Friday, February 01, 2013

Australia’s carbon market at stake in September election

I'm quoted in the current issue of the Point Carbon ANZ newsletter, regarding the recently announced Australian federal election and Australia's climate policy. The story can be found via the above link; my full response to Stian Reklev is below.


Questions: 
1. In the international climate policy context, what would be the main difference between a Labor win vs a Coalition win?

2a. Is Tony Abbott likely to eliminate the ETS and institute his Direct Action plan instead, and can it easily be done?
2b. If Abbott does, how would this impact Australia’s domestic emissions profile?

3. If Abbott wins, would that mean Australia disappearing from the scene as one of the main advocates for an international carbon market?

Answers:
The Coalition’s lack of detailed policies make their actions difficult to predict, but it’s unlikely that a Coalition government would continue Australia’s recent run of strong international climate action advocacy, especially as far as international carbon markets are concerned.

While both Labor and the Coalition support international agreements to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, such as the Kyoto protocol, only Labor has recently supported joint global action to establish emissions trading schemes. Members of the Coalition have repeatedly been less than favourable toward foreign efforts to reduce or offset emissions. See e.g.
  • “in countries or organisations with less developed and less scrupulous administrative cultures [than Australia] the scope for corruption is obvious ... This is a market based on the non-delivery of an invisible product to no one, and is almost certain to be scammed” (Source)
  • “Australian businesses are going to have to spend more than $3 billion a year purchasing abatements from abroad - and we all know the potential for fraud, the potential for scamming.'' (Source)
  • “If such a sophisticated market as Norway is facing a $5 billion fraud, how will Australians know if that money is actually reducing emissions or is it going into the pockets of criminals? ... We will reduce emissions by 700 million tonnes by purchasing abatement in Australia that will clean up our own environment rather than sending money overseas.” (Source)
  • “[The Prime Minister] must also detail the measures and safeguards which will have to be put in place to ensure that the tens of billions of Australian taxpayer dollars committed to purchasing international carbon credits do not end up in the clutches of the carbon cowboys.” (Source)
  • “We aren’t reducing our emissions, we are just engaging in a massive transfer of wealth from this country to carbon traders overseas.” (Source)
  • “emissions reduction [based on foreign carbon credits] can easily turn out to be a real life version of the emperor’s new clothes” (Source)

While I again flag the lack of detail, the abatement policies suggested by the Coalition, such as direct action, likely wouldn’t offer as much abatement potential as a carbon price, cover as much of Australia’s emissions, and would likely cost more for what they would deliver. The DA and Emissions Reduction Fund at the moment seem to be essentially the same policies that the Coalition took into the last election, and they were heavily criticised at the time for focussing on a very narrow subset of options, not being scalable to achieve larger abatement, and exploiting only the ‘low-hanging fruit’ of emissions reduction while not prompting the deeper changes needed to decarbonise the Australian economy over the long term.

Change in the electricity sector will continue, as it is currently being driven more by the RET than by the carbon price, but the advancement of other low-carbon technologies risk stalling if efforts to provide a coherent regulatory and investment environment, such as through the CEFC, are wound down as promised. Trying instead to advance individual technologies is difficult: research and development of CCS, which the Coalition strongly supports, has been negligible despite the $400 million Global CCS Institute set up under Rudd.

If the Coalition win government in September, and follow their stated promise, they will introduce legislation to repeal the carbon price. This would pass the House of Representatives, but would presumably fail in the Senate where Labor and The Greens will still hold balance of power until at least 1 July 2014, when the senators elected in the 2013 election will take their places. Unless the Coalition win the election in landslide, Labor and The Greens will probably still control the Senate on 1 July 2014, and therefore be able to block the repeal of the carbon price.

To gain control of the Senate, a Coalition government would need to introduce their legislation (after 1 July 2014), have it blocked, wait three months, reintroduce it, and have it blocked a second time before being able to call a double dissolution election. Assuming they manage all this in 2014, Senators elected at that election would take their places on 1 July 2015.

