Thursday, May 26, 2011

Cross-post: Robust Response to Climate Change Risk and Uncertainty

When I started working my "climate change is about risk" paper, I was driven to try and bring some of the issues involved into the public arena, because I don't think they get enough of a run. (Understandably, perhaps – risk and uncertainty aren't sexy top[ics.) I wrote a short, tight opinion piece, with invaluable advice from an ex-colleague and communication professional, Nicole Trick Steinbach. Since it was my first attempt at an op-ed, I also ran it past a few colleagues, which resulted in some good tips but also took ages. Finally, I gave it to my department's media office, who attempted to "place" it with a newspaper or similar.

Sadly, they failed, but in the interim I'd started writing for New Matilda, and when they asked me to comment on the latest update on climate change science from the Australian Climate Change Commission earlier this week, I decided that would be a good chance to recycle the article. It was published yesterday, and I reproduce it, below:

Risk Rising, Uncertainty Falling

The suggestion by sceptics that we should not act on climate change because the science is uncertain is at odds with sensible management of risk and uncertainty, writes environmental economist Martin Jones

Australia needs a robust response to climate change that explicitly recognises risk and uncertainty to make us more resilient to the range of possible future situations. Coverage of the Australian Climate Commission’s science update, The Critical Decade, and an interim report into Public Risk Perceptions, Understandings, and Responses to Climate Change in Australia and Great Britain have made it clear that this issue is still not fully understood.

Doing nothing in response to climate change exposes us to uncertainty: it is betting that what we currently have is able to cope with whatever the future throws at us. Like choosing clothes for a week-long trip based on today’s weather, it may work – but it would make more sense to prepare by a) finding out what the weather is forecast to be; and b) packing clothes that can adapt to all sorts of weather, in case the predictions are wrong. (Melburnians know all about this.)

Uncertainty should be distinguished from risk: risk is the combination of the likelihood of an (unwanted) event occurring and the severity of its consequences. Where the likelihood or severity are not precisely known, the predictions can be expressed in terms of probabilities; when the Climate Commission talks about “1-in-100 year events” (such as floods), they are describing risk, just as a meteorologist’s “chance of rain” describes risk.

Uncertainty is when we don’t know the risks; when we don’t know how probable an event is. (Some would argue that this describes meteorologists, but let’s be kind.) When opponents of action against climate change argue that there is “uncertainty around climate change”, they are technically correct – but it’s not that we don’t know that it’s going to get worse; we just don’t know how much worse it’s going to get.

An example is the Climate Commission’s projection of global average sea-level rises of 0.5 to 1.0 metre in 2100 compared to 1990, which would result in an increased frequency (higher risk) of high sea-level events (floods) in coastal areas. The Commission openly admits that uncertainty surrounds this figure, but that simply means we do not currently know which areas will have five, which will have ten, and which will have 100 times as many high-sea level events, not that this increase won’t occur.

If I belabour this point, it is because 56% of Australians recently surveyed by Griffith University and Cardiff University about their risk perceptions agree that the effects of climate change are uncertain, and 42% are unsure about or disagree with the notion of scientific consensus on climate change. (Source (PDF), Appendix Questions 12i, 12j, 28)  As The Critical Decade points out (PDF):
  • On a timescale of multiple decades to centuries, the Earth is warming, and at a very fast rate by geological standards. There is no doubt about this statement.
  • Human emissions of greenhouse gases are the primary factor triggering observed climate change since at least the mid 20th century. The IPCC attached 90% certainty to that statement in 2007; research over the past few years has strengthened our confidence in this statement even more.
  • Many uncertainties surround projections of the particular risks that climate change poses for human societies and natural and managed ecosystems, however, the number and magnitude of climate risks will rise as the climate warms further.
More positively, the Griffith/Cardiff University study (PDF) found that 71% of Australian respondents were personally convinced that climate change is really happening”; 90% believed that human activities were playing a causal role in climate change; 66% reported that they were “very concerned” or “fairly concerned” about climate change; and less than 6% of respondents could be characterised as being disbelievers or strong sceptics with respect to the reality of current climate change and/or the causal role of human activities and environmental impacts.

So what to do? When you know what the future will be (or can accurately predict it), taking a “big bet” of action or inaction will bring the biggest payoff – but only if the bet is correct. Under uncertainty, a robust strategy is better: one that has an acceptable outcome regardless of what happens by hedging against possible futures (even if that outcome isn’t as good as if we’d guessed correctly). Robust strategy is generally adaptable, and involves building the capability (technological, political, and institutional) to recognise the signs that we need to react and to do so quickly. 

The Australian Defence Force (ADF) is an example of robust policy: though we have no certainty about the location, timing, or nature of future conflicts, the ADF maintains a range of units and institutions with different capabilities to be able to respond quickly with whatever strategy is most appropriate. The wait-and-see approach, on the other hand, is more akin to New South Wales’ action on infrastructure, where little is done until the system is at breaking point and fixing it will take years.

The suggested course of (in)action – business as usual – from those who claim there is doubt about climate change is thus at odds with sensible management of risk and uncertainty. When you're uncertain, you prepare by hedging your bets, not by taking a punt on the non-occurrence of catastrophe.

The more certain we are that dangerous climate change is occurring – and The Critical Decade is more certain than any report before it –, the more we should invest in anticipatory measures such as emissions reduction or adaptive measures to cope with the foreseen changes. The less certain we are, the more we should explore reactive measures that allow us to improve our level of knowledge (e.g. through environmental science) and act quickly once we have become certain (e.g. through environmental technologies, similar to those encouraged by the innovation programs scrapped a few months ago by the Gillard Government). But doing little or nothing about climate change is a course we should take only if we are completely certain that climate change is NOT occurring. And less than 6% of Australians believe that.

