Thursday, August 09, 2012

A Comment on the Political Discussion of Electricity Regulations

With her speech to the the Energy Policy Institute of Australia on Tuesday, the Prime Minister Julia Gillard has moved (or at least expanded) the discussion of electricity regulations from the roundtable meetings and conferences of industry, academia, and government to the political arena. Hurrah..?

A few points:

Are there problems with dividend policy, reliability standards, and peak demand? Yes.

Have the incentives in the existing regulations led some states to act in a manner that has unnecessarily raised prices for consumers (and thus led to increased profits for the states)? Very probably.

Has this been going on for several years, including under Labor governments? Yes – but so what?

Reforming energy industry regulations isn't a particularly new issue for the industry itself, energy academics, or government bodies; the Department of Resources, Energy and Tourism (DRET) has been developing an Energy White Paper for a while now, with associated submissions and consultations. But even if you were to argue that the problems should have been addressed earlier, why shouldn't we address them now?

To suggest, as Oppisition Leader Tony Abbott did this morning, that there can't be a problem with electricity regulations, because otherwise the Federal Government would been telling us this for years, is facile. Opposition energy spokesman Ian Macfarlane might have been closer when he described the PM  as a latecomer, but again – so what?

Let's accept, for the sake of argument, that Julia Gillard's strategy is to a signicant extent motivated by political desires, chiefly to separate the effects of the carbon price from unrelated electricity price rises. If it leads to good energy market reform, I don't care.

I might be disappointed that worthy reforms aren't being undertaken because politicians don't see any votes in it,  but if a political party uses a policy debate to make its opponents look bad while focussing on implementing good policy, then I'm riding that gift horse until it gets distracted and wanders off to chew a Newspoll. (When it gets to the point of using a policy discussion chiefly to attack your opponents rather than actually try and solve any problems – see e.g. asylum seekers – that's a different matter.)

Has the carbon price made electricity prices rise this year? Yes. Yawn. Not that big of a deal. It certainly isn't the primary cause of electricity prices rises over the last few years. Spot the carbon price effect in this graph:

Energy Distribution Prices and Revenue per Customer Over Time


So when Abbott says,
"the problem is not the regulation of power prices. The problem is the carbon tax putting up power prices"
well, the Australian Energy Regulator disagrees on the first bit, and state reports disagree on the last bit.

Regardless of why they've been raised, whose fault they are, and what other problems may be out there as well, can't we just accept that these problems are real and talk about how to fix them? There's no time like the present (especially in politics).

Tuesday, August 07, 2012

The Effect of the Carbon Price on Electricity Prices

In an otherwise good article, Peter Martin today wrote that
[the TD Securities Melbourne Institute price index] reports a jump in electricity prices of 14.9 per cent and a jump in  household gas prices of 10.3 per cent, almost all of which would have  been due to the carbon tax. [emphasis mine]
This is incorrect, and, unfortunately, he is not the first journalist to make this mistaken claim. Evidence to the contrary be found in, for example, the reports from the relevant authorities in states that regulate their electricity prices:


New South Wales






Over all NSW retailers, the carbon price is responsible for slightly less than half of the latest regulated price rise.


Queensland



The regulated allowance for carbon costs was around 2c/kWh, of a 6-8c/kWh rise; 25-36%.


Western Australia

IMO – "2012 Energy Price Limits Review" (specifically the SKM MMA Final Report).

The maximum short term energy market price (STEM) rose by $9/MWh from $314/MWh to $323/MWh. In this case, the increase was entirely due to the carbon price:

However, in the last five years, the maximum STEM price has risen from $159.84/MWh to its current level of $314/MWh, and the WA Department of Finance notes:
Although WA’s electricity prices have increased, the prices are still  lower than the cost of supplying electricity. At the moment, the WA  Government covers this difference – paying a subsidy of $367 million in  the 2011–12 financial year.
As far as the trend of electricity prices rises go, the carbon price is a drop in the bucket.

57 year history of residential electricity prices in NSW and QLD

I haven't put in the effort to research the effects of the carbon price on electricity prices in states with deregulated industries (e.g. Victoria), but I'm sure they're similar.

That final image of historical prices in NSW and QLD, by the way, is from a very good fact sheet by the Energy Supply Association of Australia showing where our electricity prices sit in an international comparison. Fingers crossed for an update.

In the meantime, go forth and blame not the carbon price for the sins of the network.

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Laggard to Leader: a Review


Beyond Zero Emissions, the non-for-profit climate change group, yesterday released the latest in their series of plans to get Australia to a state of zero emissions (or below): Laggard to Leader; How Australia can lead the world to zero carbon prosperity.

The report springs from the observation, also reported by e.g. Crikey on Friday, that the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change is failing to achieve the actions required to prevent dangerous anthropogenic climate change. It then goes beyond this to suggest new means of addressing the problem, in which Australia leads the world to a zero carbon future.

Sound utopian? It’s actually reasonably well argued, by and large, even if it’s difficult to see our current crop of politicians implementing many of the report’s suggestions.

Laggard to Leader begins with a summary of the scientific need for action: if we want to constrain the rise in global temperatures to 2°C, then the world shouldn’t emit more than 550 gigatonnes (Gt) of carbon-dioxide-equivalent (CO2-e) greenhouse gases by 2050. Why 2°C? Because the really worrying thing about climate change is that the relationship between greenhouse gases and temperature could become non-linear, i.e. small emissions = big temperature rise;  this is estimated to occur somewhere between 2°C and 5°C.

On current projections, Laggard to Leader estimates the world will emit those 550 GtCO2-e by 2025 and warm by 6°C by the end of the century. With this metaphorical fire under our backsides, what is the world doing about it? Not nearly enough, writes the report, providing a very useful potted history – for those who don’t subscribe to international policy journals – of UN climate negotiations, the tactics involved, and the flaws in their outcomes; Australia in the 1990s, for example, made sure to maximise the scope of land-based emissions removals it could count as credits, while minimising those sources counted as debits; Russia and other ex-soviet states received billions of emissions credits made unnecessary by their unexpected deindustrialisation; and the USA and China seem to be engaged in a game of ‘abatement chicken’.

Having argued fairly convincing that the current top-down “treating, targets, and trading” paradigm is failing, Laggard to Leader suggests an alternative approach: countries engage in “Cooperative Decarbonisation”, in which “each country [phases] down to zero or very near zero the greenhouse gas emissions associated with every economic and social process over which it has control or influence.”

This “control or influence” argument – described as the “’sphere of influence’ approach” – is crucial for the rest of the report, as it establishes the rationale for claiming that Australia’s (and other countries’) responsibilities aren’t confined simply to the emissions produced domestically. The chapter worth reading in full, but a central point is that a focus on domestic emissions only makes sense in the context of a comprehensive, legally binding, and effectively enforced global regime of emissions reduction targets – which clearly isn’t the current situation.

Under the perhaps second-best but more realistic scenario of distributed or bottom-up action, the scope of emissions under Australia’s “control or influence” (and therefore those for which we bear at least partial responsibility) is staggering: 4% of the world’s emissions, primarily due to our fossil fuel exports.

Laggard to Leader, p. 20

Having established the scope for action – from a scientific and moral standpoint – the rest of Laggard to Leader describes in more detail the “Cooperative Decarbonisation” approach, exploring both domestic and international policy options.

It’s ambitious stuff: countries should form cooperative groups based on the goal of tackling particular causes of climate or the developing and deploying zero-carbon technology, with each group containing those countries with the greatest needs and capacities for help (and interest in participating). Where cooperation fails, countries should go it alone.

Countries should build a “race-to-the-top” culture, establishing norms and standards of conduct for the non-use of fossil fuels, as exist for e.g. nuclear testing and anti-personnel landmines, or, more formally, moratoria on mining in Antarctica and the use of nuclear weapons. Here Laggard to Leader provides past examples of Australian international leadership, arguing that we have an historical identify as a leader and are socially recognised as such by other states.

Between this ‘social’ position, our market-leading position in the fossil fuel trade – Australia is the world’s top coal exporter, and expected to be the top LNG exporter by the end of the decade –, and our high wealth, Laggard to Leader argues that we are in an almost unique position to decarbonise quickly, help developing countries do the same, and play a leadership role in facilitating international cooperation.

Under this plan, Australian fossil fuel exports (and domestic usage) should be phased out entirely, while providing assistance to developing countries to help them replace the fossil fuels with zero-carbon technology. Australia should price international flight and shipping emissions on transport to our shores, as well as implement border tax adjustments for goods whose greenhouse gas content is not adequately priced in source countries. And we should significantly ramp up investment in zero-carbon research, development, and deployment.

Much of Laggard to Leader is, if taken in isolation, not that controversial. If you accept the science, then the need for action is fairly self-evident, and the technology and policies described in the latter part of the report have been an on-going area of discussion between and within academia, industry, and government for a while. What sets Laggard to Leader apart and moves it into uncomfortable territory is – as with many of BZE’s publications – the marriage of technical possibility with ambition at a grand scale. Many won’t like the conclusions, and thus dismiss the whole report, but the argumentation is strong enough that Laggard to Leader’s conclusions bear consideration. Grand ambition may be our best hope.



