Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Healthy body, healthy soul

An analogy I just thought of:

Religion is, for me, like some sort of strange diet. Amongst religions / diets, there are some basic concepts that are almost universally regarded as sensible and a good idea, e.g. be kind to other people / don't eat too much. Then there's stuff that's more kooky and probably doesn't have all that great an effect on your health, e.g. don't mix meat and dairy / err, don't mix meat and dairy.

So, if you've got some diet that works, or that you think works, good for you. I may even be interested in the particulars, in order to compare it to other diets I've heard about and decide just; may have an academic interest, if you will. My interest in actually adhering to your odd diet, however, is nil. Zero. Do not want. No interaction desired.

And while I'm ambivalent about people practising their own diet – possibly even broadly supportive, if it contains the generally good ideas alluded to above –, if it affects what I can eat, or your actions are only understandable through the prism of your dietary handbook, then we may have a problem.

[UPDATE]
I was asked why I was an agnostic, rather than an atheist. My answer is that I see no better arguments disproving the existence of a higher being – or higher beings – than I do proving it. Do I think the Flying Spaghetti Monster exists?  In all likelihood, no, but I don't know that it can be definitively ruled out. However, I don't care: I'm not really interested in knowing the answer to that question.

There's a quote from a well-known philosopher – paraphrased, because I've forgotten his name and my Google-fu is weak; assistance appreciated – that appeals to me: if proof of the (non-)existence of God would change the way your live your life, then God is important to you.
Perhaps I'm kidding myself when I think that I wouldn't change my life if I could know that God existed, but it's how I justify my indifference to the question: it's not important to me.

No comments: