Monday, June 18, 2012

On being understood

I have a 300-word section on my Facebook in which I describe myself. This is unusual, as far as Facebook profiles I've seen go: most people don't fill the "About Me" section out at all; or if they do, it's perfunctory. When I befriend new people on the site I'll eagerly click through their profile to discover what fascinating mysteries might reveal themselves; as a rule, I am left wanting.

Having recently added a few dancers from my swing performance troupe to my Facebook, the topic of my lengthy profile came up briefly during a dinner. Later, I asked one of my new acquaintances what she thought of my profile: specifically, whether it reflected accurately her impression of me that she'd gleaned from real life. She gave me a considered answer, then asked, quite reasonably, "Why do you want to know?"

An excellent question, to which there are several answers; or, perhaps, an answer in several parts.

The primary answer is this: to be understood. 
People are multifaceted. Each of us has different sides to us, some of which are only revealed in particular circumstances. People who have known me for years in one context can be surprised by other aspects of my life or personality I consider such natural parts of my identity that their surprise baffles me. Things like that I can dance – not just swing dance, but clubbing-style dancing –; that I'm a footballer; that I love The Living End; or that I'm German. 

Reflecting upon these things, I decided to write a profile that would bring somebody familiar with one side of me up to speed with the most important other aspects necessary to understand me: my personality type, sense of humour, hobbies, etc.
Curiously, there's a paragraph in which I write about how I see myself – it's odd, in context, in quite a different tone to the rest. My dancing profile evaluator remarked on it, and as I was able to offer was that I had perhaps written it so that I might understand myself.

The search for understanding as a driver crystalised for me today when I read a piece by Martin McKenzie-Murray, a skilled speech-writer and blogger. 
“You’re born in a cage,” he said, “and you’ll stay in it because there’ll always be a gap between your experiences and the words you have to describe them. More, you’ll only ever be able to occupy one skull—you’ll never completely know what it’s like to think or feel like somebody else. But, you can enlarge that cage by developing ways to communicate and your confidence to do so. That starts with expanding your vocabulary. The strength—and intimacy—of your relationships in life will largely depend upon your ability to express yourself warmly and precisely.” (emphasis mine)

 That'd be it. Well, part of it. For his message had a coda: "It might not matter terribly, because few of us listen anyway."

How much of what I intend to convey arrives? And is the fault mine, or yours?

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Wish one is ALWAYS for more wishes

Last week I went to drinks celebrating the 5th birthday of the Centre for Policy Development, a very cool, creative think tank that sprang out of the policy development the New Matilda magazine was doing; you may remember I've written for NM now and again.

The CPD is run by Miriam Lyons, a fascinating woman well worth listening to, and at the birthday drinks I ended up with conversation with her parents. Lyons' mother, a psychologist, asked me the following question:
"If you had three wishes to change the world to help the environment, but that change had to occur through political processes, what would those wishes be?"

I found the question fascinating, and pondered it for a minute or two. Think about your own answers for a while, if you like. (You know it's a happening party when people stare into the middle distance rubbing their chins thoughtfully for a while.)
My first wish, I decided, was:
  1. Give the environment legal rights.
Once you treat the environment as a legal entity, and give it rights, any dealings with it then have to recognise those rights. Damage to the environment no longer becomes 'free', but instead requires restitution to someone (presumably the government) for infringing these rights. Okay, 'the environment' probably has de facto rights (via the government) in some sense already, and I don't know exactly what my system of rights would look like, but this is magic genie wishing at a party, remember?

I was pretty happy with this answer, and for a while I couldn't think of anything to do with my other two wishes. After a bit of needling from Lyons Senior, I decided that a framework for protecting the environment and some absolute standards probably wasn't enough; I'm protecting the environment for the sake of people, so there should be a relationship to people in my plan. Therefore, my second wish was to:
  1.  Give every person the right to a minimum amount of environmental quality.
'Environmental quality' is obviously fairly fuzzy, but it would cover things like clean air, water, land, biodiversity, etc. There are thousands of indicators of environmental quality, so I'd let my genie loose on that. (Or some applied statistics majors, whatever.)

