Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Climate change is about risk

So I'm working on a "robust policy mix" for climate change (more on that later... perhaps), but in the course of my research I've come across a nice little paragraph that, in my opinion, is a wonderful starting point for thinking about climate change:
[O]ur work suggests that climate change ought to be viewed more as a contingency problem than an optimization problem. Either society will have to make very large reductions in greenhouse-gas emissions over the course of the next century, or it will not. Since society does not yet know which future will happen, it needs to prepare for both. Thus, the most important near-term goals of climate-change policy may be to: (i) reach consensus on the observations that will indicate a need for drastic action to curtail greenhouse-gas emissions, (ii) take actions that will make large future reductions more feasible and less costly if, in fact, they are needed, and (iii) do this in such a way as to avoid over-allocating resources to a problem that turns out to be minor or preparing insufficiently for what we discover is an emerging catastrophe.
Source: Lempert & Schlesinger (2000) "Robust Strategies for Abating Climate Change" in Climatic Change Volume 45, Numbers 3-4, p. 395

The next time you hear something about climate change (more so in Australia than in Europe), take note of the mental model framing the argument – or, rather, the lack of it. This paper is 10 years old, yet a minority of pundits (and, sadly, politicians) have wrapped their head around how to approach the (possible) problem. We should be way beyond this (though at least we're ahead of the Yanks).

Oh, and here's another lovely little excerpt from the same page:
[P]olitical activity in this area [climate change] more closely resembles an evolving set of actions designed to shape the future political landscape and influence private-sector investments, rather than any firm consensus about the optimum level of emissions reductions. International negotiators often appear to regard the continuation of the process as more important than the particular results at each stage.
10 years on... how little has changed. However, the authors go on to differentiate between hedging – taking actions now to mitigate risk – and shaping – making it easier to take actions later –, and suggest that the latter approach may be as good as the former. I don't know to what extent I believe that, but it does give me a little more hope that the Conferences of the Parties are actually achieving anything.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Donating for them, or for yourself?

Accompanying the Twitter commentary of the Queensland floods (see #QLDfloods) I've noticed a number of people writing that they'll donate $1 every time their message gets "retweeted" (RTed; forwarded, in Twitter, parlance). The first message I saw was from @lilithia. I can't say for certain whether she started the trend, and once I started looking I found several others – e.g. @AUSteambieberr, @bree_101, @xander85 –, but they all seemed to share two initial characteristics:
  • These were ordinary people
  • The donations were uncapped
The second point, especially, struck me: late last year Daniel Keogh, a science presenter on the ABC, promised to donate $5 to beyondblue(1) for every time he was retweeted (until 10pm), but his offer took off and he ended up with a nominal figure of over $17,000 dollars. That was far above Keogh's self-imposed limit, but he ended up donating $5000 and the story made it into the papers.

Evidently not the papers lilithia et al. read, though, as the same thing happened to them and they started imposing limits: first $250, then $500. The trouble with RTs, though, is that often very few people follow the original poster, and retractions/corrections/clarifications are rarely retweeted as much or as quickly as the original message. Thus, even though lilithia reached her limit last night, her tweet was still making the rounds this morning. And as the original tweet contained no limits, some people got a bit narky when they found out the original authors wouldn't be donating any further.

My motivation for writing this post, however, is to wonder why people would take this route to donation. Stepwise:
  1. You have a desire to help victims of a natural disaster, so you give money to charity.
  2. If this were your only desire – i.e. you were motivated purely by altruism – you would just give the money to charity and be done with it.
  3. You may, however, also wish to raise public awareness of the issue to encourage other donations (encouraging altruism in others) and/or
  4. You may wish to garner positive reputational benefits (respect, admiration, whatever) by publicising your actions.
Now, Point 4 may not sit well with some people – if you were truly concerned about the plight of these flood victims, why would you sully that by playing your actions up for personal (reputational) gain? That's a can of worms, though, which I will try to avoid by claiming that I don't believe most of these people were coldly calculating enough to think "Well, I'm prepared to donate $X – how can I go about maximising my return on that."; I simply just don't believe their thought processes extended that far. More interesting, I think, is a fifth point:
  1. By opening your decision-making process up to public input, you are (involuntarily?) exposing yourself to peer pressure to donate more than you intended.
This requires some sort of assumption of bounded rationality, I think; a type of rationality that hasn't gone explicitly through points 1–4, or wondered what they'd do if their limit wasn't reached (would they then donate less to flood victims simply because too few people forwarded their message? That seems callous.)  By giving others the impression that they have an influence over your actions, you raise in them the expectation that you will respond to their exertion of that influence and, if only to avoid backlash (loss of reputational benefits), you might be prompted, in fact, to act beyond what you had previously decided: see lilithia donating $500 instead of $250, or Daniel Keogh donating $5000. (I don't know what he was intending to donate originally, but I suspect it was less than that.)

Penultimately, as I said in my opening, this type of "I'll donate money for every RT" message did spread; it is quite possible that it has spurred people to donate by giving them benefits above and beyond the altruistic ones. So, if being able to get a bit of recognition on a social network encourage more people to give than otherwise would have (or to give more than they would otherwise have given), I guess that's not such a bad thing.(2)

Finally, go donate. Queensland floods if you like, but I would suggest Pakistan: they need US$20 billion for their reconstruction effort, and are worse off than is Australia.

(1) An organisation against depression.
(2) There is, in fact, fascinating literature on the motivation behind charitable giving and how to maximise it.

[UPDATE]
Peter Brent has a slightly related post at his Mumble blog on why the plight of middle Australia evinces more empathy than the (more serious) plight of others.

Saturday, January 08, 2011

It's a hard life


Bronte Beach. 27 degrees Celsius. Light breeze.

Tuesday, January 04, 2011

A Cautionary Tale

In my least proud internet banking moment, I once entered the "wrong" password so often that the account was suspended, only to realise that I'd mistyped my client number and had thus accidentally caused someone else's account to be suspended.

Happy new year.