Sunday, March 20, 2011

What am I doing at the moment?

What does an environmental economist do? This will get a little long...

Let me start with what "an economist" does, because it's often (wrongly) understood that we're all about money. Rather, economics is about "utility", which is a concept somewhere between "usefulness" and "happiness", and the metric economists use to measure the value people place on a particular object or activity. We then use this to study the choices people make, in particular (but not exclusively) during the production and consumption of goods and services.
Because utility is fairy difficult to measure – if I ask you and a friend how much something is worth to each of you on a scale of one to ten, your six may not be worth her six, or twice as much as her three, or even twice as much as your three! – economists often use money as an alternative denominator. Why? Because most things are already priced in money, so we don't have to ask people about possibly hypothetical values: we just look at what they do.

Now, the environment is a little different to most of mainstream economics, because people aren't used to paying for the environment (with limited exceptions, e.g. land rights) – until quite recently it's just been there, and you could use it (or not) for free; take stuff out of it, pump stuff into it, change it, neglect it, whatever. But, fairly obviously, the environment HAS value: it absorbs pollution, gives us resources (fresh air, minerals, crops, new medicines), is somewhere we can relax, or can just be something we enjoy knowing exists (most people have never been to Niagara Falls or Ulura, but I'm sure they're "worth" something to us).
So, in the broadest sense, environmental economics is about fitting the environment into the framework used for the rest of economics: putting utility values on it or, if you like, prices. That can be anything from valuing a forest through which a developer wants to build a road to developing a system/price to charge for allowing people (firms) to dispose of their pollution into the environment (e.g. emissions trading scheme).

What is it that I do, precisely? My institution is the Centre for Energy and Environment Markets (CEEM) at the University of New South Wales (UNSW), and at the moment one of the grants we have is from the Australia Research Council on "Robust Policy Mix" for climate change  I don't want to slug you with another long explanation, but basically "robustness" is all about a policy fulfilling its goals under all possible circumstances; under a change of Government, or an economic crises, or whatever. It's got a lot to do with risk and uncertainty; being prepared for changes you can predict and changes you can't predict. The "policy mix" bit refers to the way different policies interact and positively or negatively affect each other.

Another project that I'll soon be starting with a colleague is for the Consumer Advocacy Panel, where we'll run experiments on how (possibly) solve the problem of split incentives for energy efficiency features in rental accommodation: landlords/owners have no incentive to make the properties more energy efficient, since they don't pay the utility bills, but renters who aren't assured of staying in the property long enough to recoup the costs of their investment through lower bills also lack the incentive to improve the efficiency.

When I'm not researching stuff (i.e. looking for and reading articles; I do a LOT of reading), I also do less interesting stuff like proofread papers for colleagues, clean up datasets (spreadsheets), or help organise conferences/seminars/office events. The proofreading isn't always bad; if the paper is good then I'll learn something new, and it's fun to turn on my economic brain and analyse someone else's arguments.

I'm quite enjoying it, which is good, because the job was the reason I moved to Sydney in the first place :-)  I'm in discussions to extend my contract for another year; my bosses are keen to get me into the Ph.D. programme, and have even tempted me with the possibility of spending some of said programme at a foreign institution, but I'm still uncertain – and I know enough to know that you shouldn't do a Ph.D. unless you're certain you want to do it. That's not a vote against doing one, just that I haven't yet decided.

Having also written a few letters to the editor or just expounded on economic topics of interest here on this blog (I won't link; there are plenty of examples), I've also started getting into properly writing stuff for the media. It's early days yet and, to be honest, nowadays you can hardly turn around without bumping into some sort of blogger, but so far it's good fun.
Outside of work and faffing around writing stuff, I've been taking advantage of Sydney's beaches as much as possible. I'm within cycling distance of a whole bunch of different eastern suburbs beaches, and it's a rare fortnight that I don't go down with my boogieboard for a bit of sandy action. Often my brother, Klaus, will come along, too. It's terrific having him up here: most of our adult lives we've lived in different cities or countries, so it's good fun being able to just spontaneously hang out on weekends, wrestle in the backyard (I did some basic Krav Maga training in December, and Klaus does stuff through the Army Reserves), or just kick a ball around.

