Monday, September 19, 2011

Limited foresight

Back in January, a friend asked me to tell him, in 240 characters or less, what was going on with Australia's climate policy. Here's my response:
Australia has a Multiparty Climate Change Committee, which will probably receive excellent submissions and throw them out in favour of a hacked-together update of the CPRS that gets the backing of the Greens and Indies sometime this year.
I give myself 7/10 on this one. The MPCCC has turned out a proposal that is based on the CPRS, but the updates are greater than I was expecting. However, there is still a bit of a piece-meal character about the Clean Energy Future proposal e.g. the exclusion of petrol, paying power stations to shut down.

[UPDATE]
The same friend has challenged me to update my prediction, again within 240 characters. Here goes:
The ETS will pass before 2012, with minor tinkering possible but unlikely. The other CEF policies will pass by mid 2012, so long as Labor hasn't imploded over something else by then. Debate will turn to complementary policies (e.g. RET)
He gave me 7/10 on my first prediction, too, btw.

Thursday, September 08, 2011

In the heat of the moment

I bought a new toaster yesterday.

This might seem unremarkable, until one considers that I had already bought a toaster when I moved into my apartment, and this original toaster functions as well now as it did when I bought it, then.

That first toaster seemed like a canny purchase at the time. It was a Sunbeam – a well-known brand – in good condition, with pleasant lines and clean, unmarked white plastic in which the controls sat well. I bought it second-hand, from a chap whose new 4-slice stainless steel appliance seemed to justify the sale of his 2-slice model for the low low sum of $5. Ever wary, I asked to plug my prospective toaster in, and inspected it critically as it heated. No smoke, no smells, no sparks; good.

Heating, though, is only a portion of what a toaster has to do. It also, at some point, has to stop.

Stopping is what my old toaster doesn't do. Like a demented Duracell bunny intent on producing charcoal it keeps going, and going, and going. This is... sub-optimal – but for the sake of $5 I wasn't going to chase the seller down and demand a refund. Besides – I didn't toast that often; when I did, I could just monitor the bread and halt the process manually, right?

I could, and I did. And it was irritating. And sometimes I forgot, and would be prompted only by the smell of smoke, and would stand over the sink scraping black particles off my toast until it was edible again. Edible, but cold.

When I went to the supermarket, I would inspect the toasters on offer there. Not the best of appliances, certainly, but ones, I imagined, that would be able to stop, as well as start. The cheapest was $15, and often I paused on my path to (more often than not) the chocolate aisle, pondering: was it worth the price? It never seemed like it. $15, just to automate pressing the "stop" button? Monitoring my toaster wasn't really that big a deal, was it? And I could do a lot with $15 – buy 15 chocolate bars, for example. Never mind that I'd do so anyway...

So I never upgraded my toaster. I explained to guests that they need watch their toast, but they'd forget, and we'd chuckle; "Oh, I did tell you!"  The first time, we'd chuckle. Later, not so much.

I asked an engineer about fixing it: more trouble that it's worth, he said. Just buy a new one – but I couldn't.

Yesterday, I bought a toaster. It cost me $7 dollars, on special. It's a beastly, ugly thing, with small, mean buttons and flimsy components. It has no features I desire beyond being able to heat and stop independently; no high lift feature, bun warming rack, or slice centring. It could well be from the 1970s, this new toaster of mine.


I was in the supermarket again today, buying cream and beer. (Don't ask.) Another toaster was on special: burnished aluminium, fully featured, $17.50 – down from $35. I picked it up. I put it down. I walked away. I came back. I stood there for minutes.

In the end I bought a kettle.

Monday, August 29, 2011

Empirics vs. appearance

"Is this really too heavy for you to carry?"
 - "Yes."
"Really?"
 - "Yes."
"... did you even try lifting it?"
 - "No. But it looked heavy."

Sunday, August 07, 2011

Cross-post: Implicit visions of Australia's future

I'm a few days putting this up here, but on Thursday I had another article published at New Matilda. They called it "Finally! Climate Policies Explained", but I wasn't actually trying to write an 'explainer' piece; instead, I was inspired by an article by Fergus Green to ponder the differences between what Australian political parties are saying about climate change and what they're doing. (Subsequent Twitter discussions between Fergus, Declan Kuch and myself also provided several ideas.)

The link to Fergus' article didn't make the NM editing cut, but I've restored it in my version, below (as well as one or two other bits I thought worth keeping, even if it does make the article slightly clunkier.)

What are the visions of Australia’s future reflected in our parties’ policies?

When the Government released its climate change package on July 10, it was under the moniker of a “Clean Energy Future”. This is, ostensibly, a fairly clear vision for where Labor sees Australia in 2050 and beyond. However, as Fergus Green rightly points out, the package is a mish-mash of measures that don’t deliver clear policy signals to achieve this clean energy future. While this is partially a result of the multi-party committee that spawned the package, the rhetoric the Government employs is ambiguous as to precisely what sort of society they see Australia moving toward.

But where are we really going with all this? If the world follows the suggestions of science and reduces CO2-e emissions to constrain dangerous climate change, what place is this future do our parties foresee?

There are five basic possibilities, relating to our emissions levels relative to our global entitlement and how we approach any excess/shortfall:
  1. Australia emits less than its global entitlement of CO2-e, and exports its remainder.(1)
  2. As above, but we don’t export the remainder.
  3. Australia emits at or about its share of CO2-e – a balanced carbon budget, if you like.
  4. Australia emits more than its global share of CO2-e, and offsets the difference by importing allowances/offsets from other countries.
  5. As above, but we don’t import (enough) to cover our excess emissions.
Note that these are possibilities for some stabilised-emissions future (2050 and beyond), without defining the transition path there-to.

Both the approach to calculating Australia’s right to CO2-e emissions and the position vis-à-vis offsetting domestic emissions internationally are predominantly moral decisions, even if they are underpinned by science, economics, law, and so on.

Following the argument that each person should have an equal right to the use of the global environment, which seems a sensible and equitable approach, Australia’s entitlement to emit CO2-e should be based our share of the global population. (Perhaps a little less, if you take our disproportionate historical use of the atmosphere into consideration.)

The 2011 Garnaut Review estimated that global per capita emissions would need to fall to less than two tonnes of CO2-e per year to stop CO2-e concentrations rising altogether, with even lower levels required to reduce concentrations. One to two tonnes of CO2-e per person per year seems a ballpark figure for our entitlement, then.

Offsetting domestic emissions internationally should, scientifically, be a non-issue: if the processes are of equal quality, arguing about whether Australian emissions should be offset by projects in Australia or Borneo is equivalent to arguing over offsetting in Queensland versus Tasmania; the climate responds equally well to both. And while the processes to offset emissions in Australia and Borneo are not of the same quality, we can restrict the import of foreign offsets to those that meet the relevant standards of additionality, verifiability, and so forth. This would be little different, in principle, to Australia’s importing of foodstuffs or consumer goods only from foreign companies certified to have a certain quality standard of production.

Where quality is equal, it would seem most efficient to choose the lowest cost abatement, which will probably not be in Australia. Investing in higher-cost domestic options, however, could establish new industries that prove more efficient in the long run, similar to the way Germany is fostering its solar and wind power industries. While Australia will end up importing some of our future offset and abatement technology – we simply aren’t large enough to develop everything ourselves –, a strong local market might have kept talents such as Dr. Zhongreng Shi or David Mills in Australia rather than watch them found their solar PV companies in China and the USA, respectively.

There are also the arguments that Australia should not achieve its entire net emissions reduction by shifting the work overseas. One argument involves equity: if foreign offsets are sold through intermediaries, is the money going to the end producers or the intermediaries? If it’s the intermediaries, would we prefer the money went to Australians, instead?  Another argument is that countries have an ethical responsibility to abate their own emissions (PDF). Such arguments for domestic abatement are broadly accepted (see Article 6(d) of the Kyoto Protocol, for example), though to varying degrees.

So: how do the climate policies of Australia’s political parties fit into the above framework?

Vision 1 – Low Emissions, Exporting Surplus

This is the vision of The Greens, and the clearest of the major parties. A goal of The Greens’ climate change policy is “to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as is feasible and by no later than 2050”. Emitting zero is obviously less than our entitlement, which leaves the question of trading our surplus allowances/abatement. Since The Greens are comfortable with the MPCCC proposal of importing up to 50% of permits required under the ETS – though only, they stress, permits of the highest quality that do not replace serious domestic action –, they would presumably also be comfortable exporting any surplus we might have. (Assuming, of course, that our own abatement is of the highest quality!)

Part of The Greens’ vision is a low-impact lifestyle: less energy use, less driving, less flying, more public transport use, less logging, etc. Such lifestyle change might not be absolutely necessary to reach a low-emissions scenario, but it would certainly be more difficult without it.