Regardless of your view on the correct level of a carbon price, having an appropriate emissions trading scheme gives us the crucial capability to control emissions, should we need to. Effective technological and innovation policy can give the capability to reduce or even reverse CO2e emissions, should we need to, and a sensible combination of an ETS, technology programs, and other policies will be more robust than any of these alone. Given the time lags inherent in the climate system, reducing our scientific, technological, political, and institutional response times is especially valuable; so, too, is the “learning-by-doing” effect. These strategies benefit us simply by protecting us against uncertainty, even if the worst-case scenarios don’t come to pass – and especially if they do.

Both proponents and sceptics view the risks and uncertainties involved in climate change with concern. Let’s deal with that uncertainty by implementing robust policies to secure Australia’s future under all foreseeable eventualities.



Several of the <6% have come out to comment on the piece. My favourite so far is the guy who calls carbon pricing an "unproven energy and market experiment" (as if the EU and New Zealand didn't exist), and claims that 10% of the "carbon tax money go round" will be "syphoned (sic) off to the UN". I actually laughed out loud at that.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Environment NSW versus Common Sense

As everyone does at some point, I have some chemical waste of which to dispose (batteries and fluoro lightbulbs). Being a good little greenie, I asked the New South Wales Environment Department what the recommended procedure is:


Dear Environment NSW,

I have a handful of old batteries and the odd fluorescent lightbulb of which I wish to dispose. Would you please inform me how I can best go about this?

I live in Surry Hills and work in Randwick.

Regards,
Martin Jones


Hi Martin

You can take it to the Household Chemical Cleanout (HCC) and the two remaining locations/dates for this half of the year are listed in the attachment – one at Meadowbank and one at Mt Ku-ring-gai. If these are not suitable there will be another round in the second half of the year but we will not have that information till June. You can either give us a call on 131 555 or check the link again:

http://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/households/CleanoutGuide.htm

Regards
B.
Information Centre
Office of Environment and Heritage
T: 1300 361 967  F: 9995 5911
info@environment.nsw.gov.au

Hello B.,

Thanks for the response.

Is the only option to safely dispose of batteries and lightbulbs really to travel 20km (or more) on a specific day? That's ridiculous! I mean, I'm 10 minutes from the city – are there no permanent drop-off points anywhere in the CBD or eastern suburbs?

Regards,
Martin Jones


Hi Martin

I understand that IKEA accept both batteries & compact fluro tubes for recycling. The bins are located near the exits at all their stores. This is a service for customers who have purchased those products from Ikea but they accept products purchased elsewhere too - as so far they're not overwhelmed by excessive volumes. It would be best to give them a call first to see if they are still doing this.

Participating Battery World stores will also collect rechargeable batteries. To find out if Battery World near you is collecting batteries, call 13 17 60 or visit www.batteryworld.com.au.

B.


 There you have it – I can travel several suburbs on a particular day, rely on the goodwill of retailers, or throw the damn things in the bin. "97% of batteries end up in general waste", laments the Environment NSW website. No bloody wonder!

[UPDATE]
A flyer at my local library – that's right! I went to a real life, bricks-and-mortar library! It was so nostalgic – tells me my local council is having collection in a neighbouring suburb... in July. I doubt it's going to get much better than this, but frankly, it's a fucking joke. Put a little bin up at the local Town Hall or something, for Pete's sake – EVERYBODY DISPOSES OF LIGHBULBS AND BATTERIES, you pack of knobs. Aaargh!

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

What does the typical Australian earn?

I'm a few days late on this one (I was on holiday), and apparently it's been all over the internet (and even on ABC News24), but it's good enough that I want to post it here anyway: an economist I follow on Twitter, Matt Cowgill, has written a very good post about the income of the typical Australian.

Not only does Matt go through the concepts of which measure of income is most appropriate – for example, how using the average income of full-time workers is inappropriate, because the very rich distort the average and the "typical" Australian doesn't work full-time –, he crunches the numbers; something I've always wanted, but have been too lazy to do. So I am very happy that he's done it :-)

Matt's post is worth reading in full, but here are the highlights:
  • Average weekly ordinary time earnings (AWOTE) for full time adults: $66 445 (2010)
  • Median earnings of all full time workers: $54 750 (2010)
  • Median earnings of all employees: $44 146 (2010)
  • Median earnings of all Australian taxpayers: $44 222 (2008-09)
  • Median gross household income: $67 003 (2007-08)
  • Median equivalised disposable household income: $36 082 (2007-08)
The last two figures deserve a little explanation: "households" is reasonably intuitive (broadly speaking, it's all the people who live together), and "median equivalised disposable household income" basically adjusts household income depending on how many people are in the household. To quote Matt:
[A] single person, living alone, would need around $36 000 in disposable income to sustain the typical Australian’s standard of living. Following a widely-accepted methodology, each additional adult adds $18 000 to this figure, so a childless couple would need a disposable income of $54 000 a year to enjoy a median standard of living. Each child adds $10 800 to this figure. A couple family with two children would therefore have needed $75 600 disposable income in 2007-08 to have the same standard of living as the typical Australian.

    Thursday, April 28, 2011

    "Paid leave" is simply salary smoothing

    I've mentioned on this blog before that I, though I thoroughly enjoy work, I also value my free time quite highly, and for years have told myself I'd be the sort of person who would try and get more vacation days instead of more pay, necessarily. A few more idle thoughts on the topic came to me this afternoon:

    Under current employment law (presumably for most of the western world), it's possible to have a high nominal salary and little leave but to essentially "buy" more time off by taking unpaid leave. This, however, depends on your employer approving said leave; depending on your employer, this could be difficult.

    What if, in your employment contract, you stipulated the right to unpaid leave? One or two weeks per year, say – the idea would be to make it as close to paid leave in treatment as possible, except without actually receiving any money. (Perhaps make it non-accruing between years would make it easier for employers to accept, too.)