I've also joined the UNSW football team, playing in the Eastern Suburbs Football Association Division 1. That's the top division after the State League and Premier League (and their reserves), so pretty high up; the ESFA goes down to Div 10. The season hasn't started yet, but  after a summer spent playing pick-up matches in the park I'm really enjoying a team that plays with some structure and tactics. It's a good group of lads and the standard is fairly high; I'll probably be playing as left fullback, and though it's not a new position for me I'm enjoying still being able to learn new things from my teammates, most of whom are older and more experienced that me. (That may surprise, but funnily enough the minority of the team are students.)

So – that's what I'm doing at the moment!

Tuesday, March 08, 2011

Cross-post: Give us something to talk about

In the course of researching the paper I'm currently co-writing at work, I felt that some of the themes – the role of risk and uncertainty in climate change, as well as robust policy responses to them – had not received enough attention in the Australia policy debate and wrote an opinion piece to that effect. It hasn't yet been published – our media office is pitching it to newspapers, who are mulling it over –, but as a result a colleague of mine (@agentdeclan) put me in touch with the editors of New Matilda, who were looking for someone to write a piece on the current (lack of) debate around the newly-released carbon pricing framework and the role of economists in that debate.

Being a little quicker than newspapers they published it today, and I reproduce it, below.

There's plenty of talk about the proposed carbon tax but it's short on substance - and at any rate, details are thin on the ground. Martin Jones on the role of economists in this debate
[The title and teaser are the work of the editors]

If you were hoping for some policy debate in federal politics last week, you were wasting your time. Since the Multi-Party Committee on Climate Change (MPCCC) announced its Carbon Price Framework (CPF) (PDF), the debate in Parliament has gone around in circles, finding its nadir in the literal rotations performed by Senator Mary Jo Fischer.

Where once upon a time Oppositions deconstructed Government proposals in detail, building up sustained and intense critical pressure that occasionally culminated in a motion to censure the Prime Minister (the passing of which would traditionally cause a Government to resign), the current mob have virtually ignored the CPF to focus on whether Julia Gillard broke her pre-election promise to put a price on carbon in some form other than a tax. Indeed, they rolled out the censure motions with such regularity last week that the ABC started running a sweepstakes competition to guess when the suspension of standing orders would be called for.

One problem for the Opposition is that there isn’t very much in the CPF to criticise. The document is five pages long, and lays out a rough timeframe of when the fixed-price period, flexible-price period, and discussions about the latter could occur; what sectors could be covered; and that we couldn’t use international permits during the fixed-price period. That’s pretty much it -- aside from some pleasant language about “economic transformation”, “business certainty”, and “fairness”. As Ben Eltham pointed out last week, this is a much cannier strategy than what the ALP did with the CPRS (or even with the RSPT, which, even though it had the nominal benefit of being a well-constructed piece of policy, still crashed).

With little to criticise and not much to offer as an alternative, the Opposition resorted to hypothetical scenarios about possible food, petrol, and electricity price rises. They were forced to make assumptions about details that haven’t yet been decided, such as what the price of carbon permits will be, the extent to which the sectors will be covered, and what sort of compensation will be offered. Without these crucial details, however, you could assume pretty much anything about the carbon tax – which the Opposition (and Government in response) duly did, as did much of the media and a plethora of special interest groups (with BlueScope Steel delivering a particularly flagrant example). 

The thing is, we’ve been here before: we had the same special interest commentary and pseudo-analysis during the debate about the CPRS, but also plenty of more formal modelling and analysis. Some of these modelling and analysis has been updated since then – Ross Garnaut, for example, is currently half-way through releasing the updates to his Review – and newer studies have been added to the body of knowledge we have. The MPCCC carbon price framework has not changed the validity of any of these studies and so, if you paid attention the first time around, there is very little in the current iteration of the debate worth paying attention to from a policy perspective – as opposed to a political perspective.

