Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Healthy body, healthy soul

An analogy I just thought of:

Religion is, for me, like some sort of strange diet. Amongst religions / diets, there are some basic concepts that are almost universally regarded as sensible and a good idea, e.g. be kind to other people / don't eat too much. Then there's stuff that's more kooky and probably doesn't have all that great an effect on your health, e.g. don't mix meat and dairy / err, don't mix meat and dairy.

So, if you've got some diet that works, or that you think works, good for you. I may even be interested in the particulars, in order to compare it to other diets I've heard about and decide just; may have an academic interest, if you will. My interest in actually adhering to your odd diet, however, is nil. Zero. Do not want. No interaction desired.

And while I'm ambivalent about people practising their own diet – possibly even broadly supportive, if it contains the generally good ideas alluded to above –, if it affects what I can eat, or your actions are only understandable through the prism of your dietary handbook, then we may have a problem.

[UPDATE]
I was asked why I was an agnostic, rather than an atheist. My answer is that I see no better arguments disproving the existence of a higher being – or higher beings – than I do proving it. Do I think the Flying Spaghetti Monster exists?  In all likelihood, no, but I don't know that it can be definitively ruled out. However, I don't care: I'm not really interested in knowing the answer to that question.

There's a quote from a well-known philosopher – paraphrased, because I've forgotten his name and my Google-fu is weak; assistance appreciated – that appeals to me: if proof of the (non-)existence of God would change the way your live your life, then God is important to you.
Perhaps I'm kidding myself when I think that I wouldn't change my life if I could know that God existed, but it's how I justify my indifference to the question: it's not important to me.

Sunday, December 25, 2011

Relived Childhood Christmas

Christmas! I feel like a kid again!
... in the sense that I got up early expressly to open presents, but now have to wait impatiently for hours and hours until the whole family is here.

See, usually we open presents on Christmas Eve: I do my birthday batch in the morning/midday, then the afternoon/evening is for Christmas gifts. As I only got into Melbourne at midday yesterday, and required a nap soon thereafter, my birthday celebrations took up the afternoon and early evening; Mum & Dad wanted to go to church after dinner, so we agreed to delay presents until 9am today. Come nine, I struggle out of bed to find a note from Mum on the fridge: "Back at 10:30am, latest."

Aargh!

Now, Klaus has to leave by 10am, and can't make it back before three or four. And we all need to leave the house by 4:30pm to go to a Christmas dinner. So not only am I sitting around bleary-eyed, wondering what to do without presents to play with, we probably won't have more than an hour to enjoy them and I'll feel terribly sorry for myself all through the family events.

AND STARING AT THESE PRESENTS WITHOUT BEING ALLOWED TO OPEN THEM IS KILLING ME!

So it's just like being a kid again :-)

Friday, December 16, 2011

What does this phrase even mean?

If I become famous, I want to capture the imagination of the Australian public; I'd also like to capture their hearts and minds.
Then I'll ransom them. I mean, what am I going to do with 22 million hearts, minds, and imaginations? I wouldn't know where to put the bloody things, for starters.
Now, you might wonder who might be left over with whom I could negotiate after this great capture, but as politicians manage to survive quite well without hearts, minds, or imaginations I'm sure we'd be able to come to some agreement.

Seeking aspiration

I have been thinking, recently, about doing a PhD. It's an option I've considered in the past, and one I deliberately kept open by taking my current job as a research assistant (RA).
I hadn't given the idea much thought since I began working here, though. To start with, I was just happy to have sorted my short-term future out and, after moving Germany → Melbourne → Sydney in a little over 6 months, didn't want to face the effort of thinking beyond the next 1-2 years. The RA job is very enjoyable, and so I managed to defer or deflect any serious consideration of what comes next until a few weeks ago.

What happened was that one of my centre's directors came to town, after having been in Europe since before I even started working here; we've been doing all our work together through email and Skype. Coincident with her visit is our annual conference and a whole range of annual review processes, both for the centre and at an individual level. So not only do I find myself now having lunchtime conversations about where I'm thinking of going in the next few years, I now also have to fill out my first formal annual review (!)

The whole thing has necessitated actually, seriously thinking about what I want to do over the next few years, which is something I've been quite content to avoid.
*sigh*

So, Martin, what's your five-year plan? Are you going to do a PhD?