    The thrust of my idea is to make the concept of unpaid leave more palatable; at the moment I still get the sense that many people (both employers and employees) treat it as something to be avoided, or at least a far worse alternative than paid leave.

    That whole thinking is wrong-headed though, to me. Look at it this way: if you're earning a salary of, say, $72'000 per year with four weeks paid leave, what you are actually doing is selling 48 weeks of work to your employer for $1'500 a week, but your employer is spreading that $72'000 out over 52 weeks instead of 48. The exact same effect could be achieve if you had a nominal annual salary of $78'000 with no paid leave (so still at $1,500 per week), and took four weeks of unpaid leave.

    The point: You're not actually being paid to take a holiday; "paid leave" is just unpaid leave with salary payment smoothing.

    But let's come back to my right to unpaid leave idea: one of the reasons "paid" leave accrues is that it's generally recognised and accepted that people can't just work all year – they need some time off for recovery. If an employee doesn't take leave, eventually the paid leave they accrue becomes such a liability on their employer's books that they can be forced (or at least strongly encouraged) to take that leave. (SAP did this during the great crash/global financial crisis in 2008, as I'm sure did many other companies.) So paid leave is, in a sense, the "minimum" amount of rest you want an employee to have. (This is obviously an incomplete treatment, but never mind.)

    Unpaid leave, on the other hand, is an option. You can take it, but you don't have to. You can choose to earn money, or you can choose to receive (or, rather, not sell) your time. So, while increasing the amount of paid leave in my contract would increase the minimum level of time off I should take, giving me the right (but not obligation) to unpaid leave would let me choose whether to work or not, and – this is the important bit – make it easier to get that unpaid leave approved.

    Ever the economist, I figured out what salary reduction you (should) take into account for this unpaid leave (based on my reasoning, above):
    Salary reduction = (new leave – old leave) * (old salary / [one year - old leave])
    If and when I get the chance to test my thinking out in contract negotiations, I'll let you know the result :-)

    Wednesday, April 27, 2011

    Best-known line from a porno? (AKA Warum liegt hier überhaupt Stroh 'rum?"

    Pornographic films are famous for the generally poor standard of their dialogue. However, one German film has an exchange so absurd that it's become a cult hit:

    The dialogue, roughly translated, is as follows:
    Her: So, this is the wiring box we keep having trouble with. If you could take a look.
    Him: Hmm, sure, but why is there straw lying around here, anyway?
    Her: And why have you got a mask on?
    Him: Mhm, pff, well why don't you suck me off?

    The scene is so ridiculous that the phrase "Warum liegt hier überhaupt Stroh 'rum?" ("Why is there straw lying around here, anyway?") quickly entered German pop culture, to the extent that it's referenced in newspaper headlines. (Though the TAZ is a bit more edgy than most German newspapers.)

    Which got me thinking: is there an English-language equivalent? Is there a phrase from an English-language porno that would be widely recognised outside the community of those who watch a lot of porn?

    I asked @HilltopHoods – because, after all, what is Twitter for if not asking the biggest Australian hip-hop group of the last decade to name the most well-known line in porn –, and they suggested "So I have the job?"
    That's not bad, and certainly a very common phrase (err, so I hear), but I reckon "I'm here to clean ze pool" is probably even better for a) recognition amongst non-porn watchers and b) being a phrase you wouldn't commonly hear.

    Neither, though, really has the bizarre quality of the German line. But if you come across a contender, let me know :-)

    Work should be the thing you prefer to unproductive pleasure

    A chap called Paul Graham has as some excellent advice on how to do what you love. I've only just read it, but the principle is one I've been following since high school, when I started to choose my university subjects (and now jobs) primarily on the basis of what I liked doing. I'd love to expand more on this, but I want to get to something I love even more – football training ;-)

    Here's an excerpt:

    It used to perplex me when I read about people who liked what they did so much that there was nothing they'd rather do. There didn't seem to be any sort of work I liked that much. If I had a choice of (a) spending the next hour working on something or (b) be teleported to Rome and spend the next hour wandering about, was there any sort of work I'd prefer? Honestly, no.

    But the fact is, almost anyone would rather, at any given moment, float about in the Carribbean, or have sex, or eat some delicious food, than work on hard problems. The rule about doing what you love assumes a certain length of time. It doesn't mean, do what will make you happiest this second, but what will make you happiest over some longer period, like a week or a month.

    Unproductive pleasures pall eventually. After a while you get tired of lying on the beach. If you want to stay happy, you have to do something.

    As a lower bound, you have to like your work more than any unproductive pleasure. You have to like what you do enough that the concept of "spare time" seems mistaken. Which is not to say you have to spend all your time working. You can only work so much before you get tired and start to screw up. Then you want to do something else—even something mindless. But you don't regard this time as the prize and the time you spend working as the pain you endure to earn it.

    My favourite (wonk) things

    For reasons of which I'm not entirely sure, I came up with this little verse yesterday:


    Resource rent taxes, emissions reduction;
    Sovereign wealth funds, NBN construction;
    Henry's review, letting refugees in;
    These are few of my favourite things.

    More public transport and Oz: The Republic;
    Welfare for jobless not middle-class yuppies;
    Euthanasia and plain cigs packaging;
    These are few of my favourite things.

    When the polls bite, when lobbies sting, when I’m feeling sad;
    I’ll simply go on Q&A or Lateline, then I won’t feel so bad.


    My mate Wes then suggested we form The Australian Moderate Party ("The Mods" for short) and enter politics. The advertisement campaigns virtually right themselves.