I was not involved in writing Laggard to Leader, but provided feedback on an early draft.

Laggard to Leader is being launched tonight (24/07) in Sydney, and on Thursday (26/07) in Brisbane.



Friday, July 20, 2012

New Blog Is Live: martincjones.com

When I started this blog, it was a mixture of stuff I was writing for myself and stuff I wanted to share with my friends – part diary, part mental sandbox, part way for friends to keep up with what I'm doing, as I write in the blog description. It started out over at (the now defunct) CrimsonBlog, before migrating here (and losing a few months of posts in process), and has gradually evolved as my interests in writing changed and the possibilities of communicating with friends changed (i.e. Facebook).

With my advance into Twitter, there were suddenly strangers who were interested in my opinions on economic/social/political issues of the day. "You should start a blog", they'd say, after I'd tweeted prolifically about something-or-other. "I have one," I'd respond, "but can't link you to it because it's got personal stuff on there, too."

That problem – that I write things on this blog that I want to share with strangers, but its mixed with stuff I don't feel comfortable promoting – I have solved by creating a new blog, consisting essentially of a stripped back version of this blog.

I say 'stripped back', but the truth is it's a little fancier: I shelled out for a domain name, and am paying Squarespace for hosting; the attraction of their service is that it's easier than self-hosting, but more feature-rich than a free blog. Doesn't cost the world, either. Anyway, I've a built a swish new blog there, and while I'll still be posting stuff here (with the contextual commentary I provide for the intended audience of 'people who know me'), if for whatever reason you want to share my brilliance with anyone, hop over to www.martincjones.com and send them a link from there. Strangers don't really need to know about my bus rides to school or whatever.

Though I do find myself doing this again.

Wednesday, July 04, 2012

Excel Advanced Filter OR+AND conditions

For future reference:

Consider a data range from A1:C22, with headers "Buyer", "Seller", and "Quantity" in cells A1, A2, and A3 respectively. Traders are Alan, Barry, Christina, Deborah, Evan, and Gwen. (Sample file here.)

For simple advanced filtering I would put "Buyer" and "Seller" in cells A25 and B25 (or where-ever) as the top row of my criteria range, with my conditions below. E.g., (Buyer=Alan) AND (Seller=Barry) would be
A26: ="=Alan"
B26: ="=Barry"
For (Buyer=Alan) OR (Seller=Barry), the conditions go on separate rows:
A26: ="=Alan"
B27: ="=Barry"
For (Buyer=Alan OR Barry OR Evan) AND (Seller= Christina OR Deborah OR Gwen), I need to replace my headers in the criteria range: "Buyer" and "Seller" become "Condition1" and "Condition2". Then:
A26: =OR(A2="Alan",A2="Barry",A2="Evan")
B26: =OR(B2="Christina",B2="Deborah",B2="Gwen")
Where "A2" and "B2" are the cells at the top of the columns in my data range containing the data to which the conditions are to apply.

I.e. The first condition (in A26) relates to the buyers, and the buyers are the column A. Cell A1 is the header, so the OR formula refers to cell A2.

Solution originally from Microsoft Answers.

Saturday, June 30, 2012

Pricing carbon has passed the acid test

With "carbontaxageddon" just around the corner, various Australian media outlets are doing final coverage before July 1 – I hear The Age has the duty of covering the country town of Whyalla, which Tony Abbott memorably said would be "wiped off the map" by carbon pricing. Ben Cubby, the Sydney Morning Herald's environment editor, rang me on Thursday to get some quotes for a piece he was writing. Cubby's a lot more balanced and sensible than Imre Salusinsky and Annabel Hepworth of The Australian, so I had few qualms speaking with him.

The article, "Pricing carbon has passed the acid test", is published today in the News Review section of the SMH (and, I assume, The Age). I believe this is the first time I've been quoted in an Australian broadsheet, which is kind of cool; even cooler is the fact one my lines runs as the "highlight quote" (or whatever it's called) – thanks, sub-editors! I went down and showed my neighbours :-)

Newspaper article with highlighted quote by Martin Jones, "emissions trading schemes have proven records."

I think it's a good piece, quite generally, and I'm happy with how I'm quoted in it. Here's the full text of what I sent Cubby, for the record:

Q: Will the carbon pricing scheme work to achieve 5% emissions reduction by 2020?

A: Under the assumption that the (ostensibly bipartisan) 5% target is reflected in the caps to the ETS and the scheme isn't scrapped, very probably.

