So, the Resource Super Profit Tax (RSPT) has been replaced with the Mineral Resource Rent Tax (MRRT). What's all that about?
The RSPT, as I've written about previously, was a very solidly thought out tax based upon the concept that, since the stuff the Australian people are giving the resource sector can only be sold once, we should get more from it than if the sector were using something that doesn't run out (e.g. farming). Further (and unrelated to the fact it's a non-renewable resource; this is just good general taxation policy) the amount we got should be somehow linked to the amount the stuff is worth.
The second of these reforms has been kept in the MRRT. The first – the bigger rationale behind the tax – has been beaten, bludgeoned, and finally sloughed off to die in a muddy ditch. Not to belabour the point, but I'm really not impressed with what the Australian Government has done here.
If you are of short attention span, here's the summary: dumping the RSPT for the MRRT is a very good (short-term) political move, and rubbish economic policy.
Rather than going through the whole thing again, let's look at some of the bigger changes (from the media release):
- "The Government will focus the resource tax reforms on our biggest and most profitable commodities: iron ore, coal, oil and gas." – Why only these? This is a political rationale (let's tackle a few big things that look good, while shutting all those small miners up) rather than an economic rationale (which would apply equally to all resources). That being said, this isn't all that bad: though it reduces the number of companies affected from 2,500-odd to 320, it still covers three-quarters of the market (by value). Of course, if something other than iron ore, coal, oil, or gas become valuable in future, we'll have to adjust the tax. And we can all imagine how easy that will be...
- "Iron ore and coal will be subject to a new profits-based Minerals Resource Rent Tax (MRRT) at a rate of 30 per cent." – this is a backdown, pure and simple. Choosing the rate is not really a question for economists, any more than deciding how high pensions should be is; everyone gets a say on that. So this is me talking as a regular voter, not as an economist: I think that this is soft; a cave-in to get the issue off the table quickly and make Gillard look good. It's something Rudd wouldn't have been able to do, and for that I miss him. Our new Prime Minister has brought with her a new capacity to "compromise" before being seen as back-flipping. My real revulsion, however, arises through the combination of the reduced rate with...
- "Projects will be entitled to a 25 per cent extraction allowance that reduces taxable profits subject to the MRRT. This allowance recognises the contribution of the miner's expertise to profits at the mine gate." – "contribution of miner's expertise"? Are you fucking kidding me? Not only will we be taxing the miners at a lower rate, we're going to exempt 25% of their profits from the tax because of – no, look, I'll tell you why: it's because they're good at lobbying. That's all this is. Sickening.
- "MRRT assessable profits are calculated on the value of the commodity, determined at its first saleable form (at mine gate), less all costs to that point." – I don't know enough to comment properly, but it sounds fishy.
- "Small miners with resource profits below $50 million per annum will not have an MRRT liability." – This won't change the revenues that much, but it's not like the "you don't earn much so we're going to make life easy for you" personal tax treatments (see, e.g., the proposals for bank interest or deductions) – these are companies with up to $50 million dollar profits. They can afford accountants. My opinion: buying the small miners off.
There are more changes that are less important – no more exploration rebate, a smaller company tax rate decrease – and others that, while important, I'm frankly too tired to address right after having driven from Sydney to Melbourne (a post on that should appear in the next few days).
Dumping the 40% "equity" thing and changing the way depreciation and uplifting are handled require more concentration that my post-drive (and post-football) brain is able to muster right now, but I hope to get to it soon.
Watch this space.

