Tuesday, April 05, 2011

ANU Crawford School conference: Australia's Climate Policy Options

I went to my first conference last Thursday, which I found very exciting. It was about "Australia's Climate Policy Options" and was being held by the Crawford School at the Australian National University (ANU) in Canberra. One could quibble and call it my second conference, since my very first task when I started my current job was to organise an event featuring many of the people who attended Thursday's event, but ours had the character of a workshop rather than full-blown conference; the ANU event was much larger, and was primarily speeches with panel discussions rather than actual workshopping.

According to my colleagues, one of the big purposes of conferences in networking. Yes, you go to hear the speakers, ask questions, and engage in discussions, but a big attraction is also the time spent during breaks and afterwards mingling with the other attendees and building contacts. This is not something I've traditionally been good at; as a natural introvert, I usually don't go out of my way to meet people. Not to mention that striking up a conversation with a luminary in one's field when one is just starting out is daunting for most people. 

However, you have to start somewhere, right? I figured that the worst that could come of it was that I'd have the day off work, hear some interesting talks, put a few faces to names, and build a foundation for one day being able to broach a conversation with, "You look familiar – did I see you at XYZ conference?"

I got a little beyond that minimum goal, which was nice. Aside from seeing these people in the flesh (and the really were quite a lot of well known names from the climate change policy area there; I won't list them all, but you might recognise a few of the speakers from my notes, below) and being introduced to a handful by my colleagues who were there (always the easiest way of making new contacts), I was able to approach a few off my own bat; I very cleverly asked them what they thought of an experiment I'm working on with a colleague – not only did I let them know what I was working on and have a topic of conversation, but I got some good tips for my own work :-)

Aside from the conference itself, which I won't go into much more (though I will post my notes below, and over at Scribd if you like to download a PDF version), what I also found fascinating was the experience around the conference – flying down to Canberra, taking taxis, staying in a hotel, etc. This may sound really banal, but I don't remember the last time I stayed in a hotel or took a taxi by choice; when I travel I almost always stay with friends, and I get places by bike, public transport, or car. And it wasn't even so much the experience of staying in a hotel or taking a taxi that fascinated me, but the knowledge that I wasn't paying for any of it. 

Now, I'm a thrifty bloke. The economics training has probably amplified it, but it's always been there ("typically Swabian", the Germans will say). I'm hardwired to consider the costs of things, even if I can't affect them. And, even when I'm not paying, I still consider them – at breakfast in the hotel, I pondered which option would be the better value for my (employer's) money. During the taxi trips, however,  something fascinating happened: I stopped caring. I got in the cab, told the driver where I wanted to go, and watched the meter tick over with a degree of ambivalence I've never felt before. I couldn't control it; it wasn't my money; I didn't care. "This must be what rich people feel like", I thought, and I suddenly understood the phrase "If you have to ask the price, you can't afford to buy it" a little better. The price of the service was completely irrelevant – I wanted it, so I did it.
This insouciant approach didn't extent to anything bar the taxi rides, so I'm unlikely to get used to it (the very next day I cycled from my apartment back to the airport rather than take a cab), but it was certainly quite interesting while it lasted.

Anyway, here are my notes from the conference:

[UPDATE 06/04/11: Recordings and slides from the conference are now available.]

Opening Remarks

Tom Kompas (Director of the Crawford School of Economics), Blair Comley (Secretary of DCC&EE), Will Steffen (Executive Director, ANU Climate Change Institute)
Chaired by Frank Jotzo (Director of Centre for Climate Economics and Policy)

BC: We all talk within our own communities, and infer from this how the rest of the world thinks about the climate problem. Industry and green groups will therefore have vastly different, but equally sincere beliefs about the prevailing view.

Is the world acting? Some people apply the following tests:
Test one: do we have a top-down, legally-binding international agreement? Sub-set of test one: is there an absolute emissions reduction target for every country?
Test two: does every country have an emissions trading scheme or explicit carbon tax? (Ignores some countries' existing preference for command & control measures based on past successful experience.)
These analytical frameworks aren't the ones these same people apply to domestic policy. E.g. They will argue that Australia reducing emissions by 5% from 2000 is a big effort because of the difference to BAU. This is true – but why doesn't this argument apply to other countries?

Just because assessing countries' different efforts (the implicit prices) is difficult doesn't mean we shouldn't attempt it. (Acknowledges Cameron Hepburn from Vivid Economics and the work they're doing.)

Question from audience: Are Australians happy to be followers; to wait until China acts?
BC: Doesn't want to directly address leading/following. But international action is good for comparing analytical frameworks and building trust: Monitoring, Reporting, Verification is critical. We trust our own data, but not always that in other countries.

WS: General remarks about the ANU centre.

Q: Problems of independent advisors and their role in the public debate.
WS: He's had bigger problems dealing with the media than the public, Government, or industry groups. The media are the weak chain; twisting things, false use of the "balance" principle.


Carbon pricing & Australia's mitigation commitment

Frank Jotzo, Steve Hatfield-Dodds (CSIRO Scientist, "thought leader"), Warwick McKibbin (Prof. of International Politics, RBA Board Member), John Quiggin (UQ, Economics/PolSci)
Chaired by Salim Mazouz (Founding Director of EcoPerspectives – consulting)

FJ: Australia's a very rich country (PPP per cap). Should remember that we are seen this way internationally. With carbon pricing and the revenue distribution, about 1% of Aus GDP is up for grabs. MPCCC model creates argument for limiting compensation because the price is fixed (i.e. no uncertainty). Fixed price originally proposed in original Garnaut report as viable second-best. (WM rebuts: says it goes back further (early 90s?).) FJ thinks it's the best way to achieve a broad-based and lasting consensus.
If we start with a low price, we should increase it quickly; shouldn't start with a low price and low increase. Forecast EU ETS average 2013-20 = 32€ (Deutsche Bank) .
If Australia reduces (absolute) emissions by 5% vs. 2000 levels, China will have lower emissions intensity by 2015 (under their 40-45% target).

SHD: Understanding the "signs" of climate change (what goes up, what goes down) would do wonders for public debate. A carbon price decouple domestic emissions from the national target. (Domestic = what we emit. National = emissions less (internationally purchased) offsets.)
Signs: Carbon emissions fall, but income rises (by less than BAU, but still a rise). Prices rise, but affordability improves.
Average income, employment, efficiency will improve. National total and pp emissions will fall, as will investment risk. Energy prices are really the biggest thing that should cause us headaches.
Communication: referring to the "costs" of policy risks a reference point error, triggering loss aversion. Should emphasise that incomes will not fall. Framing and reference points effect (affect?) the policy stance of 5-23% of people.
Sign of change is more important than the magnitude in people's minds.

WM: Making the same points since early 90s: Which price do we care about? What policy framework should we learn from? How should we allocate property rights?
Price: Three years of certainty is not nearly enough for electricity investment. We needs to worry about the carbon price 20, 30, 40 years from now; analogous to the long-term real interest rate.
Policy Framework: Monetary policy. Credible commitment to target over the medium-term. Pleased Garnaut has taken up the idea of a "Central Bank of Carbon." (See earlier work by McKibbin and Wilcox?) Readjusting fixed price every few years.
Rights: Tax = revenue. Allocating (long-term) property rights can give that revenue to the market. But! No futures market for taxes. Futures markets need "things" –> property rights. Allocating property rights should be regarded as a separate issue to who trades those rights. Is against risk-free loans for companies: sees the integration of property rights into the pricing framework as important.
Climate policy should be focussed on emissions reduction, not income redistribution; makes it more complicated.
Has one minute left for his talk. Would be willing to trade it, but he has no property rights and there is no market ;-)

JQ: Australia doesn't have climate policy options any more. Not going to be resolved by better communication. Has become a cultural issue. Therefore all that matter is getting a policy up that can pass both houses of Parliament. Gobs of money for lower income households hard to unwind; good idea. Heavy emitting industries had their chance a year ago and blew it when their attractive scheme failed.
People understand that companies pass taxes on to consumers, therefore more justification for compensating households than firms.

