A comment on the whole "Julia Gillard promised there would be no carbon tax before the election, therefore a carbon tax is undemocratic" tripe:
The Australian Labor Party has a mandate to price carbon (dioxide and other greenhouse gases) – that we should be able to agree on; it's been part of their policy since pre-2007. We should also be able to agree that the act of putting a price on carbon is a bigger deal than the form that pricing mechanism takes.
Now, if a majority Labor Government broke its promise on the form of pricing carbon, there might be a strong case to object – but Australia doesn't have a majority Labor Government. As a minority Government, Labor's "mandate" is conditional on what is acceptable to its (informal) coalition partners, the independents and the Greens. This is all perfectly within the bounds of democracy, and is utterly commonplace anywhere that has experience with coalitions (even with the National and Liberal Party coalition on occasion).
So if you want to price carbon in a particular way, but you won't be able to price carbon at all unless you do it in a different way, is that undemocratic? Not at all – unless you think that the elected representatives of >50% of the voting population agreeing to do something is undemocratic.
Basically: Gillard's not breaking her promise, because she has no power to keep her promise – but she can keep the most important part of her promise (the act of pricing carbon, if not the form) by compromising and cooperating with others. That, right there, is democracy.
The Australian Labor Party has a mandate to price carbon (dioxide and other greenhouse gases) – that we should be able to agree on; it's been part of their policy since pre-2007. We should also be able to agree that the act of putting a price on carbon is a bigger deal than the form that pricing mechanism takes.
Now, if a majority Labor Government broke its promise on the form of pricing carbon, there might be a strong case to object – but Australia doesn't have a majority Labor Government. As a minority Government, Labor's "mandate" is conditional on what is acceptable to its (informal) coalition partners, the independents and the Greens. This is all perfectly within the bounds of democracy, and is utterly commonplace anywhere that has experience with coalitions (even with the National and Liberal Party coalition on occasion).
So if you want to price carbon in a particular way, but you won't be able to price carbon at all unless you do it in a different way, is that undemocratic? Not at all – unless you think that the elected representatives of >50% of the voting population agreeing to do something is undemocratic.
Basically: Gillard's not breaking her promise, because she has no power to keep her promise – but she can keep the most important part of her promise (the act of pricing carbon, if not the form) by compromising and cooperating with others. That, right there, is democracy.

No comments:
Post a Comment