Vision 2 – Low Emissions, Not Exporting Surplus

While a part of the environmental movement (and The Greens) might be against Australia enabling the emissions of other countries – similar to current calls to stop fossil fuel exports –, this scenario is unrealistic. It would require explicitly rejecting a potentially quite large revenue stream, which Australian businesses are famously vociferous opposed to, and a significant change in public attitudes toward actions that might be primarily symbolic.

In particular, if Australia achieves low net emissions via plentiful offset generation rather than low gross emissions, it would be radical to ban the generating companies from selling their offsets overseas. To a certain extent, this vision seeks to impose a lifestyle choice upon other countries by limiting their options – such a vision is not always wrong (most people would be happy limiting certain countries’ access to nuclear weapons, for example), but it is controversial.

Vision 3 – Medium Emissions, Balanced Over Cycle

The use of the term “balanced” here is deliberate: this future sees Australia emitting at or about its share of global CO2-e emissions, trading allowances as and when economic or natural fluctuations require us to, but striving to maintain a roughly equal quantity of CO2-e imports and exports over time. Unlike other budgets, however, there is no pressing need that this one sum to zero over time; that would purely be a matter of preference.

Vision 4 – High Emissions, With Imported Offsets/Allowances

This is the ALP’s position – probably. It’s difficult to tell. Labor’s rhetoric has been about cutting pollution, supporting jobs, remaining competitive, increasing efficiency, and moving toward clean energy. These are all laudable goals, but jobs and competition have little to do with the climate and it’s unclear how clean the ALP’s energy future is, exactly. The Government’s long-term target of 80% reduction of CO2-e emissions versus 2000 levels by 2050 is one of the more concrete figures, but will still almost certainly lead to a future Australia that emits more than its global share.

Climate protection is not part of Labor’s core ideals. Though it’s not said so explicitly, implicit in the ALP’s rhetoric about maintaining our standard of living and its stance toward imported emissions (80% of required permits allowed under the CPRS; 50% under the current proposal) is a vision of an Australia that uses its wealth to pay other (poorer) nations to offset higher domestic consumption of CO2-e. Labor might be interested fuelling our current consumption model differently, but it’s not particularly interested in changing the style in which we live as The Greens are; the choice is for “cheaper, rather than deeper” action, to borrow a phrase.

Vision 5 – High Emissions, Without Imports

It seems harsh to ascribe this vision to the entirety of the Liberal and National parties, as it is certainly not shared by all their members. Under the current leadership, however, this is the Coalition’s vision. Its direct action plan is nonsense and won’t achieve 5% emissions reductions by 2020 under the proposed spending cap, while Liberal policy documents don’t even include a target for 2050 or beyond.

Though a theoretical commitment to 100% domestic action sounds very responsible, Tony Abbott’s tendency to frame his public opinion on climate change based largely on the views of his audience at the time (contravening common sense, his own history, and physics along the way) makes the idea that he has an underlying commitment to significant action roughly as likely as Alan Jones having an underlying commitment to fair and balanced reporting.

Between the, let’s call it ‘intellectual flexibility’ of Tony Abbott and his Shadow Minister for Climate Action, Greg Hunt, so long as no Australian is monetarily worse off – never mind the environmental costs, or the rest of the world – it seems the L/NP vision is to plant some fig trees for their metaphorical leaves and let someone else sort out the problem.


The examples here are not definitive of each category. Malcolm Turnbull’s vision, for example, sees lower emissions than Tony Abbot’s and could share a category with The Greens or the ALP, but differs from theirs in its greater emphasis on carbon capture and storage technologies, as well as a more explicit recognition of the need to manage risk and uncertainty. Similarly, Paul Frijters’ “Give up, or hope for a technological miracle” stance would fall into the same category as the Coaltion vision, though he expressly rejects their direct action policy. (And the ALP’s policy, too, to be fair.)

Which type of future you prefer is entirely your choice. But don’t kid yourself: the Coalition (under Abbott) aren’t really interested in a low-carbon economy; the ALP would like a low-carbon economy, but only where it’s not too difficult; and the Greens sincerely want a zero-carbon economy, but will want to change your lifestyle to achieve that. It’d be nice if they said it – but most voters only want so much honesty from their politicians.

(1) This needn’t be an allowance as under a global emissions trading scheme with binding national targets and permit allocations, but could simply be a level of domestic CO2-e offsetting in excess of the local demand that’s then traded abroad.