Well, until a few weeks ago I was leaning toward "no". Having several friends who have done/are doing a PhD, I had set myself the hurdle that I wouldn't commit to doing one unless I had a topic that really excited me; that I just had to find the answer to; that I could definitely see myself focussing on for three years. This level of motivation is probably the most important aspect of a PhD, as far as I've been able to ascertain, as if you don't have good reasons for submitting yourself to years of low income, long hours, hard work, stress, and an incredibly small audience of people who care, you'll have a difficult time getting through it.

The problem was that I hadn't found such a topic.I'd found lots of topics that were cool, and that I enjoyed spending a few months, even half a year on. But usually I had something else going on on the side, so it wasn't just tunnel vision. Spending three years on just one thing? I hadn't found that thing yet.

That was until I sat down with my newly-arrived director for lunch, and we talked about the possibility of doing a three-paper PhD: I could do, say, a thesis on "Methods of Policy Evaluation", comprising one paper on econometric analysis of a policy – say, the EU ETS; I've been cleaning up a dataset there that could be quite useful –; one paper on a field experiment to test the effects of a particular policy design; and one paper on running a prediction market* for policy-relevant outcomes.
(* a prediction market, also called an informational aggregation market, is an attempt to get people to reveal their information (or beliefs) about an outcome by rewarding them if they make correct prediction. It's similar to betting, in that you get people to express an opinion and back it up with money, except that the goal of the prediction market operator is not necessarily to make money but to reveal information, i.e. make predictions. It's already used in a few settings, e.g. "Who will run against Obama in the next US election?", or "Will we get nuclear fusion running before the end of 2014?".)

Now here was something that got me a little excited! Prediction markets aren't something I know a great deal about, but they seem totally cool. And running a field experiment would be totally cool, too! That these are both methodologies, not topics, might be a slight problem, however; I can't rely on enthusiasm for methodology alone (especially enthusiasm about what I imagine a methodology to be like) for three years.

The topic, then, broadly speaking, was "policy analysis". Do I love policy analysis? Well... I'd like to be the kind of person who loves policy analysis, so it'd be a case of using my actions to shape my attitudes. That's not optimal, but I'm okay with that; at some point you have to step up and be the person you aspire to be, and not the person you're comfortable being.

That last point is an important one: in the recent past I have certainly felt as though I've been someone I was comfortable being, not someone I aspired to be. Not that I'm unhappy with myself – I have a interesting job I enjoy, in which I learn about and contribute to topics that I think are important; I lead a healthy, active, and environmentally conscious lifestyle; and I earn more than most Australians. (Alright, no girlfriend, but if that's my biggest problem I won't complain too loudly.)

But I'm not getting more awesome as quickly as I used to, and that's mainly because I've stopped pushing myself. A PhD would be definitely be pushing myself, which is a point in its favour. I'd also get to go to cool conferences, earn that marvellous "Doctor" title, and have achieved something in my chosen field.
On the down-side, I'd learn much less money, put myself through a lot of stress, and have to stay in Sydney another four years.

That last one's a big one. I miss Melbourne, and I'd only complete my PhD by the time I'm 32-33. And even though I don't have particularly firm life plans, being 33 and still a student is not an appealing prospect. In fact, up until that thought went through my head – you'll be 33 and have just finished being a povo student – my mind was pretty much in the groove of figuring out how to do a PhD; the topic/s, supervisor/s, scholarships, admission processes, etc. I'd even gotten so far as to write all this planning down on the annual review forms I sent to my directors before our meeting.

For some reason, that consideration was a catalyst, and the night before my review I decided I wasn't going to do a PhD. And I felt absolutely fine about it. I hadn't figured out what I was going to do in any detail, but that the decision not to do a PhD felt so good was a clear indication it was the correct choice. You can only talk yourself into so much.

So, the next morning I walked into the review meeting, sat down, and told my directors things had changed a little since yesterday arvo and I should probably re-write that whole "future plans" section. They took it quite well, I thought.

What am I going to do now? For the moment, exactly what I've been doing. I love the mix of research and policy I'm doing now, especially with the freedom to involve myself in public debate (even if only at low levels). I really just want to keep doing this as long as possible (well, for another year at least) to gather experience before moving to something in the same area. I have some things in mind (some vague, some more concrete), but this post has already dragged on long enough.

In a nutshell: not doing PhD; keeping on doing what I'm doing; and feeling pretty good about it.