Why:
- If you assume the political will to implement the scheme is there (a huge if), then the question is whether the scheme is designed well enough to achieve its goals. I think it is.
- The mechanism is an effective one: emissions trading schemes have proven records of reducing emissions; not just for greenhouse gases (e.g. in the EU), but also for other permits (e.g. sulphur dioxide in the USA).
- We have independent regulatory oversight and review, which is important and positive. The parties governing and reviewing the scheme are competent, well-respected in their fields, and have good track records (as does Australian governance and regulation generally).
- The scheme covers a sufficiently large proportion of Australia's emissions to have a material effect. (I haven't actually heard if it's still 60% directly/two-thirds indirectly since we're only covering 294 installations, but I assume so).
 - Emissions from excluded sectors – agriculture, forestry, part of transport – could throw a spanner in the works, if their emissions increase (counteracting decreases within the ETS). Hopefully transport will be included – ideally all, but at least the heavy transport planned from 2014. Agriculture is partially addressed through the CFI, but including that and forestry in the ETS would improve it – they're tricky areas, though. A few natural disasters could throw our emissions budget right out of whack.
- The potential exists in Australia to achieve sufficient abatement at costs low enough that it would not impose too onerous costs upon businesses or consumers. (Based on several studies I've seen, but my favourite is the ClimateWorks' update of McKinsey's cost curves for Australia in their "low carbon growth plan")
- Emissions reductions achieved through international credits/offsets are, by and large, 'real' reductions. Certainly not all of them are, and we're a little at the mercy of the certification agencies, but at least we have certification agencies (and the higher-rated ones are quite confidently legit.) The choice between low-cost and confidence in additionality/legitimacy is a political one.
- Most (reasonable) criticisms of the scheme I've seen have been whether the emissions reduction will be lowest-cost (e.g. the 'buying power stations out' component), not will it occur.

No hard feelings

After my neighbours locked me out on their balcony I wrote them a note of apology, saying, in essence, "I'm sorry I made you feel uncomfortable; I didn't know you were so weird." I found this response out on the balcony today, though judging by its condition it'd been there a few weeks and I just hadn't seen it:
Hi Martin,
It was the end of a long night – lots of drinks had, no hard feelings.
Cheers A.
I particularly like the bit where they accept my apology, but fail to offer one of their own. That's my favourite.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

UNSW in winter

Floodlight next to Village Green


UNSW library building framing half-moon

Cross-post: Does it make sense for Australia to restrict its export of fossil fuels?

A friend of mine wrote for the ABC about Australia taking responsibility for the greenhouse gas emissions generated by the fossil fuels we export, which inspired me to sit down and sort out my views on the topic. The notion of responsibility is often bound up with the idea of refusing to export fossil fuels – an idea also often ascribed to The Greens, though I wasn't able to find it in their official policies – which is an idea I think silly. After I figured out why I thought I was silly, I put my arguments into an article format, which New Matilda published today:

Who's Responsible For Exported CO2?


By Martin Jones

Once we dig up and sell the coal, are we still responsible for the emissions? 'Stop exporting fossil fuels' isn't a good enough solution when people in developing countries need to eat and build, writes environmental economist Martin Jones


During the Rio+20 sustainable development summit, Fergus Green and Reuben Finighan last week called for Australia to take responsibility for the greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) it enables through its exports of fossil fuels. Is this a good idea? How would we go about it?

Green and Finighan wrote that the Australian federal government should take a broader look at the sustainability of mining, focussing on the product, not just the process; i.e. it should consider the GHG generated by fossil fuels during their whole use cycle, not just the emissions generated during the mining process.

Mining nations such Australia, Green and Finighan argue, should take responsibility for the emissions caused when their exported fossil fuels are burned; assigning responsibility to the importers only makes sense in the context of an enforceable international climate change regime in which all major emitting countries were limiting their domestic emissions in line with science-based objectives.

Australia is certainly a large player in fossil fuels. We have around 9 per cent of the world’s proven coal reserves, and in 2011 were responsible for 5.8 per cent of the world’s production – down 2.2 percentage points on 2010 – making us the world’s third-largest coal producer after China and the USA. [1] 

Not needing nearly as many fossil fuels as China or the USA, we’re the world’s largest coal exporter, accounting for around 27 per cent of global trade [2]  Including liquid natural gas (LNG) exports and accounting for currently planned projects, critics of fossil fuel exports estimate that Australian fossil fuels could be responsible for 9 per cent of global GHG emissions by 2020 – and that’s excluding any domestic emissions. [3]

If Australia takes responsibility for its exported emissions, then presumably we would need to follow the same course as for our domestic emissions and reduce them. How? The most obvious answer is, “stop exporting fossil fuels.”