Having now established a framework of sorts and a mandated supply of environmental quality, my economist brain decided the final piece of the puzzle was obvious: create demand for environmental quality. How, though? Creating demand, especially ingrained demand, is tough – it's often as much cultural as anything else, and creating or changing culture is a barrier I've never been able to surmount. In genie-party-land, however, I was able to get away with:
  1. Create an ingrained (cultural) demand for environmental quality, e.g. through education.
When it comes to affecting (or effecting) culture, I usually throw my hands up and look for a sociologist/psychologist/theologian/whatever to pass the question to; they invariably profess to not know the answer either – and I don't know I'd believe them if they claimed they did! But educating people to value the environment, e.g. through bush walks or family outings, seems to be a fairly effective method. It was certainly a good topic of further conversation.

We asked the same question of another researcher at the CPD, and the differences in our answers was fascinating: her first wish would be to "assassinate some people – clear the decks!" (Lest you get the wrong idea about the CPD, remember this was birthday drinks, and I don't think she took the question quite as seriously as I did.)
I've forgotten her second wish, unfortunately, but her third was to take over a large stake in the media to promote her message: "buy Channel 9", basically.

It's intriguing how differently people approach the question; I think I'll squirrel it away as a conversation starter. You have been warned.

Sunday, May 20, 2012

CL Final 2011/12 impressions

Dropped off by a girl with a frog.
Three scarves, a jersey, and a flag around the shoulders
Drunk fat English Man City fan asking people where they came from. The African bartender replied, "Brisbane", then summarily ignored him. Tried to speak to Varisht with "allaballabu" then "I don't speak Indian. I only speak Muslim." Pushed in line, but since none of the bar staff were white, he kept calling out "Agua! Aguerra!" Didn't get service.

Rival chants. Screens on both sides of the crowd. African bloke with dreads in Chelsea shirt spent minutes shouting "Looosers! You are looosers! You will looooose!" to us, but we gave back.
"We are going to score in the next 10 minutes. Then you will loooose!". 15 minutes later, at 0-0 – "What's the time, mate?"
"I like standing here between you loooosers!" // "Yeah, you like the kind of guy who likes to be between two men."
"Those girls are looking at you, because you're so ugly!" // "Maybe, but next to you I'm like an Adonis."
After Bayern's 1-0 he disappeared to the Chelsea side of the crowd, only reappearing when Drogba equalised. His mate kept asking, "Who do you really support?"

Two Englishmen (Liverpudlians?) behind us, ad infinitum: "Ah luv football. But ah fookin' hate Chelsea. Go England!"

Bald racist English fuck putting finger under nose and goose-stepping with Hitler salute. Even other Chelsea fans thought he was racist.

Consoling pats on the back. Screens off as soon as the whistle blew. Emptiness.

Shattering emptiness.

Friday, May 11, 2012

Cross-post: Surrendering to the idea of a price floor

After my previous misadventures with major media, I was pleasantly surprised when Stian Reklev, the chief correspondent for Reuters Point Carbon, asked me to write a comment piece on the Australian ETS price floor mechanism and its effect on the market for international permits. In retrospect, I perhaps lapsed a little too much into 'explainer' mode, but with only 650 words to play with there's only so much analysis you can do – I feel weird not backing statements up with solid argumentation and a few links. Here's the piece, published today in the Carbon Market Australia-New Zealand May newsletter:

Surrendering to the idea of a price floor

From July 2015, the Australian federal government will set the price of the permits in its emissions trading scheme free – within limits. The government intends to introduce a price floor and price ceiling until at least 2017/18, in order to provide certainty and reduce risks for market participants and investors.

