adhere to our committment: it's about the methods in which we intent to break it. A sad state of affairs.

Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Healthy body, healthy soul

An analogy I just thought of:

Religion is, for me, like some sort of strange diet. Amongst religions / diets, there are some basic concepts that are almost universally regarded as sensible and a good idea, e.g. be kind to other people / don't eat too much. Then there's stuff that's more kooky and probably doesn't have all that great an effect on your health, e.g. don't mix meat and dairy / err, don't mix meat and dairy.

So, if you've got some diet that works, or that you think works, good for you. I may even be interested in the particulars, in order to compare it to other diets I've heard about and decide just; may have an academic interest, if you will. My interest in actually adhering to your odd diet, however, is nil. Zero. Do not want. No interaction desired.

And while I'm ambivalent about people practising their own diet – possibly even broadly supportive, if it contains the generally good ideas alluded to above –, if it affects what I can eat, or your actions are only understandable through the prism of your dietary handbook, then we may have a problem.

[UPDATE]
I was asked why I was an agnostic, rather than an atheist. My answer is that I see no better arguments disproving the existence of a higher being – or higher beings – than I do proving it. Do I think the Flying Spaghetti Monster exists?  In all likelihood, no, but I don't know that it can be definitively ruled out. However, I don't care: I'm not really interested in knowing the answer to that question.

There's a quote from a well-known philosopher – paraphrased, because I've forgotten his name and my Google-fu is weak; assistance appreciated – that appeals to me: if proof of the (non-)existence of God would change the way your live your life, then God is important to you.
Perhaps I'm kidding myself when I think that I wouldn't change my life if I could know that God existed, but it's how I justify my indifference to the question: it's not important to me.

Friday, December 16, 2011

Seeking aspiration

I have been thinking, recently, about doing a PhD. It's an option I've considered in the past, and one I deliberately kept open by taking my current job as a research assistant (RA).
I hadn't given the idea much thought since I began working here, though. To start with, I was just happy to have sorted my short-term future out and, after moving Germany → Melbourne → Sydney in a little over 6 months, didn't want to face the effort of thinking beyond the next 1-2 years. The RA job is very enjoyable, and so I managed to defer or deflect any serious consideration of what comes next until a few weeks ago.

What happened was that one of my centre's directors came to town, after having been in Europe since before I even started working here; we've been doing all our work together through email and Skype. Coincident with her visit is our annual conference and a whole range of annual review processes, both for the centre and at an individual level. So not only do I find myself now having lunchtime conversations about where I'm thinking of going in the next few years, I now also have to fill out my first formal annual review (!)

The whole thing has necessitated actually, seriously thinking about what I want to do over the next few years, which is something I've been quite content to avoid.
*sigh*

So, Martin, what's your five-year plan? Are you going to do a PhD?

Well, until a few weeks ago I was leaning toward "no". Having several friends who have done/are doing a PhD, I had set myself the hurdle that I wouldn't commit to doing one unless I had a topic that really excited me; that I just had to find the answer to; that I could definitely see myself focussing on for three years. This level of motivation is probably the most important aspect of a PhD, as far as I've been able to ascertain, as if you don't have good reasons for submitting yourself to years of low income, long hours, hard work, stress, and an incredibly small audience of people who care, you'll have a difficult time getting through it.

The problem was that I hadn't found such a topic.I'd found lots of topics that were cool, and that I enjoyed spending a few months, even half a year on. But usually I had something else going on on the side, so it wasn't just tunnel vision. Spending three years on just one thing? I hadn't found that thing yet.

That was until I sat down with my newly-arrived director for lunch, and we talked about the possibility of doing a three-paper PhD: I could do, say, a thesis on "Methods of Policy Evaluation", comprising one paper on econometric analysis of a policy – say, the EU ETS; I've been cleaning up a dataset there that could be quite useful –; one paper on a field experiment to test the effects of a particular policy design; and one paper on running a prediction market* for policy-relevant outcomes.
(* a prediction market, also called an informational aggregation market, is an attempt to get people to reveal their information (or beliefs) about an outcome by rewarding them if they make correct prediction. It's similar to betting, in that you get people to express an opinion and back it up with money, except that the goal of the prediction market operator is not necessarily to make money but to reveal information, i.e. make predictions. It's already used in a few settings, e.g. "Who will run against Obama in the next US election?", or "Will we get nuclear fusion running before the end of 2014?".)

Now here was something that got me a little excited! Prediction markets aren't something I know a great deal about, but they seem totally cool. And running a field experiment would be totally cool, too! That these are both methodologies, not topics, might be a slight problem, however; I can't rely on enthusiasm for methodology alone (especially enthusiasm about what I imagine a methodology to be like) for three years.

