The University of New South Wales (UNSW) has been holding a series of public lectures under the title of "
At The Edge"; the first two were on Climate Change and the Emissions Trading Scheme; tonight there was one on sustainable population. The panel consisted of
Dick Smith,
Bob Carr,
Ross Gittins, Nigel Stapleton (Head of Economics at UNSW), and Wendy Shore (Human Geographer at UNSW). These are my notes from the evening (most of which I flooded Twitter with under the
#attheedge hashtag): first 5-minute talks from each panellist, then questions from the audience.
Dick Smith
- People my age have buggered up the country for you <30-year-olds
- Sustainability: In any given period,the goods & energy you use are replaced.
- Currently we (the world?) uses double that which we replace.
- Free market based on exponential growth. Business and Governmental leaders sacked if they don't deliver growth.
- Most capitalists believe in growth now, for their own benefit, but not in the long run.
- Some people say capitalism can't work without growth – he doesn't believe that. Compares that to the argument that capitalism can't survive without slavery.
- Up until WW2, efficiency gains were used to reduce working hours. Since then, used to produce more stuff.
- Australia _could_ go up to 100m people – but what would the advantage be?
- 8/10 richest countries in the world have small, stable populations: ~10m
- All we have to have to do is move from an economic system based on the growth of resource consumption, to one based on the growth of efficiency.
- We need a different GDP
Nigel Stapleton, Head of Economics
- Human footprint depends on population. In Japan, this footprint is starting to decline.
- Without the struggle for day-to-day survival, rich countries are spending more on the environment.
- China has low birthrate; will keep that, even once it's repealed the One Child Policy; will follow Japan
- India will have the higher birth rates, and larger human footprint.
- Raising GDP will lower birth rates. Thus, we'll see a peak, then a decline in global population as countries get rich.
- Zero chance that Australia's population will stay at 22m. Doesn't know how high they'll go.
- Benefits of higher immigration: benefiting global prosperity. Make poor people richer, and lower their birth rate by doing so.
- Sustainability a function of technology; today's population not possible with the tech from 1800
Bob Carr
- Starts off with a jibe at Tony Abbott and his supposed sincerity by walking amongst the crowd.
- Increase of population in going to occur along the eastern coast of Australia; not the bush.
- Two arguments that shit him:
- "It's all a matter of planning. Let's make the power Federal."
- The cities have good plans.
- But when the ppl in Canberra double immigration overnight, by stealth, that creates pressure!
- No-one supports a state government when they say growth means going up, or out. (Sydney has chosen to go up.)
- What was the second point?
Wendy Shore, Human Geographer from Faculty of Science
- Core debate: how to grow or stem Australia's population through immigration. Is that really sustainability?
- Going through measures of sustainability.
Ross Gittins
- Comment from the moderator about the title of Gittins' latest book, "The Happy Economist": first book to be both a tautology AND an oxymoron
- Economists say economic growth and environmental sustainability are compatible
- Ross reckons it's because they look at the two separately, and place too much trust in the ability of technology and man-made capital to substitute for the use of non-renewable resources.
- Warns non-economists: contribution of immigration to net living standards isn't as high as you think.
- Companies like "bigger is better", but that doesn't apply to people: does growth apply to increased GDP per person? (Greater material prosperity.)
- Plenty of studies have shown immigration doesn't raise income per person – except amongst the immigrants themselves.
- Why? Because that extra labour requires more capital (capital broadening): homes, machines, infrastructure.
- Economic benefits of extra workers cancelled out by the cost of that capital.
- We only surrender our control over immigration to the economy if we assume that the economy is the only thing that matters and ignore the environment.
Questions
Are there different understanding of sustainability between ecologists/environments and economists/politicians?
DS: Business people and politicians don't understand sustainability; they don't want to.
NS: Notion that we aren't going to change the environment hasn't ever been true: humans have always done that.
BC: Doesn't answer question.
WS: Ecological arguments came from fruit flies; economic argument from "sustainable growth"
RG: Goes back to the fallacy of technology. Misunderstanding on both sides: "We need an end to growth" – no, we just need different growth. GDP growth through productivity, not inputs. Scientists and economists can agree on that. Once people understand that, economists in demand, b/c on they can deliver it.
Which ecosystem would you destroy in order to save the environment?
NS: Won't name an ecosystem. But we can't make the poor suffer. Rich can't keep prosperity for themselves.
DS: Has problem with continually growing populations (and Nigel's support there-of). Down with the baby bonus! Women aren't stupid! *cheers*
I think we can't feed 9.1billion under any circumstances; no second "green boom" (tech won't save us).Why can't economists see this?
RG: Can't see it because they won't look.
DS: Everyone who's predicted doom in the past has been wrong; therefore we assume they'll always be wrong. All my rich friends are climate deniers. Not one of them believes in it. People are stupid! Young people of today do nothing!
Would we be able to sustain a higher population if we lived in smaller regional centres?
WS: Dunno, but I...
BC: I have a view on that- sorry, did you want to say something?
BC: Can't stop people from moving. Problem of water, no matter where you are. Going to be density on east coast regardless.
DS: We are an arid country. All our river flows don't add up to that of the Mississipli. We probably have too many people now. Already net importer of fruit and vegetables.
WS: Australia does not have a water problem: it has a distribution and use problem. Dams in the wrong places, etc. (DS "That's ridiculous!")
What is Australia's sustainable population?
DS: No idea. Our scientists have let us down!
NS: Not going to put a number on it, but more than we have now.
BC: Sydney's water/population ratio is the best of any capital city. He'd like to see higher urban density, more public vs. private transport use, better water efficiency, lower greenhouse emissions per head. These are his key indicators. Supports nuclear power (scattered applause). Not naming a number, but wants a debate.
WS: I don't think like that (in numbers). But we'd have to accept people from the region of they came.
RG: Also no numbers. But, responding to DS, scientists didn't explore the question b/c politicians didn't throw any money at it.
DS: Australian families optimise their family size – why, when we talk about Australia, is bigger always better?
Final thought from moderator, Paul Willis (scientist and television host): Watch Catalyst – you've paid for it!
And final thought from the hosts: Hydroponics: can grow pot, but also tomatoes. Bob Carr: the first politicians to not like people.
My final thoughts: while I greatly respect and admire Ross Gittins for his tremendous ability to make economics understandable and interesting for the general public, and will spruik his columns almost unreservedly, I can't always say the same about his more complex views. Other economists (whom I also respect)
have expressed slightly more forceful reservations.