This is good news for emission reduction activities whose viability depends on prices several years hence, such as larger, more complex projects. Further, the goal of abatement at least-cost should be balanced against the goal of abating as rapidly as possible; should reaching current targets be cheaper than expected, a floor price can ensure a minimum level of spending on abatement. Several EU countries already have or are considering similar measures, in recognition that adjusting the targets of an ETS in response to price movements often isn’t possible rapidly.

Last December, the government released a discussion paper and called for submission on the price floor, which combines a reserve price for Australian carbon units at auction with an ‘international unit surrender charge’ that ensures international carbon credits cost at least as much as domestic units.

Four options are being considered for the international unit surrender charge, with two main approaches: Options 1 and 2 calculate the charge based on the difference between the price floor and the price of the international unit when it was purchased; Options 3 and 4 calculate the charge based on the difference between the price floor and the price when the unit surrendered.

While calculating the surrender charge based on the difference between the buying price and the price floor is intuitively appealing, it has implementation issues ranging from administrative complexity, through estimating firms’ time value of money (to adjust the prices of credits purchased earlier rather than later), to the possibility of firms gaming the system by artificially inflating the price of purchased credits. The government paper also notes that Options 1 and 2 would create a preference for foreign units as “if the international price goes up, [firms] could sell the unit at a profit, purchase another unit at a similar (or the same) price, and pay a lower surrender charge.” (Source)

Option 3 appears the most likely: when firms surrender their international units, a charge is applied based on the difference between the prevailing spot price and the price floor. This is the “purest” option, with minimal government involvement and low administration costs. The risk that the price of units changes between purchasing and surrendering them is borne by the liable firms, though financial markets are expected (e.g. by Westpac (PDF)) to provide hedging products or forward contracts.

The costs of hedging, in addition to the surrender charge, could promote the purchase of domestic units over foreign credits. However, it’s worth noting that, since markets for foreign units will likely exist further forward than domestic units (which will only be auctioned three years in advance, based on current plans), there will be a strong bias toward international credits from firms looking to hedge long-term.

Option 4 is similar to Option 3, though with an option for firms to lock in a surrender charge ahead of time based on a regulator-calculated forward curve. This interesting idea would assist firms who, for reasons of cost, access, or complexity are unlikely to use financial markets’ hedging products. Though adding complexity, it would avoid any bias Option 3 has toward domestic units. However, is it the government’s role to insure traders from carbon price risk?

While an MP who supported the ETS, Rob Oakeshott, has recently spoken out against the price floor, the government has an advantage: the relevant legislation has already been passed, and the remaining details (e.g. the choice of option) can be passed by regulation. Regulation passes automatically unless blocked, so the opposition would need to find a 75-seat majority in the House of Representatives to do so. (Under convention established by Speaker Denison, the Speaker votes against motions in case of a tie.)

Even in the government’s current precarious position, this seems unlikely – the defection of Oakeshott alone would not suffice –, so that, if the government survives long enough to introduce a price floor, it will likely pass.

Martin C. Jones is a researcher at the Centre for Energy and Environmental Markets, UNSW.

Sunday, May 06, 2012

The chill of neighbourly distrust

I have neighbours on one side, A. and D., whose apartment has the same layout as mine. Our balconies are adjacent, and so we've had a bit of friendly interaction since I moved in a year and a half ago. It's irregular and infrequent, but we'll hang out on our respective balconies with a drink or something to eat and shoot the breeze. Sometimes they'll have parties and I'll perch on our shared balcony wall and chat with the guests. They're perfectly nice people, I thought.

Tonight I got home from a hip-hop gig in the city, and found A. & D. having another party. I went onto my balcony to say hello, and they – or their guests, or all together; I don't remember, exactly – offered me a beer. Then they realised they'd run out of beer, so they told me it was BYO beer. "No problem!", I said: went inside, grabbed a ginger beer, and climbed over onto their balcony.

I'll admit: I had not received the explicit invitation to set foot on A. & D.'s balcony – but the "come join us" vibe was definitely there. After a year and a half of living next to and interacting with someone, I think it would have been weirder to offer them a drink but then expect them to stay on their own property.

