Showing posts with label university. Show all posts
Showing posts with label university. Show all posts

Friday, December 16, 2011

Seeking aspiration

I have been thinking, recently, about doing a PhD. It's an option I've considered in the past, and one I deliberately kept open by taking my current job as a research assistant (RA).
I hadn't given the idea much thought since I began working here, though. To start with, I was just happy to have sorted my short-term future out and, after moving Germany → Melbourne → Sydney in a little over 6 months, didn't want to face the effort of thinking beyond the next 1-2 years. The RA job is very enjoyable, and so I managed to defer or deflect any serious consideration of what comes next until a few weeks ago.

What happened was that one of my centre's directors came to town, after having been in Europe since before I even started working here; we've been doing all our work together through email and Skype. Coincident with her visit is our annual conference and a whole range of annual review processes, both for the centre and at an individual level. So not only do I find myself now having lunchtime conversations about where I'm thinking of going in the next few years, I now also have to fill out my first formal annual review (!)

The whole thing has necessitated actually, seriously thinking about what I want to do over the next few years, which is something I've been quite content to avoid.
*sigh*

So, Martin, what's your five-year plan? Are you going to do a PhD?

Well, until a few weeks ago I was leaning toward "no". Having several friends who have done/are doing a PhD, I had set myself the hurdle that I wouldn't commit to doing one unless I had a topic that really excited me; that I just had to find the answer to; that I could definitely see myself focussing on for three years. This level of motivation is probably the most important aspect of a PhD, as far as I've been able to ascertain, as if you don't have good reasons for submitting yourself to years of low income, long hours, hard work, stress, and an incredibly small audience of people who care, you'll have a difficult time getting through it.

The problem was that I hadn't found such a topic.I'd found lots of topics that were cool, and that I enjoyed spending a few months, even half a year on. But usually I had something else going on on the side, so it wasn't just tunnel vision. Spending three years on just one thing? I hadn't found that thing yet.

That was until I sat down with my newly-arrived director for lunch, and we talked about the possibility of doing a three-paper PhD: I could do, say, a thesis on "Methods of Policy Evaluation", comprising one paper on econometric analysis of a policy – say, the EU ETS; I've been cleaning up a dataset there that could be quite useful –; one paper on a field experiment to test the effects of a particular policy design; and one paper on running a prediction market* for policy-relevant outcomes.
(* a prediction market, also called an informational aggregation market, is an attempt to get people to reveal their information (or beliefs) about an outcome by rewarding them if they make correct prediction. It's similar to betting, in that you get people to express an opinion and back it up with money, except that the goal of the prediction market operator is not necessarily to make money but to reveal information, i.e. make predictions. It's already used in a few settings, e.g. "Who will run against Obama in the next US election?", or "Will we get nuclear fusion running before the end of 2014?".)

Now here was something that got me a little excited! Prediction markets aren't something I know a great deal about, but they seem totally cool. And running a field experiment would be totally cool, too! That these are both methodologies, not topics, might be a slight problem, however; I can't rely on enthusiasm for methodology alone (especially enthusiasm about what I imagine a methodology to be like) for three years.

The topic, then, broadly speaking, was "policy analysis". Do I love policy analysis? Well... I'd like to be the kind of person who loves policy analysis, so it'd be a case of using my actions to shape my attitudes. That's not optimal, but I'm okay with that; at some point you have to step up and be the person you aspire to be, and not the person you're comfortable being.

That last point is an important one: in the recent past I have certainly felt as though I've been someone I was comfortable being, not someone I aspired to be. Not that I'm unhappy with myself – I have a interesting job I enjoy, in which I learn about and contribute to topics that I think are important; I lead a healthy, active, and environmentally conscious lifestyle; and I earn more than most Australians. (Alright, no girlfriend, but if that's my biggest problem I won't complain too loudly.)

But I'm not getting more awesome as quickly as I used to, and that's mainly because I've stopped pushing myself. A PhD would be definitely be pushing myself, which is a point in its favour. I'd also get to go to cool conferences, earn that marvellous "Doctor" title, and have achieved something in my chosen field.
On the down-side, I'd learn much less money, put myself through a lot of stress, and have to stay in Sydney another four years.

That last one's a big one. I miss Melbourne, and I'd only complete my PhD by the time I'm 32-33. And even though I don't have particularly firm life plans, being 33 and still a student is not an appealing prospect. In fact, up until that thought went through my head – you'll be 33 and have just finished being a povo student – my mind was pretty much in the groove of figuring out how to do a PhD; the topic/s, supervisor/s, scholarships, admission processes, etc. I'd even gotten so far as to write all this planning down on the annual review forms I sent to my directors before our meeting.

For some reason, that consideration was a catalyst, and the night before my review I decided I wasn't going to do a PhD. And I felt absolutely fine about it. I hadn't figured out what I was going to do in any detail, but that the decision not to do a PhD felt so good was a clear indication it was the correct choice. You can only talk yourself into so much.

So, the next morning I walked into the review meeting, sat down, and told my directors things had changed a little since yesterday arvo and I should probably re-write that whole "future plans" section. They took it quite well, I thought.

What am I going to do now? For the moment, exactly what I've been doing. I love the mix of research and policy I'm doing now, especially with the freedom to involve myself in public debate (even if only at low levels). I really just want to keep doing this as long as possible (well, for another year at least) to gather experience before moving to something in the same area. I have some things in mind (some vague, some more concrete), but this post has already dragged on long enough.

In a nutshell: not doing PhD; keeping on doing what I'm doing; and feeling pretty good about it.

Monday, March 01, 2010

Redefining success

When I graduated from high school, I had an Equivalent National Tertiary Entrance Ranking (ENTER) of 94.3 (out of a possible 99.95). Though this is a pretty good recent result, it was not one I was really happy with; I think my goal at the time was 95.0, and I certainly remember thinking that I had the potential to reach that.

A few years later, I had to have this ENTER converted to the German marking system (see previous explanation) for my university applications, and was assigned an equivalent score of 1.9. Though I didn't really have a specific idea of what sort of marks I wanted to achieve here – in my first semester, just getting my head around the language, maths, and passing everything was enough – after my marks bettered in later semesters I adopted a goal popular amongst fellow students and decided to try and improve upon my high school final mark.(1)

I have failed in this endeavour, if only just: my final Diploma mark is exactly 1.9, and thus improves upon my high school mark not one jot. That's not to say I feel like a failure – one could reasonably argue that maintaining the same mark whilst switching the language of instruction constitutes a real improvement.

On the other hand, I had set my goal to improve upon my high school mark, not simply maintain it. And, had I scored just slighly higher on my final piece of work – my Diploma thesis – than 1.7, I would have reached that goal.
Now, you may look at that 1.7 thesis mark and consider it to be pretty good. And it is pretty good! It reflects the quality of the thesis – I'm not claiming to have been unfairly marked or anything –, is one of the better theses of the year, and is a mark most students would be glad to have.

In that respect, it's exactly like my ENTER score. In both cases, I really have very little complain about. Scoring those few points higher would, in both cases, not really change my life significantly. But, in both cases, my achievements were just a smidge below my goals.

I can live with that. I'm not happy, certainly, but neither am I unhappy. Marginally dissatisfied, perhaps – a state I have learnt to accept as a necessary part of a character that tends towards perfectionism. The type of character that sees achieving a goal almost as a sign that the goal wasn't challenging enough, and wonders what could have been achieved had the sights only been set further.

From that point of view, failing to achieve a goal by the smallest amount possible is, well... it's almost success.

(1) I omit my Bachelor here for the simple reason that I have no single mark for it.

Friday, November 13, 2009

Thesis completed!

After four months of hard slog I handed my diploma thesis in economics in today, and breathed a mighty sigh of relief. 80 pages, 20,000 words, 38 charts & graphs –I think I can be happy with the result.

The topic was "An international comparison of alternatives to GDP as a measure of welfare." If that's still a little broad, here's a brief synopsis (if you'd prefer a polemic speech, go listen to this 2min Bobby Kennedy speech on the topic):

After the Great Depression in 1929 the Yanks decided they could do with a system of national accounts to deliver comprehensive information about how the economy was faring. Out of this process sprung the Gross Domestic Product, or GDP, which measures the value of all goods and services produced by an economy over a period of time; basically, it tell you how big an economy is.

Now, what the GDP doesn't do is tell you how well off people are, for the simple reason that it doesn't measure everything that affects how well off we are. What kind of things does it leave out? Income distribution, for starters: GDP doesn't tell you if the rich folk are earning more, or the poor folk, or both. Levels of health, education, crime, environmental pollution, unemployment, over-employment (working too much), unpaid work; these all affect our welfare, too, but aren't part of GDP. Unpaid work is one of my favourites. An example: I cook myself dinner every night, and so does my neighbour. That doesn't count towards GDP. If my neighbour pays me to cook her dinner and I pay her to cook mine, suddenly GDP increases. Are we any better off? Not really. But if we use GDP to measure how well off we are, then we would have to say yes.

Another problem with GDP is that some things are part of it, but probably shouldn't be. If, for example, I run a factory and pump black smoke into the air so that no one gets to see the sun, lots of people are unhappy and circle my house with torches and pitchforks during their lunch break (they need the torches to see because it's so dark). So I spend a lot of money installing filters to get rid of the smoke. All of that increases GDP, but are the people better off than they were before I started polluting? Not really. They can see the sun again, but they could beforehand, too. They're not accidentally stabbing each other with pitchforks in the dark any more, but that was also my fault. So GDP has gone up, even though our welfare hasn't increased.

Finally, our welfare doesn't just depend on how we're doing today, but also how we'll be doing tomorrow, in a few years and decades, and how our descendants will be doing. Going out and fishing the oceans empty would result in really, really cheap fish for a while (yay! more GDP! everyone's better off!), but after that it wouldn't be so swell. So our welfare also depends on how sustainably we're living.

So these are some of the reasons why GDP isn't a great measure of welfare. People have known this for yonks – the chap who invented GDP, in fact, told the American Congress that that wasn't how it was supposed to be used while he was inventing it. But they didn't listen.
Anyway, about 40 years ago some economists got together and decided they'd create an alternative, which they called the "Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare" – ISEW. A few other economists thought, "bonzer!", and took up this concept for their own countries. Over the years it was extended, and refined, and given prettier names like "Genuine Progress Indicator" (GPI). There's ISEWs and GPIs and indexes by a bunch of other names for all sorts of countries now, sometimes several for the same country. Some of them define welfare a little differently than the others, but most of them come back to the same principles.(1) A lot of the differences are in the way they go about measuring welfare – does emitting a ton of CO2 cause $30 of damage, or $60, $160 or perhaps even more?(2)

Now, what I did – after explaining all that stuff up there for 15 pages because, well, that's what you do when you're an academic – is take three of these ISEW studies, look at them very sternly, and ask, "Are you a valid and reliable measure of welfare?"(3)
I then wrote down all the bits where I thought they were and weren't very good measure of welfare, considered all the technical stuff they did, made some suggestions of how I thought they could be improved, and tried some of my own suggestions out to see what the results were. That one sentence covers 70% of my thesis and 100% of the attractive and very time consuming graphs and tables.

Attentive readers will have noticed that 15 + 70% does not equal 80, and they're right: on the remaining pages I drew dirty pictures, then deleted those and I wrote, "I did not plagiarise" one-thousand times.

So that's my thesis. Those who find the topic interesting should check out Beyond GDP (www.beyond-gdp.eu) and perhaps the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress (www.stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr), both of which have loads of material on the subject. Particularly hardcore is the 292-page report by the CMEPSP, written by half-a-dozen Nobel-prize winning economists, whom I nevertheless harbour a grudge against because I waited almost half a year for their report and when it came out it was just "We need better data" written three-hundred-thousand times and no index for me to study.

But they're Nobel laureates, so I guess they're allowed to do that.


(1) Some of them just go around and ask people how happy they are. Which is great but, y'know, a little useless.
(2) If you ask Penny Wong she'll answer, "Whatever the coal lobby says", but that's because she hates kittens and only has her position because it looks incredibly good having a female, Asian, homosexual Minister for Climate Change. (Sorry Philipp Rösler, lesbianism beats adoption. And she was only 3 years older that you when she took office, so nerr.)
(3) If I'm honest I only whispered the question under my breath, but this a joke only Seb will understand.

Tuesday, January 08, 2008

One of the reasons I'm still skinny...

... is because I always have a lot on my plate. Though the latter half of this sentence holds true in both the literal and metaphorical sense, the statement as a whole really only makes sense metaphorically.

I've been bemoaning the fact that my Christmas holidays weren't (and I trust you with the required amount of judgement to determine that the missing condition in that equation was not the calendarial one), but I'm not making things any better for myself. Right now, I am trying to do the following:
  • Attend classes (12 hours a week)
  • Work @ SAP (20 hours a week)
  • Finish editing a video for my brother's 21st birthday (20 hours and counting; his birthday was on the 3rd, I'm aiming to have this vid. done in time for his party this weekend)
  • Translate a 12-page academic paper for a professor friend of mine (~12 hours, due by the 18th)
  • Give a friend a crash course in HTML and prepare her for a job interview at SAP (not least because I recommended her for the job)
  • Read 50 pages of Environmental Economics and Microeconometrics material a week
  • Do the homework for my national income accounting class (??? hours – I rarely get around to this :-S )
  • Revise for Env. Eco with a mate (coz I'm nice; he needs it more than I)
  • Come up with a lesson plan for the swing classes I'm going to start teaching again next week (!)
  • Clean my apartment
  • Get in some pre-pre-season football training
  • Send out the football tipping results from.. mid December :-0
  • Get over this cold
  • Blog
I reeeeally miss lying around in the heat watching cricket *sigh*

Saturday, November 03, 2007

Holiday round-up

Not much happened over the holiday break (August, September, October) that I haven't already talked about: the visit to Hamburg, the waterskiing, the Darmstadt Swing Workshop (Update: there's now a post about it), and the Munich Lindy Exchange a week after that (pretty much the same as last year, except with different Australians & hello Mark, Tessa, and Xavier & and a different beer tent).

Mostly I worked, then towards the end of September / start of October I took some time off to study for exams. They went alright.. Environmental Economics I was satisfied with (prediction: 2,7-3,7), Political Economics: The Assessment of Economics Policy less so. I wrote a heap of rubbish in that exam, far worse than what I'm capable of. I just couldn't interest myself in the material, even though it's not that boring. Ah well. As long as I pass that subject I'll be happy. Fingers crossed!

What else is new... well, my new apartment, obviously. I've been putting off writing about that until I get some pictures to go with it, and I've put off taking pictures until I get all my furniture, and I'm getting my furniture this afternoon, when I'm visiting IKEA for the first time in years. Armed with measurements of my apartment, a large car boot, and a freshly deposited paycheck :-)))

Uni is going well so far. The dearth of subjects on offer this semester drove me up the wall when I saw them, since they pretty much condemned me to another semester of study (I was hoping to be done in 2 + 1 for the thesis, now it'll be 3 + 1 for the thesis), but I've responded by only taking three subjects and spending the extra time at work. If you're confused as to why I'm back at Uni after just having written exams: in Heidelberg you can write exams at the start or the end of your holidays. I did two at the start, and two at the end.

Right. Now I'm going to pick up the car, go watch football, meet Annette and Johannes and go furniture shopping. Hurrah!

Sunday, December 31, 2006

Final Group Email for 2006

Hello everybody. Are you sitting comfortably? Good. Then let's begin.

First off, a hello to anyone who is receiving this group email for the first time; I went through my mailing list over Christmas and fixed up a couple of incorrect or missing addresses, so that you too may now experience the textual wonders that leap from my fingers like jello from a penguin's flippers.

I last wrote two months ago, in my first week of University here in Heidelberg. For those whose memories have taken time off to watch the cricket, I'm doing the last two years of a Diploma in Economics and had just moved into the basement apartment below the house my Aunt Martina inhabits with her family. It was a time of confusion, struggle, and resentment; of coming to terms with a set of circumstances that seemed designed expressly to vex and annoy - and that was just trying to put my cousins to bed. Uni, on the other hand, wasn't that bad!

The biggest adjustment I had to make was the amount of maths involved: where my degree at Monash involved predominantly explanations of theories, circumstances or occurrences, the emphasis here is on the calculation of same. Some of the maths is stuff I've learnt but haven't used seriously in 5 years or more (derivatives, logarithms), but plenty was entire new (matrixes - matrices? - , the Jacobi matrix, Slutzki, l'Hospital, Lagrange vector plotting). I think they're trying to teach me Greek, too: I reckon we have half the alphabet down so far, so verbs and prepositions can't be too far off.

The difference in the approach results from the traditional aim of German Universities, which is to educate people for academic rather for business purposes; business education occurs through the businesses themselves. In the dual-stream system you won't study Finance or Marketing at Uni, but instead at directly a bank or marketing company, respectively. Though you don't end up with an academic qualification, you do get paid while studying/working.

The difference in approaches was one of the things that made a German degree attractive to me, but even so I was surprised by just how little interpretation of the results occurs. These students can do more with a set of numbers that I can (at the moment), but I'm much better at explaining it all to a lay-person: and in the real world there are few economic numbers, but a hell of a lot of lay-people. Maybe that's a 4th year subject: "What does it all mean?"

Aside from that academic vs. workforce orientation, there wasn't much else to get used to. Professors are treated with a little more deference, but that's your regular German respect for authority thing - though teaching, it must be said, is a well-regarded and -paid career generally. The food in the canteen is actually subsidised with your student fees, would you believe it? I haven't met a single student yet who's actually from Heidelberg, but that doesn't mean much; I only knew one chap at Monash who lived in Clayton. The second biggest difference after the material would be the structure of the university: the exasperatingly incomprehensible course structure, and the way you don't enrol in subjects, but instead in exams. Did I mention you get two exams to choose from? One at the start of the holidays, and one at the end. If you fail the first time, you get to do the second - or you can skip the first exam entirely and just do the second. It's a bit harder, though.

Regular recipients (victims) of my group emails may have noticed I'm writing more than usual, instead of just linking to my blog like I usually do. Mainly it's because I'm writing offline, but also a teeny part of me thinks you deserve having me repeat something I've already written so you don't have to follow a link - it's Christmas, right? :-P

So.. Uni.. oh, yeah - I was in the middle of picking subjects in my last email. I ended up taking all four for the first two weeks, then, sadly, Economic Growth sprung a whole bunch of nasty maths on me. Had the maths come _now_, I reckon I could have dealt with it, but at the time I was playing catch-up-algebra for General Equilibrium Theory, Macroeconomics, and Financial Taxation. So I've dropped that, and am contenting myself with just the 3 'core' subjects.

My week is 10-12, Monday-Thursday, with 2-4 on Wednesday and 1-4 on Thursday afternoons. 12:00 is a leisurely lunch, followed by a leisurely coffee and conversation, after which it's either time for more class, or a nap. Or both.

Tuesday and Thursday afternoons I train with the local football (soccer) team, who have teams in the lowest and third lowest divisions. Games are on Sundays, and though I'm part of the squad I couldn’t play until my player passport arrived. That happened two weeks before the mid-season break, but the combination of top-of-the-ladder opponents and pressure from the first team's coach to give his 2nd picks a run meant throwing the new guy on wasn't in the mix. Pre-season training should hopefully start up soon, weather permitting, and then the season resumes in March *sigh* So far away..

The weather's been quite unusual here this year. Some of you may remember seeing some of Germany's record summer during the telecast of the little football tourney we hosted back in June. The warm weather has continued, with the result that, for the first time in most people's memory, there's been no snow this winter. None. Melbourne had a whiter Christmas than I did. The supermarkets are selling snowboards while the leaves refuse to fall off the trees, ice-rinks melt, and birds start singing their spring songs. Forecast for New Years Eve: 12°. 12 degrees! It's supposed to be cold enough to crystallise water, not warm enough for Englishmen to sunbathe!

Ah well. What else have I been doing since October? The Living End gig in London, that's right! It was at Brixton Academy, and flying in on Saturday afternoon I had this vague sort of notion it'd be a venue like the Palace, maybe, with a couple of thousand people, but pretty good chances of getting to the barrier if you were willing to ignore the squeals of the 14-year-olds you were displacing. It turned out to be at least twice the size of the Palace - built like the Forum, with a big raised ceiling and stuff on the walls. No stars on the roof though. The queue was incredible, too. I don't say this just because it was long (at least 400m, around 3 sides of the block), but also because it moved really, really fast. I know the English have that whole queuing reputation, but it never really sunk in until I was in that line.

I was meeting up with Paul (the same Paul I went to Zurich with), and had asked him to save me a spot in the queue, but the thing went so fast he was inside before I'd even arrived. We found each other inside, and were standing in line for the cloakroom (a 50m line, with no discernible movement at all) when the opening bars of "Roll On" came through the doors. Rapidly abandoning that line we bolted back out to the pit, where, luckily, most of the crowd was still trying to decide whether they could fool the barman into letting them buy a beer. I must shamefully admit I never looked back to see if Paul had made it as far to the front as I had, as I was busy exercising my cold-weakened voice to its fullest.

It was a good gig! One of the few times I've seen TLE as a support act, but – if audience reaction is anything to go by – they did a fine job of winning some new fans. Not a few strangers said the set was great when they saw my TLE shirt/hat/jacket/pants, and one chap even gave me his VIP Bar pass! Though reluctant to ditch Paul (again), I popped upstairs to see some other friends who had VIP passes. I managed to persuade a slightly drunk Irish girl to lend me her pass in exchange for my phone as security, and so it came to be that Paul and I, totally unexpectedly, got to watch the Dropkick Murphys and Less Than Jake from the comfort of the VIP bar. Which was nice.

Chris Cheney (singer/guitarist) came to the bar after a little while, and while I was pretty much dead on my feet (the cold, the flight), I did enjoy being responsible for the fact that Paul was able to meet him. Made up for the ditching him earlier, I thought. Plenty more hi-jinks occurred after that, but if your eyes are as tired as my fingers are from typing, I'd wonder why you were typing with your eyeballs. Let me therefore skip over the part where I got the see the band's dressing room, had a nap in a bus terminal, and discovered the "chewable toothbrush". Another time, perhaps.

*yawwwn* Well, I wanted to get this email out before the end of the year, so if I want to do that I'm going to have to sadly leave out any mention of my birthday, christmas, new year, the christmas market, the fact I'm now teaching swing in Heidelberg, or my chocolate salami. Oh, alright, you can know about the chocolate salami: it's a salami, made out of chocolate. Still confused? Check out the pictures. Everything else in this paragraph shall be, or is, a post on my blog, so do feel free to visit/comment/reply.

Have a great New Year's (if you read this before midnight), and Happy 2007 (if not)!

I ... am going to bed.

Good night, and good luck!

/Martin

Friday, November 24, 2006

A mix-basket of updates

The weather has been unseasonably mild of late, with no frost to rattle the leaves from the trees. The hills nestling Heidelberg thus provided a panoply of autumn reds, yellows, and citrus greens, until the start of the week saw a more traditional climate take over the city. The blanket of autumn colours has been replaced with a not-unattractive brown, peppered by remnants of colour from the hardier forms of foliage.

