The think-thank Per Capita released a report during the week, in which they surveyed Australians' Public Attitudes towards Taxation and Government Expenditure. I posted a section of it to Twitter and Facebook:
OECD countries whose taxes are higher than Australia's (as percentage of GDP): everyone except Korea, USA, Turkey, Chile, Mexico – so 26 of 33.
Proportion of Australians who correctly identified us as a low-taxing, small-government nation: 4%
One of my friends reposted it, where it received the following comment.
And isn't it great that we are, given that the low taxing, small govt and more importantly no debt govt is what got us through the gfc then why are we reverting? Now we have huge debt which if swans magic 3bn surplus ever comes to fruition will take 50 years to repay. A govt which is not only increasing taxes, but burning through out savings (I.e. Selling down the future fund). The most annoying one is the mining tax that will simply be burned up in consolidated revenue rather than a sovereign wealth fund. Or the carbon tax that will effectively make 9 out of 10 house holds welfare recipients without taking a single gram of carbon out of the air (globally), but will cost jobs. So if we are a financially sound low taxing small govt country then it has fuck all to do with worlds greatest treasurer swan [MCJ: Wayne Swan recently received an award from Euromoney magazine as being Finance Minisiter of the Year] and the rest of his rabble, and more to do with their fiscally responsible predecessor.
This sort of stuff is crap I hear all the time, and I was feeling a little cranky this morning, so I couldn't help but respond.
The statement that a "no debt" Government got us through the GFC is complete rubbish. What got us through was prompt, sizeable, and well-targeted stimulus spending, reasonably strong institutions, and a bit of luck.
Australia's "huge debt" is also a falsehood. Australia Government Debt as a % of GDP in 2010 – the latest figures from the OECD database stats.oecd.org – is 11.0%. The only developed countries with lower proportions of debt are Estonia, and Chile. Here's what that looks like:
Which taxes are we increasing? The Government wants to lower the corporate tax rate. It's increasing the personal income tax-free threshold – less tax paid there. Even with the increased monetary costs of carbon price, consumers will come out ahead – particularly if you take into account the (non-monetary) environmental costs that we were bearing, are bearing, and will bear because the externalities embodied in CO2-e emissions have not been adequately priced.
Resource extraction will attract a new tax (the MRRT), which will affect Australian consumers roughly jot in terms of our extra costs, but deliver us billions in revenue. (The original, if terribly named, RSPT was even better, but that's politics for you.)
I don't know what you mean by "burning through our savings" in relation to the Future Fund, since (even when they ran a deficit) Labor still made contributions to the Fund, and I'm not aware of any attempts to sell the Fund or tap it for recurrent expenditure.
You decry 9 out of 10 household becoming "welfare recipients" due to compensation for the emissions trading scheme. What rank stupidity: the compensation is a higher tax-free threshold. If a tax-free threshold is "welfare", every single earner of income is a welfare recipient.
Your characterisation of the ineffectiveness of carbon pricing is similarly misguided. Emissions trading has been proven to have reduced emissions, and your statement is only true in the sense that emissions will continue to rise (in the near future). Well, yes, but they'll rise less than they would otherwise have. And if you don't think that's good enough, well, perhaps you'd better stop eating, because eating doesn't stop ageing, either: it just slows the rate at which you're dying. Alternatively, pick up a maths textbook and relearn second derivatives.


No comments:
Post a Comment