At any rate, I took an empty chair on their balcony and chatted with their guests. It was A.'s birthday, so I congratulated her. We talked about the gig I was at. The conversation turned to dancing, and one of the guests, J., challenged me to dance. 
"Really?", I said, "Because I will. What style?" Perhaps influenced by the DJ inside pumping out cool house music, J. replied, "Melbourne Shuffle." 
"I'm from Melbourne," I said, "I can do that."
And I did. And they were impressed.

I sat down again, and chatted some more.  As this apartment has the same floor layout as mine (but, from A. & D.'s accounts, a much more responsible owner), I was curious to see what it was like. "Can I have a look around your apartment?", I asked. A. paused slightly.
"Um. Alright. J., go with him, would you?"

Being chaperoned mystified me slightly, but I strode inside a few steps to where D. was standing with some of the other guests. We danced on the spot a little. A few moments later, one of the women on the balcony called me back out to them. I went. Then it got weird. 
They asked me to sit; I did. With great hesitation and obtuseness, A. and friends eventually explained that they'd called me out because I had

I'm going to interrupt here for a second, because this is the sort of experience it was. You've done something: you don't know what it is, but it seems bad. Was it asking to see the apartment? Have I come across as a thief? I asked. No, no, it wasn't that. What I'd done, was...

Had I called out A.'s name, they asked. Huh? When? (Oh, god – had I gotten her name wrong all this time? Had I called it out in my sleep, for some bizarre reason? Has I played a movie – or porn – where somebody calls out "A." really loudly? (No, no, and no.))
Had I ever stood on my balcony and called out A.'s name when she wasn't on her balcony, they clarified.
"I... guess. Probably. I don't remember."
"Why?"
"... because the lights were on, the balcony doors were open, and I wanted to say hello?"
"Did you ever want to use her internet?"
"Oh. Yes. Yeah, when I first moved in, before I got mine hooked up."
"But why call her name? Why not go and knock on her door?"
"Why would I go down two flights of stairs, out into the street, ring a doorbell, and make A. come down two flights of stairs to answer it, when I'm right next door."
What followed was a bizarre discussion about the appropriateness of calling people by their names, or not, which all made much more sense when they revealed that they were incredibly high. Okay! Much less weird. Or, at least, weird, but explainable. A. told me it didn't matter, and – we were standing by that point – gave me a friendly waist-hug.

All sorted! Hurrah! D. and the other party guests came out, as did the DJ, and we all stood on the balcony talking rubbish for a while. Lutherans vs. Catholics, bloodlines, why to invest in silver, that sort of thing. (I don't know what "that sort of thing" is, but then, I wasn't on nearly as many drugs.)

It was pretty cold by this stage, so everyone except D., the DJ and I went inside. A. called us in, and I would've been happy to comply, but D. gently pulled on my arm to indicate that I should stay. I guessed he didn't want to be stuck alone in conversation with the silver-investing, Lutheran DJ, so I stayed. I was wearing a thin jacket, though, so I tried to stand on the apartment-side of our trio for warmth. D. casually position himself between me and the doors. We talked until the DJ decided it was getting cold, and suggested we go inside. Gratefully, I moved to follow, but D. grabbed me again and suggested we stay and talk outside. I began to sense a theme.

We shut the double balcony doors, so the guests inside weren't cold, then D. and I took a chair. (Each.) I asked whether we were out here because he wanted to be outside, or because he didn't want me to be inside. 
"A little bit of both."
Aha. I joked about "feeling the love." We got into a discussion about trust, and D. – who was not high, he said, but possibly drunk – told me I've been "overly familiar" in coming onto their balcony and going inside. I responded that I was invited.
"I didn't invite you."
"Well, I don't remember who invited me. I felt invited."
"Well, we didn't."
Awkward.
"Shall I go? I don't feel particularly welcome any more."
"No, no, it's alright."
What the fuck?