Q: How can we better get across a message with clear guiding principles:
JQ: Just act. Communication won't help much any more.
WM: Opportunity was lost some time ago. Giving households long-term rights would have been a terrific sell. Screwed it up by treating this issue as a political football. Go back to treating it as a long-term proposition.
FJ: Agrees with JQ, but doesn't see Government giving away discretionary policy control over carbon revenues. Perhaps turn this into a tax reform issue?

Do companies need an adequate "balance sheet effect" (free permits)?
WM: If your price is fixed in the world market you can't pass costs on to customers (i.e. small open markets)

Questions on policy from Richard Denniss, Andrew Leigh, and others. Clever policy, short-term vs. long-term, repealing public legislation.
JQ: If the price is clear and positive is will be hard to unravel.
WM: Emphasises the importance of long-term price again. Managing risk in the market.
JQ: Disagrees with WM. Says there are plenty of markets where people invest without 40yr+ certainty. There is some bickering between the two. JQ won't look at WM.
SHD: "Smart" policy is not the same as "first-best" – may have to accept third-best or fifth-best. Thinks short-term prices over 5-10 years can make a big difference with a lesser political battle than setting long-term prices.
FJ: Once it's demonstrated that the sky isn't going to fall it will be difficult to undo the taxes.

Steve's views on John's presentation; EU ETS as success story vs. FITs; measurement issues; will the conditions for emissions trading be there is 3-5 years?
JQ: Smart economics is where prices do most of the heavy lifting. Only way to communicate is to things is to do them. What matters is the political situation, not the economic reality; in 3-5 years other countries will have moved and we'll have more trading partners. Also the prophets of doom will  have been disproven.
WM: EU ETS shows you how you can make mistakes. Over-allocation, variability. Open question what the marginal benefit of the ETS is vs. FITs and solar subsidies. Investing in a 5th-best solution (e.g. EU common currency without credible government backing. Result: Euro about to explode) makes our life harder when we have to fix it; better to get it right now. Grateful that the Europeans are making all these mistakes for us to learn from.
SHD: People resist uncomfortable ideas. If you don't like the idea that Government action is required to fix things, that causes you to reject science that suggests this course of action. "Cultural warriors." Industrial and fossil-fuel emissions we know very well, LULUCAF poorly known; should be different policy settings. Repeal of any scheme unlikely.
FJ: We can mitigate by joining an international agreement, or creating our own arrangement (with local countries?).


Garnaut Climate Change Review Update

Ross Garnaut
Chaired by John Quiggin

RG: Issues that gave rise to debate in the update papers:
Science has firmed, toward the pessimistic end of projections. We should stick to the science in peer-reviewed journals though, even if there is a publication lag, because the debate is difficult enough as it is with the current science.
Great Crash of 2008 has changed the way we discuss economic policy.
Very important that China and India (and other developing countries) are approaching emissions reductions, even at such low per-capita levels.
Copenhagen fiasco: What came out what inchoate at the time, but order was given to it at Cancun. 2°C ≈ 450ppm.
We are bending the curve from BAU. Not enough to meet 2°C, but it's a start. US heading toward its commitments.
Emissions-intensive trade-exposed industries is a difficult, messy, but very important issue. We will seriously distort our political economy and the politics of our own policy-making if we get it wrong. Measurement is a difficult problem, but we need to devote the resources to it.
Original purpose with electricity paper was to show that the carbon price effect on electricity would be small in comparison to the other price rises, but as he got into it he started to wonder whether the other price rises needed to be happening.
Rubbishes the editorial in the Australian for not having read his electricity paper carefully.

Q: Effect of carbon prices on innovation; Should we just get on with making policy or hold out for first/second-best; has your role in this debate changed - are you taking sides; can politicians superimpose themselves on the electricity regulation process?
RG: Carbon price is not necessary for innovation, but it will be an incentive. Not enough to rely on carbon price alone, need public support. Past flawed innovation policies are no argument against this. Renewable energy targets pretty awful in encouraging innovation. Gives all the incentive to the lowest cost renewable energy rather than ... ?
We don't have much time left to act, and we would need to see fatal flaws in a policy to avoid implementing something now that lets us improve upon it later. But we can't start again.
Doesn't see his role in the debate as having changed; rather, others have changed their positions.