    Australia's democratic pricing of CO2e

    A comment on the whole "Julia Gillard promised there would be no carbon tax before the election, therefore a carbon tax is undemocratic" tripe:

    The Australian Labor Party has a mandate to price carbon (dioxide and other greenhouse gases) – that we should be able to agree on; it's been part of their policy since pre-2007. We should also be able to agree that the act of putting a price on carbon is a bigger deal than the form that pricing mechanism takes.

    Now, if a majority Labor Government broke its promise on the form of pricing carbon, there might be a strong case to object – but Australia doesn't have a majority Labor Government. As a minority Government, Labor's "mandate" is conditional on what is acceptable to its (informal) coalition partners, the independents and the Greens. This is all perfectly within the bounds of democracy, and is utterly commonplace anywhere that has experience with coalitions (even with the National and Liberal Party coalition on occasion).

    So if you want to price carbon in a particular way, but you won't be able to price carbon at all unless you do it in a different way, is that undemocratic? Not at all – unless you think that the elected representatives of >50% of the voting population agreeing to do something is undemocratic.

    Basically: Gillard's not breaking her promise, because she has no power to keep her promise – but she can keep the most important part of her promise (the act of pricing carbon, if not the form) by compromising and cooperating with others. That, right there, is democracy.

    Thursday, April 21, 2011

    The landlord cometh (uninvited)

    I was running a little (well, quite) late for work today, and as I was brushing my teeth in the bathroom I heard the landlord open and walk through my front door. When he noticed I was there, he exited, shut the door, knocked, then asked if the Foxtel guy with him could gain access to my balcony. (Apparently my downstairs neighbours have Foxtel, but I don't – at least that I know of.)

    This is weird, right? Landlords aren't supposed to – allowed to – enter my apartment with notice or permission, are they? At least as far as I can tell from this Tenants NSW factsheet. I now wonder on how many other occasions he's been in my apartment without my knowledge or consent. 

    Last week the Eastside Realty office rang to ask whether I were happy for handymen to come it to do some work on my bathroom to stop it leaking into the downstairs apartment (I was), and I could understand if the landlord were to enter if, say, the situation had worsened and downstairs were flooding. But this was just to show the Foxtel guy my satellite dish! And the landlord obviously assumed that I wasn't home.

    In fact, when I mentioned the work on the bathroom to him (whatever white paste was laid down over the grouting is peeling off since my shower doesn't drain properly), he told me he was planning on replacing the shower tiles later today. First I've heard of it! 

    Troubling.

    [UPDATE: 22/04/2011]
    I had a chat to the landlord today, and he says it was the Foxtel guy who entered first, not him. Since I didn't see who entered (just heard someone enter), I'm willing to accept this explanation. It doesn't make the incident okay, necessarily, but I'm not worried about how often the landlord's been sneaking in my premises any more. 

    Tuesday, April 05, 2011

    ANU Crawford School conference: Australia's Climate Policy Options

    I went to my first conference last Thursday, which I found very exciting. It was about "Australia's Climate Policy Options" and was being held by the Crawford School at the Australian National University (ANU) in Canberra. One could quibble and call it my second conference, since my very first task when I started my current job was to organise an event featuring many of the people who attended Thursday's event, but ours had the character of a workshop rather than full-blown conference; the ANU event was much larger, and was primarily speeches with panel discussions rather than actual workshopping.

    According to my colleagues, one of the big purposes of conferences in networking. Yes, you go to hear the speakers, ask questions, and engage in discussions, but a big attraction is also the time spent during breaks and afterwards mingling with the other attendees and building contacts. This is not something I've traditionally been good at; as a natural introvert, I usually don't go out of my way to meet people. Not to mention that striking up a conversation with a luminary in one's field when one is just starting out is daunting for most people. 

    However, you have to start somewhere, right? I figured that the worst that could come of it was that I'd have the day off work, hear some interesting talks, put a few faces to names, and build a foundation for one day being able to broach a conversation with, "You look familiar – did I see you at XYZ conference?"

    I got a little beyond that minimum goal, which was nice. Aside from seeing these people in the flesh (and the really were quite a lot of well known names from the climate change policy area there; I won't list them all, but you might recognise a few of the speakers from my notes, below) and being introduced to a handful by my colleagues who were there (always the easiest way of making new contacts), I was able to approach a few off my own bat; I very cleverly asked them what they thought of an experiment I'm working on with a colleague – not only did I let them know what I was working on and have a topic of conversation, but I got some good tips for my own work :-)

    Aside from the conference itself, which I won't go into much more (though I will post my notes below, and over at Scribd if you like to download a PDF version), what I also found fascinating was the experience around the conference – flying down to Canberra, taking taxis, staying in a hotel, etc. This may sound really banal, but I don't remember the last time I stayed in a hotel or took a taxi by choice; when I travel I almost always stay with friends, and I get places by bike, public transport, or car. And it wasn't even so much the experience of staying in a hotel or taking a taxi that fascinated me, but the knowledge that I wasn't paying for any of it. 

    Now, I'm a thrifty bloke. The economics training has probably amplified it, but it's always been there ("typically Swabian", the Germans will say). I'm hardwired to consider the costs of things, even if I can't affect them. And, even when I'm not paying, I still consider them – at breakfast in the hotel, I pondered which option would be the better value for my (employer's) money. During the taxi trips, however,  something fascinating happened: I stopped caring. I got in the cab, told the driver where I wanted to go, and watched the meter tick over with a degree of ambivalence I've never felt before. I couldn't control it; it wasn't my money; I didn't care. "This must be what rich people feel like", I thought, and I suddenly understood the phrase "If you have to ask the price, you can't afford to buy it" a little better. The price of the service was completely irrelevant – I wanted it, so I did it.
    This insouciant approach didn't extent to anything bar the taxi rides, so I'm unlikely to get used to it (the very next day I cycled from my apartment back to the airport rather than take a cab), but it was certainly quite interesting while it lasted.

