Friday, September 17, 2010

Real-life Prisoner's Dilemma

Who says economics is boring? A real-life Prisoner's Dilemma:

Whom to believe on the NBN

I've been following the debate about Australia's proposed National Broadband Network (NBN) closely since I've been back, and it appears that it will remain a fairly big topic in the coming months. I would like to, therefore, recommend the two persons whose writing I most respect on the subject (the links go to some examples):
These guys deliver consistently high-quality, thought-out arguments on the topic.
Honourable mention goes to Bernard Keane.

(On the "against" side, Christopher Joye and Peter Martin are worth reading; I rarely agree with most of their points, but, unlike most critics, they usually ask the right questions.)

[UPDATE]
The always excellent Possum Comatitus has a post over at Pollytics explaining why calls for a cost-benefit analysis of the NBN are rubbish. Basically it's the difference between risk (quantifiable unknowns; the chance of rolling a 1 on a fair 6-sided die) and uncertainty (unquantifiable unknowns; the chance of rolling a 1 on a die whose properties are unknown – 4-sided, 6-sided, 20-sided, weighted, whatever).

Monday, September 13, 2010

Arranged marriage vs. free choice: the wrong statistic

Apparently I had a letter published in yesterday's "Sunday Life" (a supplement in the weekend Fairfax papers). I haven't seen the issue, because I'm apartment hunting in Sydney, but here is my original letter in any case:

In an short piece entitle "Pitfalls of Passion" in the August 29 issue of "Sunday Life", Bella Ellwood-Clayton writes that "[t]he type of love Westerners chase doesn't, by and large, last. Arranged marriages, on the other hand, have a global divorce rate of about four per cent compared to Australian, American and Canadian figures, which place us at about the 40% figure. So what do do countries such as Turkey, Pakistan, Bangladesh and India – where most marriages are arranged – know that we don't?"

This statistic is not only rubbish, it is insults (through ignorance) the plight of those women who are forced into arranged marriages. The major reason arranged marriages last is that unhappy partners – invariably the women – are not allowed to divorce, or face incredibly high barriers (physical punishment, social stigmatism, ostracisation) to do so. Comparing the statistics from the two regions assumes they are both indicators of how happy/successful a marriage is, when this is patently not the case. Is Ms. Ellwood-Clayton really touting a culture in which loveless, one-sided marriages are accepted over one in which partners are free to amicably separate and seek new relationships over different periods in their lives?

While I hardly expect a detailed discussion of the topic in an article that is scarcely longer than this letter, and broadly agree with the ideas otherwise raised in it (including possible benefits of arranged marriages), I do expect an absence of crap; and that use of statistics was crap.

Saturday, September 04, 2010

Undermanned, but not outclassed.

I played my last game of football for the Eltham Eagles today – the last of the season, and probably the last for many years, if not ever – and, though we lost 2-1 and fell from 4th to 6th as a result, it was one of the best games we've played all season. 

My biggest problem with this team has been the lack of footballing culture: of hunger, of real desire to give everything in pursuit of victory. I know I can't really expect it in this league, but that doesn't mean I can't want it. Today, we showed it.

The match was down at Knox, the catch-up game to one that was cancelled during the season due to an unplayable pitch. The conditions weren't much better, with steady wind and rain, but at least the pitch was playable. Not that it was a good pitch! While not the most uneven pitch I've played on this year – that honour goes to Monbulk's home ground, which has the characteristics of an A4 sheet of paper with a weight placed in the middle of one long side –, it is so curved that you can stand at one corner and just barely see the top of the diagonally opposite corner flag. The grass was patchy, and the soil varied between firm & slick and deep & muddy. "Challenging" is a polite description. 

Oh, and did I mention we only had nine (9) players? Our star striker called in sick, the big sook, and at least three blokes just went AWOL. We lost the toss, and spent the first half playing uphill, with the wind and rain in our faces. That we were only 2-0 down at half-time – with both of those goals coming from dreadful goalkicks that went straight to the opposition, rather than us being really outplayed – was really quite encouraging, as was the fact we'd actually threatened their goal on occasion.
Now, our keeper today was a somewhat excitable chap, and after his errors his blood was up and he wanted to get out on the pitch and vent a bit. Trouble is, we didn't have anyone else to fill that position. So, fuming, he started the second half in goals, and pumped a bit of aggression into the very next ball he go into his hands. The wind caught it and carried it to the edge of the opposition's penalty area, where their keeper misjudged bounce (a slippery surface works both ways) and scrambled backwards as the ball travelled over his head – in vain: goal!

That lifted our spirits, obviously, and for the next 40 minutes we played as if possessed. We ran, and ran, and dominated the game to the extent you would not have believed we were two players down. For a while it was even three: our right winger ran so much he cramped first in one leg, then, five minutes later, in the other. That I managed to fill the central midfield basically by myself owes surely just as much to the inexplicable ineptitude of the opposition as it does to my meagre talents, but darn it was satisfying.

Yes, we came off the field wet, muddy from head to toe, tired as all buggery, and as losers to a team that leapfrogged us on the ladder as a result. But damn if that wasn't just the kind of spirit I'd been wanting to see all season. Now if only we'd had it a few games earlier...

Saturday, August 28, 2010

Death of a Salesman('s Intelligence)

My family went to have its picture taken a few weeks ago, in an experience that left me altogether doubting the photographer's rationality. It wasn't the photographs themselves – he was clearly skilled in that respect –, but the way he sold them to us that frustrated me.

The photographer took perhaps 60 shots, from which we were then able to select one or several to be displayed in a framed montage. This main item alone cost several thousand dollars (depending on size), but, to sweeten the deal, the guy threw in a few smaller copies of different photographs; reasonably textbook marketing there. Finally, once we'd selected the handful of photographs we wanted, the photographer offered us a "first run" edition of all the photographs for around $300. "First run" is his clever way of saying "I'm not going to bother touching these up", and revealing this offer at the end of the process, when one has spent an hour agonizing over which pictures to keep and which to cull, lets the customer insure against their "What if I made the wrong choice?" fears for a comparatively low sum (given that one has already committed to paying a few months wages(1)). He compounds these fears and induces a sense of urgency by saying that he doesn't store the photos he's taken on his computer, but that he deletes them once we're done. 
In case we were already expenditure-weary, he outlined all the things we could do with this complete set – scan them, email them to friends and family, give them to loved ones. Here's where I made the following offer: how about we pay the same price for this set, but he gives them to us in electronic format. 

"Easiest money he's ever made", I thought.He has the files on his computer, and, instead of printing them out (for a marginal cost of whatever), he burns them onto a CD/DVD (marginal cost: <$1) and sells us that. For the same price – I mean, that's a no-brainer, right?

He refused.
I couldn't believe it. He knows we're going to scan these photos – he's practically counting on it. The images are going to go electronic format on his computer, to physical form, and then to electronic format on my computer – but, in the meantime, I've had to invest my time in scanning the bloody things, and the results aren't as good as the original.

I don't understand it! Nobody wins from this. Perhaps my benefits in getting the photos on a disc outweigh his benefits; but that only suggests that he should seek some of my surplus. Differential pricing is hardly new here:  the last time I had passport photos taken, I had the choice between 8€ for the physical photos or 15€ for the electronic copy, in what amounts to pretty much the exact same situation. I thus asked our photographer if we could get the "first run" set electronically if we paid more than for the physical set. Still no. We "wouldn't be able to open the RAW formatted files", he said. "Pig's arse!", we thought (never mind the fact that he sent the pictures to the printer as JPGs, as the filenames on the back reveal). If it was the image quality he was worried about (though I struggle to find a rational explanation for that), he could always run a batch process over the set and sell them to us at whatever quality he felt appropriate.

This is possibly amplified because I'm an economist, but the photographer's behaviour in this issue is the most blantantly stupid conduct I have ever experienced in a salesman.

(1) My father, an engineer, rounds numbers to the closest relevant figure; anything with more than one decimal place is treated with significant scepticism. "2.96%? That's 3%. What do I care about 0.04%?"  The prices for the main picture were all  $5 off a round figure – a relatively basic marketing trick. When my father rounded the price off (up), the photographer specifically and repeatedly asked him/us not to do so: "Please don't say that. I don't want you to say that. Say 'X-thousand, ninehundred and ninety five dollars'. Say it with me." His persistence when we refused was astonishing.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Second-hand markets for used games

There's a bit of discussion over at Penny Arcade on the practice of buying used games rather than new ones – views apparently range from "It's basically piracy" to "It's legal, why should I care if the developers don't get my money?"

Here's my contribution:
Hey Gabe,

I’m an economist as well as a gamer, so a few thoughts from that direction: while a second-hand game purchase doesn’t directly benefit developers, it’s not a 1:1 decrease in sales – I might purchase more new games if I know that I can sell them later (like buying a new car every 10 years when the old one is still drive-able), and/or use the money used from selling old games to buy new games. Cheapskates who wait for used games probably wouldn’t buy new games, anyway – they’re paying with their time (waiting for games to appear on the second-hand market) rather than money. Second-hand games also increase exposure in younger/poorer audiences that later, when they have the money, can go out and buy new original games.