Australian Climate Policies

John Daley (Grattan Institute), Richard Denniss (The Australia Institute), Leo Dobes (Economist, Climate Change Adaptation)
Chaired by Steve Hatfield-Dobbs

JD: His is a completely inappropriate presentation for economists, since it'll tell us something that we all know: markets work better than other frameworks (grants, rebates, standards). Based on a paper coming out next week (Thursday morning?). What can help Australia meet its targets for 2020 (160 Mt below BAU)?

Grants and rebates haven't delivered much reduction, and rebates are by far the most expensive form of CO2e reduction. Market and efficiency measures have delivered far more, and efficiency measures are cost-negative! (Similar trend for future.)
Market measures have delivered more reductions than legislated at lower costs than expected.
Grants struggle to spend the money. Usually less than 20% after 10 years. Bidders overpromise, Government needs to pick winning technology and firms, tender process slow, and winners often drop out if there are financial or technology problems.
Rebates: $5 billion over last 10 years for insulation, solar PV, water heaters. Activities chosen for political popularity, reward actions that would have happened anyway.
Efficiency is great, but slow: has taken at least 5 years to agree to regulatory standards.
Need to talk about the fact that emissions reduction will cause us pain, but market measures are by far the best (cheapest) way to do it. That is the history of Australia over the last 15 years.
Going after tech stuff with price schemes or FITs will be better than picking the best solar plant proposal.

RD: "I don't have slides, so I always finish on time. Power corrupts, Powerpoint corrupts absolutely."
Complementary policies: how can we talk about carbon prices but not about subsidies for fossil fuel industries ("Contradictory policies" – paper by Denniss and Macintosh). Why does the airline industry not pay fuel tax? First step toward complementary policies is therefore to remove the contradictory (perverse) policies. Need to have good policies. Agrees with JD about what's come before. No-one's been angrier about subsidies to solar PV than Andrew Macintosh. We'd be better off putting fake panels on people's roofs.

LD: No-one is asking "What happens after mitigation?"
People are using risk-management to address adaptation; presumes certain knowledge of risk, where there is none. Different strategy: absorb shocks with a resilient economy. "Socio-economic resilience" requires micro-economic reform (a "no-regret" option).
Avoid 'climate proofing', deterministic approaches, and promote 'real-option'  thinking. Applicable to almost every sphere of activity. Can be done by individuals as well as government.
For governments: compensation risks huge fiscal churn. Should be limited to genuine market failure.

Q: Solar-PV was supposed to bring tech forward, not reduce CO2e; Is adaptation more important than mitigation, or just underappreciated; other schemes to encourage energy efficiency.
JD: Solar PV program not just inefficient (which may be the wrong measure), but also ineffective – most of the money isn't given away, and the programs fall over. There are schemes to encourage business energy efficiency, but the jury is still out as to whether they're working.
RD: PV policy goal: is it abatement? No. Is it bringing tech forward? No – Australia is far too small a market to achieve that. It's about symbolism and misunderstanding. Suggested alternative schemes: mandates. We have mandates for seatbelts, health insurance, superannuation, etc.
LD: Obviously mitigation is necessary, but you need to think the strategy through.


Power Sector and Land Use

Iain MacGill (Director, CEEM), Lorraine Stephenson (Lightning Consulting Services), Andrew Macintosh (ANU Centre for Climate Law and Policy)
Chaired by Steve Hatfield-Dodds

IM: Most of the energy sector sits in the energy policy framework, not the climate policy framework. One framework for policy intervention is to look at correctable market failures, and the energy sector can exhibit all forms of market failure. The NEM is Australia's largest environmental externalities market.  The health costs may outweigh the operating costs!
Not all objectives of the NEM are reflected in the market design. Lack of environmental and sustainability goals in a design choice.
In SA we've gone from 0-20% wind in about 5 years. Market working fine.
LS: We're not going to run out of coal and gas any time soon. Our alternatives to coal-fired power are relatively expensive in Australia. Investors will want 30-40 year regulatory certainty for new power generation assets. Should we be paying for abatement ahead of the abatement curve (i.e. paying a premium) to account for the learning effect?
AM: We got a big freebie with the Kyoto rules on deforestation, and we'll probably make up much of our Kyoto target with that. (The reason we use 2000 as a target rather than 1990?) 50-100 Mt savings pa if we stop logging native forests. There are perverse impacts from the incentives to reforest, though, because they negatively affect the albedo (?) – so why are we crediting them?
Perverse impacts on biodiversity, water, employment, local communities.