    Anyway, here are my notes from the conference:

    [UPDATE 06/04/11: Recordings and slides from the conference are now available.]

    Opening Remarks

    Tom Kompas (Director of the Crawford School of Economics), Blair Comley (Secretary of DCC&EE), Will Steffen (Executive Director, ANU Climate Change Institute)
    Chaired by Frank Jotzo (Director of Centre for Climate Economics and Policy)

    BC: We all talk within our own communities, and infer from this how the rest of the world thinks about the climate problem. Industry and green groups will therefore have vastly different, but equally sincere beliefs about the prevailing view.

    Is the world acting? Some people apply the following tests:
    Test one: do we have a top-down, legally-binding international agreement? Sub-set of test one: is there an absolute emissions reduction target for every country?
    Test two: does every country have an emissions trading scheme or explicit carbon tax? (Ignores some countries' existing preference for command & control measures based on past successful experience.)
    These analytical frameworks aren't the ones these same people apply to domestic policy. E.g. They will argue that Australia reducing emissions by 5% from 2000 is a big effort because of the difference to BAU. This is true – but why doesn't this argument apply to other countries?

    Just because assessing countries' different efforts (the implicit prices) is difficult doesn't mean we shouldn't attempt it. (Acknowledges Cameron Hepburn from Vivid Economics and the work they're doing.)

    Question from audience: Are Australians happy to be followers; to wait until China acts?
    BC: Doesn't want to directly address leading/following. But international action is good for comparing analytical frameworks and building trust: Monitoring, Reporting, Verification is critical. We trust our own data, but not always that in other countries.

    WS: General remarks about the ANU centre.

    Q: Problems of independent advisors and their role in the public debate.
    WS: He's had bigger problems dealing with the media than the public, Government, or industry groups. The media are the weak chain; twisting things, false use of the "balance" principle.


    Carbon pricing & Australia's mitigation commitment

    Frank Jotzo, Steve Hatfield-Dodds (CSIRO Scientist, "thought leader"), Warwick McKibbin (Prof. of International Politics, RBA Board Member), John Quiggin (UQ, Economics/PolSci)
    Chaired by Salim Mazouz (Founding Director of EcoPerspectives – consulting)

    FJ: Australia's a very rich country (PPP per cap). Should remember that we are seen this way internationally. With carbon pricing and the revenue distribution, about 1% of Aus GDP is up for grabs. MPCCC model creates argument for limiting compensation because the price is fixed (i.e. no uncertainty). Fixed price originally proposed in original Garnaut report as viable second-best. (WM rebuts: says it goes back further (early 90s?).) FJ thinks it's the best way to achieve a broad-based and lasting consensus.
    If we start with a low price, we should increase it quickly; shouldn't start with a low price and low increase. Forecast EU ETS average 2013-20 = 32€ (Deutsche Bank) .
    If Australia reduces (absolute) emissions by 5% vs. 2000 levels, China will have lower emissions intensity by 2015 (under their 40-45% target).

    SHD: Understanding the "signs" of climate change (what goes up, what goes down) would do wonders for public debate. A carbon price decouple domestic emissions from the national target. (Domestic = what we emit. National = emissions less (internationally purchased) offsets.)
    Signs: Carbon emissions fall, but income rises (by less than BAU, but still a rise). Prices rise, but affordability improves.
    Average income, employment, efficiency will improve. National total and pp emissions will fall, as will investment risk. Energy prices are really the biggest thing that should cause us headaches.
    Communication: referring to the "costs" of policy risks a reference point error, triggering loss aversion. Should emphasise that incomes will not fall. Framing and reference points effect (affect?) the policy stance of 5-23% of people.
    Sign of change is more important than the magnitude in people's minds.

    WM: Making the same points since early 90s: Which price do we care about? What policy framework should we learn from? How should we allocate property rights?
    Price: Three years of certainty is not nearly enough for electricity investment. We needs to worry about the carbon price 20, 30, 40 years from now; analogous to the long-term real interest rate.
    Policy Framework: Monetary policy. Credible commitment to target over the medium-term. Pleased Garnaut has taken up the idea of a "Central Bank of Carbon." (See earlier work by McKibbin and Wilcox?) Readjusting fixed price every few years.
    Rights: Tax = revenue. Allocating (long-term) property rights can give that revenue to the market. But! No futures market for taxes. Futures markets need "things" –> property rights. Allocating property rights should be regarded as a separate issue to who trades those rights. Is against risk-free loans for companies: sees the integration of property rights into the pricing framework as important.
    Climate policy should be focussed on emissions reduction, not income redistribution; makes it more complicated.
    Has one minute left for his talk. Would be willing to trade it, but he has no property rights and there is no market ;-)

    JQ: Australia doesn't have climate policy options any more. Not going to be resolved by better communication. Has become a cultural issue. Therefore all that matter is getting a policy up that can pass both houses of Parliament. Gobs of money for lower income households hard to unwind; good idea. Heavy emitting industries had their chance a year ago and blew it when their attractive scheme failed.
    People understand that companies pass taxes on to consumers, therefore more justification for compensating households than firms.

    Q: How can we better get across a message with clear guiding principles:
    JQ: Just act. Communication won't help much any more.
    WM: Opportunity was lost some time ago. Giving households long-term rights would have been a terrific sell. Screwed it up by treating this issue as a political football. Go back to treating it as a long-term proposition.
    FJ: Agrees with JQ, but doesn't see Government giving away discretionary policy control over carbon revenues. Perhaps turn this into a tax reform issue?