That’s also a poor answer, though, at least in the short- to mid-term. It’s probably by now common knowledge that mining products are Australia’s largest export earner, and large proportion of these are fossil fuels: as of April 2012, 27.5 per cent of our merchandise exports (by value) came from mineral fuels, lubricants, and related materials (primarily fossil fuels). [4]  

And though the mining industry isn’t nearly as large an employer or tax-payer as they’d like us to think – employing 2.3 per cent of the Australian workforce as of this May [5] , and paying 15 per cent of company taxes in 2009-10 [6]  – removing this revenue stream from the Australian economy would be a long and painful process.
(I refer not only to the ‘pain’ of economic transition, but also the pain the mining industry would inflict upon anyone trying to reduce their profits, and the pain Australians would go through listening to it all.)

There are moral problems to consider, too. The Australian Coal Association (ACA) lists China and India as the second- and fourth-largest importers of Australian coal; Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan are the first-, third-, and fifth-largest, respectively. [7] 

The ACA is not alone in expecting demand for resources from China, India, and other developing countries to increase dramatically in the next decade [8], which means refusing to export fossil fuels would make India or China’s transition to a first-world country longer and/or more expensive. A refusal to export also smacks a little of paternalism; a “we know better” attitude where we don’t trust nations to put our resources to good use.

This may well be a path we’re willing to take. There is a precedent for refusing to export resources to countries that we consider might not use them responsibly: fuels for nuclear weapons, such as uranium. Applied to fossil fuels, one could imagine a stance where Australia refuses to export coal, etc. to countries that haven’t signed sufficient agreements on low-emissions usage.

Where the consequences of the actions we enable are severe enough – burning Australia's fossil fuel reserves would take the world 60 per cent of the way to 2 degrees warming, write Green and Finighan – a degree of unilateral action can be justified.

(Given Australia now looks like exporting uranium to India despite its refusal to sign the Nuclear non-Proliferation Treaty, though, this is a weak precedent. [9]  Nor would I envy the foreign minister who has to sell such a policy to two of the world’s largest economies.)

The bigger moral problem, though, in my opinion, is a policy that would see Australia reduce our export of fossil fuels before reducing our own usage of them. For starters, our exported fuels are generally higher-quality resources that are less polluting than what we use domestically; our coal exports, for example, are almost exclusively black coal, which releases significantly less GHGs than the brown coal used in Australia (especially Victoria) for power generation.

Not only that, our fossil fuels are arguably put to better use by developing countries than they would be in Australia: building infrastructure in China or India, while it may be more carbon-intensive than here, will probably do more to improve the lives of their citizens than using those resources here would improve ours.

By no means do I wish to suggest that Australia should wash its hands of responsibility for the emissions of the resources we export: I welcome Green and Finighan’s call for Australian leadership on this issue. That fairly broad concept, however, involves some tricky questions, some – by no means all – of which I have raised here. I expect Green and Finighan’s upcoming report for Beyond Zero Emissions will address many of them, and I look forward more discussion of this issue in the future.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Grammar: less ambiguity, but fewer dickheads, please

I was having a discussion with @ephant today about grammar -- specifically the fewer/less rule -- and her argument was that the rule leads to hypercorrection, which is needless and ugly, and we would be better served teaching people, "if what you write might be ambiguous, reword it."

I like that rule. It's a good rule. It is, however, not enough. I mean, we teach people that already, don't we? "If your writing might be bad, try making it better." And it obviously doesn't work well enough to rely on it.

Given this -- that some people have trouble recognising the ambiguity of their own writing, let alone correcting it -- what's wrong with teaching them an additional, fairly simple rule to make their writing clearer?

Okay -- in some cases, strict adherence to the fewer/less rule can lead to clunky (read: uncommon) formulations. And ephant pointed to supermarket managers getting harassed over "X items or less" signs.
But, in the former case, I think trading the odd bit of clunkiness for the removal of ambiguity is worth it. And in the latter, the problem isn't the rule: it's zealotry. Simply because some people take an issue too far does not invalidate the issue.

It's not as though the hypercorrecters are the target, anyway. The less/fewer "rule" is for those who would write unclearly without it; hypercorrectors, by and large, don't fall into this camp. To reach them, just append the following to the less/fewer rule: "Don't be a dickhead about it." Then those who need the help have a rule, and those who don't can worry about more important things.

Like "Thru to shops" signs.