Tuesday, August 02, 2011

POWERLESS: A Play in One Act

SCENE:In front of the office printer.

CAST:Your Intrepid Hero;

A Colleague;

The Printer.

[COLLEAGUE:]"Martin, the printer does not work."
[MARTIN:](Striding purposefully past, flicks power switch without missing a beat.)
[PRINTER:]"Whrrrrr!"

THE END

Sunday, July 31, 2011

Locking good

When I bought my new mountain bike in Heidelberg in 2008 (as a result of the one I'd brought over from Melbourne being stolen), I followed the rule-of-thumb advice that suggests you should spend ~10% of the value of the bicycle on securing it. To this effect, I bought not one, but two locks: an ABUS Steel-O-Flex 950 (one of the best in the independent tests of the time), and a folding lock from Trelock; the latter was also rated highly, but what particularly appealed to me about the folding lock was that they're fairly unusual.

Now, professional bicycle thieves can crack pretty much any lock, given the time. However, like almost thieves, the majority concentrate on the low-hanging fruit; stuff that it easy to steal. (Three minutes is roughly low long they'll spend on one bike, reckon the German police.) And because of the different techniques used to get through different locks (bolt cutters or hacksaw for a chain/cable; prybar for D-locks; etc), professional bike thieves tend to specialise. By having two different styles of lock (including one fairly uncommon one), I hoped to just make my bike too much of a hassle to bother with.

Four winters (and zero maintenance *shame*) later, my ABUS finally carked it, after being caught out in last week's torrential Sydney downpour. I tried for a couple of days to get it open, and eventually wheeled my bike – still locked up – to my local bicycle workshop. I did this on a Saturday afternoon, in broad daylight, roughly around the time that the AFL match at the nearby SCG finished; yet despite wheeling this – still locked up – bike past hundreds of people, not a single one challenged me. Hmmph.

The guys at the workshop unable to open the lock, either, despite copious quantities of WD-40, so I asked them to cut it off. After about 30 seconds with a hacksaw, the mechanic realised that the Flex-O-Steel's cable was surround by steel shells that simply rotated with his strokes, and that he wasn't going to get anywhere. Since they couldn't use their angle grinder with customers around, I left my bike with the mechanics over the weekend and came back on Monday – only to be told that their regular angle grinder blade was having the same problems with the steel shells, and they needed to get a different one. Thank god I hadn't locked my bike to anything.

Two days later, I finally had an unlocked bike. Hurrah! However, I also only had one lock (my folding lock), which wasn't nearly as convenient to carry around as the ABUS after the Trelock carrying bag wore out. So, I needed a new lock – and, given the one I had lasted so long in the workshop, I was pretty happy with the old! Being gainfully employed now, (and not using the second lock as much) I treated myself to the next model up: the ABUS Granit Flex-O-Steel 1000. This model is, in fact, also marketed by ABUS as a lock for scooters. So, pretty tough!

But I still promise not to leave it out in the rain as much :-/

P.S. The London Cyclist has some good tips on how to lock your bike.

Saturday, July 30, 2011

New Fonts!

I have indulged myself in a bit of geekiness: in honour of getting my first piece of writing (unexpectedly) paid for – this piece about the "Big Picture" of carbon pricing, for Crikey –, I treated myself to a font I've been eyeing off for a while: Sabon.

And not just the standard Sabon, either – I gots me the Pro version. Versions! I gots all the versions: roman, bold, italic, and bold-italic.
Alright, so that cost a little more than what Crikey paid me. And it's probably overkill for what little publishing I do. But I don't care! I have my own font now! No more standard Microsoft malarkey for me!

I've gone right ahead and redone the title to this blog in Sabon Bold; nothing like a bit of customisation ;-)
 
Whaddya think? I'm considering re-printing my diploma thesis in this (it's currently predominantly Cambria). Yep – that geeky :-)

Saturday, July 23, 2011

Miami Horror, TLE Launch, Faustus

It's been a big week! Last Saturday I went to see Melbourne synth-pop/disco-house band Miami Horror play at the Metro Theatre, which was good fun. The first support act, I Know Leopard, were unremarkable, but the second, Goldfields, had plenty of attitude. They're five young blokes from Ballarat (hence the name), and bounce around like they've been snorting something (especially the singer). Goldfields also have a drummer and a percussionist – always good –, and a further snare drum in the middle of the stage for when the singer or guitarist want to make even more noise.Good music, tremendous energy, and a bit of stage-destroying action that makes you wonder what they'd be like if they played rock & roll.