    Do companies need an adequate "balance sheet effect" (free permits)?
    WM: If your price is fixed in the world market you can't pass costs on to customers (i.e. small open markets)

    Questions on policy from Richard Denniss, Andrew Leigh, and others. Clever policy, short-term vs. long-term, repealing public legislation.
    JQ: If the price is clear and positive is will be hard to unravel.
    WM: Emphasises the importance of long-term price again. Managing risk in the market.
    JQ: Disagrees with WM. Says there are plenty of markets where people invest without 40yr+ certainty. There is some bickering between the two. JQ won't look at WM.
    SHD: "Smart" policy is not the same as "first-best" – may have to accept third-best or fifth-best. Thinks short-term prices over 5-10 years can make a big difference with a lesser political battle than setting long-term prices.
    FJ: Once it's demonstrated that the sky isn't going to fall it will be difficult to undo the taxes.

    Steve's views on John's presentation; EU ETS as success story vs. FITs; measurement issues; will the conditions for emissions trading be there is 3-5 years?
    JQ: Smart economics is where prices do most of the heavy lifting. Only way to communicate is to things is to do them. What matters is the political situation, not the economic reality; in 3-5 years other countries will have moved and we'll have more trading partners. Also the prophets of doom will  have been disproven.
    WM: EU ETS shows you how you can make mistakes. Over-allocation, variability. Open question what the marginal benefit of the ETS is vs. FITs and solar subsidies. Investing in a 5th-best solution (e.g. EU common currency without credible government backing. Result: Euro about to explode) makes our life harder when we have to fix it; better to get it right now. Grateful that the Europeans are making all these mistakes for us to learn from.
    SHD: People resist uncomfortable ideas. If you don't like the idea that Government action is required to fix things, that causes you to reject science that suggests this course of action. "Cultural warriors." Industrial and fossil-fuel emissions we know very well, LULUCAF poorly known; should be different policy settings. Repeal of any scheme unlikely.
    FJ: We can mitigate by joining an international agreement, or creating our own arrangement (with local countries?).


    Garnaut Climate Change Review Update

    Ross Garnaut
    Chaired by John Quiggin

    RG: Issues that gave rise to debate in the update papers:
    Science has firmed, toward the pessimistic end of projections. We should stick to the science in peer-reviewed journals though, even if there is a publication lag, because the debate is difficult enough as it is with the current science.
    Great Crash of 2008 has changed the way we discuss economic policy.
    Very important that China and India (and other developing countries) are approaching emissions reductions, even at such low per-capita levels.
    Copenhagen fiasco: What came out what inchoate at the time, but order was given to it at Cancun. 2°C ≈ 450ppm.
    We are bending the curve from BAU. Not enough to meet 2°C, but it's a start. US heading toward its commitments.
    Emissions-intensive trade-exposed industries is a difficult, messy, but very important issue. We will seriously distort our political economy and the politics of our own policy-making if we get it wrong. Measurement is a difficult problem, but we need to devote the resources to it.
    Original purpose with electricity paper was to show that the carbon price effect on electricity would be small in comparison to the other price rises, but as he got into it he started to wonder whether the other price rises needed to be happening.
    Rubbishes the editorial in the Australian for not having read his electricity paper carefully.

    Q: Effect of carbon prices on innovation; Should we just get on with making policy or hold out for first/second-best; has your role in this debate changed - are you taking sides; can politicians superimpose themselves on the electricity regulation process?
    RG: Carbon price is not necessary for innovation, but it will be an incentive. Not enough to rely on carbon price alone, need public support. Past flawed innovation policies are no argument against this. Renewable energy targets pretty awful in encouraging innovation. Gives all the incentive to the lowest cost renewable energy rather than ... ?
    We don't have much time left to act, and we would need to see fatal flaws in a policy to avoid implementing something now that lets us improve upon it later. But we can't start again.
    Doesn't see his role in the debate as having changed; rather, others have changed their positions.


    Australian Climate Policies

    John Daley (Grattan Institute), Richard Denniss (The Australia Institute), Leo Dobes (Economist, Climate Change Adaptation)
    Chaired by Steve Hatfield-Dobbs

    JD: His is a completely inappropriate presentation for economists, since it'll tell us something that we all know: markets work better than other frameworks (grants, rebates, standards). Based on a paper coming out next week (Thursday morning?). What can help Australia meet its targets for 2020 (160 Mt below BAU)?

    Grants and rebates haven't delivered much reduction, and rebates are by far the most expensive form of CO2e reduction. Market and efficiency measures have delivered far more, and efficiency measures are cost-negative! (Similar trend for future.)
    Market measures have delivered more reductions than legislated at lower costs than expected.
    Grants struggle to spend the money. Usually less than 20% after 10 years. Bidders overpromise, Government needs to pick winning technology and firms, tender process slow, and winners often drop out if there are financial or technology problems.
    Rebates: $5 billion over last 10 years for insulation, solar PV, water heaters. Activities chosen for political popularity, reward actions that would have happened anyway.
    Efficiency is great, but slow: has taken at least 5 years to agree to regulatory standards.
    Need to talk about the fact that emissions reduction will cause us pain, but market measures are by far the best (cheapest) way to do it. That is the history of Australia over the last 15 years.
    Going after tech stuff with price schemes or FITs will be better than picking the best solar plant proposal.

    RD: "I don't have slides, so I always finish on time. Power corrupts, Powerpoint corrupts absolutely."
    Complementary policies: how can we talk about carbon prices but not about subsidies for fossil fuel industries ("Contradictory policies" – paper by Denniss and Macintosh). Why does the airline industry not pay fuel tax? First step toward complementary policies is therefore to remove the contradictory (perverse) policies. Need to have good policies. Agrees with JD about what's come before. No-one's been angrier about subsidies to solar PV than Andrew Macintosh. We'd be better off putting fake panels on people's roofs.