Q: Why isn't the coal power industry using "co-firing"; suggestion for the compensation of power industry; is Australia likely to build more coal power plants/can we meet out power needs with renewables & gas?
LS: Co-firing is used at about 5%, but many plants don't find it easy to do. Once you start trying to get biomass, it starts to become expensive (rather than being a free waste product). Hard to upscale. At $20 CO2e price we probably wouldn't get another coal plant without CCS (also because of politics), but we'd have to upgrade transmission infrastructure. Thinks we should compensate the current asset owners in a way that encourages them to reinvest. Also as a practical means of getting people on board: once-off, up front, lump sum compensation though, nothing ongoing.
IM: Coal isn't a great fuel, except that it's cheap. Probably won't see new coal plants, but tough to get the old ones to leave. Iain opposes the idea of compensation, because  that implies you're correcting a wrong and taxing pollution isn't wrong. Also sends bad investment signal ("Government won't stick us with the bill.")


International Climate Policy

David Victor (School of International Relations, UCal. Video-link), Mark C. Lewis (Energy Research, Deutsche Bank), Cameron Hepburn (LSE/Oxford/Vivid Economics)
Chaired by Stephen Howes (Development Policy Centre, ANU)

DV: Updates on America
Issues surrounding international credibility,  "Gridlock and Global Warming". Three points:
Progress at international level and international credibility. Hasn't been much progress, and not much credibility. Price level now less important that expectations for the future. Need to spend more time at the international level getting Governments to make commitments based on what they can actually do. Respond to reality that changes in temperature will be >2°C
Not much is happening in the USA. No expectation of action – not just the current political make-up, but also because the debate has polarised people and they are away of what's at stake (i.e. the free emissions credits). Rent-seeking is getting messy.
But if you widen the focus, a bunch is happening on energy security, emissions from coal-fired power plants (targeting air pollution more so than CO2). Should see over 1/3rd of coal plants shut over next decade, replaced by renewables & gas. Doesn't reach Obama's Copenhagen target, but gets close.
Picture at state level is highly variable. Northern states have cap & trade schemes, but at very low levels. Most of the action is in California e.g. cap & trade, low carbon fuel standards.
Also moves in some places to connect to international schemes.
If the US were to have a national carbon price scheme, it would almost certainly include some sort of trade protection; wouldn't get enough votes otherwise. Not obvious that the good approaches for such a scheme would be followed; could be deeply toxic for developing countries.

ML: Design flaw in EU ETS: no way to modulate supply (of permits) based on changes in demand (e.g. in response to RETs). The average residual abatement (ARA) requirement is the minimum of what actually has to be reduced, after taking banked credits, CDMs, etc into account. The current ARA can probably be covered by fuel switching (coal –> gas), though this analysis was made pre-Fukushima. Increasing the level of ARA (to 30-40%) would exceed fuel-switching, so that the cost of abatement is aligned with the long-run cost of abatement (capital investment) rather than the short-run cost (fuel switching).
Germany will probably close down 7GW of nuclear power (10% of German power production) very soon, in response to Fukushima. Nuclear power investment internationally, which already had cost problems, can probably ruled out for the next five years at least. Instead, gas prices will increase.
Crazy that Australians bring the "Why should we move first?" argument; as if Europe doesn't exist.

CH: Clean-tech is a structural revolution; traditional marginal cost analyses have only limited application.
There is a massive proliferation of (different) climate change policies around the world (a large number of which are probably ineffective or "me too" policies). How can we compare them? Using implicit prices (not shadow prices). C.f. Vivid Economics / Climate Institute report. Productivity Commission is doing an update of that.

Q:Use of international units of compliance / sale of Australian units overseas
ML: Political reasons are the impediment, rather than state of the international carbon market.