Miami Horror, though: noice. Big light show, great crowd interaction – including some singing-while-crowd-surfing action –, and their singer/guitarist can sure throw his lanky frame around. I can't embed any photos, but here are some I found on Flickr.

The synth player (not to be confused with the keyboardist/bassist, though there was a bit of instrument switching) had a bit of Korg action going, which I like to see, and a startling resemblance to Justin Wolfers. Must be the surfer hair. I didn't find the songs translated particularly well from their album, and that wasn't even to do with the difficulty in replicated complex layers on stage – I just didn't think the vocals sounded anywhere near as good. The guy wasn't a bad singer, he was seemed a bit weak.

That might have been because it was the last show of Miami Horror's tour, though. The got Goldfields back on stage with them for the last song, and busted out a massive final few minutes. Very cool.





Three days later, on Tuesday, I braved the torrential rain to go to the launch of The Living End's sixth album, The Ending is Just the Beginning Repeating. Regular readers will know I'm a massive TLE fan, and I was lucky enough to snaffle one of the tickets given away in one of those "tell us why you deserve to go in 25 words or less" competitions. (For the record, my answer was along the lines of having driven from Melbourne to Port Pirie to see gigs, to secret shows out in country, flying to London, and following their entire 2009 Germany tour.) As my +1, I invited the biggest TLE fan I know, a woman from Melbourne who's seen over 100 shows and is currently decking out her car in TLE style. I'm not nearly that hardcore.

My brother wanted to go, too, and as luck would have it one of my friends works at the venue that was hosting the album launch, so she was able to take him in as her +1. Now my friend, J., knows me through swing dancing, and had no idea of my rock & roll predilections – which would go for most of my Sydney friends, I imagine –, so she was quite amused when I wandered straight to the front row and started saying hello to the crowd there.

The concert itself was great. The album wasn't out yet, but concert-goers had been treated to a sneaky online listen all of Monday. The Living End are also playing their new tour with a fourth member (Adrian Lombardi, of Blueline Medic), to fill out those guitar parts you don't usually get to hear. It worked really well, I thought; very tight. The concert was also the first Australian concert to be streamed live via YouTube, and I had several friends spot me on the broadcast and tell me about it *grins*  I don't know when, exactly, but I think it was probably when I started the chant that brought the guys back for their encore – for the record, it was the "woah-woahs" from the start of TEIJTBR. Yep, that's mine: I claim it. All you people who do it on tour from here on in – I started it :-P

After the show, Chris, Scott, and Andy came out to do the standard meet and greet. Those who weren't taking advantage of the open bar flocked to them, but all those TLE fans who were on the band's messageboard were trying to organise a group photo. No sooner had we assembled everyone (which took yonks) than Chris walked in front of our photographer. That wouldn't have been so bad, except he was followed by a crowd of people who completely blocked her view! Once he noticed us, however, Chris grabbed Scott and Andy and they joined us for the photo – which promptly turned into a bit of a free-for-all as others jumped in and a multitude of cameras flashed.

My brother and I hung around for a while chatting to J. as everything was being packed up, and after she popped off to her office we were just about ready to go, before J. scurried back out and said, "Guys – there's a party in my office. Wanna come have a look?" So, we did! Lo and behold, TLE and their crew had decided J.'s spacious office was the perfect place to have some post-show drinks, so I took off my rain pants and booties (it was still pissing down) and joined them.

Now, I've seen The Living End lots and lots of times, and hung out with them after shows a few times, too. My brother, however, spent several minutes chatting to Scott (the bass player) before having to ask someone whether Scott was actually in the band or not – and this was after having seen the concert! *facepalm* Meanwhile, I was catching up with Woody, the ex-Webmaster/sound mixer, and some of the record label guys I didn't know.

When the party left J.'s office to head to a local Darlinghurst pub, the Gaslight Inn, Klaus and I were going to split, again – but, again, J. convinced us to come along, so we spent a few more hours at the (by that stage) after-after-party. And this on a Tuesday night, remember. Great fun! Great, great fun. I'm not sure how much more I can reveal here without possibly implicating people in criminal activity, but it was a night to remember :-D





Two days later – what are we up to, now, Thursday? – I went from rock concert to a completely different sort of event: Bell Shakespeare Company performing "Faustus", that classic German tale of selling your soul to the devil. I almost missed it – after getting caught in the rain on Tuesday, my bicycle lock was refusing to open, so I was catching buses everywhere. My bus to the Opera House was supposed to arrive at 7:00pm (for a 7:30pm performance), but Sydney doesn't know what the fuck to do when it's wet. As a result, between 7:00pm and 7:20pm my bus had only managed to move about 300m, from Oxford St to Liverpool St.