It's finally started to rain regularly, mostly drizzle through the morning fog. Though the cold is biting, a newly acquired jacket and, when necessary, my trusty beanie provide sufficient warmth to continue to cycle about. The moisture has occasioned a higher rate of public transport use on my part, though: despite its torpidity compared to the youthful thrill of making suburban streets your own on a bicycular contraption, it does have the significant advantage of being dry. Which, when much of your life involves an expensive electronic implement susceptible to said moisture, is an important consideration.

I'm playing football regularly for the first time in long pants. "Playing", I have to unfortunately say, should perhaps more accurately be replaced by "training", since I have not as yet received my official Player Pass. Until it arrives, my opportunities are limited to the twice-weekly training on an increasingly sodden pitch. Whether the pass arrives before the winter break is doubtable.

Uni is challenging, but not overly so. Sometimes I can't understand what possible practical purpose being able to calculate all these overly simplified scenarios might have, but I guess it's an important component for those who will go on to do research rather than business. In the latter case, a broader understanding of the concepts might be more appropriate, but in that stead I'm served well by my Australian studies. I do find much of the mathematics interesting, at least, and the impotent frustration of having to just copy down material in lectures without comprehending it is ebbing as I bring more concepts into my understanding.

At home – and there's still a little pause when I call it that; though I'm at 'home' in Germany generally, individual domiciles have not yet attained the levels of familiarity I associate with my first home – things are fine. My oldest aunt, Hedy, visits regularly, and I tend to argue with her on most of those visits. Not to the point where we get mad, but there seem to be very few topics where I don't find her point of view somewhat... detached from reality. I like a good argument – or perhaps ‘vigorous discussion’ is the better phrase – but I know to stop arguing when I reach the limits of my knowledge. Hedy seems quite happy to cross those borders; maybe a hangover from her days as a stewardess. In any case, I have trouble with people whose viewpoints are grounded in a lack of knowledge, and this doesn’t bother them.
How’s that quote? “Against logic there is no armour like ignorance.” *sighs*

With the kids, the only incident has been with Nele (the 8 year old middle child), who hasn’t yet learned that I operate a little bit differently to her parents: to put it simply, I’m stricter. I tolerate as much as I can, but when I indicate that the boundaries have been reached, it means I expect the behaviour to stop there. I’m not going to accept being hit on the head again because she thought I wasn’t serious after the first time: after the second time, she’s getting a smack, end of story.
This isn’t necessarily a statement about how I intend to raise my own children, but because I’m not raising these kids I can tolerate a few days of not being spoken to if it spares me some blood loss.


Monday, October 16, 2006

On the eve of a new beginning

It's my first day of lectures tomorrow, and almost everything has fallen into place. I've figured out my timetable, found a football team to play (or at least train) with, and there is more floorspace visible in my apartment than not.

Sorting out my timetable was probably the hardest of those tasks, and even now isn't 100% definite. Though I'd read through all the stuff the Uni had online I really wasn't clear as to what subjects I was supposed to be picking: over the course of my Hauptstudium (the second half of the Diploma) I have to take subjects worth 80 semester-hours-per-week, but also choose 7 specialisations – nowhere was I told what on earth categorized a "specialisation". Worse still, when I rang the help desk I was told that, firstly, they were a general help desk and couldn't help me with the specialisation question – and, by the way, that thing with the 80 hours is wrong. Great!

Though loitering around the office of the student body for most of the week I was unable to find anyone to talk to until Friday, when I joined a tour for first-years. That didn't prove a problem, however, because German Universities don't make you sign up for lectures. They hardly make you sign up for anything at all, in fact. Most students recommended I go along to whatever subjects I think look interesting for the first few weeks, then pick my timetable. Certainly a bit different to Monash.

My 10 year old cousin Leander plays for the local football team, so I've started training with the senior team there. They're in one of the lower divisions, but the difference between these guys and the blokes I played with/against back in Australia is noticeable. They're probably no more talented, but the fact they've grown up kicking a ball around since the age they could walk means that even the crap players have some idea of what they're doing. I'm a bit out of form at the moment, but my fitness and positioning are only a little sub-par. My touch will take a bit longer to return, but I'm looking forward to being able to work on it twice a week at training.