Why is the proposed Australian carbon price so high compared to Europe, when we can abate at much lower costs?
CH: AU$25 is roughly equal to what the EU has now, so could be seen as an expensive place to start. But in the long run, it may not be; short-run focus may not be sensible. OTOH, Australia still has "low-hanging" fruit. How those effects balance up, and whether Australia should have a carbon price commensurate to Europe's is an open question.


Australia's Climate Change Strategy in the Global Context

Erwin Jackson (Climate Institute), Harry Clarke ((Micro)Economics, La Trobe Uni), Peter J Wood (Mathematics, ANU)
Chaired by Howard Bamsey

EJ: Australia's national interest is (should be) the strongest feasible global mitigation outcome – lower than 450ppm-e. Countries' ambition is likely to come under review in 2013-14. Legally binding outcome is end game; may reduce short term ambition, but should build longer-term confidence. Little chance of treaty in short-term. Transparency key to trust building.
Challenge for Australia: overemphasis of UNFCCC/treaty as proxy for international action. There are heaps of separate domestic policy interventions, which is what actually reduces emissions. Need to act as if treaty exists – leap of confidence. Key elements of a pollution price package: ensure domestic transformation, act in good faith, build credible global markets, and conduct Research, Demonstration & Development (RD&D).

HC: (How) should we rebate taxes for exporters? Border taxes theoretically better for preventing carbon leakage than free permits. But argument about instruments is silly, because effect on competitiveness is tiny. Aluminium has one of the largest effects, but it's still modest. The effects are more important from a political economy point of view (acceptability), but the noise about the economic effects is larger than the actual impact.

PW: Climate change action as multiple-stage games.

Q: What was your methodology, Harry? Did you look at our report?
HC: I did, but I don't trust other people's reports :-P  Just looked at industry level.


Parliament and the Politics of Climate Change

Anita Talberg (Commonwealth Parliamentary Library), Andrew Leigh (ALP Member for Fraser; formerly Economics, ANU), John Hewson (Former Liberal Leader; Prof. of Economics), Lenore Taylor (Fairfax's National Times correspondent)
Chaired by Frank Jotzo

AT: Survey about politicians' attitudes/awareness of climate change (PDF). Conducted during Rudd era, late 2009. 26 interviewees, systematic stratified sampling. 20-min semi-structured phone interviews.
Underlying attitudes rather than policy stances. Expertise: little/no 29%, Some 63% (self-rated 53%), Good 9% (self-rated 47%!!). 96% agree cc is occurring. 88% thought at least partly caused by humans. 90% unlikely to go away by itself. 43% of LNP were deniers.
On most issues, LNP/ALP not statistically separable – except for attitude on leading globally, where Greens/ALP strongly for and LNP strongly against. LNP members also had much lower concern about climate change; could be predicted by political party, belief in science, and importance of issue for them politically (not other variables!)
Attitudes broadly in line with population, but also partisan.

AL: Tony Abbott believes in tipping points – at least for Malcolm Turnbull. Political speech more so than speech about politics.

JH: "Please excuse my confused remarks, I'm still struggling to explain the carbon footprint of a birthday cake." Used to believe that good politics was just good policy with a bit of a lag. "TAbbott has had more positions on the climate change than the Karma Sutra."
Worst case is where polls keep going down for Govt. Oakeshott, a man of great principle, may switch sides, force an election, and get TAbbott in.
Gillard is bleeding to the left. Announcing the tax without details is a free kick to Abbott; lets him use fear and ignore any real debate. Back in the mid-70s, as a young politician, Hewson could not wait for interest and exchange rates to be set by the market. Eventually it came. So too will it be with  climate change.

LT: Debate went off the rails last year when the Coalition turfed Turnbull and stopped supporting the market mechanism, and – by extension – any serious treatment of the issue at all. The LNP policy is there to be seen to be doing something. ALP, OTOH, did the political equivalent of running away with their hands over their ears by not going to a DD election after the CPRS was defeated, and not prosecuting the case at all at the 2010 election.
If you believe the anti-action brigade, apparently Greg Combet signed a secret deal at Cancun to give 10% of our carbon price revenues to some secretive UN cabal.
The debate over this issue has devolved to a political fight to the death. But sensible parties should not abandon the field and let them fight it out, because otherwise the pressure on the independents will be to great and everything will go off the rails again.