The topic, then, broadly speaking, was "policy analysis". Do I love policy analysis? Well... I'd like to be the kind of person who loves policy analysis, so it'd be a case of using my actions to shape my attitudes. That's not optimal, but I'm okay with that; at some point you have to step up and be the person you aspire to be, and not the person you're comfortable being.

That last point is an important one: in the recent past I have certainly felt as though I've been someone I was comfortable being, not someone I aspired to be. Not that I'm unhappy with myself – I have a interesting job I enjoy, in which I learn about and contribute to topics that I think are important; I lead a healthy, active, and environmentally conscious lifestyle; and I earn more than most Australians. (Alright, no girlfriend, but if that's my biggest problem I won't complain too loudly.)

But I'm not getting more awesome as quickly as I used to, and that's mainly because I've stopped pushing myself. A PhD would be definitely be pushing myself, which is a point in its favour. I'd also get to go to cool conferences, earn that marvellous "Doctor" title, and have achieved something in my chosen field.
On the down-side, I'd learn much less money, put myself through a lot of stress, and have to stay in Sydney another four years.

That last one's a big one. I miss Melbourne, and I'd only complete my PhD by the time I'm 32-33. And even though I don't have particularly firm life plans, being 33 and still a student is not an appealing prospect. In fact, up until that thought went through my head – you'll be 33 and have just finished being a povo student – my mind was pretty much in the groove of figuring out how to do a PhD; the topic/s, supervisor/s, scholarships, admission processes, etc. I'd even gotten so far as to write all this planning down on the annual review forms I sent to my directors before our meeting.

For some reason, that consideration was a catalyst, and the night before my review I decided I wasn't going to do a PhD. And I felt absolutely fine about it. I hadn't figured out what I was going to do in any detail, but that the decision not to do a PhD felt so good was a clear indication it was the correct choice. You can only talk yourself into so much.

So, the next morning I walked into the review meeting, sat down, and told my directors things had changed a little since yesterday arvo and I should probably re-write that whole "future plans" section. They took it quite well, I thought.

What am I going to do now? For the moment, exactly what I've been doing. I love the mix of research and policy I'm doing now, especially with the freedom to involve myself in public debate (even if only at low levels). I really just want to keep doing this as long as possible (well, for another year at least) to gather experience before moving to something in the same area. I have some things in mind (some vague, some more concrete), but this post has already dragged on long enough.

In a nutshell: not doing PhD; keeping on doing what I'm doing; and feeling pretty good about it.

Friday, September 30, 2011

Just in passing...

Scenario A
You ring your bell before you cycle past people: they freak out.

Scenario B
You cycle past people without ringing: they freak out.
You can't win. But, at least in B, you're past them by the time they start in unexpected directions.

Thursday, September 08, 2011

In the heat of the moment

I bought a new toaster yesterday.

This might seem unremarkable, until one considers that I had already bought a toaster when I moved into my apartment, and this original toaster functions as well now as it did when I bought it, then.

That first toaster seemed like a canny purchase at the time. It was a Sunbeam – a well-known brand – in good condition, with pleasant lines and clean, unmarked white plastic in which the controls sat well. I bought it second-hand, from a chap whose new 4-slice stainless steel appliance seemed to justify the sale of his 2-slice model for the low low sum of $5. Ever wary, I asked to plug my prospective toaster in, and inspected it critically as it heated. No smoke, no smells, no sparks; good.

Heating, though, is only a portion of what a toaster has to do. It also, at some point, has to stop.

Stopping is what my old toaster doesn't do. Like a demented Duracell bunny intent on producing charcoal it keeps going, and going, and going. This is... sub-optimal – but for the sake of $5 I wasn't going to chase the seller down and demand a refund. Besides – I didn't toast that often; when I did, I could just monitor the bread and halt the process manually, right?

I could, and I did. And it was irritating. And sometimes I forgot, and would be prompted only by the smell of smoke, and would stand over the sink scraping black particles off my toast until it was edible again. Edible, but cold.

When I went to the supermarket, I would inspect the toasters on offer there. Not the best of appliances, certainly, but ones, I imagined, that would be able to stop, as well as start. The cheapest was $15, and often I paused on my path to (more often than not) the chocolate aisle, pondering: was it worth the price? It never seemed like it. $15, just to automate pressing the "stop" button? Monitoring my toaster wasn't really that big a deal, was it? And I could do a lot with $15 – buy 15 chocolate bars, for example. Never mind that I'd do so anyway...