No job at the moment, and I probably won't get one this first semester. I want to leave enough time outside of the football and dancing to compensate for any problems I have with Uni – I'm not expecting any, necessarily, but I'd prefer to approach this semester with caution and not overload. Time enough for that next semester :-)

Saturday, August 19, 2006

Political Economics, at the Univeristy of Heidelberg

As I was reviewing my blog (for aesthetic issues, don't worry; I leave all my typos so as to convince you I'm human and not some kind of robot. That, and I'm too lazy to proofread) when I realised I'd not even updated you on how my university applications and the like were going. I told my folks, of course, and that must've ticked the little checkbox in my head that reads "tell someone who cares". I'll thank you to keep comments on that point to yourselves :-P

So, here's the skinny: before the World Cup I'd done a lot of the ground work for my applications. I started with four universities (Cologne, Bonn, Mannheim, and Constance) that had been recommended to me by academic contacts as being good to study economics. While researching those I added to them another 6 (Heidelberg, Hamburg, Essen, Magdeburg, Karlsruhe, Tuebingen) which also received good rankings from Die Zeit, a large and well-respected German newspaper that conducts yearly reviews. The shortlist was then rounded out with two Universities that were not top-notch, but had locational advantages: Stuttgart (coz my friends live here) and Munich (I've got some friends there too, my football teams plays there and it's got a decent swing scene).
From this list I had to figure out: a) whether the universities offered a Diploma or a Masters course, b) whether they'd let me in if they did. Karlsruhe, Mannheim, Stuttgart and Tuebingen fell off the lists pretty quickly. Either they weren't offering what I wanted, or they wouldn't allow me to transfer into a higher semester. The course in Bonn was entirely in English, which would have defeated the purpose of travelling around the world to study in Germany, so I put it on my "emergency" pile. Essen went there, too, because it was fairly maths-heavy.

That left Hamburg, Heidelberg, Cologne, Constance, Magdeburg, and Munich. To these (and Bonn & Essen, just in case) I sent copies of my Bachelor, my VCE, and a certificate from a government body in Stuttgart recognising the aforementioned documents as sufficient to pass high school, and with what mark. I was asking whether: a) the university would recognise my degree, and; b) how many semesters (in the case of transer into a Diploma) they would credit me with.

Before I go any further, I should say a brief word to the German University system. First of all, it's much more focussed at fostering knowledge and producing academics than training for the workforce. Germans are big on knowledge for knowledge's sake (this is a simplification, but hopefully any Germans, any academics, and especially any German academics will excuse me for painting with broad strokes here). Secondly, the usual couse here has been the Diploma, which runs 8-9 semesters. Not that people complete it in that time: another great German tradition is the 'eternal student'. I know a guy who's in his mid-30's, and may or may-not be approaching completion of his course. A Diploma is divided into a 'base' degree, which takes 4 semesters (and is worthless outside of the context of the course, but it means you don't have to repeat those units ever again), and the a 'main' degree, which is the other 4-5 semesters.
This is all in a state of flux at the moment, because several years ago, in Bologna, the EU decided to standardise its universities. Bye-bye Diplomas, hello Bachelor/Master. It was pretty much a political decision, since no academic I know of supports the 'reform' - and I live with a Professor, so if he says no-one supports it, I believe him. Anyway, since all Universities have to offer a Bachelor/Master by the end of next year, some of them are already offering a Bachelor (but not yet a Master, since the kids doing the Bachelor haven't finished it yet, so who would enrol?), some are offering both Bachelor and Master, some are still teaching Diplomas (but have stopped admitting people since they just want to let the Diploma run its course and be done with it), some are offering Diplomas and will let you apply, and some are offering everything: Bachelor, Master, Diploma, and probably night school if you ask nicely.

This might give you some context as to why I was applying for all these different things depending on the University, and also provided a yardstick for accreditation: German Diplomas are rated very highly internationally (often on par with a Masters, esp. in Engineering fields), so from my Bachelor I was hoping to get 4 semesters - the 'base' degree - as credit. For 3 years study, getting 2 recognised would be swell, since many of my subjects - my 5 German subjects and my 3 Australian law subjects, for example - had little use here. Stats, Management, Marketing, Accounting: they were pretty much all the same.. I hoped.

Anyway, a week after the World Cup finished I'd received replies from some Uni's saying "yes, you can apply", without necessarily telling me how much they'd credit me with, so I was busy writing applications to everyone. The one place that had given me an indication was Cologne, and they were offering a measly two semesters. It didn't look great.
Two days before the application deadline, Heidelberg offered me 4 semesters. Now, Heidelberg wasn't my first choice. Mannheim was - it had a better repuation, but wasn't admitting any more students. However, if I'd gotten into Mannheim I'd have planned to live nearby with my Aunt Martina, who was one town away. What town does Martina live in? Heidelberg :-)

That was pretty much the decision. I've since gotten a few other replies accepting me (and crediting me with 4 semesters, which tells me Cologne is mean-spirited. And smelly. And they have a lousy football team, so nuts to them *blows a raspberry*), but I've pretty much decided to go to Heidelberg.
It's a lovely city - which sucks, because it's full of tourists. And I'm not a huge fan of Tourists, which I capitalise to indicate those incredibly visible American & Japanese (but mainly American) drongos who try and cram as much as possible into a day and then piss off. Sure, I went to Rome and visited the Colusseum, but I didn't complain to my buddy about how "It's not nearly as big as in the movie." I almost killed that fucking Yank.
Anyway, Heidelberg is lovely. The University (at least, the main campus) is in the old part of town, which is something else entirely. I'll be taking lectures in theatres that were old when Abel Tasman was still regretting having named an island something as ridiculously long as "Anthoonij van Diemenslandt" (It's not like old Anthony was ever going to visit the bloody thing, was it?). I mean seriously old - this University was grounded in 1386.
Martina has a cellar apartment I can stay in, in return for which I will do roughly what Klaus did when he lived there: take care of the kids now and then, run tech support, and make nachos. I'm not as good on the tech side as Klaus, but I've offered to help with the tax returns - which, since Arnd (Martina's husband, and a throughly nice bloke to boot[1]) is a sole contractor, he's delighted with. I don't know how long I want to live there for. If I can find a part-time job - a proper one, seeing as I have a degree now and such - that earns me enough money I might try and find a share-house. Or not - I'll play it by ear. Heidelberg is close enough to Stuttgart that I can pop down for a visit on weekends or for the holidays, too, which is great.

So, that's the state of affairs. Officially I have to register, but that deadline is late September. That's roughly the time I'll move from Stuttgart to Heidelberg, too. The semester starts October 1, with lectures commencing October 15. The name of my course is 'Political Economics', which I think sounds pretty cool. I'll probably be one of the youngest people in the course, but that's okay; I like older chicks, anway *grins*

[1] I know there's a comma missing, but I like the ambiguity ;-)

Tuesday, August 02, 2005

Tastes like gossip

Regular readers of this column might have picked up that I'm a teetotaller. Well, that's not exactly true; I do drink - but little stronger than a Lemon, Lime & Bitters - and I absolutely refuse to pay for my alcohol. I don't need it to have fun; I have plenty of fun without it; and the downsides of higher cost and being drunk (vomiting, acting like a twat, and so forth) mean I'm quite happy to stick with the cheaper, more watery concoctions.
I'm also, as it happens, very financially responsible - a stingy prick, to use the vernacular *grins*. It's what makes me such a good treasurer, and it contributes to my aforementioned refusal to pay for alcohol. I get more from my money on things other than it, so I see no point in buying it myself. Especially ridiculous I find these events which serve essentially as glorified piss-ups (another vernacular: for our international and Tasmanian readers, a piss-up is an opportunity to get drunk and, well... that's about it) - yes, I'm talking about University Balls.

Alright, alright, before I get flooded by hate mail from my reader (hi mum), that's a generalization. Uni balls aren't simply production lines where you enter with your dignity, clothes and wallet intact and emerge stumbling, missing a shoe and with stubble rash given to you by Jean-Luc from the Social Alternative party (yes fellas, you too), proud of the fact you have not needed your stomach pumped. They also provide second-rate entertainment (boom boom!).

No no, just kidding again; lots of uni balls have good bands, a nice meal, and quite pleasant surrounds. But with tickets at anywhere up to $90+ a head, anybody who thinks they're not paying predominantly for the booze is kidding themselves. And since there's no way of not paying for the alcohol - even if you're not going to drink any - who would spend all that money without the slightest intention of drinking?

I don't think anyone really does, though. Hell, the Monash University Italian Club's Ball is called 'The Booze Cruise'. You can't get much more direct than that! And to those who go, I wish you the best. I don't look down on drinking, any more than I look down on guys who wear pastel-coloured shirts covered in artistic graffiti with the collar turned up. Alright, so maybe I look down on them a little, but I don't go around ripping their shirts off or anything (I might mess up their hair or make-up!) Different strokes for different events and all that stuff. Errm, different folks, yeah.

"This is one hell of a build-up, Martin", you're thinking. "Just get to the bloody gossip already".

Well, I'm sorry. This is about it. Like the Collingwood football team I'm going to take you right to the end, then leave you empty handed. A Norm Smith equivalent, though, in recognition for your dedication in reading this far though: I got invited to a ball; I said no with plenty of sarcasm; inviter got offended. For the sake of the person's feelings and group harmony I'm not going to go post the emailed exchange verbatim, but here's an excerpt:


J: i'll do you the favour of making your life easier and stop inviting you out altogether, as there will always be some sort of alcohol presence whenever uni students go out, which to you is clearly unbearable and unacceptable

M: To spin a well-worn record (though you may not have heard this mix): I don't like paying for alchohol.

Let me rewind that for you *wikky-wa, wikky-wiky-wa*

I don't like paying for alchohol. Here's the bridge: So, if we can go somewhere where I don't have to pay for alchohol, I'm happy to wander along. But, when I'm forced into doing so by the very nature of the event, I'll say no. Coz (Chorus): I don't like paying for alchohol.

Break it down, yo.