Basically, second-hand are markets are not at all unique to gaming – practically every physical product has one (ebay, craigslist, etc), and those producers have learnt to cope (e.g. planned obsolescence).

I note that these effects don’t apply to piracy, though.

/Martin

I forgot to mention that there's obviously a key difference between video games and most physical products in the sense that games don't degrade in quality nearly as quickly – however, off-setting that, video games have a strong "state of the art" component that reduces over time.

This was all just off the top of my head, but interested parties can check out further reading here.

Monday, August 16, 2010

Dick Smith's population puzzle: a Q&A

Whadaya reckon about this whole Dick Smith $1m prize thing? He seems to be after a practical strategy for decoupling economic and physical growth. It's not like people haven't been thinking about that already. What are your thoughts?



I see three questions:
 1) Do I agree with Smith's premise?
 2) Do I agree with his goal?
 3) Do I agree with his methodology of achieving that goal?

1) Premise
Based on his letter (I didn't watch his TV shows), Smith has clearly linked "population" to "environmental degradation". That, by itself, is an incomplete equation: what's important is not just the number of people, but how each of them behaves i.e. how much "environment" they consume.
That most of the worldwide debate has been about changing how people act is, I suspect, less to do with any ignorance of the factor "population" than the knowledge that it's much easier to convince a family of four to consume less than it is to convince them to stop at one child (at least in most societies); we're simply focussing on the solution that appears easiest to implement.
This, I think, is the key point: yes, the number of people is a problem – but it's only a part of the problem, and it may be much more difficult (or even unnecessary) to change this part than to focus on other causes.

2) Goal
For the sake of argument, though, let's assume that changing our consumptive behaviour won't be enough (if that's not true now, it may well be in the future), and we need to change the number of people we "generate" as well. That requires either a big cultural shift (bottom-up change) or lots of enforcement (top-down change). China and some other states can do autocratic change; we can't.
So, cultural reproductive change (to complement our lifestyle change in consumption) – how does one best go about achieving that?

3) Methodology
This is where I'm as ignorant as the next guy (unless the next guy is Hari Seldon) – how do you go about manipulating society? In general, I guess you have to get the idea "out there"; create awareness. In that sense, a TV show seems like a good idea. Whether it's better than a thoughtful book, a few opinion pieces in the paper and some radio interviews, I can't say. But I'm pretty certain Smith is doing more good than harm, since this prize thing means the issue should float around in public consciousness for a while.
Note that I've completely ignored the fact that the prize is to be awarded for "something"; an invention or scheme or whatnot. Unless I'm wrong in my thinking that our reproductive behaviour is primarily due to culture (having passed the point of requiring children to provide for us in our old age [provide, not care]), any winning entry that doesn't change culture is pointless.

4) Verdict
If one wants to be generous, one could say that Dick Smith is a long-term thinker concerned about sustainability who is trying to sow the seeds for a cultural shift in our attitude towards reproduction. Perhaps he's even thought, "Oh – I'm not sure how best to change societal thinking; perhaps creating a prize will encourage people to come with ideas."
However – and this is where I pull my economist hat down firmly over my ears – is this the best way to spend this one million dollars? I freely admit I don't know much about changing cultural mores, but I'll bet you buttons to bootstraps that any solution we come up with will be harder to spread to the rest of the world than one that changes (the impact of) our consumptive behaviour – and spread these solutions to the world we must, because Australia doesn't have enough proportion of the world's population that changing culture here alone will make a big difference. Could Smith achieve more for (global) sustainability by investing his money to develop and/or spread (existing) changes to our consumptive lifestyle? I suspect so. But then, he probably wouldn't get as much publicity for that...

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Louis Armstrong for the Youff

This popped into my head, and I'm so taken by it that I'm posting it everywhere :-)

I see peeps fist-bumping, saying "Yo! 'sup, foo'?". They're really saying "I ♥ u."

Monday, August 09, 2010

Wilfull Property Destruction

It's been a week for collisions: on Monday, I had dropped my brother off and was driving to pick my mother up when a lady drove into the back of me while I was stopped in a queue of cars. Not only did the force of the impact seriously dent the rear of my car, but it pushed me into the car in front of me. Possibly as a result of the sandwiching, the car's a write-off. Barring a sore neck and shoulders for the next few days, however, I appear to be fine.
Yesterday, I was the recipient of a rather hefty challenge that left a several-centimetre long wound on my leg – under the shin pad! It's not a serious wound by any means, but the shin-pad is done for (first time that's happened):
Cracked shinpad, scraped leg
In both cases the first thoughts were about the regrettable damage to the property, but upon reflection, I'm much happier that they took the damage than I did. I shudder to think what my leg would look like if I hadn't worn pads.