Q: How do we drive a new industrial revolution in Australia?
AL: Markets.

Why are deniers given so much space in the media? Is it the role of individual journalists or the organisations? Ditto for the gap between the science and the reporting.
LT: Bizarre form of balance. Not the way she defines it. Scientific debate outside the realms of real-politick.
AT: 80% of pollies rely on the media for info on climate change.
AL: Decision to release principles then follow with detail is deliberate. We don't want to get caught up in hypothetical traps. Would prefer to talk about principles.

Is there a chance TAbbott will get enough rope to hang himself? If you're in the ALP and are worried about CC, why would you not support nuclear?
LT: TAbbott isn't getting more popular, but he's under much less pressure since the MPCCC announced its proposal. Nuclear often gets raised as though it were free – but it's still bloody expensive (to build).
JH: Abbott may never be popular, but he can win. Carbon tax and the way it has been handled have been a lifeline for him. He'll be the best leader of the Opposition in our history. Wouldn't govern well, but will lead the opposition to a government admirably...



Thursday, March 24, 2011

Brief an Deutschland: Grüße aus der Ferne II

Liebe Freunde, Verwandte, Kollegen, Kameraden, Kopfgeldjäger, usw.,

es ist mittlerweile knapp ein Jahr seitdem ich mit 15kg Übergewicht – also im Gepäck, ich selbst bin noch ein Strich in der Landschaft – Deutschland verließ. (Bericht vom Flug.) Der 60. Geburtstag meiner Mutter, was die Reise veranlasste bzw. den Zeitpunkt bestimmte, war sehr spaßig und erfolgreich. (Ja, genau, erfolgreich.) Im Monat danach ließ ich es mir gut gehen bei meinen Eltern, genoss den Australischen Herbst, und besuchte alte Freunde. Nach vier Jahren hatte sich zwar einiges geändert, aber vieles war auch genauso wie immer; wie eine Fernsehreihe, die man nach Jahren wieder zu schauen anfängt, hat sich die Geschichte weiterentwickelt, aber die Kulisse, Schauspieler und Beziehungen sind weitgehend gleich geblieben.

Im Mai fing ich dann langsam an nach Arbeit zu schauen. Es war mir wichtiger eine interessante Stelle zu finden als eine sofortige, und so stellte ich mich auf eine mehrmonatige Suchzeit ein. Da ich aber sowohl in Australien wie auch Deutschland und West-Europa suchte war mein Leben in Australien leicht beschränkt; ich konnte nicht viel weiter ein einen Monat im Voraus planen, da jeder Zeit ein Angebot kommen könnte und ich Melbourne verlassen müsste. Demnach war ich irgendwie mehr als nur zu Besuch da, aber auch nicht so wirklich „zurückgekehrt“. Vor allem bei vielen Freundschaften merkte ich das: nach vier Jahren Abwesenheit war ich nicht mehr automatisch Teil des Kreises den man freitags anruft um das Wochenende zu planen. Das war nicht unerwartet, und ich nahm meinen Freunden es auch nicht übel, aber ganz so wie früher war es dann doch nicht.

Beim Swing-Tanzen und Fußball war es einfacher. Meine Tanzfreunde von damals sind mittlerweile fast alle Tanzlehrer oder zählen zum „harten Kern“ der Szene (sofern sie noch aktiv sind), und es war irgendwie ganz lustig wie viele „jüngere“ Tänzer es verwirrte, dass ich eines Tages auftauchte und von diesem Kern so behandelt wurde, als sei ich immer dabei gewesen.