A. came to the balcony doors. She tried to open them, but D. pushed them shut in her face. She scolded him, and he relented.
"D., I need you for something. Right now. It's important."
"Later."
"No, it needs to be now. It's important."
"I'll do it later!"
"It's alright, D.," I said, "go inside. I'll sit out here by myself. In plain sight."
A. and D. stepped inside the balcony doors to keep arguing about whether D. should do this thing or not. As soon as they were inside, D. locked the doors.  
He locked me outside on his balcony.

D. didn't go and do whatever it was A. wanted him to, if this thing wasn't just a pretext of some sort anyway. After a minute or two he came back outside, where I was playing with my phone. 
A. locked the door after him.
"Samsung Galaxy?"
"Yep. S II."
"Yeah, I've known you've had one of those for a few months now."
I looked at him blankly. Had I shown it to him? Bragged about it?
"I've had it for about a year."
"You tried to connect to our network with it. I saw it come up: 'Martin's Galaxy'"
"Umm... okay. Perhaps. Must've been by accident, I–"
"Don't get defensive."
"... I'm not getting defensive, I'm just saying that I have my own, high-speed internet connection, and I have no need to connect to your network. I don't even know what your network is called. Which one is it?"
"That doesn't matter. You tried to connect to it. It's fine; you don't need to defend yourself."

This is so. fucking. weird.

A. came to the balcony door again and called D. in for something else. He refused, again, and she told him off for being so aggressive. Whether to me (our conversation was probably audible inside) or to her, I don't know. I'd had enough, and told D. he should go inside; I was just leaving.
"Yeah, you were just leaving", affirmed A., pulled D. inside, and bolted the doors again.

Weirdos. Fucking weirdos.

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

Just the way the bilby crumbles

A summary of my Easter:
  • Played many board games with friends. Won convincingly at Boggle (a word game), and did well in other games. Felt very smart.
  • Realised that, when loading my bike into a friend's car to get to the games night, I'd left my front wheel, expensive lock, and all my keys on the ground in Redfern (a low socio-economic area). Unsurprisingly, they were no longer there when I returned five hours later. Felt not very smart.
  • Went camping! Four days at Turon Gates, out past the Blue Mountains.
  • Canoed, rode a horse, built lots of camp-fires, smelled of smoke, read novels in a hammock. Did not mountain bike :-(
  • Spent ~$330 on a new front wheel, lock, and keys. Am telling everyone they were "stolen". But you know better, dear readers. (All three of you.)
  • Ate chocolate! Not eggs, or bunnies, or anything... just chocolate. Because I like chocolate. (I'm not sure what chocolate really has to do with Easter anyway, now that I think about it.)

Monday, April 09, 2012

Better no quote than a misquote

On Wednesday afternoon last week, a journalist called Imre Salusinszky from The Australian – a national broadsheet daily newspaper – asked me to ring him, as he had a question about carbon trading. I'd never heard of, let alone had anything to do with Salusinszky until then, so it's anyone's guess as to why he decided to contact me. (My suspicion is he read my piece on complementary measures on The Conversation.)

The Australian has an anti-climate change action editorial stance, and is openly anti-Greens, so I was a little apprehensive about what I was getting myself into, but Salusinszky seemed like reasonably enough chap on the phone. His questions were about the NSW GGAS, a state baseline-and-credit emissions reduction scheme that was shutting down when the national emissions trading scheme started on July 1. (In short: a company's levels of greenhouse gas emissions are projected into the future: this is the baseline. By reducing its emissions, a company receives a 'credit'. It can also buy credits from/sell to others. Each year, companies are required to submit credits to the Government.) From its conception, GGAS was intended to run only until a national scheme superseded it, but its closure had not officially been announced until Thursday. (The Oz had advance notice of the announcement.)