Repealing the carbon price would be an incredibly tortuous process legislatively, for the public, and most of all for the businesses wondering whether they need to account for their liabilities under the existing carbon price, some replacement scheme, or nothing at all.

Sunday, December 09, 2012

Maybe don't lead with that

My party conversation needs a little work:
Her: "So, what do you do?"
Me: "I'm an environmental economist. I do research into climate change and energy policy."
Her: "Oh, that sounds cool!"
Me: "Yeah, I love it!"
Her: "So, what the latest on climate change? Are we all going to suffer in 5° higher temperatures? Haha."
Me: "Yeah, actually, we're pretty well fucked. It's not as though we don't know what to do – we're just not doing it. It's a bit depressing, actually."
Her: *pause* "So.. umm, hobbies?"

Friday, December 07, 2012

Backing the wrong horse

This conversation really occurred tonight, during a dance:

Her: "Do you have anything to do with horses, or horse-racing?"
Me: "Errm... no. Why?"
Her: "You smell like you do."
Me: "........... I smell like I do?"
Her: "Yeah. I'm a little psychic about stuff like that sometimes. What about betting on horses – are you a bookie?"
Me: "I'm not a bookie. I have nothing to do with horses at all. I'm an economist and work in a university."
Her: *shrug* "Well, you smell like you work with horse-racing."

I still don't know what to make of this. Except that bookies apparently smell like Hugo Boss and two hours dancing's worth of sweat.

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

Economics for five-year-olds

My neighbour's daughter asked what my job was. "I'm an economist," I replied.

"What's that?"

Normally I tell people that economists think about cost and benefits; the demand and supply of goods and services. I tell them we want to maximise 'utility', but since we can't measure it directly or ask people, we watch what people do instead (e.g. in markets) and use prices (money) as a proxy for utility.

From there, I explain that my field – environmental economics – is about valuing things that don't have markets, e.g. the environment. If they're really paying attention, I may even talk about externalities.

My neighbour's daughter, however, is five. She doesn't understand markets, or utility, or costs and benefits in an abstract sense. So I was stumped.

Months later, I've got a good answer:
An economist figures out how to share things so that everyone can be as happy as possible.


You're welcome.

Monday, September 24, 2012

Porto

Porto, Portugal. A beautiful city, when it's not raining.

Houses along the north bank of the Rio Duoro, Porto

Square on the north bank of the Rio Duoro, Porto

It's hilly as all buggery, with narrow, winding cobblestone lanes wedged between a brightly-coloured patchwork of three-, four-, five-storey buildings that wouldn't seem out of place in South America.

Steep, narrow stairs

Steep, narrow stairs

Rooves of Porto

The facades are as likely to be dirty crumbling slabs spicked with broken windows as gorgeous patterned tiles that remind me of the china adorning my mother's kitchen.

Building with broken windows

Cut-outs in windows

P1000161.JPG

We ate heartily and cheaply, though not well; I had a very tasty cod, but it was accompanied by fatty potato crisps swimming in the cod's vinegary soup. An earlier meal of calamari disappointed, with undercooked, fatty (again) french fries next to seafood from a freezer. Sunday is a poor day to try and find a decent meal, apparently, so I shan't be dissuaded.

P1000138.JPG

P1000140.JPG

P1000145.JPG

P1000158.JPG

P1000159.JPG

P1000162.JPG

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Der böse Ball

From a tram in Stuttgart


Der böse Ball

Kam ein böser Ball brusthoch geflogen;
Und ein guter Spieler nam ihn an.
Und der Böse flog in hohem Bogen
An den rechten Pfosten und sprang dann


An die Latte und dann ungelogen
An den linken, wo der gute Mann
Wie vom Bösen magisch angezogen
Stand und schoß: mit seinem rechten Spann.


Und der Böse, weil er Linksdrang hatte,
Flog vom linken Pfosten hocherfreut
Hin zum rechten, gleich drauf an die Latte


Und von dort, den Casus auszukosten,
Vor des Guten Fuß. Der traf erneut:
Zweimal Latte, einmal Außenpfosten.


Thomas Gsella, aus »Nennt mich Gott. Schönste Gedichte aus 50 Jahren«

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

Why drop the price floor? Taking a gamble on the EU ETS

I couldn't make much at first  of today's announcement by Greg Combet, Minister for Climate Change and Energy Efficiency, that Australia was going to link its ETS with the EU ETS – and oh, by the way, we're dropping the price floor.

That Australia and the EU will link their schemes good news, but it's an expected development. Dropping the price floor, on the hand, had been speculated about (notably by the AFR; well done, Marcus Priest), but wasn't part of the original plan.

As I wrote back in May, a price floor has some good things going for it, despite being technically challenging; and as it's only regulation the government has the numbers to pass it even against Rob Oakeshott's opposition. So my initial reaction was that the floor price had been put in the "too hard" basket and the ETS linkage was just used to disguise that announcement somewhat.

I've since heard, however, that dropping the price floor was a condition of the EU agreeing to link the schemes, and Australia replaced it with the restriction of foreign units. This makes more sense.

The EU currently has an oversupply of permits (European Union Allowances; EUAs), and will have for a quite a few years yet, so it would welcome a new source of demand: Australia. (Even if our purchase volumes aren't that great in the scheme of things.) An Australian price floor would not only lessen demand for EUAs, it would also make integrating the schemes more complex.

The price floor, though, was there to stop the Australian market being flooded by cheap foreign permits; to give domestic sources of investment into potential abatement (or offsets) the certainty that they would be able to get at least $15 for their product. What fulfils that role?

Well, we've moved from a price restriction to a (sort-of) quantity restriction. Previously, entities could meet up to 50% of their AU ETS liabilities with foreign units, but the only foreign units decided upon were those from the Kyoto Protocol: CERs, ERUs, and RMUs. The CDM market is currently even more oversupplied than the EUA market, and prices are down, down, down;(1) well below the $15 price floor.

Now, the 50% limit on international units is still there, but only 12.5% (of total liabilities) can be met by Kyoto units. Once that limit is reached, the relevant price domestic permits (ACUs) and offsets (ACCUs) have to compete against is that of EUAs. (Remember that the large amount of free permits – I don't have exact figures, but it's around 30-40% of our cap, I think; leave a comment if you've better info – lowers the effective size of the domestic market, so the 50% international unit cap isn't as strict as it sounds.)

That 12.5% limit suits not only the EU, since the EUAs don't have to compete against the Kyoto units for the other 37.5%, but also suits  those like The Greens who want the carbon price to rise over time: they expect the EUA price to rise over time, pulling ACU/ACCU prices with it. It's not a bad gamble – certainly, I think the chance of EUA prices rising above $15 is higher than that of CDM prices doing so. (Exchange rates play a role in all this as well, but I'm buggered if I know which way they're going.)

Limiting Kyoto units also does a little bit to allay concerns about the additionality of some of those units, though it's a fairly blunt instrument; a quantity control is not a quality control.

That's the policy side of things. On the politics side, the EU ETS integration/no price floor does some interesting things. The lack of an auction price floor and international surrender charge (which together constitute the 'price floor' we've been discussing) could well reduce government revenue from the carbon price; it depends on what the EUA price does.

More interestingly, though, I think the EU integration and lack of a price floor will make the AU ETS appeal more to free market types, especially since at first glance it looks like providing opportunities for cheaper abatement. (You fine readers, of course, know better.) And unless the Liberals want to start slagging off Europeans, they might reign back calling foreign abaters cowboys, scammers, frauds, and criminals.

Yeah, okay, I don't buy that last one, either. But at least the government now have a better response to that.

Finally, integrating more fully with the EU ETS effectively places more responsibility for domestic prices in their hands: if EUA prices go up, so will Australia's prices – sorry, guys, it's out of our hands! (Though we keep the price ceiling, I understand it will be set with reference to the EUA price; so no great limit, there.)

A lot depends on how well the EU can reform its ETS to drive prices back up into its preferred (by almost everyone but Poland) range – but then, that's always been the case.



(1) Come at me, Coles.

Sunday, August 19, 2012

Competition in dancing

A friend of mine got upset after a recent dancing competition in which he or she failed to finish in the top three. (Lower placings are not announced on the night.)

I left this comment on his or her blog, which was well received, and as I find the topic interesting I reproduce it here along with an except of the original post.


Original post (excerpted):
When you're being judged, regardless of result, its really hard, excruciatingly hard not to take things personally. So, ultimately in a creative space, being judged is large a contradiction. How do you NOT take things personally? I'm guessing that you need to have enough self resolve, enough worthy self esteem and enough perspective that conditions and subjectivity explains the judgement.

If I don't have a goal, then I'm just messing around. And in this creative field, there certainly is space for faffing about. But my goal was to achieve. To be validated. Which is unfortunate because the nature of competition is to be validated by others. I certainly feel like I got the skills, but do others? Do my peers think the same? They can SAY I got the skills but in my book, it needs to translate. You are good and here is the evidence. Without my goals, I am merely faffing. I don't wanna faff. I wanna succeed. And if I faff about then in an amazingly absolute statement, I don't wanna be a part of it.

There seems to be too much out of my control. There are those who have so much natural talent, effort and time to continue to win and get the box ticked in their favour. Its an equation of variables. Sometimes, you don't have what it takes to win.

So: you competed, and expected validation in the form of a placing; it was not forthcoming. You feel rejected. But what have you failed at?

You have failed at only one thing: convincing the judges that you were one of the three leads who best demonstrated mastery of the criteria by which the event you danced in was assessed.

Succeeding at this task would not have made you "good at dancing". While it is true that it's practically impossible to win a dance event and not be "good at dancing" – which is why it works so well as a validator – it's eminently possible to be "good at (almost all) dancing" and suck at competing. So while I recognise the attraction of competition, I think you should be clear about what role it plays in your dancing.

Most people's goal in dancing is, I posit, to be as good as they can be – or, at least, to be good enough to do X. (X = have fun, dance at 200 bpm, do an aerial, whatever.) Most people don't enter dancing with the goal of being better than anyone else. However, trying to be better than someone else is one of the best ways of improving yourself – that's the point of competition in the swing dancing scene. The goal is not simply to be the best: it is to have become the best by improving. And good on competition for doing that.

I have a competitive personality. Board games, foot-races, mental puzzles, sport – subconsciously, I will want to win, even if I don't enter them with that purpose; and to win, I need to beat other people. For mainly that reason, I don't compete as a swing dancer: my goals as dancer are to be good enough to do X, and I don't want my satisfaction with my dancing to become something that relies on me beating other people. Even if that means I don't improve as quickly as others.

Do I want to be "good at dancing"? Absofuckinglutely. Does it feel awesome to be recognised as such in front of a crowd? Hell yeah. Are competitions the only form of validation? Fuck no. Do people come up to you and complement you on your dancing? Do follows seek you out for dances? Repeatedly? Do people watch you dance; hoot and/or cheer? More importantly, do you feel as though you can express yourself musically through the form of dance? Do you get those moments of 'flow'? Isn't that why you dance?

TL;DR
Competitions are great for making you better dancer, but to win you need to be better than other people. If your goal is to be a better dancer, but you can't handle being worse than other people (even if you're better than you used to be), reconsider competing and/or your attitude.

Thursday, August 09, 2012

A Comment on the Political Discussion of Electricity Regulations

With her speech to the the Energy Policy Institute of Australia on Tuesday, the Prime Minister Julia Gillard has moved (or at least expanded) the discussion of electricity regulations from the roundtable meetings and conferences of industry, academia, and government to the political arena. Hurrah..?

A few points:

Are there problems with dividend policy, reliability standards, and peak demand? Yes.

Have the incentives in the existing regulations led some states to act in a manner that has unnecessarily raised prices for consumers (and thus led to increased profits for the states)? Very probably.

Has this been going on for several years, including under Labor governments? Yes – but so what?

Reforming energy industry regulations isn't a particularly new issue for the industry itself, energy academics, or government bodies; the Department of Resources, Energy and Tourism (DRET) has been developing an Energy White Paper for a while now, with associated submissions and consultations. But even if you were to argue that the problems should have been addressed earlier, why shouldn't we address them now?

To suggest, as Oppisition Leader Tony Abbott did this morning, that there can't be a problem with electricity regulations, because otherwise the Federal Government would been telling us this for years, is facile. Opposition energy spokesman Ian Macfarlane might have been closer when he described the PM  as a latecomer, but again – so what?

Let's accept, for the sake of argument, that Julia Gillard's strategy is to a signicant extent motivated by political desires, chiefly to separate the effects of the carbon price from unrelated electricity price rises. If it leads to good energy market reform, I don't care.

I might be disappointed that worthy reforms aren't being undertaken because politicians don't see any votes in it,  but if a political party uses a policy debate to make its opponents look bad while focussing on implementing good policy, then I'm riding that gift horse until it gets distracted and wanders off to chew a Newspoll. (When it gets to the point of using a policy discussion chiefly to attack your opponents rather than actually try and solve any problems – see e.g. asylum seekers – that's a different matter.)

Has the carbon price made electricity prices rise this year? Yes. Yawn. Not that big of a deal. It certainly isn't the primary cause of electricity prices rises over the last few years. Spot the carbon price effect in this graph:

Energy Distribution Prices and Revenue per Customer Over Time


So when Abbott says,
"the problem is not the regulation of power prices. The problem is the carbon tax putting up power prices"
well, the Australian Energy Regulator disagrees on the first bit, and state reports disagree on the last bit.

Regardless of why they've been raised, whose fault they are, and what other problems may be out there as well, can't we just accept that these problems are real and talk about how to fix them? There's no time like the present (especially in politics).

Tuesday, August 07, 2012

The Effect of the Carbon Price on Electricity Prices

In an otherwise good article, Peter Martin today wrote that
[the TD Securities Melbourne Institute price index] reports a jump in electricity prices of 14.9 per cent and a jump in  household gas prices of 10.3 per cent, almost all of which would have  been due to the carbon tax. [emphasis mine]
This is incorrect, and, unfortunately, he is not the first journalist to make this mistaken claim. Evidence to the contrary be found in, for example, the reports from the relevant authorities in states that regulate their electricity prices:


New South Wales






Over all NSW retailers, the carbon price is responsible for slightly less than half of the latest regulated price rise.


Queensland



The regulated allowance for carbon costs was around 2c/kWh, of a 6-8c/kWh rise; 25-36%.


Western Australia

IMO – "2012 Energy Price Limits Review" (specifically the SKM MMA Final Report).

The maximum short term energy market price (STEM) rose by $9/MWh from $314/MWh to $323/MWh. In this case, the increase was entirely due to the carbon price:

However, in the last five years, the maximum STEM price has risen from $159.84/MWh to its current level of $314/MWh, and the WA Department of Finance notes:
Although WA’s electricity prices have increased, the prices are still  lower than the cost of supplying electricity. At the moment, the WA  Government covers this difference – paying a subsidy of $367 million in  the 2011–12 financial year.
As far as the trend of electricity prices rises go, the carbon price is a drop in the bucket.

57 year history of residential electricity prices in NSW and QLD

I haven't put in the effort to research the effects of the carbon price on electricity prices in states with deregulated industries (e.g. Victoria), but I'm sure they're similar.

That final image of historical prices in NSW and QLD, by the way, is from a very good fact sheet by the Energy Supply Association of Australia showing where our electricity prices sit in an international comparison. Fingers crossed for an update.

In the meantime, go forth and blame not the carbon price for the sins of the network.