So I never upgraded my toaster. I explained to guests that they need watch their toast, but they'd forget, and we'd chuckle; "Oh, I did tell you!"  The first time, we'd chuckle. Later, not so much.

I asked an engineer about fixing it: more trouble that it's worth, he said. Just buy a new one – but I couldn't.

Yesterday, I bought a toaster. It cost me $7 dollars, on special. It's a beastly, ugly thing, with small, mean buttons and flimsy components. It has no features I desire beyond being able to heat and stop independently; no high lift feature, bun warming rack, or slice centring. It could well be from the 1970s, this new toaster of mine.


I was in the supermarket again today, buying cream and beer. (Don't ask.) Another toaster was on special: burnished aluminium, fully featured, $17.50 – down from $35. I picked it up. I put it down. I walked away. I came back. I stood there for minutes.

In the end I bought a kettle.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

"Paid leave" is simply salary smoothing

I've mentioned on this blog before that I, though I thoroughly enjoy work, I also value my free time quite highly, and for years have told myself I'd be the sort of person who would try and get more vacation days instead of more pay, necessarily. A few more idle thoughts on the topic came to me this afternoon:

Under current employment law (presumably for most of the western world), it's possible to have a high nominal salary and little leave but to essentially "buy" more time off by taking unpaid leave. This, however, depends on your employer approving said leave; depending on your employer, this could be difficult.

What if, in your employment contract, you stipulated the right to unpaid leave? One or two weeks per year, say – the idea would be to make it as close to paid leave in treatment as possible, except without actually receiving any money. (Perhaps make it non-accruing between years would make it easier for employers to accept, too.)

The thrust of my idea is to make the concept of unpaid leave more palatable; at the moment I still get the sense that many people (both employers and employees) treat it as something to be avoided, or at least a far worse alternative than paid leave.

That whole thinking is wrong-headed though, to me. Look at it this way: if you're earning a salary of, say, $72'000 per year with four weeks paid leave, what you are actually doing is selling 48 weeks of work to your employer for $1'500 a week, but your employer is spreading that $72'000 out over 52 weeks instead of 48. The exact same effect could be achieve if you had a nominal annual salary of $78'000 with no paid leave (so still at $1,500 per week), and took four weeks of unpaid leave.

The point: You're not actually being paid to take a holiday; "paid leave" is just unpaid leave with salary payment smoothing.

But let's come back to my right to unpaid leave idea: one of the reasons "paid" leave accrues is that it's generally recognised and accepted that people can't just work all year – they need some time off for recovery. If an employee doesn't take leave, eventually the paid leave they accrue becomes such a liability on their employer's books that they can be forced (or at least strongly encouraged) to take that leave. (SAP did this during the great crash/global financial crisis in 2008, as I'm sure did many other companies.) So paid leave is, in a sense, the "minimum" amount of rest you want an employee to have. (This is obviously an incomplete treatment, but never mind.)

Unpaid leave, on the other hand, is an option. You can take it, but you don't have to. You can choose to earn money, or you can choose to receive (or, rather, not sell) your time. So, while increasing the amount of paid leave in my contract would increase the minimum level of time off I should take, giving me the right (but not obligation) to unpaid leave would let me choose whether to work or not, and – this is the important bit – make it easier to get that unpaid leave approved.

Ever the economist, I figured out what salary reduction you (should) take into account for this unpaid leave (based on my reasoning, above):
Salary reduction = (new leave – old leave) * (old salary / [one year - old leave])
If and when I get the chance to test my thinking out in contract negotiations, I'll let you know the result :-)

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

My favourite (wonk) things

For reasons of which I'm not entirely sure, I came up with this little verse yesterday:


Resource rent taxes, emissions reduction;
Sovereign wealth funds, NBN construction;
Henry's review, letting refugees in;
These are few of my favourite things.

More public transport and Oz: The Republic;
Welfare for jobless not middle-class yuppies;
Euthanasia and plain cigs packaging;
These are few of my favourite things.

When the polls bite, when lobbies sting, when I’m feeling sad;
I’ll simply go on Q&A or Lateline, then I won’t feel so bad.


My mate Wes then suggested we form The Australian Moderate Party ("The Mods" for short) and enter politics. The advertisement campaigns virtually right themselves.