More interesting are the frameworks established by these studies, and how the CPF fits into them. These frameworks are the contributions of experts in science, economics, sociology, law, philosophy; each discipline has its own structure, theories, body of knowledge, and a field over which it claims expertise. Sometimes these fields overlap, but more often they are complementary. When communicated well, they enrich public knowledge and enable us to better assess the arguments being put to us.

The strength of my field, economics, in the climate change debate is in evaluating the suitability of different policy instruments to achieve a stated set of (economic) objectives – for example, under which scenarios taxes are better than quantity controls; how firms and consumers will be affected by particular cost increases; weighing up the economic costs and benefits – through the use of models of human behaviour on a large scale, including the examination of secondary, possibly unintended, effects. Stating that economics is best for economic objectives may seem a little tautological, but, well, everyone is guilty of thinking their field can do it all at one point or another.

That we don’t have a consistent stated set of objectives or a climate policy philosophy from any party bar the Greens makes the task of the economist more difficult, of course. But, at the moment, anthropogenic climate change is widely accepted by all sides as a problem and the debate concerns the mechanism of the solution, with the CPF bearing more than a passing resemblance to proposals put forward by the Garnaut Review in 2008.

Any final carbon pricing framework could do much worse than base itself on the Review; it addresses prices, compensation, institutional arrangements, transitions, emissions-intensive trade-exposed industries, enforcement mechanisms, innovation policy, sectoral peculiarities, broad uncertainties, and eventual global agreements, all in the Australian context. A sensible economic analysis of any future climate policy could compare it to the Review’s recommendations (or those of the updated version of the Review, due to be released in May), spot the differences, and question whether they are decisions made within the economic framework or a political framework. Chances are, many of the compensation arrangements we’ll see will not be grounded in economic reasoning – if they are sold as such.

I have colleagues who believe that politicians’ decision-making processes are governed almost exclusively by the desire to win the next election – and sometimes it is difficult to believe otherwise. With the ALP struggling to clearly outline its core ideals and the Opposition functioning as a party of, well, opposition, their medium- and long-term goals for this country are opaque. But if we step away from the content-free zone of Question Time and offer our politicians frameworks and ideas – be they a more powerful social-justice imperative or the need for a mix of instruments in climate policy (PDF) –, perhaps they’ll take some of them up. Then we’d at least have something worth talking about.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Money, meet mouth

So, I work as an environmental economist, right? I vote for The Greens, cycle everywhere, buy organic food, turn all my appliances off when I'm not using them, reuse my shower water, and generally try to follow the reduce/reuse/recycle motto. But, since 2006, I've flown from Australia to Germany (and back), between Germany and London several times, and between Melbourne and Sydney even more often. Oh, and driven Melbourne-Sydney and back. Against all those emissions (particularly the Australia-Germany flights), the marginal changes I've made to my life are paltry.

Last week, I was hunting around for figures on how many carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2-e) emissions Earth could remove from the atmosphere each year, in order to calculate roughly what each person would be able to emit without increasing the concentration of CO2-e in the atmosphere. The answers were a little confusing, as the climate system is ridiculously complicated and there are many higher-order effects1, but roughly speaking the Earth absorbs 12 Gt (gigatonnes; thousand million tonnes) of CO2-e per year, giving us roughly 2 tonnes of CO2-e allowance per person per year.

The current world average closer to 4 t/year, and developed countries are usually much, much higher; Australia's are around 28 tCO2-e/person/year. 

That's not direct emissions, of course: most my share of Australia's average emissions I have little to no control over. My flights, however, are entirely of my own doing. So I followed up an idea I've been toying around with for a few years, which is to purchase carbon offsets. How that works is that other people offer to reduce CO2-e emissions via different projects (renewable energy rather than fossil fuels; reduced fuel usage via efficiency measures; planting trees), these savings are verified/certified to a particular standard, and other people can then "purchase" these savings in a market: basically, I'm paying someone to have (had) lower CO2-e emissions on my behalf, offsetting my own. (I've started with past flights and those currently booked, long car trips, and will offset future travel as it occurs; my day-to-day emissions I'm counting against my "allowance" – I'm almost certainly exceeding it, but right now I have no way of accurately calculating by how much.)

