Friday, August 29, 2008

Exam 08 results pt. 1

Another semester, another round of results. Most of them, anyway – I'm still waiting for my Public Economics exam to be graded.

The other subjects I took last semester were Environmental Resource Accounting & Sustainability Reporting, The Economics of Innovation & the Life Sciences, and a seminar on The Private Provision of Public Goods.

Environmental Resource Accounting & Sustainability Reporting, or Umweltökonomische Gesamtrechnungen und Nachhaltigkeitsberichterstattungen (UGR), was environmental follow-up to the National Income Accounting class I took last semester. I've decided that this area (Economic and Social Statistics) will be my major, so this was the second of three subjects I'm taking in this field. The third, Socioeconomic Resource Accounting Internationally, is up this coming semester.
Essentially UGR is about quantifying the Environment in a statistically sound manner that can be integrated into the National Income Accounts (e.g. GDP) to give a more complete picture of an economy's operation. Example: Company A produces goods and, say, pollutes a river. To clean up the river, filters costing 100,000€ need to be installed. Net effect = GDP rises by 100,000€ – even though all that's been done is to restore the environment to its previous state.
There's heaps of other stuff, and I'm really quite into the subject, but it's late and you probably don't care all that much so I'll skip the rest. I could ramble on about it for hours though, totally love it.
Anyway, so this was the same Prof. whose exam I managed to ace last semester, and with many of the same people in the course there were expectations (not least from myself) on me to repeat my stellar performance. I ended up getting... 1,3. I recent found an explanation of the marking scale, which goes something like
  • 1,0 = excellent
  • 2,0 = good
  • 3,0 = satisfactory
  • 4,0 = acceptable
  • 5,0 = fail
with +0,3 or -0,3 being given for a slightly better/worse performance (0,7 and 4,3 aren't possible).
As such, a 1,3 is pretty awesome, and I'm probably the only person in the entire class who would be unhappy with that mark, but I kind of am. I was really gunning for that second 1,0, but I knew even as I took the exam that it wasn't as easy as the previous semester. Ah well. Given that I my exam preparation took place over the course of only 2.5 days, I shouldn't be too hard on myself ;-)

Second subject, although it was actually the first subject chronologically speaking, was the Economics of Innovation and Life Sciences. This was all about, well, Innovation – inventions, research & development, technology, patents, intellectual property rights – all that sort of stuff. Should companies be granted patents on the drugs they develop? For how long? Might they be better off simply keeping the formula secret – patents mean disclosure, after all. Coke never patented their recipe, and they're still going strong. Very very interesting, but a very strange subject as far as the organisation went. We had to read about 100 pages each week, which is a hell of a lot for one subject! I must have spent 60%-70% of my time learning just for this one blasted course, because the literature was necessary to write the one-page essays we had to hand in each week, written about the lecture of the previous week. Then there was the mid-semester exam that didn't get marked before the end of term, and the weekly tute presentation on an innovation assigned to us, the marks for which we also weren't given, so that at the end of the semester I had no idea where I stood. With zero feedback it was hard to plan my revision, and, even though I'm usually pretty bloody good at predicting how an exam went, I honestly had no idea in this case.
It ended up being a 2,0, which is good. I'm happy because it gets averaged together with a subject in which I scored a 1,0, so 1,5, then that gets rounded up to straight 1 for that particular subject category – hurrah!

My first seminar, The Private Provison of Public Goods: Empirical Studies, was also pretty cool. The way seminars work here (at least in the Economics and Social Sciences Faculty) is that there is a general topic (The PP of PG), and everyone chooses/gets assigned sub-topics to do with that theme. I chose empirics, because I'd done Microeconometrics the semester before and wanted to keep my hand in the game.

Veering off topic a little bit: Nobel Laureate (that means he won a Nobel Prize) James Heckman recently did a little (4-page) study in which he econometrically studies the effects of prayer on the attitude of (a) Higher Being(s). Result (and I quote): A little prayer does no good and may make things worse. Much prayer helps a lot.
It's pretty awesome, you should check it out (despite the stats): http://ftp.iza.org/dp3636.pdf I consider it the Nobel Laureate version of telling jokes. I'm expecting Amartya Sen to reply next month with a study regressing productivity against heroin consumption. (Thanks to Chris Danne for putting me on to this, btw.)

Anyway, where was I – the seminar, right. So, everyone gets a topic, and writes a 4,000* word essay. We get one 45 minute consultation period with our supervisor on how we're going, then after two or three months we (at least here, this is necessarily the case across the board) we send our essay to another person doing the lecture, and receive one in turn. We critique that person's essay, both in the form of a 1,000 word essay and verbally. The verbal critiques occur on one or two or three days, depending on how many people there are, on which each person also has to present their own essay to the class. The idea is you learn everything about the topic from people's presentations, get feedback on your own written work from a fellow student, then the class (mainly the Professor and the supervisors) pick apart your presentation, then you have a few days to adjust your essay before handing it in.

I wrote a pretty good essay, and was quite pleased with it before the talk I gave. My talk also went relatively well, expect for three things:
1) I was first up after lunch (in a warm, stuffy room)
2) I was presenting statistics
3) I was doing it in English
I didn't have to do it in English – it just plain never occurred to be to do it in German! The literature was in English, my essay was in English, and every week in a different subject (the Eco of Innovation & etc) I was giving presentation that did have to be in English, so I just went with it. Anyway, I packed a whooole lot of stuff in, trying to explain all the results to everyone, and not just what they meant but how they got there and the criticisms and I had to speak slowly and clearly and... well, it went alright.
Actually it must have gone quite well, because a few days later the Professor from the seminar, Timo Goeschl, asked if I wanted to hold some of the tutes for the introductory first-year economics class this semester. He didn't just pick me from that one talk, obviously, I've taken three other lectures by him, but I was pretty chuffed anyway. So I'll be first-year tutor this semester, hurrah!
Okay, after all that, I ended up with a 1,3 in this seminar, which I'm quite proud of. I don't know whether I'm prouder of that or being asked to tutor, but both are pretty cool.

I may as well give a prediction on the Public Economics mark, seeing as I've lauded myself earlier about my abilities in that regard. I didn't have a great deal of motivation to study for this class, since the other half of the subject I'd written a 4,0 (my very first exam in Germany) and to get an average of higher than 3 I would need to absolutely ace this exam (as in 1,0). Since that wasn't going to happen, I kinda coasted; but the exam was easier than I expected, so I'm thinking somewhere between 2,3 and 3,0. Actually, I heard around the traps that a lot of people did so poorly on the exam they're thinking of marking it up, so perhaps I'll get a 2,0. But I think a 2,3 or a 2,7 would be more in line with what I deserve.

Alright, beddy-byes – I'm off to another Bundesliga-match tomorrow, and need some rest so I can convincingly pretend to work all day beforehand ;-)


*okay, I'm being totally inconsisten with my commas here. Previously, with the marks, they were supposed to be decimal points: 1,3 = 1.3 Here, they're the separator for the thousands. 4,000 = 4 thousand. Fucking English-German mish-mash... sorry.

----------------
Now playing: The Herd - The World Keeps Turning

No comments: