A friend asks:
I did a piece last year on the economic benefits of paid organ donation schemes. I was just wondering if you had encountered this topic at all. I couldn't find an economic reason to oppose it.
I only just tossed off an answer, but I thought the topic interesting enough to preserve:
I haven't come across any studies of paid organ donation schemes, no.
The biggest economic problem I can think of is that it's paying people to do what 'right' anyway. If that sounds totally non-economisty, let me rephrase it: markets provide an extrinsic incentive, via payment. However, many – most – things also have an intrinsic value: "pride in your work"; "the satisfaction of a job well done"; the respect of others; the comfort of following your morals.* If you focus too strongly on extrinsic motivation – performance-related pay is a good example – you remove intrinsic motivation, and intrinsic motivation is a MUCH stronger force than extrinsic.
So a (possible) problem with paid organ donation schemes, depending on how they're set up, is that you may begin by supplementing your 'free' pool of donations with paid donations, but you end up having to pay everyone as payment becomes the prime motivator for donation.
Better, IMO, are non-monetary schemes to increase intrinsic motivation or overcome barriers to action: make organ donation opt-out, for example, rather than opt it. Marketing, awareness campaigns, stuff like that. Create a culture of giving, rather than a culture of 'pay me to do something good for other people'.
* Interesting side note: happiness studies have found people with strong (not strict; more, 'well-defined') moral codes are likelier to be happy than people with weak or no morals. The speculated reason is that acting in accordance with your morals lets you feel good about yourself (in addition to however good the activity makes you feel), while not having morals mean you get the benefit of the activity.
The biggest economic problem I can think of is that it's paying people to do what 'right' anyway. If that sounds totally non-economisty, let me rephrase it: markets provide an extrinsic incentive, via payment. However, many – most – things also have an intrinsic value: "pride in your work"; "the satisfaction of a job well done"; the respect of others; the comfort of following your morals.* If you focus too strongly on extrinsic motivation – performance-related pay is a good example – you remove intrinsic motivation, and intrinsic motivation is a MUCH stronger force than extrinsic.
So a (possible) problem with paid organ donation schemes, depending on how they're set up, is that you may begin by supplementing your 'free' pool of donations with paid donations, but you end up having to pay everyone as payment becomes the prime motivator for donation.
Better, IMO, are non-monetary schemes to increase intrinsic motivation or overcome barriers to action: make organ donation opt-out, for example, rather than opt it. Marketing, awareness campaigns, stuff like that. Create a culture of giving, rather than a culture of 'pay me to do something good for other people'.
* Interesting side note: happiness studies have found people with strong (not strict; more, 'well-defined') moral codes are likelier to be happy than people with weak or no morals. The speculated reason is that acting in accordance with your morals lets you feel good about yourself (in addition to however good the activity makes you feel), while not having morals mean you get the benefit of the activity.

3 comments:
It's important to note that, interesting as the theoretical possibility is, whether there is substantial crowding out of intrinsic motivation when extrinsic benefits are provided is an empirical question and one that might have completely different answers in different settings (norms are tricky things...). For what it's worth, here's the latest and best empirical study on _blood_ donations (I don't know of anything about organ donations but would be very interested): http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2011/12/rewarding-altruism-blood-for-money.html
I fully agree, Toby: this is undoubtedly an empirical question. Thanks for the link to the Lacetera, Macis, and Slonim study – my previous understanding has been more along the lines of Frey & Oberholzer-Gee (1997).
A quick scan of recent literature finds a number of experiments that conclude there are crowding out effects or aversion to for monetary (but not necessarily non-monetary) rewards, and that the effects are larger in women – e.g. [1], [2], [3]
Lacetera et al.'s new work, however, (as opposed to Lacetera & Macis' at [3]) is certainly larger and more comprehensive. Fascinating stuff.
http://sjp.sagepub.com/content/39/2/156.abstract
This was the article I referred to prior, Omar et al 2011. Sorry if you can't access the full record.
He proposed instead of direct financial payments there could be an option for example, for the state to contribute towards the deceased donors funeral costs.
I certainly believe that there would be very few refusals if we're taking $50-100K, especially if it is a heart or liver where the donor is deceased. But I'm just basing that on rational behaviour which is often lacking.
Post a Comment