    LD: No-one is asking "What happens after mitigation?"
    People are using risk-management to address adaptation; presumes certain knowledge of risk, where there is none. Different strategy: absorb shocks with a resilient economy. "Socio-economic resilience" requires micro-economic reform (a "no-regret" option).
    Avoid 'climate proofing', deterministic approaches, and promote 'real-option'  thinking. Applicable to almost every sphere of activity. Can be done by individuals as well as government.
    For governments: compensation risks huge fiscal churn. Should be limited to genuine market failure.

    Q: Solar-PV was supposed to bring tech forward, not reduce CO2e; Is adaptation more important than mitigation, or just underappreciated; other schemes to encourage energy efficiency.
    JD: Solar PV program not just inefficient (which may be the wrong measure), but also ineffective – most of the money isn't given away, and the programs fall over. There are schemes to encourage business energy efficiency, but the jury is still out as to whether they're working.
    RD: PV policy goal: is it abatement? No. Is it bringing tech forward? No – Australia is far too small a market to achieve that. It's about symbolism and misunderstanding. Suggested alternative schemes: mandates. We have mandates for seatbelts, health insurance, superannuation, etc.
    LD: Obviously mitigation is necessary, but you need to think the strategy through.


    Power Sector and Land Use

    Iain MacGill (Director, CEEM), Lorraine Stephenson (Lightning Consulting Services), Andrew Macintosh (ANU Centre for Climate Law and Policy)
    Chaired by Steve Hatfield-Dodds

    IM: Most of the energy sector sits in the energy policy framework, not the climate policy framework. One framework for policy intervention is to look at correctable market failures, and the energy sector can exhibit all forms of market failure. The NEM is Australia's largest environmental externalities market.  The health costs may outweigh the operating costs!
    Not all objectives of the NEM are reflected in the market design. Lack of environmental and sustainability goals in a design choice.
    In SA we've gone from 0-20% wind in about 5 years. Market working fine.
    LS: We're not going to run out of coal and gas any time soon. Our alternatives to coal-fired power are relatively expensive in Australia. Investors will want 30-40 year regulatory certainty for new power generation assets. Should we be paying for abatement ahead of the abatement curve (i.e. paying a premium) to account for the learning effect?
    AM: We got a big freebie with the Kyoto rules on deforestation, and we'll probably make up much of our Kyoto target with that. (The reason we use 2000 as a target rather than 1990?) 50-100 Mt savings pa if we stop logging native forests. There are perverse impacts from the incentives to reforest, though, because they negatively affect the albedo (?) – so why are we crediting them?
    Perverse impacts on biodiversity, water, employment, local communities.

    Q: Why isn't the coal power industry using "co-firing"; suggestion for the compensation of power industry; is Australia likely to build more coal power plants/can we meet out power needs with renewables & gas?
    LS: Co-firing is used at about 5%, but many plants don't find it easy to do. Once you start trying to get biomass, it starts to become expensive (rather than being a free waste product). Hard to upscale. At $20 CO2e price we probably wouldn't get another coal plant without CCS (also because of politics), but we'd have to upgrade transmission infrastructure. Thinks we should compensate the current asset owners in a way that encourages them to reinvest. Also as a practical means of getting people on board: once-off, up front, lump sum compensation though, nothing ongoing.
    IM: Coal isn't a great fuel, except that it's cheap. Probably won't see new coal plants, but tough to get the old ones to leave. Iain opposes the idea of compensation, because  that implies you're correcting a wrong and taxing pollution isn't wrong. Also sends bad investment signal ("Government won't stick us with the bill.")


    International Climate Policy

    David Victor (School of International Relations, UCal. Video-link), Mark C. Lewis (Energy Research, Deutsche Bank), Cameron Hepburn (LSE/Oxford/Vivid Economics)
    Chaired by Stephen Howes (Development Policy Centre, ANU)

    DV: Updates on America
    Issues surrounding international credibility,  "Gridlock and Global Warming". Three points:
    Progress at international level and international credibility. Hasn't been much progress, and not much credibility. Price level now less important that expectations for the future. Need to spend more time at the international level getting Governments to make commitments based on what they can actually do. Respond to reality that changes in temperature will be >2°C
    Not much is happening in the USA. No expectation of action – not just the current political make-up, but also because the debate has polarised people and they are away of what's at stake (i.e. the free emissions credits). Rent-seeking is getting messy.
    But if you widen the focus, a bunch is happening on energy security, emissions from coal-fired power plants (targeting air pollution more so than CO2). Should see over 1/3rd of coal plants shut over next decade, replaced by renewables & gas. Doesn't reach Obama's Copenhagen target, but gets close.
    Picture at state level is highly variable. Northern states have cap & trade schemes, but at very low levels. Most of the action is in California e.g. cap & trade, low carbon fuel standards.
    Also moves in some places to connect to international schemes.
    If the US were to have a national carbon price scheme, it would almost certainly include some sort of trade protection; wouldn't get enough votes otherwise. Not obvious that the good approaches for such a scheme would be followed; could be deeply toxic for developing countries.

    ML: Design flaw in EU ETS: no way to modulate supply (of permits) based on changes in demand (e.g. in response to RETs). The average residual abatement (ARA) requirement is the minimum of what actually has to be reduced, after taking banked credits, CDMs, etc into account. The current ARA can probably be covered by fuel switching (coal –> gas), though this analysis was made pre-Fukushima. Increasing the level of ARA (to 30-40%) would exceed fuel-switching, so that the cost of abatement is aligned with the long-run cost of abatement (capital investment) rather than the short-run cost (fuel switching).
    Germany will probably close down 7GW of nuclear power (10% of German power production) very soon, in response to Fukushima. Nuclear power investment internationally, which already had cost problems, can probably ruled out for the next five years at least. Instead, gas prices will increase.
    Crazy that Australians bring the "Why should we move first?" argument; as if Europe doesn't exist.