Depending on the type of project, its location, and the standard to which it's certified, the offsets cost more or less money: the cost of one tonne of CO2-e in the EU emissions trading market (1 EUA) has hovered around 15€ for the last two years, while permits generated to slightly less stringent conditions (CERs; often from developing countries where standards aren't quite as high) have hovered around 12€.

Starting with the excellent Victorian Government/RMIT website http://www.carbonoffsetguide.com.au/, I went through a list of companies that offer to sell you carbon offsets, comparing the certification standards they met and the types of projects they offered. Eventually I settled on First Climate (http://www.firstclimate.com), a German company with an Australian offices; I chose First Climate  primarily because they offered Gold Standard Verified Emission Reductions (VERs), which was the level of quality I wanted to buy. Their record of operating internationally, and particularly in Germany, was another reason.

I sent them off an e-mail, and within minutes a charming fellow called me to talk about how much I wanted to offset, and how. Having already used one of the online emissions calculators (see the offset guide website, earlier) and thought about the options, I was able to give him a tonnage and project preference, where-upon he sent me a list of possible projects with different standards and the corresponding prices per tonne.

The end result is that, just now, I have bought and retired 20 tonnes of CO2-e emissions credits (Gold Standard VERs) from the Yuntdag Wind Power Project in Turkey (PDF) (Project Number 22-07-283) at AU$30 per tonne. That's not cheap – but, for me, it's worth it.

[UPDATE I]
One problem I had with First Climate is that they ask you to deposit your money into a non-Australian bank account, which necessitates an international transfer; at my bank, that involved a $22 fee and a minimum transfer of AU$500. I've asked whether there are alternatives, since I would rather purchase fewer carbon offsets at a time in future, but haven't yet received a reply.

[UPDATE II]
First Climate's response:

Unfortunately the reality is that our key focus in the Australian market is at the corporate/wholesale level and as such we are unable to provide alternatives for transactions via our Frankfurt trading desk, which can only be achieved via international bank transfers.  As you highlighted this obviously presents a problem for retail buyers seeking to make purchases of less than $500 which fail to trigger the threshold for most banks.

I believe that it would be best if in these circumstances we refer you directly to our retail channel partner The Carbon Reduction Institute (http://www.noco2.com.au), who is more than capable and willing to assist in this regard.  CRI are recognised as one of the best carbon offset retailer in the Australian market.

I have not had any dealings with the Carbon Reduction Institute, but will try them out the next time I want to purchase carbon offsets and keep you posted.

1 When one thing directly affects another (I push the cup: it moves; the price of something rises; the sun rises: it gets warmer), that's called a first-order effect. When the causal chain has intermediate steps or multiple sources, there are more – higher – "orders" of effect (e.g. the sun-warmed air rises and begins to circulate; the rotation of the earth changes the pattern of circulation; the circulating air absorbs moisture and forms clouds, changing the pattern of heating and therefore further changing the pattern of circulation).

Monday, February 21, 2011

Buying your way backstage

Several times when I've bought tickets to concerts recently, I've noticed that the bands offer "Meet and Greet" packages; these usually cost ~$50 more than just admission to the concert (which is itself ~$50), and get you:
  • Entry to the show via name on doorlist, rather than a ticket
  • Personal Meet and Greet with $_BAND
  • 2 items signed
  • Souvenir tour laminate
  • Official tour poster
  • Priority Entry
From an economist's perspective, this is a fairly sensible idea: the people who will want these things – colloquially "hardcore" fans – have an increased willingness to pay relative to the rest of the public, and insituting a tiered pricing system is an excellent way for the band to capture more of this willingness to pay in the form of money.

Previously, of course, fans used to get this sort of stuff by hanging around after the show long enough and/or getting to know the band manager/touring crew well enough to cajole their way back stage. This is the way I've done it with, for example, The Living End. It's an investment – sometimes a significant one; ask me about TLE's German tour some time – but it's an investment of time and effort, rather than money.

What does the band get out of that? Not much: at the end of the day, they're still talking to plebs, signing shit, and smiling wanly into a parade of cameras. Especially for touring bands, who may only visit a country once every few years, selling this time may be worth more than developing a dedicated and loyal fanbase of the sort engendered by repeated access on the basis of effort.

As a music fan, of course, the practise disgusts me. It feels mercenary, and the "cred" of backstage access loses a lot of its value (for me) when earned with money, rather than time. My economist brain tells me that this is silly: like actors who request money for photographs or autographs when appearing at conventions, someone is simply using a price to adjust the relationship between (fixed) supply and (limited, but still vastly larger) demand.

I don't want to claim that all bands that do this are mercenary: recently I hung out, post-show, with (part of) a band that sold these "VIP" tickets. How? The old-fashioned way: I hung around long enough and got to know the right people.

(For the record, The Living End do not do this sort of shit: most of the time they'll come out after shows – regardless of what country they're in – sign stuff, pose for photographs, and have a chat. Sure, they won't invite you backstage – but hey, they're working! It's often not that exciting backstage, anyway. Seriously, what are these touring bands offering? Card games with the bands? Pre-show pep talk? For $50, I'd want a decent feed and maybe a back massage.)

Animal Beatbox – Tropfest Winner

Beatboxing, i.e. simulating the sounds of instruments using your voice = cool
Simulating those sound using animal names = awesome
Setting the whole thing to a film clip = Tropfest winner!

Sunday, February 13, 2011

The eyes have it

I've been fiddling around with recent photographs (headshots) taken of me, and, comparing them to an set taken back in November of 2009, I was struck by how very different they appeared. Though all that's really changed between then and now is my hairstyle, the difference in lighting makes me appear – I think – almost a different person.
I have exactly the same expression, almost exactly the same pose, the same hint of stubble, and I've lightened the background of the recent photo (on the right) to make the comparison easier. (I stopped short of colouring the shirts the same.) Yet, at first glance, I still think they are different people. Only when I look a little longer do I notice the similarities.

Maybe it's because I don't spend much time looking at myself? I'm not so convinced by that. Possibly it's the eyes: the difference between the quite dark pupils irises in the left shot and the light blue pupils irises in the right is stark.

Below is the end of my fiddling, at any rate. I've done little more than crop and blur the background a little (which I did with not a little irony, as this was the only photo of many that the photographer – a colleague of mine – managed to take in focus.)

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Climate change is about risk

So I'm working on a "robust policy mix" for climate change (more on that later... perhaps), but in the course of my research I've come across a nice little paragraph that, in my opinion, is a wonderful starting point for thinking about climate change:
[O]ur work suggests that climate change ought to be viewed more as a contingency problem than an optimization problem. Either society will have to make very large reductions in greenhouse-gas emissions over the course of the next century, or it will not. Since society does not yet know which future will happen, it needs to prepare for both. Thus, the most important near-term goals of climate-change policy may be to: (i) reach consensus on the observations that will indicate a need for drastic action to curtail greenhouse-gas emissions, (ii) take actions that will make large future reductions more feasible and less costly if, in fact, they are needed, and (iii) do this in such a way as to avoid over-allocating resources to a problem that turns out to be minor or preparing insufficiently for what we discover is an emerging catastrophe.
Source: Lempert & Schlesinger (2000) "Robust Strategies for Abating Climate Change" in Climatic Change Volume 45, Numbers 3-4, p. 395

The next time you hear something about climate change (more so in Australia than in Europe), take note of the mental model framing the argument – or, rather, the lack of it. This paper is 10 years old, yet a minority of pundits (and, sadly, politicians) have wrapped their head around how to approach the (possible) problem. We should be way beyond this (though at least we're ahead of the Yanks).

Oh, and here's another lovely little excerpt from the same page:
[P]olitical activity in this area [climate change] more closely resembles an evolving set of actions designed to shape the future political landscape and influence private-sector investments, rather than any firm consensus about the optimum level of emissions reductions. International negotiators often appear to regard the continuation of the process as more important than the particular results at each stage.
10 years on... how little has changed. However, the authors go on to differentiate between hedging – taking actions now to mitigate risk – and shaping – making it easier to take actions later –, and suggest that the latter approach may be as good as the former. I don't know to what extent I believe that, but it does give me a little more hope that the Conferences of the Parties are actually achieving anything.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Donating for them, or for yourself?