The issue was that the GGAS scheme had generated millions more credits – emissions reductions – than required, and while the holders of these credits would have used them to meet their submission requirement in later years, there obviously wouldn't be any later years now that the scheme was closing. The Oz had a quote from the NSW Energy Minister calling for the Federal Government to compensate the holders of NSW GGAS credits, and a quote from the Federal Government saying it was the state's problem.

Salusinszky asked me some questions about GGAS – e.g. What was the highest price the credits had ever reached? When was the scheme originally due to end? Could/should the two schemes coexist? Has GGAS worked? – and I answered them as best I could, sending a follow-up email with details on answers on which I was unclear. The line Salusinszky wanted to take seemed pretty clear – the national government was leaving companies in the lurch – and while I thought this a silly stance, I hoped to at least temper the piece with more realistic information.

When the draft piece arrived, my suspicions were confirmed: it clearly portrayed the NSW scheme as being victim of the national scheme; worse, it misquoted me as supporting a phased reduction of GGAS, when I had quite clearly said there was no point in the national and state schemes coexisting. Perhaps Salusinszky misheard me; perhaps he decided that, on the basis of my support for both national AND state schemes in The Conversation, it's what I should have said; perhaps the line came from his co-author, Annabel Hepworth, who's a bit of hack. In any case, I corrected the errors and sent the piece back.

The piece, "Carbon tax to scuttle state's pioneer ETS", left my quotes out entirely. I can only imagine why :-P

I criticised the article on Twitter, pointing out not only its flaws but that the authors well knew better, as I'd told them so the previous day. Following that, the Thomson Reuters Point Carbon reporter covering climate change policy in the Asia-Pacific, Stian Reklev, got in contact with me. (Reklev does follow me on Twitter.) I sent him my views, and he ended up quoting my in his piece (see below). That's probably less exposure than I would have gotten in The Australian, but far more reputable!

New South Wales bins carbon trading scheme (readable with free trial)

Australian state New South Wales will abandon its Greenhouse Gas Abatement Scheme (GGAS) on July 1, when the federal government introduces a tax on CO2 emissions, state Energy Minister Chris Hartcher announced Thursday.
The baseline-and-credit scheme has operated since 2003, targeting emission cuts primarily in the state electricity sector, but also in industry and forestry.

The phase-out was expected, but leaves market participants with 16 million surplus credits that will be ineligible for use in the nationwide scheme.

This spurred Minister Hartcher to demand in local media Thursday that the federal government compensate the credit holders.

However, market observers dismissed Hartcher’s claims.

“It’s been clear from the outset of GGAS to all participants and government that GGAS would finish when a national carbon pricing scheme started,” said Martin Jones, a researcher at the University of New South Wales.

“The problem of excess supply and an upcoming end date have been on the radar for at least half a decade, and insufficient efforts to address it have little to do with the federal government,” he told Point Carbon News.

STEADY TARGET

The scheme aimed to bring per capita emissions of CO2 equivalent to 7.27 tonnes in 2007, down from 8.65 tonnes in 2003.

However, since 2007 the per capita target has remained steady at 7.27 tonnes.

Meanwhile, the scheme has led to emission cuts far beyond the target, noted Rob Fowler, Australia and New Zealand representative at the International Emissions Trading Association (IETA).

He said he was not convinced that holders of the surplus credits should be compensated, as the GGAS legislation only goes to 2012, and it was always clear it would be replaced by a national scheme.

“But the underlying abatement activities still have value under the new national regime,” he added.

FUTURE CFI CREDITS

The activities covered under the current GGAS will either be brought under Australia’s A$23 ($23.70) carbon tax from July 1, or qualify to generate offsets under the Carbon Farming Iniative (CFI).

GGAS projects seeking eligibility under the CFI must apply, and emission cuts achieved until now cannot be used in the new scheme.

But all in all, Thursday’s news was unlikely to impact emission reduction efforts in the state, according to Fowler.

“There is a low chance that abatement activities will cease,” he said.