Monday, February 21, 2011

Buying your way backstage

Several times when I've bought tickets to concerts recently, I've noticed that the bands offer "Meet and Greet" packages; these usually cost ~$50 more than just admission to the concert (which is itself ~$50), and get you:
  • Entry to the show via name on doorlist, rather than a ticket
  • Personal Meet and Greet with $_BAND
  • 2 items signed
  • Souvenir tour laminate
  • Official tour poster
  • Priority Entry
From an economist's perspective, this is a fairly sensible idea: the people who will want these things – colloquially "hardcore" fans – have an increased willingness to pay relative to the rest of the public, and insituting a tiered pricing system is an excellent way for the band to capture more of this willingness to pay in the form of money.

Previously, of course, fans used to get this sort of stuff by hanging around after the show long enough and/or getting to know the band manager/touring crew well enough to cajole their way back stage. This is the way I've done it with, for example, The Living End. It's an investment – sometimes a significant one; ask me about TLE's German tour some time – but it's an investment of time and effort, rather than money.

What does the band get out of that? Not much: at the end of the day, they're still talking to plebs, signing shit, and smiling wanly into a parade of cameras. Especially for touring bands, who may only visit a country once every few years, selling this time may be worth more than developing a dedicated and loyal fanbase of the sort engendered by repeated access on the basis of effort.

As a music fan, of course, the practise disgusts me. It feels mercenary, and the "cred" of backstage access loses a lot of its value (for me) when earned with money, rather than time. My economist brain tells me that this is silly: like actors who request money for photographs or autographs when appearing at conventions, someone is simply using a price to adjust the relationship between (fixed) supply and (limited, but still vastly larger) demand.

I don't want to claim that all bands that do this are mercenary: recently I hung out, post-show, with (part of) a band that sold these "VIP" tickets. How? The old-fashioned way: I hung around long enough and got to know the right people.

(For the record, The Living End do not do this sort of shit: most of the time they'll come out after shows – regardless of what country they're in – sign stuff, pose for photographs, and have a chat. Sure, they won't invite you backstage – but hey, they're working! It's often not that exciting backstage, anyway. Seriously, what are these touring bands offering? Card games with the bands? Pre-show pep talk? For $50, I'd want a decent feed and maybe a back massage.)

Sunday, February 13, 2011

The eyes have it

I've been fiddling around with recent photographs (headshots) taken of me, and, comparing them to an set taken back in November of 2009, I was struck by how very different they appeared. Though all that's really changed between then and now is my hairstyle, the difference in lighting makes me appear – I think – almost a different person.
I have exactly the same expression, almost exactly the same pose, the same hint of stubble, and I've lightened the background of the recent photo (on the right) to make the comparison easier. (I stopped short of colouring the shirts the same.) Yet, at first glance, I still think they are different people. Only when I look a little longer do I notice the similarities.

Maybe it's because I don't spend much time looking at myself? I'm not so convinced by that. Possibly it's the eyes: the difference between the quite dark pupils irises in the left shot and the light blue pupils irises in the right is stark.

Below is the end of my fiddling, at any rate. I've done little more than crop and blur the background a little (which I did with not a little irony, as this was the only photo of many that the photographer – a colleague of mine – managed to take in focus.)

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Donating for them, or for yourself?

Accompanying the Twitter commentary of the Queensland floods (see #QLDfloods) I've noticed a number of people writing that they'll donate $1 every time their message gets "retweeted" (RTed; forwarded, in Twitter, parlance). The first message I saw was from @lilithia. I can't say for certain whether she started the trend, and once I started looking I found several others – e.g. @AUSteambieberr, @bree_101, @xander85 –, but they all seemed to share two initial characteristics:
  • These were ordinary people
  • The donations were uncapped
The second point, especially, struck me: late last year Daniel Keogh, a science presenter on the ABC, promised to donate $5 to beyondblue(1) for every time he was retweeted (until 10pm), but his offer took off and he ended up with a nominal figure of over $17,000 dollars. That was far above Keogh's self-imposed limit, but he ended up donating $5000 and the story made it into the papers.

Evidently not the papers lilithia et al. read, though, as the same thing happened to them and they started imposing limits: first $250, then $500. The trouble with RTs, though, is that often very few people follow the original poster, and retractions/corrections/clarifications are rarely retweeted as much or as quickly as the original message. Thus, even though lilithia reached her limit last night, her tweet was still making the rounds this morning. And as the original tweet contained no limits, some people got a bit narky when they found out the original authors wouldn't be donating any further.