Accompanying the Twitter commentary of the Queensland floods (see #QLDfloods) I've noticed a number of people writing that they'll donate $1 every time their message gets "retweeted" (RTed; forwarded, in Twitter, parlance). The first message I saw was from @lilithia. I can't say for certain whether she started the trend, and once I started looking I found several others – e.g. @AUSteambieberr, @bree_101, @xander85 –, but they all seemed to share two initial characteristics:
  • These were ordinary people
  • The donations were uncapped
The second point, especially, struck me: late last year Daniel Keogh, a science presenter on the ABC, promised to donate $5 to beyondblue(1) for every time he was retweeted (until 10pm), but his offer took off and he ended up with a nominal figure of over $17,000 dollars. That was far above Keogh's self-imposed limit, but he ended up donating $5000 and the story made it into the papers.

Evidently not the papers lilithia et al. read, though, as the same thing happened to them and they started imposing limits: first $250, then $500. The trouble with RTs, though, is that often very few people follow the original poster, and retractions/corrections/clarifications are rarely retweeted as much or as quickly as the original message. Thus, even though lilithia reached her limit last night, her tweet was still making the rounds this morning. And as the original tweet contained no limits, some people got a bit narky when they found out the original authors wouldn't be donating any further.

My motivation for writing this post, however, is to wonder why people would take this route to donation. Stepwise:
  1. You have a desire to help victims of a natural disaster, so you give money to charity.
  2. If this were your only desire – i.e. you were motivated purely by altruism – you would just give the money to charity and be done with it.
  3. You may, however, also wish to raise public awareness of the issue to encourage other donations (encouraging altruism in others) and/or
  4. You may wish to garner positive reputational benefits (respect, admiration, whatever) by publicising your actions.
Now, Point 4 may not sit well with some people – if you were truly concerned about the plight of these flood victims, why would you sully that by playing your actions up for personal (reputational) gain? That's a can of worms, though, which I will try to avoid by claiming that I don't believe most of these people were coldly calculating enough to think "Well, I'm prepared to donate $X – how can I go about maximising my return on that."; I simply just don't believe their thought processes extended that far. More interesting, I think, is a fifth point:
  1. By opening your decision-making process up to public input, you are (involuntarily?) exposing yourself to peer pressure to donate more than you intended.
This requires some sort of assumption of bounded rationality, I think; a type of rationality that hasn't gone explicitly through points 1–4, or wondered what they'd do if their limit wasn't reached (would they then donate less to flood victims simply because too few people forwarded their message? That seems callous.)  By giving others the impression that they have an influence over your actions, you raise in them the expectation that you will respond to their exertion of that influence and, if only to avoid backlash (loss of reputational benefits), you might be prompted, in fact, to act beyond what you had previously decided: see lilithia donating $500 instead of $250, or Daniel Keogh donating $5000. (I don't know what he was intending to donate originally, but I suspect it was less than that.)

Penultimately, as I said in my opening, this type of "I'll donate money for every RT" message did spread; it is quite possible that it has spurred people to donate by giving them benefits above and beyond the altruistic ones. So, if being able to get a bit of recognition on a social network encourage more people to give than otherwise would have (or to give more than they would otherwise have given), I guess that's not such a bad thing.(2)

Finally, go donate. Queensland floods if you like, but I would suggest Pakistan: they need US$20 billion for their reconstruction effort, and are worse off than is Australia.

(1) An organisation against depression.
(2) There is, in fact, fascinating literature on the motivation behind charitable giving and how to maximise it.

[UPDATE]
Peter Brent has a slightly related post at his Mumble blog on why the plight of middle Australia evinces more empathy than the (more serious) plight of others.

Saturday, January 08, 2011

It's a hard life


Bronte Beach. 27 degrees Celsius. Light breeze.

Tuesday, January 04, 2011

A Cautionary Tale

In my least proud internet banking moment, I once entered the "wrong" password so often that the account was suspended, only to realise that I'd mistyped my client number and had thus accidentally caused someone else's account to be suspended.

Happy new year.