Energy efficiency measures were part of GGAS when it launched in 2003, but was moved to a separate Energy Savings Scheme in 2009.

“The energy efficiency scheme will continue, and they will most likely expand it,” Fowler said, adding it could be linked to a similar scheme in neighbouring Victoria.

The federal government’s carbon tax will move to an emissions trading scheme on July 1, 2015.

 
Beijing

Sunday, April 01, 2012

Clint Eastwoon, grammar cop

Wes was giving me a film recommendation – "Every Which Way But Loose: it has Clint Eastwoon [sic] in it (as a street-figher) with a pet orangutan called Clyde" – when I misunderstood him and got the impression the film had something to do with Eastwood fighting typos. The following exchange ensued:

Me: I was trying to come up with scenarios in which Eastwood was somehow forced into fighting because of a fateful typo.
Wes: I would totally watch that. “You’ve used one too many apostrophes on that sign, and, well, now you going to pay.” *fighting stance*
M: "Comma get me, Eastwood!" "I'll put a stop to that, period. You hyphen't seen nothing yet." 
M: "Stop that bracket down there! People are trying to sleep." / "How do you know what he's saying?" "I read his ellipses."
W: “You can take your grammar rules & stick ‘em right up your colon!” “I’ll slash you!” “Well then, don’t make a hash of it, come @ me!”
M: "I think we have due clause to pursue this case, Chief. Conjugating with minors is a capital offence. Don't decline it."
W: “The suspect has a grave accent, and our profiler suggests he was abused by his parentheses.”
W: “Is he dangerous?” “Time will tilde, asterisk we’ll have to take. We’d like him in the station for an interrobang before he can dash”
M: We are very funny.
W: Yes, we are hilarious.



Thursday, March 29, 2012

Cross-post: State climate schemes are still worthwhile under a carbon price

My first piece for The Conversation, written in response to recent events:

State climate schemes still worthwhile under a carbon price

In justifying their recent abandonment of state-based climate schemes, the governments of Queensland and Victoria have both claimed that the schemes will be redundant under the federal emissions trading scheme (ETS) that begins in July.¹ Yet this justification is only a smokescreen, as a carbon price can well exist with other environmental and climate schemes.

The goal of putting a price on carbon – more correctly, on greenhouse gases, but “carbon” is shorter – is to reduce the amount of carbon emissions. The flexible nature of an ETS lets the market decide whether this occurs. It reduces the activities that produce carbon or conducts those activities more efficiently.

The industries in which these reductions occur, and the people that are affected by them, can be only broadly selected by the Government. This is the point, since the idea is that the market will do the job more cheaply than if the Government prescribed everything. And the argument that state climate programs within a national ETS can make emissions reduction more expensive is correct.

However, getting the cheapest emissions abatement is not the only possible goal. Another goal might be to target particular geographic or social groups, such as rural areas or low-income households. South Australia’s Residential Energy Efficiency Scheme, for example, aims to reduce household electricity use, but requires a certain proportion of that reduction to occur in disadvantaged households. Energy costs are thus reduced where households are most struggling with them, rather than just where it’s cheapest to do so (which is usually higher-income households). Similar goals could well be pursued through state-based measures complementing a carbon price.

A goal of further policies might be to target areas that don’t respond well or rapidly to price changes, whether because of habit, socially shaped preferences, intrinsic motivation, or market problems. It’s certainly possible that carbon-price-related rises in electricity bills may cause us to go and demand more energy efficient appliances and houses, or at least appliances and houses that can be upgraded when better technology arrives. But these connections are often tenuous and it can make more sense simply to mandate minimum standards, as we already do for safety. (It is considered unacceptable to let the market decide how safe appliances and houses will be based on “price”, i.e. lawsuits.)

Yet the Victorian Government has removed support for precisely such a policy: coal power standards that would have required a certain level of emissions efficiency from new plants, and required them to be ready to install clean coal technology if it became viable.