I convinced the driver to let me out (in the middle of the street, but it wasn't like traffic was moving), and ran the remaining 2km, through the rain, to take my sodden place just minutes before the show started. It was well worth it, though. John Bell was magnificent as Mephistopheles, and the rest of cast very good, too. I don't know enough about the play to judge their interpretation, but the execution was very good. Definitely something I'd do again. Bell, especially, just makes the rhyming prose sound like natural speech. Remarkable actor.





Lest you think that was all, tonight my brother's house is hosting a "house cooling" party, to which at least 300 people have been inviting. "Only" 120 or so have responded in the affirmative, but it should be massive, and very messy. It's a costume party, but without a theme i.e. wear whatever costume you like. There will be totem tennis, giant Jenga, beer bongs, danceable DJs, and other alliterative accoutrements.

At this rate, I'm kind of glad my football games this weekend have been cancelled!

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Power to the people

An update on my dispute with my real estate agent: I am not an evictee!

As I'd suspected, Eastside Realty were just using the CTTT hearing to try and intimidate me and, once they had their money – which, remember, I'd starting paying back before I even received the hearing notice –, they cancelled their hearing.

Not that they told me, of course. I turned up on Monday to the tribunal, in the middle of the day, and stood around awkwardly for a while as clerks with conflicting lists tried to figure out whether I was supposed to be there or not.

On the one hand, I was a little sad not have the hearing: I was well-prepared, and had jotted down a few points I wanted to make to George in the comfort of the conciliation room about how the fundamental problem here was that he wasn't treating me with any respect, yadda yadda yadda. (I won't repeat the rest here; I feel a bit silly doing so.) In a sense, I was spoiling for the fight.

On the other hand, I was happy to take the "victory", if you want to see it as such. Perhaps things might not have gone my way. Perhaps my advice may have been wrong, perhaps I might simply have antagonized George further. Lack of hearing = lack of risk.

Whether related or not, however, there is another development: after not having to pay any utility bills in my tenancy so far, due to the lack of individual metering for the units, Eastside Realty sent me a letter on Tuesday informing me that individual electricity meters had now been installed and I should ring an electricity provider to avoid possible disconnection.

I think the reason for this change has more to do with the fact that the ground floor shop, which used to pay the bills for the whole building, has had no tenants for a few months now; apparently every business that moves in has much higher costs than expected and closes down (!). That means the landlord is now paying our bills, and since his attempt to run a pie shop failed (I hear he was shut down for not having the proper authorization), he's decided this can't go on.

Not that I blame the landlord! I feel a bit sorry for him (and the shop tenants), actually: having seen the power-sucking televisions and heaters the girls downstairs use, I wouldn't want to be paying their bills either. And if I get to switch my electricity use renewable energy, so much the better. However, our individual meters are all installed inside the ground floor shop – where we can't get to them, obviously. I'm currently trying to find out whether a unit can count as being individually metered if the tenant doesn't have access to that meter – the fun and games isn't over yet!

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Floor Pricing for Alcohol

A journalist whose views I usually respect today derided calls for an increase in the minimum price of alcohol as coming from the "killjoy" crowd, who "do not even attempt to ... estimate the value of the pleasure given by alcohol to the vast majority of Australians who do not abuse it."

This is balderdash. As with gambling, the problem is not with what the vast majority of Australians do, but with the problematic excesses of a few. In the case of alcohol, it is the problem of those who purchase litres of cask wine at 30c per standard drink and proceed to destroy their health and lives. Prevalently, these are people of lower socio-economic status, especially Aborigines. Coles, Woolworth, and IGA have already almost quadrupled this minimum price in Alice Springs by selling alcohol at no less than $1.14 per standard drink, without affecting the prices of beer, spirits, better wines, etc – the stuff the vast majority of Australians actually drink.

The Henry Review suggested that the final rate of volumetric tax should "be intended solely to optimise price signals facing consumers. It should be set without regard to the government's fiscal position, and irrespective of any specific spending commitments related to alcohol abuse" (Australia's Future Tax System, Chapter E5-3, 2010).

Floor pricing for alcohol is a sensible health proposal that deserves support, not to be dismissed out of hand as coming from the "killjoy" crowd.