Friday, August 06, 2010

Countering some poor arguments for a mining tax

I was recently asked by Xavier Shay (blog, twitter) to comment on an article in The Age by Michael Gilding, entitled "More tax dollars and less mining? That's a win-win situation". Here is my response: 

Short version: Gilding identifies several problems for which a reduction in mining – though it might help – is the wrong solution.
Longer, point by point version:

Gilding's first argument, that "mining sucks oxygen (capital investment) from the rest of the economy", is one I can't support. The reason is that a basic tenet of economics is that people (the market) make their own best decisions – in this case, investing in mining rather than, say, toll roads. The first rule of taxation is therefore that it distorts private decision-making as little as possible, which makes justifying a mining tax on the grounds that it distorts decisions problematic. (The RSPT, I note, was lauded precisely for NOT distorting investment decisions.)

There is a notable exception to this non-distorting policy: when the social costs/benefits are not adequately reflected by the monetary costs/benefits. That's why we have extra taxes on cigarettes – the "costs" they impose are less than the untaxed price a market sets on them. Similarly, education provides (societal) benefits far in excess of what it costs to deliver, and is therefore subsidised.

Now, Gilding argues that capital that goes to mining could instead go to "innovative technologies or creative industries", like solar power. Well, yes, but it could also go to building apartment buildings, shopping centres, car manufacturing plants, coal power stations, wharves, or toll roads. I am open to the idea of stimulating innovative and creative industries (and solar power), but reducing capital investment in mining is a silly way of doing it.


Gilding's second argument is about the effects that mining exports have on the Australian dollar. It is true that a higher Australian dollar reduces our (quantity of) exports. Gilding expresses the commonly held view that exports are better than imports, and we should increase our net exports. In the first point, I am agnostic: exports are like saving, imports are like borrowing. As long as I'm in balance over time, there is no intrinsic "better" or "worse". I have more sympathy for the second point – that we should increase our net exports at this point in time –, as we have reasonably high levels of private foreign debt that really should be addressed. However, the proposed mechanism is, again, rubbish: if we wanted to increase our exports by devaluing the Australian dollar (by reducing mining production), why not just do as the Chinese do and go back to a pegged currency? Oh, that's right – decades of economic and political doctrine advocating the contrary.
In short: making one industry less competitive (mining) does not make other industries (cars) more competitive.


Gilding's third argument is about the difficulty in managing a two-speed economy. That difficulty absolutely exists, and skimming profits off high-performing industries to help (through reform, not subsidies!) low-performing industries is good economic management. But why is mining unique is this regard? There are other industries in Australia whose return on investment is just as high (in percentile terms), and taking "super profits" from one high-performing industry while ignoring others is inequitable, unfair, and distortionary policy. (An economy wide super-profits tax – essentially progressive company taxes, as we have on income – is certainly an interesting idea, but not one that's within a coo-ee of public debate. I don't even know how theoretically valid it is.)
No, the rationale for the extra tax on mining was: 1) natural resources are non-renewable; and 2) natural resources are pubic assets. That the revenue then be used to reform the rest of the economy – yes, absolutely! Using that RSPT/MRRT/$ACRONYM revenue for anything other than infrastructure and/or business investment would be awful, short-sighted policy.


There is a fourth argument in Gilding's piece, though he barely touches on it: "[M]inerals are not going to go anywhere. In fact, it might be prudent to leave some of those minerals in the ground for future generations of Australians." This is a rather tricky issue of inter-temporal profit maximisation – is it better to sell something now or later? Just imagine you have a bar of gold sitting at home – when you do you sell it? All now, all later, bits and pieces over time (let's assume you can separate it into discrete portions easily)? The answer depends on when you think you'll need money over your lifetime, your expectations of the development of the value of gold, and your expectations of the development of the value of alternative investments. Maybe, in 50 years, gold can be cheaply synthesised and will become very cheap. Maybe it will be discovered to be a key ingredient in life-prolonging elixirs and will sky-rocket in value. Maybe you have a high preference for getting a return on your gold in the next 10 years and don't care about anything else. (How long does a CEO typically stay at a company?) But, certainly, it's a very complex topic.

Actually, I lie – Gilding does touch on the topic again, in his summary: "Mining is robbing future generations of natural resources." Where is our future generations' "right" to natural resources? Would they be just as happy with the proceeds of alternative investments funded by selling those resources? Huge, thorny topic; barely scratched in the article.