My motivation for writing this post, however, is to wonder why people would take this route to donation. Stepwise:
  1. You have a desire to help victims of a natural disaster, so you give money to charity.
  2. If this were your only desire – i.e. you were motivated purely by altruism – you would just give the money to charity and be done with it.
  3. You may, however, also wish to raise public awareness of the issue to encourage other donations (encouraging altruism in others) and/or
  4. You may wish to garner positive reputational benefits (respect, admiration, whatever) by publicising your actions.
Now, Point 4 may not sit well with some people – if you were truly concerned about the plight of these flood victims, why would you sully that by playing your actions up for personal (reputational) gain? That's a can of worms, though, which I will try to avoid by claiming that I don't believe most of these people were coldly calculating enough to think "Well, I'm prepared to donate $X – how can I go about maximising my return on that."; I simply just don't believe their thought processes extended that far. More interesting, I think, is a fifth point:
  1. By opening your decision-making process up to public input, you are (involuntarily?) exposing yourself to peer pressure to donate more than you intended.
This requires some sort of assumption of bounded rationality, I think; a type of rationality that hasn't gone explicitly through points 1–4, or wondered what they'd do if their limit wasn't reached (would they then donate less to flood victims simply because too few people forwarded their message? That seems callous.)  By giving others the impression that they have an influence over your actions, you raise in them the expectation that you will respond to their exertion of that influence and, if only to avoid backlash (loss of reputational benefits), you might be prompted, in fact, to act beyond what you had previously decided: see lilithia donating $500 instead of $250, or Daniel Keogh donating $5000. (I don't know what he was intending to donate originally, but I suspect it was less than that.)

Penultimately, as I said in my opening, this type of "I'll donate money for every RT" message did spread; it is quite possible that it has spurred people to donate by giving them benefits above and beyond the altruistic ones. So, if being able to get a bit of recognition on a social network encourage more people to give than otherwise would have (or to give more than they would otherwise have given), I guess that's not such a bad thing.(2)

Finally, go donate. Queensland floods if you like, but I would suggest Pakistan: they need US$20 billion for their reconstruction effort, and are worse off than is Australia.

(1) An organisation against depression.
(2) There is, in fact, fascinating literature on the motivation behind charitable giving and how to maximise it.

[UPDATE]
Peter Brent has a slightly related post at his Mumble blog on why the plight of middle Australia evinces more empathy than the (more serious) plight of others.

Monday, November 22, 2010

Pulling carbon offset figures out of the air

I just booked flights down to Melbourne over Christmas with Jetstar – why Jetstar? Their price beat guarantee: tough to find on their website, but if you find a cheaper flight within an hour of one of theirs, they'll sell you their flight for 10% cheaper than whatever the competition is offering. Proviso: you must book by phone (1300 369 516)

Anyway, I booked my flights, and asked whether Jetstar offered the opportunity to purchase carbon offsets. The answer was, "Yes – sort of. Only if you fly between Sydney and Melbourne-Avalon, but not between Sydney and Melbourne-Tullamarine."  (For those playing at home: Tullamarine is the airport closest to the city, while Avalon could be more correctly described as being in Geelong; it's the Frankfurt-Hahn of Victoria.)  So, disappointingly (and curiously), I couldn't purchase any carbon offsets.

The price, however, had I been able to buy them, was ridiculously low: AU$0.70 per flight. Seventy cents! You couldn't buy a pack of gum for 70c, but you can offset flying 700km for that amount? That doesn't seem right.
Now, Carbon Planet estimate the emissions from a flight of this distance at 0.3 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent gasses (0.3 tCO2e), and Climate Spectator has today's spot price of 1 tCO2e at >AU$20 on the European market and >AU$15 tCO2e on the New Zealand(1) market. So, realistically, offsetting my 0.3 tonnes of CO2e emissions should cost at least AU$5 – indeed, Carbon Planet offers me the opportunity to purchase the offsets for AU$7.50 (each way).

That means that Jetstar either has a carbon offset scheme 10 times more cost-effective than Carbon Planet (and most of Europe), or they're engaging in a bit of greenwashing. Alternatively, Carbon Planet's figures are wrong: QANTAS' carbon calculator puts the emissions for a SYD/MEL flight at 0.108 tCO2e – fully 2/3rd lower. If that were realistic, it would put the market abatement cost at ~AU$1.50 (buying the offset from New Zealand.) QANTAS, who own Jetstar, offer the 0.108 tCO2e offset for AU$1.025. That's comparable with Virgin Blue, who offer an offset for the same route for AU$1.09.

So what does that tell us? Since QANTAS owns Jetstar, we can virtually discount them having carbon offset schemes that cost different amounts – but Jetstar offers offsets for the same route for less than its parent company, which implies that it's emitting less CO2e. If Jetstar's fleet of smaller aircraft is more efficient that QANTAS', that might be possible. However, Virgin Blue operates aircraft of a similar class to Jetstar, and its carbon offset is fully 55% more expensive. And all the airlines offer offsets (and presumably abatement) at less than the market value under international carbon trading schemes, and have stated emissions less than Carbon Planet. 

As so often, that probably comes down to the methodology used to measure emissions: Carbon Planet calculates 0.3 tCO2e for 700 km of air travel, while the ABC's "Carbon Cops" estimates 0.127 tCO2e, and Carbon Neutral tells you it's 0.24 tCO2e. 
What makes the difference? Future Climate has the answer: if you calculating just the impact from burning fuel, you get emissions of 0.13 tCO2e; take all the impacts associated with flight travel into account, however, and you get emissions of 0.26 tCO2e.

Now, without knowing how "All impacts associated with flight travel" are calculated I don't want to give that method my seal of approval – but I can confidently say that just measuring running costs isn't the best way of accounting for the actual environmental impacts of an action. Taken in combination with the vast difference between the apparent abatement costs for our airlines and the cost of carbon internationally (and this is with an Australian dollar at record highs; 12 months ago the gulf would have been even wider!), I am very, very sceptical of the efficacy of these carbon offsets.

On the other hand, if airlines really can undertake carbon abatement at nothing to fear from an emissions trading scheme in Australia ;-)

(1) As an aside: my spellchecker doesn't recognise "New Zealand" – ouch.

Saturday, August 28, 2010

Death of a Salesman('s Intelligence)

My family went to have its picture taken a few weeks ago, in an experience that left me altogether doubting the photographer's rationality. It wasn't the photographs themselves – he was clearly skilled in that respect –, but the way he sold them to us that frustrated me.

The photographer took perhaps 60 shots, from which we were then able to select one or several to be displayed in a framed montage. This main item alone cost several thousand dollars (depending on size), but, to sweeten the deal, the guy threw in a few smaller copies of different photographs; reasonably textbook marketing there. Finally, once we'd selected the handful of photographs we wanted, the photographer offered us a "first run" edition of all the photographs for around $300. "First run" is his clever way of saying "I'm not going to bother touching these up", and revealing this offer at the end of the process, when one has spent an hour agonizing over which pictures to keep and which to cull, lets the customer insure against their "What if I made the wrong choice?" fears for a comparatively low sum (given that one has already committed to paying a few months wages(1)). He compounds these fears and induces a sense of urgency by saying that he doesn't store the photos he's taken on his computer, but that he deletes them once we're done. 
In case we were already expenditure-weary, he outlined all the things we could do with this complete set – scan them, email them to friends and family, give them to loved ones. Here's where I made the following offer: how about we pay the same price for this set, but he gives them to us in electronic format. 

"Easiest money he's ever made", I thought.He has the files on his computer, and, instead of printing them out (for a marginal cost of whatever), he burns them onto a CD/DVD (marginal cost: <$1) and sells us that. For the same price – I mean, that's a no-brainer, right?

He refused.
I couldn't believe it. He knows we're going to scan these photos – he's practically counting on it. The images are going to go electronic format on his computer, to physical form, and then to electronic format on my computer – but, in the meantime, I've had to invest my time in scanning the bloody things, and the results aren't as good as the original.

I don't understand it! Nobody wins from this. Perhaps my benefits in getting the photos on a disc outweigh his benefits; but that only suggests that he should seek some of my surplus. Differential pricing is hardly new here:  the last time I had passport photos taken, I had the choice between 8€ for the physical photos or 15€ for the electronic copy, in what amounts to pretty much the exact same situation. I thus asked our photographer if we could get the "first run" set electronically if we paid more than for the physical set. Still no. We "wouldn't be able to open the RAW formatted files", he said. "Pig's arse!", we thought (never mind the fact that he sent the pictures to the printer as JPGs, as the filenames on the back reveal). If it was the image quality he was worried about (though I struggle to find a rational explanation for that), he could always run a batch process over the set and sell them to us at whatever quality he felt appropriate.

This is possibly amplified because I'm an economist, but the photographer's behaviour in this issue is the most blantantly stupid conduct I have ever experienced in a salesman.

(1) My father, an engineer, rounds numbers to the closest relevant figure; anything with more than one decimal place is treated with significant scepticism. "2.96%? That's 3%. What do I care about 0.04%?"  The prices for the main picture were all  $5 off a round figure – a relatively basic marketing trick. When my father rounded the price off (up), the photographer specifically and repeatedly asked him/us not to do so: "Please don't say that. I don't want you to say that. Say 'X-thousand, ninehundred and ninety five dollars'. Say it with me." His persistence when we refused was astonishing.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Second-hand markets for used games

There's a bit of discussion over at Penny Arcade on the practice of buying used games rather than new ones – views apparently range from "It's basically piracy" to "It's legal, why should I care if the developers don't get my money?"

Here's my contribution:
Hey Gabe,

I’m an economist as well as a gamer, so a few thoughts from that direction: while a second-hand game purchase doesn’t directly benefit developers, it’s not a 1:1 decrease in sales – I might purchase more new games if I know that I can sell them later (like buying a new car every 10 years when the old one is still drive-able), and/or use the money used from selling old games to buy new games. Cheapskates who wait for used games probably wouldn’t buy new games, anyway – they’re paying with their time (waiting for games to appear on the second-hand market) rather than money. Second-hand games also increase exposure in younger/poorer audiences that later, when they have the money, can go out and buy new original games.

Basically, second-hand are markets are not at all unique to gaming – practically every physical product has one (ebay, craigslist, etc), and those producers have learnt to cope (e.g. planned obsolescence).

I note that these effects don’t apply to piracy, though.

/Martin

I forgot to mention that there's obviously a key difference between video games and most physical products in the sense that games don't degrade in quality nearly as quickly – however, off-setting that, video games have a strong "state of the art" component that reduces over time.

This was all just off the top of my head, but interested parties can check out further reading here.

Monday, August 16, 2010

Dick Smith's population puzzle: a Q&A

Whadaya reckon about this whole Dick Smith $1m prize thing? He seems to be after a practical strategy for decoupling economic and physical growth. It's not like people haven't been thinking about that already. What are your thoughts?



I see three questions:
 1) Do I agree with Smith's premise?
 2) Do I agree with his goal?
 3) Do I agree with his methodology of achieving that goal?

1) Premise
Based on his letter (I didn't watch his TV shows), Smith has clearly linked "population" to "environmental degradation". That, by itself, is an incomplete equation: what's important is not just the number of people, but how each of them behaves i.e. how much "environment" they consume.
That most of the worldwide debate has been about changing how people act is, I suspect, less to do with any ignorance of the factor "population" than the knowledge that it's much easier to convince a family of four to consume less than it is to convince them to stop at one child (at least in most societies); we're simply focussing on the solution that appears easiest to implement.
This, I think, is the key point: yes, the number of people is a problem – but it's only a part of the problem, and it may be much more difficult (or even unnecessary) to change this part than to focus on other causes.

2) Goal
For the sake of argument, though, let's assume that changing our consumptive behaviour won't be enough (if that's not true now, it may well be in the future), and we need to change the number of people we "generate" as well. That requires either a big cultural shift (bottom-up change) or lots of enforcement (top-down change). China and some other states can do autocratic change; we can't.
So, cultural reproductive change (to complement our lifestyle change in consumption) – how does one best go about achieving that?

3) Methodology
This is where I'm as ignorant as the next guy (unless the next guy is Hari Seldon) – how do you go about manipulating society? In general, I guess you have to get the idea "out there"; create awareness. In that sense, a TV show seems like a good idea. Whether it's better than a thoughtful book, a few opinion pieces in the paper and some radio interviews, I can't say. But I'm pretty certain Smith is doing more good than harm, since this prize thing means the issue should float around in public consciousness for a while.
Note that I've completely ignored the fact that the prize is to be awarded for "something"; an invention or scheme or whatnot. Unless I'm wrong in my thinking that our reproductive behaviour is primarily due to culture (having passed the point of requiring children to provide for us in our old age [provide, not care]), any winning entry that doesn't change culture is pointless.

4) Verdict
If one wants to be generous, one could say that Dick Smith is a long-term thinker concerned about sustainability who is trying to sow the seeds for a cultural shift in our attitude towards reproduction. Perhaps he's even thought, "Oh – I'm not sure how best to change societal thinking; perhaps creating a prize will encourage people to come with ideas."
However – and this is where I pull my economist hat down firmly over my ears – is this the best way to spend this one million dollars? I freely admit I don't know much about changing cultural mores, but I'll bet you buttons to bootstraps that any solution we come up with will be harder to spread to the rest of the world than one that changes (the impact of) our consumptive behaviour – and spread these solutions to the world we must, because Australia doesn't have enough proportion of the world's population that changing culture here alone will make a big difference. Could Smith achieve more for (global) sustainability by investing his money to develop and/or spread (existing) changes to our consumptive lifestyle? I suspect so. But then, he probably wouldn't get as much publicity for that...

