Saturday, December 12, 2009

Climate Scoreboard

Funky widget that shows how close the current global proposals are to achieving the stated goals.

Friday, December 11, 2009

iFamily


This is how my cousin and uncle spend family gatherings: playing on their respective iDevices.

Friday, November 13, 2009

A bold choice

One particular telephone company here in Germany has a "BlackBerry Deal" for students running at the moment, and though (or perhaps precisely because) I've had unsavoury dealings with this company in the past I've taken up the offer to borrow a BlackBerry for a week or so.

The model I have is a BlackBerry Bold or BlackBerry 9000, the latest and greatest BlackBerry. Based on the reviews I had high expectations, but so far I haven't been convinced. Okay, as with any new phone, you have to get used to the navigation, in this case the trackball. My first irritation came, however, when I realised I couldn't scroll off the top of a menu and appear at the bottom, or scroll off the left and appear at the right. With long lists, this is a huge time-waster.
The second irritation is the input of umlauts or other accents, which – incredibly intuitively – involves holding down the desired letter and scrolling with the trackball. First of all, that's pretty much impossible to do with one hand. Secondly, the list of possible accents aren't displayed, so you don't know whether the one you're looking for is one, three, or five steps away and have to carefully scroll through each selection.

Still, I find myself entranced by the device. I think 80% of the attraction is the larger screen and GPS, which I plan on utilising intensively when I go on my little cross-Germany tour with The Living End next week. The BlackBerry is doubtlessly a much better device for emails than my Sony Ericsson W580i, but I only occasionally read emails on the go and hardly ever respond, so that's not a deal-breaker. I don't use much internet on the go aside from Twitter (deliberately – I spend enough time online at home!), but where the BlackBerry could convince me is if it proves better at music playback than my current "Walkman" phone. That I haven't tested yet, but the presence of the 2.5mm headset jack rather than a proprietary connection is a terrific start.

I'll keep you updated. Possibly via BlackBerry ;-)

Thesis completed!

After four months of hard slog I handed my diploma thesis in economics in today, and breathed a mighty sigh of relief. 80 pages, 20,000 words, 38 charts & graphs –I think I can be happy with the result.

The topic was "An international comparison of alternatives to GDP as a measure of welfare." If that's still a little broad, here's a brief synopsis (if you'd prefer a polemic speech, go listen to this 2min Bobby Kennedy speech on the topic):

After the Great Depression in 1929 the Yanks decided they could do with a system of national accounts to deliver comprehensive information about how the economy was faring. Out of this process sprung the Gross Domestic Product, or GDP, which measures the value of all goods and services produced by an economy over a period of time; basically, it tell you how big an economy is.

Now, what the GDP doesn't do is tell you how well off people are, for the simple reason that it doesn't measure everything that affects how well off we are. What kind of things does it leave out? Income distribution, for starters: GDP doesn't tell you if the rich folk are earning more, or the poor folk, or both. Levels of health, education, crime, environmental pollution, unemployment, over-employment (working too much), unpaid work; these all affect our welfare, too, but aren't part of GDP. Unpaid work is one of my favourites. An example: I cook myself dinner every night, and so does my neighbour. That doesn't count towards GDP. If my neighbour pays me to cook her dinner and I pay her to cook mine, suddenly GDP increases. Are we any better off? Not really. But if we use GDP to measure how well off we are, then we would have to say yes.

Another problem with GDP is that some things are part of it, but probably shouldn't be. If, for example, I run a factory and pump black smoke into the air so that no one gets to see the sun, lots of people are unhappy and circle my house with torches and pitchforks during their lunch break (they need the torches to see because it's so dark). So I spend a lot of money installing filters to get rid of the smoke. All of that increases GDP, but are the people better off than they were before I started polluting? Not really. They can see the sun again, but they could beforehand, too. They're not accidentally stabbing each other with pitchforks in the dark any more, but that was also my fault. So GDP has gone up, even though our welfare hasn't increased.

Finally, our welfare doesn't just depend on how we're doing today, but also how we'll be doing tomorrow, in a few years and decades, and how our descendants will be doing. Going out and fishing the oceans empty would result in really, really cheap fish for a while (yay! more GDP! everyone's better off!), but after that it wouldn't be so swell. So our welfare also depends on how sustainably we're living.

So these are some of the reasons why GDP isn't a great measure of welfare. People have known this for yonks – the chap who invented GDP, in fact, told the American Congress that that wasn't how it was supposed to be used while he was inventing it. But they didn't listen.
Anyway, about 40 years ago some economists got together and decided they'd create an alternative, which they called the "Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare" – ISEW. A few other economists thought, "bonzer!", and took up this concept for their own countries. Over the years it was extended, and refined, and given prettier names like "Genuine Progress Indicator" (GPI). There's ISEWs and GPIs and indexes by a bunch of other names for all sorts of countries now, sometimes several for the same country. Some of them define welfare a little differently than the others, but most of them come back to the same principles.(1) A lot of the differences are in the way they go about measuring welfare – does emitting a ton of CO2 cause $30 of damage, or $60, $160 or perhaps even more?(2)

Now, what I did – after explaining all that stuff up there for 15 pages because, well, that's what you do when you're an academic – is take three of these ISEW studies, look at them very sternly, and ask, "Are you a valid and reliable measure of welfare?"(3)
I then wrote down all the bits where I thought they were and weren't very good measure of welfare, considered all the technical stuff they did, made some suggestions of how I thought they could be improved, and tried some of my own suggestions out to see what the results were. That one sentence covers 70% of my thesis and 100% of the attractive and very time consuming graphs and tables.

Attentive readers will have noticed that 15 + 70% does not equal 80, and they're right: on the remaining pages I drew dirty pictures, then deleted those and I wrote, "I did not plagiarise" one-thousand times.

So that's my thesis. Those who find the topic interesting should check out Beyond GDP (www.beyond-gdp.eu) and perhaps the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress (www.stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr), both of which have loads of material on the subject. Particularly hardcore is the 292-page report by the CMEPSP, written by half-a-dozen Nobel-prize winning economists, whom I nevertheless harbour a grudge against because I waited almost half a year for their report and when it came out it was just "We need better data" written three-hundred-thousand times and no index for me to study.

But they're Nobel laureates, so I guess they're allowed to do that.


(1) Some of them just go around and ask people how happy they are. Which is great but, y'know, a little useless.
(2) If you ask Penny Wong she'll answer, "Whatever the coal lobby says", but that's because she hates kittens and only has her position because it looks incredibly good having a female, Asian, homosexual Minister for Climate Change. (Sorry Philipp Rösler, lesbianism beats adoption. And she was only 3 years older that you when she took office, so nerr.)
(3) If I'm honest I only whispered the question under my breath, but this a joke only Seb will understand.

Friday, November 06, 2009

I statistically hope you receive a kick in the balls

Perhaps it's just the stress of my thesis making me cranky, but I've been noticing a glut of statistically uninformed commentary lately. Four examples from this week:

"Statistically, HSV is as good as through: Celtic have never won in Germany."

"Only 1 of the 12 is female, but, statistically, she has good chances: the last three events were all won by women."

"Statistically, Valencia have pretty much won this game: no German team has scored here since 1982."

"The US economy has climbed out of its worst recession since World War II but there is concern that this may only be a statistical recovery."

To quote The Princess Bride, – actually, no, let me quote KC from Treed Murray: "You don't know what the fuck you're talking about."

Tuesday, November 03, 2009

Alan Jones is a nutcase

I don't tend to listen to Alan Jones, but yesterday he had a cracker of an interview with Malcolm Turnbull (for those playing at home, they are a well-known Sydney radio host and leader of the Liberal party, respectively). And by "cracker", I mean "totally off the rails and into conspiracy la-la land." It really is astonishing what kind of rubbish this guy believes – on refugees, global warming –, how he brings it across, and that politicians never-the-less appear on his program. At least Turnbull slapped him down when he was able.

Have a listen.

Friday, October 30, 2009

Inside the tube

There are some incredible pictures of breaking surf waves – "tubes" – over at internetpopculture.com – really, really awesome (in the original sense) photos. Here are a few, just to give you a taste:





Friday, October 23, 2009

The impact of a global temperature rise of 4ºC

International Migration and Remittances

Broadly following the theme of my last post, here's a relatively basic, but nonetheless interesting videographic of international migration and remittances by The Economist