Tonight I was at a public lecture by Naomi Oreskes from the University of California; she's co-authored a book called "Merchants of Doubt", about the people behind the denials of climate science (among other things). Here are my notes from her talk (also posted on Twitter using the #MODaus hashtag).
In the mid-2000s, it seemed like Americans had gotten the message: 72% completely or mostly convinced global warming was underway.
Frank Luntz, Republican strategist, issued a 2003 memo – use scientific uncertainty as a political strategy; make it a primary issue in the deabtes.
"Scientific uncertainty" is at odds with the IPCC reports of 2001 and 1995. Are the IPCC reports consistent with general scientific opinion? A random survey by Oreskes of 1000 articles in peer reviewed journals found no dissenting opinions.
In the 1970s, there was consensus that climate changes will result from man's combustion of fossil fuels and changes in land use. The only serious question was "when".
Recalls a story of a scientist briefing the White House: when will this happen? / maybe in 40 years / get back to me in 39.
Had changes already started? 1982: probably, but no definite signal.
James Hansen testified to Congress in 1998: 99% certain that CC is underway. Led to Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in 1988
Attacks from late 1980: George C. Marshall Institute, Washington DC think tank – "uncertainties too great"
What is its origin and motivation?
Founded in 1984 by three men: Robert Jastrow, Frederick Seitz, William Nierenberg – successful and respected physicists who worked in rocketry and similar industries, and worked together on the "Star Wars" SDI program. Many scientists boycotted the SDI because it went away from the doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction.
Seitz worked as a consultant for tobacco industry: principle strategy was "doubt-mongering".
1989: cold war ended, Soviets were gone, SDI not needed. Marshall Institute found a new enemy: "environmental extremism". Began to apply the tobacco strategy. (1969 memo: "Doubt is our product, since it is the best means of competing with the 'body of fact' that exits in the minds of the general public")
Doubt-mongering needs its own science.
Tobacco
Acid Rain
Ozone Hole
Global warming
How?
Cherry-picking data
Take data out of context
Personals attacks on leading scientists (stealing private emails)
Pressuring journalists to write "balanced" stores giving equal weight to industry position
Find tiny handful of dissenting scientists, promote them on television, radio, and in print media to create impression of real scientific debate.
Why would scientists do that?
Not for personal gain, but out of free market idealism: neo-liberalism
Environmentalism => regulation => socialism!
Driven by S. Fred Singer; another rocket scientist.
Senator James Inhofe: "Liberal conspiracy to bring down global capitalism"
Think tanks backed by companies whose money was at stake.
Alexis de Tocqueville Institute, Cato Institute, Competitive Enterprise Institute, American Enterprise Institute, Heartland Institute, Acton Institute, Frontiers of Freedom, Committee for Constructive Tomorrow, Institute for Public Affairs (I've emboldened the IPA because it's Australian; beware!)
Tobacco, Fossil Fuel, Mining, Chemical industries
Libertarian Foundations: Olin, Scaife, Smith-Richardson, Coors, Charles G. Koch
Problem: science was finding problems that couldn't be solved locally at the same time as government was moving away from national action.
Socialism does not necessary lead to fascism, nor capitalism to democracy
Irony: the longer we wait, the more likely that large-scale government intervention will be necessary (precisely the opposite of what these people want).
It's important to understand the science in order to understand the risks that will determine the required level of regulation.
How did these people "win"? Their work as cold war physicists had put them in contact with people in power: in media and government.
Pressure and threaten the media. Climate Scientists don't have this power.
Questions:
Australian conservative politicians want command & control; progressives want market solution – WTF? Any similar examples overseas?
Can't think of any, but that we act is more important than how we act.
Have you found a difference between scientists and engineers?
Didn't answer the question.
Nuclear as the way forward?
Kyoto protocol "one-size-fits all" no good; the French broadly accept nuclear power, for example, while the Germans don't. Oreskes doesn't have a problem with nuclear power in principle, but we have to consider the costs of fuel extraction and the dangers of proliferation and waste disposal.
Worth mentioning is also the entreaty by Robin Williams, the presenter of ABC radio's "The Science Show", to audience member to keep their questions brief: "It's a well-known fact that you're born with a certain number of words, and when you've said them all, you die. Your question, sir?"
Seitz worked as a consultant for tobacco industry: principle strategy was "doubt-mongering".
1989: cold war ended, Soviets were gone, SDI not needed. Marshall Institute found a new enemy: "environmental extremism". Began to apply the tobacco strategy. (1969 memo: "Doubt is our product, since it is the best means of competing with the 'body of fact' that exits in the minds of the general public")
Doubt-mongering needs its own science.
Tobacco
Acid Rain
Ozone Hole
Global warming
How?
Cherry-picking data
Take data out of context
Personals attacks on leading scientists (stealing private emails)
Pressuring journalists to write "balanced" stores giving equal weight to industry position
Find tiny handful of dissenting scientists, promote them on television, radio, and in print media to create impression of real scientific debate.
Why would scientists do that?
Not for personal gain, but out of free market idealism: neo-liberalism
Environmentalism => regulation => socialism!
Driven by S. Fred Singer; another rocket scientist.
Senator James Inhofe: "Liberal conspiracy to bring down global capitalism"
Think tanks backed by companies whose money was at stake.
Alexis de Tocqueville Institute, Cato Institute, Competitive Enterprise Institute, American Enterprise Institute, Heartland Institute, Acton Institute, Frontiers of Freedom, Committee for Constructive Tomorrow, Institute for Public Affairs (I've emboldened the IPA because it's Australian; beware!)
Tobacco, Fossil Fuel, Mining, Chemical industries
Libertarian Foundations: Olin, Scaife, Smith-Richardson, Coors, Charles G. Koch
Problem: science was finding problems that couldn't be solved locally at the same time as government was moving away from national action.
Socialism does not necessary lead to fascism, nor capitalism to democracy
Irony: the longer we wait, the more likely that large-scale government intervention will be necessary (precisely the opposite of what these people want).
It's important to understand the science in order to understand the risks that will determine the required level of regulation.
How did these people "win"? Their work as cold war physicists had put them in contact with people in power: in media and government.
Pressure and threaten the media. Climate Scientists don't have this power.
Questions:
Australian conservative politicians want command & control; progressives want market solution – WTF? Any similar examples overseas?
Can't think of any, but that we act is more important than how we act.
Have you found a difference between scientists and engineers?
Didn't answer the question.
Nuclear as the way forward?
Kyoto protocol "one-size-fits all" no good; the French broadly accept nuclear power, for example, while the Germans don't. Oreskes doesn't have a problem with nuclear power in principle, but we have to consider the costs of fuel extraction and the dangers of proliferation and waste disposal.
Worth mentioning is also the entreaty by Robin Williams, the presenter of ABC radio's "The Science Show", to audience member to keep their questions brief: "It's a well-known fact that you're born with a certain number of words, and when you've said them all, you die. Your question, sir?"

No comments:
Post a Comment