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Louis Armstrong for the Youff

This popped into my head, and I'm so taken by it that I'm posting it everywhere :-)

I see peeps fist-bumping, saying "Yo! 'sup, foo'?". They're really saying "I ♥ u."

Friday, August 06, 2010

Countering some poor arguments for a mining tax

I was recently asked by Xavier Shay (blog, twitter) to comment on an article in The Age by Michael Gilding, entitled "More tax dollars and less mining? That's a win-win situation". Here is my response: 

Short version: Gilding identifies several problems for which a reduction in mining – though it might help – is the wrong solution.
Longer, point by point version:

Gilding's first argument, that "mining sucks oxygen (capital investment) from the rest of the economy", is one I can't support. The reason is that a basic tenet of economics is that people (the market) make their own best decisions – in this case, investing in mining rather than, say, toll roads. The first rule of taxation is therefore that it distorts private decision-making as little as possible, which makes justifying a mining tax on the grounds that it distorts decisions problematic. (The RSPT, I note, was lauded precisely for NOT distorting investment decisions.)

There is a notable exception to this non-distorting policy: when the social costs/benefits are not adequately reflected by the monetary costs/benefits. That's why we have extra taxes on cigarettes – the "costs" they impose are less than the untaxed price a market sets on them. Similarly, education provides (societal) benefits far in excess of what it costs to deliver, and is therefore subsidised.

Now, Gilding argues that capital that goes to mining could instead go to "innovative technologies or creative industries", like solar power. Well, yes, but it could also go to building apartment buildings, shopping centres, car manufacturing plants, coal power stations, wharves, or toll roads. I am open to the idea of stimulating innovative and creative industries (and solar power), but reducing capital investment in mining is a silly way of doing it.


Gilding's second argument is about the effects that mining exports have on the Australian dollar. It is true that a higher Australian dollar reduces our (quantity of) exports. Gilding expresses the commonly held view that exports are better than imports, and we should increase our net exports. In the first point, I am agnostic: exports are like saving, imports are like borrowing. As long as I'm in balance over time, there is no intrinsic "better" or "worse". I have more sympathy for the second point – that we should increase our net exports at this point in time –, as we have reasonably high levels of private foreign debt that really should be addressed. However, the proposed mechanism is, again, rubbish: if we wanted to increase our exports by devaluing the Australian dollar (by reducing mining production), why not just do as the Chinese do and go back to a pegged currency? Oh, that's right – decades of economic and political doctrine advocating the contrary.
In short: making one industry less competitive (mining) does not make other industries (cars) more competitive.


Gilding's third argument is about the difficulty in managing a two-speed economy. That difficulty absolutely exists, and skimming profits off high-performing industries to help (through reform, not subsidies!) low-performing industries is good economic management. But why is mining unique is this regard? There are other industries in Australia whose return on investment is just as high (in percentile terms), and taking "super profits" from one high-performing industry while ignoring others is inequitable, unfair, and distortionary policy. (An economy wide super-profits tax – essentially progressive company taxes, as we have on income – is certainly an interesting idea, but not one that's within a coo-ee of public debate. I don't even know how theoretically valid it is.)
No, the rationale for the extra tax on mining was: 1) natural resources are non-renewable; and 2) natural resources are pubic assets. That the revenue then be used to reform the rest of the economy – yes, absolutely! Using that RSPT/MRRT/$ACRONYM revenue for anything other than infrastructure and/or business investment would be awful, short-sighted policy.


There is a fourth argument in Gilding's piece, though he barely touches on it: "[M]inerals are not going to go anywhere. In fact, it might be prudent to leave some of those minerals in the ground for future generations of Australians." This is a rather tricky issue of inter-temporal profit maximisation – is it better to sell something now or later? Just imagine you have a bar of gold sitting at home – when you do you sell it? All now, all later, bits and pieces over time (let's assume you can separate it into discrete portions easily)? The answer depends on when you think you'll need money over your lifetime, your expectations of the development of the value of gold, and your expectations of the development of the value of alternative investments. Maybe, in 50 years, gold can be cheaply synthesised and will become very cheap. Maybe it will be discovered to be a key ingredient in life-prolonging elixirs and will sky-rocket in value. Maybe you have a high preference for getting a return on your gold in the next 10 years and don't care about anything else. (How long does a CEO typically stay at a company?) But, certainly, it's a very complex topic.

Actually, I lie – Gilding does touch on the topic again, in his summary: "Mining is robbing future generations of natural resources." Where is our future generations' "right" to natural resources? Would they be just as happy with the proceeds of alternative investments funded by selling those resources? Huge, thorny topic; barely scratched in the article.