I sent a letter to The Age yesterday about the Resource Super Profit Tax (RSPT), which was published today with minor alterations. Here is my original text:
RSPT was always going to kick in above 6%
Sir,
Lest the Government's negotiations to raise the rate at which the RSPT takes effect be seen as weakness on their part: the original "Australia's Future Tax System" report clearly stated that the industry needs to be compensated for "the time value of money (the risk-free return) and a premium for the risk associated with investment (the risk premium return for systematic risk)."
Dr. Henry confirmed as much in his post-budget address to the ABE, stating in an example, "The appropriate rate of return for a resource project will include an appropriate risk premium, say 9 per cent. With a risk free rate of 6 per cent, the required rate of return is 15 per cent."
The Government and the miners will now argue about how high the level of systematic risk is, and rightly so. But it seems clear from the report and Dr. Henry's remarks that the RSPT was always going to kick in at 6% + X.
I hold little hope that my letter will be read (or understood) by many, but I do hope I'm taken more seriously than the drongo whose letter followed mine.
N.B. The quotes were taken from the Australia's Future Tax System report and Dr. Henry's address.
Further reading:
Though I don't wish to turn this blog into merely an outlet for my economic and political views, I do find this topic particularly interesting because it's a) a rare public discussion of fairly "pure" economics and b) an issue of political importance, not simply because of the possible tax income but because it's an issue the Rudd Government needs to "perform" on and can't put on the backburner like the Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme. Success here could – this is my hope – give Labor the guts to engage on climate change again and submit something better than the crap that was their Emissions Trading Scheme.
In any case, I would like to recommend the following three articles by three well-respected economists:
- Paul Frijters provides an overview of the winners and losers of the RSPT. (PRO)
- Henry Ergas keenly identifies some pitfalls. (CONTRA)
- Nicholas Gruen says the RSPT could be a leading Australian policy innovation. (PRO)
None of them provide all the answers, and you can argue about whether they even ask the right questions. (For the most part, I'd say they do.) But wouldn't it be boring if they did?

No comments:
Post a Comment