Scrapping investments in climate-related infrastructure or research and development, as the Queensland Government is doing, only makes sense if you believe that markets always make the best choices. Research, however, is an area where markets commonly do too little, because the benefits of research tend to be shared amongst many (including competitors) rather than just the researching organisation itself.

Strategic government investment in technology can make it viable years before the market would deliver a similar result. A prime example is Germany’s highly advanced solar power industry, which it developed with subsidies despite being covered by the EU ETS. And while it’s unclear how well Germany’s bolstered solar industry will survive long-term against its rivals from China, it is inarguable that the solar industry made Germany’s power supply robust to the kind of shock that saw its nuclear reactors shut down after the disaster in Fukushima.

This robustness – the ability to maintain a minimum level of performance under a range of possible future conditions – was not delivered because of the EU ETS: it came from additional, smaller-scale policy. And while it may involve some amount of duplication, such robustness is valuable when unforeseen events occur; what if, against all expectation, the constitutional challenge to the Clean Energy Future legislation were to succeed? Achieving our environmental goals would be significantly easier if states still had their individual programs.

These are just a handful of reasons why complementary environmental and climate policies could be worth pursuing, even at a state level, under a national carbon price. There are more. And I do not claim that all policies will be worth it: complementary policies should be evaluated under frameworks such as the one recently published by Denniss, Grudnoff, & Macintosh.

If the Queensland and Victorian Governments had justified abandoning their climate programs based on such an evaluation, it would be easier to believe their faith in a “carbon tax”. And, to be fair, Victoria did conduct a review (PDF) that found no compelling case for a state-based emissions reduction target under a national carbon scheme. But the review also found other Victorian climate programs are worth keeping, and that the merits of state emissions target should be reviewed if the national scheme is altered or repealed.

The reason that state governments are backpedalling on climate policies isn’t because they believe that the “carbon tax” will solve all our environmental problems: this is a smokescreen. The reason is that they don’t share the goals that the federal legislation pursues, of reducing carbon pollution, encouraging renewable energy generation, and “future-proofing” the economy. For if they did, there are plenty of state climate schemes that would still be worthwhile.

¹ Readers may be more familiar with the incorrect, though widespread term, “carbon tax”. More on that here.

[UPDATE 30/03]
Green industry newsletter Climate Spectator republished the article today :-)

Friday, March 23, 2012

Paying for organ donation

A friend asks: 
I did a piece last year on the economic benefits of paid organ donation schemes. I was just wondering if you had encountered this topic at all. I couldn't find an economic reason to oppose it.


I only just tossed off an answer, but I thought the topic interesting enough to preserve:

I haven't come across any studies of paid organ donation schemes, no.

The biggest economic problem I can think of is that it's paying people to do what 'right' anyway. If that sounds totally non-economisty, let me rephrase it: markets provide an extrinsic incentive, via payment. However, many – most – things also have an intrinsic value: "pride in your work"; "the satisfaction of a job well done"; the respect of others; the comfort of following your morals.* If you focus too strongly on extrinsic motivation – performance-related pay is a good example – you remove intrinsic motivation, and intrinsic motivation is a MUCH stronger force than extrinsic.

So a (possible) problem with paid organ donation schemes, depending on how they're set up, is that you may begin by supplementing your 'free' pool of donations with paid donations, but you end up having to pay everyone as payment becomes the prime motivator for donation.

Better, IMO, are non-monetary schemes to increase intrinsic motivation or overcome barriers to action: make organ donation opt-out, for example, rather than opt it. Marketing, awareness campaigns, stuff like that. Create a culture of giving, rather than a culture of 'pay me to do something good for other people'.

* Interesting side note: happiness studies have found people with strong (not strict; more, 'well-defined') moral codes are likelier to be happy than people with weak or no morals. The speculated reason is that acting in accordance with your morals lets you feel good about yourself (in addition to however good the activity makes you feel), while not having morals mean you get the benefit of the activity.