    CH: Clean-tech is a structural revolution; traditional marginal cost analyses have only limited application.
    There is a massive proliferation of (different) climate change policies around the world (a large number of which are probably ineffective or "me too" policies). How can we compare them? Using implicit prices (not shadow prices). C.f. Vivid Economics / Climate Institute report. Productivity Commission is doing an update of that.

    Q:Use of international units of compliance / sale of Australian units overseas
    ML: Political reasons are the impediment, rather than state of the international carbon market.

    Why is the proposed Australian carbon price so high compared to Europe, when we can abate at much lower costs?
    CH: AU$25 is roughly equal to what the EU has now, so could be seen as an expensive place to start. But in the long run, it may not be; short-run focus may not be sensible. OTOH, Australia still has "low-hanging" fruit. How those effects balance up, and whether Australia should have a carbon price commensurate to Europe's is an open question.


    Australia's Climate Change Strategy in the Global Context

    Erwin Jackson (Climate Institute), Harry Clarke ((Micro)Economics, La Trobe Uni), Peter J Wood (Mathematics, ANU)
    Chaired by Howard Bamsey

    EJ: Australia's national interest is (should be) the strongest feasible global mitigation outcome – lower than 450ppm-e. Countries' ambition is likely to come under review in 2013-14. Legally binding outcome is end game; may reduce short term ambition, but should build longer-term confidence. Little chance of treaty in short-term. Transparency key to trust building.
    Challenge for Australia: overemphasis of UNFCCC/treaty as proxy for international action. There are heaps of separate domestic policy interventions, which is what actually reduces emissions. Need to act as if treaty exists – leap of confidence. Key elements of a pollution price package: ensure domestic transformation, act in good faith, build credible global markets, and conduct Research, Demonstration & Development (RD&D).

    HC: (How) should we rebate taxes for exporters? Border taxes theoretically better for preventing carbon leakage than free permits. But argument about instruments is silly, because effect on competitiveness is tiny. Aluminium has one of the largest effects, but it's still modest. The effects are more important from a political economy point of view (acceptability), but the noise about the economic effects is larger than the actual impact.

    PW: Climate change action as multiple-stage games.

    Q: What was your methodology, Harry? Did you look at our report?
    HC: I did, but I don't trust other people's reports :-P  Just looked at industry level.


    Parliament and the Politics of Climate Change

    Anita Talberg (Commonwealth Parliamentary Library), Andrew Leigh (ALP Member for Fraser; formerly Economics, ANU), John Hewson (Former Liberal Leader; Prof. of Economics), Lenore Taylor (Fairfax's National Times correspondent)
    Chaired by Frank Jotzo

    AT: Survey about politicians' attitudes/awareness of climate change (PDF). Conducted during Rudd era, late 2009. 26 interviewees, systematic stratified sampling. 20-min semi-structured phone interviews.
    Underlying attitudes rather than policy stances. Expertise: little/no 29%, Some 63% (self-rated 53%), Good 9% (self-rated 47%!!). 96% agree cc is occurring. 88% thought at least partly caused by humans. 90% unlikely to go away by itself. 43% of LNP were deniers.
    On most issues, LNP/ALP not statistically separable – except for attitude on leading globally, where Greens/ALP strongly for and LNP strongly against. LNP members also had much lower concern about climate change; could be predicted by political party, belief in science, and importance of issue for them politically (not other variables!)
    Attitudes broadly in line with population, but also partisan.

    AL: Tony Abbott believes in tipping points – at least for Malcolm Turnbull. Political speech more so than speech about politics.

    JH: "Please excuse my confused remarks, I'm still struggling to explain the carbon footprint of a birthday cake." Used to believe that good politics was just good policy with a bit of a lag. "TAbbott has had more positions on the climate change than the Karma Sutra."
    Worst case is where polls keep going down for Govt. Oakeshott, a man of great principle, may switch sides, force an election, and get TAbbott in.
    Gillard is bleeding to the left. Announcing the tax without details is a free kick to Abbott; lets him use fear and ignore any real debate. Back in the mid-70s, as a young politician, Hewson could not wait for interest and exchange rates to be set by the market. Eventually it came. So too will it be with  climate change.

    LT: Debate went off the rails last year when the Coalition turfed Turnbull and stopped supporting the market mechanism, and – by extension – any serious treatment of the issue at all. The LNP policy is there to be seen to be doing something. ALP, OTOH, did the political equivalent of running away with their hands over their ears by not going to a DD election after the CPRS was defeated, and not prosecuting the case at all at the 2010 election.
    If you believe the anti-action brigade, apparently Greg Combet signed a secret deal at Cancun to give 10% of our carbon price revenues to some secretive UN cabal.
    The debate over this issue has devolved to a political fight to the death. But sensible parties should not abandon the field and let them fight it out, because otherwise the pressure on the independents will be to great and everything will go off the rails again.

    Q: How do we drive a new industrial revolution in Australia?
    AL: Markets.

    Why are deniers given so much space in the media? Is it the role of individual journalists or the organisations? Ditto for the gap between the science and the reporting.
    LT: Bizarre form of balance. Not the way she defines it. Scientific debate outside the realms of real-politick.
    AT: 80% of pollies rely on the media for info on climate change.
    AL: Decision to release principles then follow with detail is deliberate. We don't want to get caught up in hypothetical traps. Would prefer to talk about principles.

    Is there a chance TAbbott will get enough rope to hang himself? If you're in the ALP and are worried about CC, why would you not support nuclear?
    LT: TAbbott isn't getting more popular, but he's under much less pressure since the MPCCC announced its proposal. Nuclear often gets raised as though it were free – but it's still bloody expensive (to build).
    JH: Abbott may never be popular, but he can win. Carbon tax and the way it has been handled have been a lifeline for him. He'll be the best leader of the Opposition in our history. Wouldn't govern well, but will lead the opposition to a government admirably...