I was musing that the further I looked into how the private health insurance rebate (and Medicare high-income levy) work, the weirder the incentive structures got. Some friends asked me to elaborate, so here goes:
Your basic tax-welfare compact is that you pay tax, and the government uses that to provide a range of services – including, in this case, health care. The amount of tax you pay varies depending on your level of income, while the services you're entitled to are – generally speaking – the same for everyone. So your level of tax shouldn't affect the level of services to which you're entitled. And underpinning Australia's universal health care system is the idea that everyone 'deserves' health care, even if they can't afford to pay for it themselves.
However, not all services are created equal. For example, everyone can drive on public roads for free. However, you may not be satisfied with the roads the government is offering you – perhaps too many other people use them, or they don't go where you want to go. You are free to go purchase extra, private services, such as toll roads. You still, however, keep your entitlement to use government services.
Now, replace "roads" with "health care". The government supplies everyone with a particular range of health care services, but the system can get overcrowded and may not cover what you want covered, so people who value health care – like people who value travelling on roads – are free to go off and purchase private services.
The big difference is that the government actively encourages some Australians not to use its services, but to instead use the private alternatives. It effectively pays them, by taxing them less. Who gets this encouragement? People who value health services? No: people with high incomes.
That's right: if you're on a high income (>$70k for singles) and you take out PHI, you effectively get money from the government by avoiding a levy. If you earn less than that, but you value health care highly enough that you take out PHI, you get no tax breaks.
That's a little weird.
So now we have this strange incentive system that assumes all high-income earners value health care and subsidises their use, instead of, say, assigning each person an amount of health care funding for a limited range of services regardless of where they go, and letting them purchase extra services if and when they choose. (Which would make it like our road system. Or like the way our education should work, but doesn't. But that's a different gripe.) The closest we come to giving everyone choice-independent health care funding is the PHI rebate, which pays for a portion of the health care costs for everyone who chooses the private rather than the public system
That's the current situation. Here's what's changing: the PHI rebate will be means-tested, which means fewer high-income people will get it. And, the Medicare surcharge for high-income earners is increasing – this is the levy high-income earners can avoid by taking out PHI. So we're reducing the choice-independent funding for high-income earners at the same time the incentive for high-income earners to take out PHI is increasing – why??
A point I'm indebted to Henry Ergas for (he also uses a road analogy, though I swear I thought of mine independently) is that the more you encourage people to take up PHI by offering them tax breaks, the less responsive they are to the actual costs of that health care: their incentives are being distorted. Less responsiveness to prices makes it more likely prices will rise, so that people who value health highly but are price-sensitive – lower-income people – will be less likely to take out PHI, and our health care system stratifies further. And, given that almost all high-income people take out PHI, means-testing the rebate is basically hidden progressive taxation. While I'm in favour of progressive taxation, hiding it isn't a great thing.
All of this makes me far more ambivalent about this reform than I was. I still don't think I'm fully across the topic, but it appears clear these health care reforms are at best okay, and at worst magnify pre-existing distortions. There are better reforms.
(My thoughts on this issue were prompted by this Stephen King piece – worth reading the comments. See also King's earlier piece.)
[Edited on 15/02/12 for clarity.]
[Edited on 15/02/12 for clarity.]

No comments:
Post a Comment