Sunday, July 17, 2011

Down on the corner, out in the street

...is where my landlord wants to see me: an eviction order, he doth seek.

Actually, that's not quite true: the application has been made by the real estate agents, Eastside Realty, thus continuing their established history of being cocks. Here's the story:

To get to my apartment from the street, you go through a gate into the garage, from which a hallway leads into a stairwell with stairs (!) that lead to apartment door. In December of 2010, the lock on the gate broke. Though there are doors between the garage and hallway, and hallway and stairwell, they are unlockable, so the broken gate lock meant there was free access to all the common areas of the property (including where I store my bicycle).

In December of 2010, I emailed the property manager of Eastside, George Karabalios. He didn't respond. I emailed him again, rang, emailed, rang, emailed, etc, until April of 2011, when nothing had been done, I wasn't getting any response from George, and was sick of the whole thing. So I took Eastside Realty (well, technically my landlord, since Eastside are just the agents) to the Consumer, Trader, and Tenancy Tribunal (CTTT).

Going to the CTTT was annoying, since I had to pay a fee and take a morning off work – but George sucks at communication, so there we were. At the CTTT, you don't just go in a get a ruling: you try and work things out in conciliation beforehand. In conciliation, George told me that, while they were working on fixing the lock (which I had been hearing for months; the extent of their 'repairs' were to rip the cover off the lock and bend the inner workings a bit, which didn't achieve anything) and were happy to submit to an order to that effect, I didn't actually have a right to have the lock fixed, because my rights as a renter stop at the door to my apartment. "Umm, no", said the conciliator: "It's common property. He has a right to reasonable security. Fix the lock." 'You cockspank', I added in my head.
So, in mid-April, I left with an order requiring the lock be fixed within two weeks.

At the end of April, I went on holiday for two weeks. When I left, the lock was broken. When I returned, the lock was broken. Interim summary: communication = no result. CTTT order = no result. Upset and frustrated, I did what every rental advice you will ever get warns you to not do: I withheld rent. Not much: just 1/3rd of my weekly amount each week. And before doing so, I emailed George and told him I was cancelling Eastside's direct debit from my bank account and switching to the reduced payments. He didn't respond. (Quelle surprise!)

I almost get the feeling emails from me land in a special "PIA" folder, because when a leasing agent rang to enquire about the missing rent she had heard nothing about my email. I told her to ask George – and THEN I got a response from him. My reply was simple: "You fix the lock, and I'll start paying rent again." You cockspank.

After a second week of partially withheld rent, George sent me a letter telling me I was behind, and had an obligation to pay. I told him he was (by that stage) six months behind on his obligations, and suggested he treat me with some respect by addressing the actual problem: the fucking lock.

Two weeks later – after being broken for seven months –, the lock was fixed, and I resumed full payments of my rent. Did I pay the withheld portion of my rent back? Are you kidding?? After seven months of being ignored, dicked around, and generally being treated with a lack of respect, I decided to turn the tables on Eastside and make them chase me. So I did what they did: nothing. Missed a few phone calls (mostly by mistake, actually). When I did answer, told them I'd look into it. Was generally an arse. It felt good.

After a month of this, I'd had my satisfaction, and started paying back the 4/3rds of week's rent I owed Eastside Back in weekly instalments of a 1/3rd. Just before that, however, George had obviously decided to escalate the issue (no four months waiting for him), and applied for an order to the CTTT himself. His request? That I be evicted within 14 days; lose my bond; and pay a fine.

The letter didn't arrive until a week and a half later, and when I got it was I very nervous for a while. Could this happen? Could they just throw me out like that? I asked Twitter for advice, and some people pointed me toward factsheets that seemed to suggest that, if I didn't owe the landlord any rent (or entered into a repayment plan), it would be unusual to be evicted. By that point, I had already paid half my withheld rent back, and – seeing as I had obviously been even more trouble to Eastside than I had hoped (though still not as much as they to me), I transferred the other half over.

I still have the hearing, though: tomorrow, in fact. I feel like I'm on fairly solid ground: advice I got from the Tenants advice line suggests that I need to be at least 14 days rent in arrears before the matter will even go before the judge – while I was arrears in some amount of rent for more than 14 days, the amount of rent I owed was only 4/3rds of a week: less than 14 days' worth, in other words. Further, even if the advice line was wrong on this point, the landlord would need to show that I were someone who frequently failed to pay rent. I had never failed to pay rent, only reduced it; and I didn't do so frequently, only within the context of this dispute.

So, there's what's happening right. Pretty exciting, if not necessarily in a positive way! Certainly a bit of nervousness, though less than at the start. I am, however, holding off a few things until Monday afternoon when I know where I'll be living for the next few months. Even if I win this round, my lease only runs until the end of September – it'll be interesting to see what happens after that :-/

No comments: