Thursday, November 03, 2011

IETA GHG Market Report 2011

A little over a month ago I alluded to an article I co-authored for the International Emissions Trading Association's (IETA) annual report on Greenhouse Gas Markets. That IETA GHG Market Report 2011 has now been published, and our article forms the very first chapter – hurrah!

It's too early to say whether this counts as a proper peer-reviewed publication or not – there was peer review, but other criteria come into play, as well –, but this is a nice little feather in my cap, regardless :-)

Saturday, October 29, 2011

Still not famous

Today, on Twitter:
GemmaBajgar1409: Oi, follow me ? :) I'm aussie to. :L hehehe. I'll follow back.
Me: Yeah, that's not how this works. Be interesting, then I'll follow you.
GB: lame.
Me: *shrug* it works for me. How is propositioning random people going?
GB: no idea what that word means. :L how'd you get so many follower's. You're not even famous. :L
I'm still wiping the tears off my keyboard.

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Adelaide conversations

I was in Adelaide over the weekend, at the Church City Blues event. Blues dancing is something I picked up through swing dancing, and CCB is organised by one of my old teachers from way back when, Josh McKiterick. (My other main teacher from that period, Noni Clarke, spearheads the Melbourne blues scene.)

CCB itself was fantastic. Terrific DJs, cool venues, and scores of awesome dancers made dancing into the wee hours a joy. An "all levels" workshop format meant the classes weren't always as challenging as perhaps I might have liked, but that same structure (plus a limit on how many people could attend) meant you very soon met almost everyone who was at the event. It's definitely an event I'd like to attend again.

This was my first visit to Adelaide proper – the closest I had previously come was passing through its outskirts in 2006 on the way to go see The Living End perform in Port Pirie. I can't believe I never blogged about that... but I digress.

I stayed in the Adelaide YHA on Light Square, which is fairly central in the CBD. It was really close to all the venues, and at least a dozen other dancers were staying there as well, which made for a cool experience. However, it was also a bit loud – both from outside (road noise, construction site) and inside (school groups) – and muggy, so that I rarely had an uninterrupted sleep. Given I only had five or six hours in which to sleep each night, that was unfortunate. A relocation to the Oakes Embassy might be in order next year: just as many swing dancers, a little more up-market, and with a pool! If Adelaide is as warm and humid again next year – it felt like the kind of weather Sydney should be having –, a pool is a definite plus.

Despite staying and moving about in inner Adelaide, it was surprisingly quiet. I thought Hindley St, which seems to be the main nightclub area, was virtually dead during the day, but even down at the Central Market you could stroll across the street through the generous gaps between passing cars. Try doing that in Melbourne or Sydney! I guess the "big country town" cliche is a little deserved. Certainly I searched in vain for skyscrapers.

The definitive cliche – "The City of Churches" – was certainly well deserved: they seem to be everywhere! Not that that's a bad thing. However, the cliche I was most looking forward, that of the Adelaide accent, was completely absent; I didn't meet a single local with an "English" accent. Instead, they were predominantly bogans.

Perhaps it's the event's proximity to Hindley St, which is replete with strip clubs, massage parlours, and pokies venus, but CCB courses with stories of encountering seedy types at night or seeing drunk girls urinating in the gutter. This year's highlight story was the "Adelaide in a nutshell" sighting of a girl in a tight dress vomiting in the driveway of a church in the early evening.

My own experiences with the locals were less putrid, but still a little disturbing. On Sunday afternoon, after the workshops had finished, I sat outside the Adelaide College of the Arts on a bench with other dancers and munched a muesli bar. A greasy-haired young man with stained Fila tracksuit pants, beaten-up runners, and fading pimples came and sat next to me. He was clearly not a dancer; rather, he was the type of fellow retail staff keep their eye on if they spot him entering the premises, just in case.

Without looking at me, he spoke:
Him: What's happening?
Me: Not much. Just enjoying my muesli bar.
A pause
Him (still not looking): You got any money?
Me: Nah, man. I spent it all on muesli bars.
He flicked me a glance, just briefly, then looked away again, as if keeping an eye out.
Him: D'you know where I can get any pussy around here?
Me: All along Hindley St! There's places everywhere.
He nodded, but pursed his lips.
Him: Yeah, but they're all stuck up.
A further pause, while I considered whether this was a serious comment or deadpan humour. Also, I closed the flap on my bag, which sat between us.
Me: I think they'll take anyone with money, mate.
We sat in silence for a while, as he glanced about.
Him: Where are we?
Me, turning to the four-storey building five metres away: "Adelaide College of the Arts", it says there. Pretty cool. It'd be fantastic for a paintball tournament.
(This is true: it would be.)
Him: Man, this place sucks.
Me: Oh, I don't know. Why's that?
Him: You can't rob anyone. No-one's got any money.
At this point, my mind wildly vacillated between thinking he's a scummy thief or a brilliant master of deadpan humour. He still wasn't looking at me.
Him: D'you know if I can get any free food there?
He motioned toward a cafe with his chin.
Me: No idea, mate.
Him: Guy I know runs that place. Says they give out free food to the homeless and shit.
Me: Dunno. I'm good here with my muesli bar.
We sat in silence for a further half-minute or so, then he abruptly got up and walked off toward Hindley St. On the way he passed Josh, who came in the other direction.
Me: Hey Josh! You got any money? D'you know where I can get some pussy?


My second weird conversation with a local came later than night, at one of the dance venues. A woman from the workshops had asked me for a dance, but right at the moment I was busy running an errand and told her I'd come find her later. After my errand I became sidetracked by some of the terrific music playing and ended up solo-dancing to five or six funky soul/blues numbers in a row, after which my shirt was thoroughly soaked. Passing the same woman at the bar, I told her I'd just go and dry off, but then we could dance.

So I sat outside on the balcony for a while, until I'd stopped sweating and my t-shirt was just uncomfortably moist instead of disgustingly wet. Standing next to my bag, I was chatting with friends when the woman walked by; I tapped her on the arm.
Me: Hey, I'm just about to change my shirt. If you wait 30 seconds we can go dance. Or if you're impatient, I can keep this shirt on. But it's a little damp.
Her: Let's see.
She put her hand on my chest. Now, physical contact between dancers is common, and especially so during blues dancing – it's often basically a musical hug. But, outside the context of dancing, our norms on touching tend toward those of general society. So for a middle-aged, portly woman to put her hand on the chest of stranger 10-15 years her junior is a little odd – but whatever.
Her: Oh, it's alright.
Me: Heh. Nah, I think I'd better take it off.
Her: Well, go on then.
Me: Okay, hold on. I got to get my other shirt, first, unless you want me to dance shirtless.
This was clearly rhetorical, and not a suggestion.
Her: Oh, I wouldn't mind.
Me: Ha! Well, I'm not sure I'd get many dances with anyone else if I go out there with my shirt off.
Her: That wouldn't be so bad! I could have you all to myself.
At this point she was attempting to make sultry eyes at me, and I was beginning to worry, while the friends to whom I'd been talking were staring at her with a mixture of bafflement and alarm. I mumbled something and turned away to grab my fresh shirt.

Now, I have no problem with changing my shirt in public. It's only a few seconds, and I'm comfortable with my body, so whatever. I hadn't, however, expected to generate the whoop/squeal that this woman emitted, or else I might have reconsidered my action. Freshly clothed, I went and danced with her, and tried to ignore the more.. forward elements of her.. movements. Yes. 

Awkward. Thank you, Adelaide.

Friday, October 14, 2011

Polling in Australia

Excellent political blogger and numbers man Scott Steel (aka Possum Comitatus) lays down some "polling reality 101" in a series of tweets:
There are 5 types of pollsters for politics in Australia:
  1. Firstly, those with an exceptional online panel are good. They are very rare (EMC).
  2. Face to face suffers from stated vs revealed preference issues because of F2F intimacy and sample selection bias. Not so good.
  3. Phone polls come in 3 levels.
    Commercial pollsters (Newspoll, Nieslen etc) which are the least accurate. OK, but....
  4. Next comes those with access to the Integrated Public Number Database (requires polling "on behalf" of elected representatives).
  5. Finally there are those that have access to the IPND *and* capability to wash against the electoral roll. The most accurate.
So while Nielsen, Newspoll etc are good - they do the best they can by using a very limited base for selecting phone numbers. Unfortunately, most of the questions commercial pollsters ask, while interesting, ell us very very little about political preference behaviour. Which unfortunately also means that most of the commentary you read about polling (especially issues) and what it "means" is just horseshit.
You've been told.

(Source: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9])

Saturday, October 08, 2011

Attitudes follow from actions

This is a fascinating, and possibly quite important article about how our attitudes are influenced by our behaviour, rather than vice versa:

Attitude is the psychological term for the the bundle of beliefs and feelings you experience toward a person, topic, idea, etc. without having to consciously think. For many things, your attitudes came from actions which led to observations which led to explanations which led to beliefs. It is well known in psychology the cart of behavior often gets before the horse of attitude. Your actions tend to chisel away at the raw marble of your persona, carving into being the self you experience day-to-day. It doesn’t feel that way though. To conscious experience, it feels like you are the one holding the chisel, motivated by existing thoughts and beliefs. It feels as though the person wearing your pants is performing actions consistent with your established character, yet there is plenty of research suggesting otherwise. The things you do often create the things you believe.

Self perception theory says your attitudes are shaped by observing your own behavior, being unable to pinpoint the cause, and trying to make sense of it. You look back on a situation as if in an audience trying to understand your own motivations. You act as observer of your actions, a witness to your thoughts, and you form beliefs about your self based on those observations.
“We are what we pretend to be, so we must be careful about what we pretend to be.”
–
Kurt Vonnegut

Friday, September 30, 2011

Just in passing...

Scenario A
You ring your bell before you cycle past people: they freak out.

Scenario B
You cycle past people without ringing: they freak out.
You can't win. But, at least in B, you're past them by the time they start in unexpected directions.

Thursday, September 29, 2011

Cross-post: Details of the Clean Energy Future package

About a month ago, the International Emissions Trading Association (IETA) asked one of my directors whether we'd like to prepare an overview of the last in Australian climate change politics for their annual report. Because I spend a lot of time following this sort of stuff and looking over the proposals from the Government, I got to take the lead on this (at least as far as the factual elements were concerned). Even though I'm only a lowly RA, my colleagues kindly decided my efforts were enough to warrant having my name listed first on our article, which I'm quietly pleased about.

After we'd sent our submission off, but before it was published (I think it comes out in October or November [UPDATE] in early November), New Matilda contacted me and asked if I'd like to summarise the details of the Clean Energy Future package – so, pretty much what we'd just done for IETA, but without the political analysis. I'm sometimes a little baffled by the things people ask me to write about, since I imagine they're of limited interest other than to wonks like myself (and wonks will probably have looked at the source material), but since I had the material fresh in my head I assented.

Here it is, then: a summary (at length) of the details of the Clean Energy Future package. I won't hold it against you if you don't read it – it's so long,  in fact, that NM split it into two parts! But if you want an explanation of the scheme, here you go.

Our Clean Energy Future Explained

The Government’s Clean Energy Future is underway, with 18 bills – the Clean Energy Legislative Package  – being introduced to Parliament on September 13th.

The legislation is lengthy and boring, but it’s important: these 18 bills (and a few more to come in the first half of next year) lay the framework for what will be the primary driver of Australia’s attempt to mitigate dangerous anthropogenic climate change – assuming they pass, of course. Ben Eltham has already taken an excellent look at the Clean Energy Future package (henceforth: CEF) for New Matilda. What follows in this article and its sequel is a summary of some of the CEF’s nitty-gritty details.

Much of my summary is based on the CEF package as it was released in July. As far as I’ve been able to tell, not much has changed in the current legislation, but if you spot any discrepancies, please comment.

The Emissions Trading Scheme
The best known, and arguable most important piece of the CEF package is an emissions trading scheme (ETS) which will begin on 1 July, 2012. Under an ETS, parties (generally companies) that emit those greenhouse gases covered by the scheme will be required to surrender permits to the Government equal to their emissions.

The ETS will cover four of the six greenhouse gases counted under the Kyoto Protocol – carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide and per fluorocarbon emissions from the aluminium sector. The remaining two (hydrofluorocarbons and sulphur hexafluoride) will face an equivalent carbon price through existing synthetic greenhouse gas legislation. To simplify things, the climate change potential of each greenhouse gas is measured in terms of how much carbon dioxide (CO2) it is equivalent to; hence the references to “CO2-e” (technical) or simply “carbon” (colloquial).

Emitters can purchase permits – officially called “carbon units” – for a tonne of CO2-e from the Government, or other participants in the ETS. During the first three years of the scheme, the price of permits will be fixed, and permits are immediately surrendered to the Government when purchased. This means that in the first phase the ETS will function very similarly to a tax, without actually being one: there is still the ability to trade, albeit at a fixed price. Non-governmental sellers of permits might be companies that have more permits than they need (see Compensation and Assistance, below), or farmers who have generated permits through the Carbon Farming Initiative (see Regulatory Bodies and Complementary Measures, below). For more on the fundamental differences between an emissions trading scheme and a tax, see Carbon Pricing 101.

Permits will cost $23 per tonne of CO2-e when the ETS begins in 2012, and will rise at 5 per cent per year (nominally); $24.15/t in 2013-14 and $25.40/t in 2014-15. From July 1, 2015, the price will be variable, and set by the market. The idea is that, by 2016, the international price of CO2-e will be around $29/t. 
No foreign permits or credits will be accepted during the fixed-price period, and a maximum of 50 per cent of a party’s obligation during the flexible-price period may be sourced internationally. Kyoto Protocol-compliant credits created under the Carbon Farming Initiative can be used for up to 5 per cent of compliance during the fixed price period. (This limit is far higher than then the number of credits the Carbon Farming Initiative is likely to produce.)

From 2015, some international permits will be allowed. These include Certified Emissions Reductions (CERs), Emissions Reductions Units (ERUs), Removal Units (RMUs), and other units the Government may allow. The Government’s view is that linking to other credible trading schemes, including the EU Emissions Trading Scheme and the NZ Emissions Trading Scheme, is in Australia’s national interest.

From 2015 to 2018 there will be a price ceiling of $20/t above the international price, and a price floor of $15/t. This is to reduce wild fluctuations and provide some measure of certainty for those who have to factor the price of carbon into their decision-making. These stabilisers will rise by 5 per cent and 4 per cent in real terms, that is, plus inflation, per year, and will be reviewed in 2017 by the Climate Change Authority (CCA). It is unclear which instrument will form the basis of this international price – will it be EU units (EUAs) or New Zealand Units (NZUs) – and to which foreign schemes the Australian ETS will be linked.

During the fixed-price period, permits allocated for free can be traded domestically or returned to the government, but not banked for use in later years. Parties that fail to surrender enough permits in a year will incur fines of 1.3 times the permit price for that year.

In the flexible-price period, an unlimited number of permits can be banked and up to 5 per cent of the current year’s liability can be met by “borrowing” from the next year’s permit vintage. Each year’s vintage of permits will be auctioned in advance by the government, and shortfalls will incur fines which are double the average permit price for that year.

ETS – Targets

Emissions caps – the maximum number of permits, and therefore emissions, permitted within the ETS each year – for the flexible-price period have not yet been decided. The lack of political agreement here is one of the reasons the ETS begins with a fixed price, but the targets will be announced in 2014 and then set five years in advance. Should no emissions cap be set by Parliament, the cap for 2015-16 will default to 38 MtCO2-e less than total emissions in 2012-13. From 2016 the default cap will be 12 MtCO2-e less than the previous year.

To put that into perspective: Treasury’s carbon price modelling estimated Australia’s emissions at 578 MtCO2-e in 2010, growing steadily, and our bipartisan target at around 527 MtCO2-e by 2020. (Non-Treasury estimates have different figures, but similar magnitudes.) The Government’s goal is to reduce Australia’s emissions by 5 per cent on 2000 levels by 2020 (up to 25 per cent depending on global action), and by 80 per cent by 2050 (previously 50 per cent) – but it’s not quite clear from the CEF package precisely how many tonnes of CO2-e that is.

Voluntary action will be taken into account when setting caps – the CCA will determine the methodology – and will be treated as additional, as will renewable electricity purchases through GreenPower. People will be able to make a tax-deductible contribution to a Pledge Fund to retire Australian carbon permits, Kyoto compliant and non-Kyoto compliant Australian Carbon Credit Units, and eligible international units.

ETS – Coverage

The ETS will fully cover emissions from stationary energy, industrial processes, fugitive emissions – which are those from coal mines or from extracting gas – and emissions from some waste. The transport sector will be partially covered: domestic aviation, shipping, rail transport, and non-transport fuels will face lower fuel tax credits or higher fuel excises (unless the companies voluntarily participate in the ETS), while household transport fuels, light vehicle business transport, and off-road fuel use by the agriculture, forestry and fishing industries will be excluded from the ETS. The Government wants to include heavy transport from 2014. (This last was rejected by the regional independent MPs. The Greens would like to include all transport.)

Roughly 60 per cent of Australia’s emissions are thus covered directly by the ETS, and two-thirds are covered indirectly (e.g. through fuel excise changes). Those companies (around 500) with facilities that have direct greenhouse gas emissions of 25,000 tonnes of CO2-e a year or more (excluding emissions from transport fuels and some synthetic greenhouse gases) must join the ETS, while others can join voluntarily. Companies may do this to profit through trading, hedge against risks, or because they would otherwise face costs such as higher fuel excises but see the opportunity to achieve their abatement more cheaply in the open market – which is the point of an ETS. Agricultural emissions, which form roughly 15 per cent of Australia’s total emissions, will be exempt, as will emissions from forestry and land-use change (e.g. conversion of bush into agricultural land).

Who Will Keep it Clean?

Regulatory Bodies and Complementary Measures

An independent Climate Change Authority (CCA) will be established to report publically on the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS). Beginning in February, 2014, and then every two years, it will examine all aspects of the scheme, including the price floor and ceiling, and recommend targets and emissions caps. The CCA will be made up of nine experts with a particular focus on climate science, economics, climate change mitigation, emissions trading, investment, and business, and will be chaired by Bernie Fraser (formerly head of the Reserve Bank of Australia).

The CCA’s recommendations are not binding on the government of the day, but the government must justify any difference between its legislation and the recommendations.

This is stronger independent regulation than was proposed under Kevin Rudd’s CPRS, and is complemented by a new Clean Energy Regulator and reviews by the Productivity Commission. The Productivity Commission will review industry compensation and assistance, in particular to emissions-intensive and trade-exposed industries, fuel taxation arrangements, and foreign action. The Clean Energy Regulator will combine administration of the ETS, the Carbon Farming Initiative – where farmers generate credits for storing carbon in soil or trees, or reducing/avoiding emissions –, the Renewable Energy Target, and the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting System.

To encourage the construction of renewable energy generation, the CEF package will establish a Clean Energy Finance Corporation to invest – via loans or equity – $5 billion in renewable energy technologies, and $5 billion in low-pollution, and energy efficiency technologies which may include renewable energy projects. The Corporation will not invest in carbon capture and storage technology, though this is still supported by existing programs.

The Government will also establish an Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA), which will provide grant-based funding for renewable energy projects. ARENA largely brings existing programs together into one organisation – and this should result in more coordinated and consistent operation of these programs. Both ARENA and the Clean Energy Finance Corporation will be independent agencies.

Australia’s Renewable Energy Target remains at 20 per cent by 2020. (Currently 8 per cent of Australia’s electricity is renewable; gas accounts for 16 per cent and coal 75 per cent.) The CEF package includes an Energy Security Fund, which will tender for bids to shut down 2000MW of highly emissions-intensive coal-fired power by 2020. The Fund will also offer transitional assistance of $5.5 billion, in the form of free permits and cash, to coal power generators facing significant asset loss. An Energy Security Council will advise the Government on emerging risks to energy security.

Compensation and Assistance

Simultaneous to the introduction of the ETS on July 1, 2012, personal tax-free thresholds will be trebled to $18,200, rising to $19,400 in 2015. This is designed to fully or over-compensate lower income households (yearly earnings of up to $30,000 for singles) for increased costs resulting from pricing CO2-e, and to partially compensate middle income households ($30-80,000 pa). Marginal tax rates for the new lower brackets will rise, so that those on higher incomes ($80,000 and above) do not pay less tax. The average increase in household costs from pricing CO2-e is expected to be $9.90 per week, with average compensation of $10.10 per week. There are also increases to the Pension, Senior Supplement for self-funded retirees, and Family Tax Benefit.

The ETS is expected to increase electricity prices by 10 per cent during its first year of operation. However, electricity prices have risen rapidly in recent years and are expected to do so in the future, largely in response to network infrastructure investment by operators; these increased prices are being conflated by many – sometimes deliberately – with the future effects of the carbon price.

Many industries covered by the ETS will receive some form of Government assistance. A Jobs and Competitiveness Program ($9.2 billion) will be available for the most emissions-intensive sectors (primarily manufacturing and heavy industry), with a Clean Technology Program ($1.2 billion) for less emissions-intensive sectors, and further programs for small businesses and supply chains. Most assistance will be in the form of free permits, the rest in grants.

Emission-intensive trade-exposed (EITE) industries will receive:
  • 94.5 per cent of their expected permit requirement for industries with average baseline of at least 2,000 tCO2-e/$m revenue or 6,000t CO2-e/$m value-added
  • 66 per cent of their expected permit requirement for industries with average baseline of at least 1,000 tCO2-e/$m revenue or 3,000t CO2-e/$m value added
  • 50 per cent of their expected permit requirement for the LNG industry
A trade-exposed industry is one whose value of imports and exports to domestic production exceeds 10 per cent, and that demonstrates a lack of capacity to pass through costs due to the potential for international competition.

Baseline for the free permits will be the historic industry average level of emissions per unit of production, and are based on those from the CPRS (including the extra free permits added as a “recession buffer” in 2009). Assistance will reduce 1.3 per cent each year, and be reviewed by the Productivity Commission from 2014-15 onwards with a view to winding assistance back to the levels suggested in the 2011 Garnaut Review.

The CEF package also includes an Energy Security Fund, which will tender for bids to shut down 2000MW of highly emissions-intensive coal-fired power by 2020. The Fund will also offer transitional assistance of AU$5.5 billion, in the form of free permits and cash, to coal power generators facing significant asset loss. An Energy Security Council will advise the Government on emerging risks to energy security.

In addition to the assistance described above, the Government plans to give the coal sector $1.3 billion over six years for “gassy” mines – those with high levels of fugitive emissions. The steel industry will also receive $300 million over five years. This assistance is separate to the CEF package, as not all members of the MPCCC agreed with it.

The CEF is highly likely to pass both Houses of Parliament before the end of the year, and then the next challenge beckons: implementation. I, for one, look forward to it.

These articles draw on material prepared for an upcoming annual report by the International Emissions Trading Association [http://www.ieta.org/].

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Russian Unicorn

I rarely post random YouTube videos on this blog, but I am totally in love with this one. Not just the way they've overdubbed Michael Bublé with bizarre, but matching lyrics, but the sheer quality of the non-sequiturs and the accompanying music mean I've currently got this song on repeat.

Friday, September 23, 2011

Taxing My Patience

The think-thank Per Capita released a report during the week, in which they surveyed Australians' Public Attitudes towards Taxation and Government Expenditure. I posted a section of it to Twitter and Facebook:
OECD countries whose taxes are higher than Australia's (as percentage of GDP): everyone except Korea, USA, Turkey, Chile, Mexico – so 26 of 33.
Proportion of Australians who correctly identified us as a low-taxing, small-government nation: 4%
One of my friends reposted it, where it received the following comment.
And isn't it great that we are, given that the low taxing, small govt and more importantly no debt govt is what got us through the gfc then why are we reverting? Now we have huge debt which if swans magic 3bn surplus ever comes to fruition will take 50 years to repay. A govt which is not only increasing taxes, but burning through out savings (I.e. Selling down the future fund). The most annoying one is the mining tax that will simply be burned up in consolidated revenue rather than a sovereign wealth fund. Or the carbon tax that will effectively make 9 out of 10 house holds welfare recipients without taking a single gram of carbon out of the air (globally), but will cost jobs. So if we are a financially sound low taxing small govt country then it has fuck all to do with worlds greatest treasurer swan [MCJ: Wayne Swan recently received an award from Euromoney magazine as being Finance Minisiter of the Year] and the rest of his rabble, and more to do with their fiscally responsible predecessor.
This sort of stuff is crap I hear all the time, and I was feeling a little cranky this morning, so I couldn't help but respond.
The statement that a "no debt" Government got us through the GFC is complete rubbish. What got us through was prompt, sizeable, and well-targeted stimulus spending, reasonably strong institutions, and a bit of luck.

Australia's "huge debt" is also a falsehood. Australia Government Debt as a % of GDP in 2010 – the latest figures from the OECD database stats.oecd.org – is 11.0%. The only developed countries with lower proportions of debt are Estonia, and Chile. Here's what that looks like:

Which taxes are we increasing? The Government wants to lower the corporate tax rate. It's increasing the personal income tax-free threshold – less tax paid there. Even with the increased monetary costs of carbon price, consumers will come out ahead – particularly if you take into account the (non-monetary) environmental costs that we were bearing, are bearing, and will bear because the externalities embodied in CO2-e emissions have not been adequately priced.

Resource extraction will attract a new tax (the MRRT), which will affect Australian consumers roughly jot in terms of our extra costs, but deliver us billions in revenue. (The original, if terribly named, RSPT was even better, but that's politics for you.)

I don't know what you mean by "burning through our savings" in relation to the Future Fund, since (even when they ran a deficit) Labor still made contributions to the Fund, and I'm not aware of any attempts to sell the Fund or tap it for recurrent expenditure.

You decry 9 out of 10 household becoming "welfare recipients" due to compensation for the emissions trading scheme. What rank stupidity: the compensation is a higher tax-free threshold. If a tax-free threshold is "welfare", every single earner of income is a welfare recipient.

Your characterisation of the ineffectiveness of carbon pricing is similarly misguided. Emissions trading has been proven to have reduced emissions, and your statement is only true in the sense that emissions will continue to rise (in the near future). Well, yes, but they'll rise less than they would otherwise have. And if you don't think that's good enough, well, perhaps you'd better stop eating, because eating doesn't stop ageing, either: it just slows the rate at which you're dying. Alternatively, pick up a maths textbook and relearn second derivatives.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

For Whom the Bell Tolls

I had this poem, by John Donne, hanging on my wall for a while before I moved. I may put it up again, if I can find it. Troy Davis' execution seems like a good excuse as any to post it.
For Whom the Bell Tolls

No man is an island,
Entire of itself.
Each is a piece of the continent,
A part of the main.
If a clod be washed away by the sea,
Europe is the less.
As well as if a promontory were.
As well as if a manner of thine own
Or of thine friend's were.
Each man's death diminishes me,
For I am involved in mankind.
Therefore, send not to know
For whom the bell tolls,
It tolls for thee.