Beim Fußball hatte zwar meine komplette Mannschaft von damals hingeschmissen, aber die Klubfunktionäre kannte ich noch (und umgekehrt). Seit 2006 war der Verein zweimal abgestiegen, aber da ich ja nicht wusste wie es bei mir weitergeht hatte ich keine Lust, mir einen neuen (besseren) Verein zu finden und mich da durchzukämpfen. Durch den Fußball in Deutschland war ich selbst deutlich besser geworden, sodass es auch einfach war, mich in der neuen alten Mannschaft zu behaupten; ich wurde sogar – zum ersten und wahrscheinlich letzten Mal – der Mittelfeldmotor (und Kapitän) der Mannschaft. „Rennen, Zweikampf, Ball an jemand besseren weitergeben“ war schon beim TSV Handschuhsheim meine Devise; hier konnte ich vor dem letzten Schritt sogar noch den einen oder anderen Gegner ausspielen, was ganz lustig war. Gegen Ende der Saison knickten wir leider ein und wurden 6. statt 3., aber es war trotzdem eine gute Zeit – ich wurde zum „Spieler der Mannschaft“ gewählt, und um zwei Punkte hätten mich die Schiedsrichter auch zum Liga-besten Spieler ernannt. (Zur Erinnerung: in Heidelberg spielte ich in der untersten Liga und war meistens Ersatzspieler, wenn ich es überhaupt in den Kader schaffte. Entsprechend lustig fand ich diese Ehrung.)

Zurück zur Arbeitssuche: ich entdeckte relativ schnell, dass ich mit meinem deutschen Diplom in Australien etwas benachteiligt war. Nicht unbedingt, weil es nicht anerkannt wurde (ich schrieb einfach „Master-equivalent“ dahinter, und gut war’s), sondern weil wenige Australier einen Master machen und Firmen demnach stark auf Bachelorabsolventen ausgerichtet sind; für sie gibt es Graduiertenprogramme, die der übliche Einstieg in den Bereich bildet. Nichts gegen Bachelorstudenten, aber ich hab ja ein Bachelor und dann noch ein Diplom oben drauf; mich dann mit den ganzen Bubis um einen 30 000€/Jahr Job zu Streiten wollte ich nicht. Dazu kam, dass – was ich nicht wusste – man sich für die Graduiertenprogramme ein Jahr im Voraus bewerben sollte (währen man im letzten Jahr vom Studium ist). Um Anfang 2010 eine Stelle zu haben hätte ich mich also Anfang 2009 bewerben sollen; damals hatte ich noch nicht mal ein Thema für meine Diplomarbeit, oder eine Ahnung wann ich in Australien sein würde. Eine erfolgreiche Bewerbung in 2010 für ein Graduiertenprogramm hätte mir also erst Anfang 2011 eine Stelle gesichert… „sub-optimal“, beschreibe ich das mal.

Ich bewarb mich also hauptsächlich für „normale“ Stellen (in Australien; in Deutschland sowieso). Da war das Problem weiterhin, dass viele Firmen wenig Erfahrung mit Masterabsolventen hatten; meine Konkurrenten hatten meistens einen einfachen Bachelor aber drei Jahre Berufserfahrung (statt einen zweiten Abschluss), und wenn man nicht gerade nach einen Masterabsolventen sucht nimmt man im Zweifel doch lieber den Kandidat mit Berufserfahrung.

Wenn sich das ganze jetzt dramatisch oder traurig anhört: war es nicht. Leicht frustrierend, manchmal, aber am Ende habe ich dann doch genau so eine Stelle gefunden wie ich wollte: im August/September erhielt ich ein Angebot als Forschungsassistent beim „Centre for Energy and Environmental Market“ (CEEM), ein Forschungsinstitut an der University of New South Wales in Sydney, zu arbeiten. Die nahm ich dann auch an.

Wie der Name schon sagt konzentriert sich CEEM auf Umwelt- und Energiemärkte. Das kann alles sein von der optimalen Bestrafung für Emissionshandel über die Vorhersage von Elektrizitätsnachfrage zur Entwicklung von „robuster“ Klimapolitik. Gerade letzteres war an dieser Stelle attraktiv, da mich der politische Aspekt – also die Umsetzung der Theorie – doch stark interessiert. (Ab und zu denke ich an das Bismarcksche Zitat, „Gesetze sind wie Würste, man sollte besser nicht dabei sein, wenn sie gemacht werden.“ Für den Moment halte ich es noch aus.)

Die Arbeit ist also interessant (ein bisschen mehr dazu hier), aber das Arbeitsklima ist doch etwas anderes als das, was ich gewohnt war. Wenn man vom Hauptsitz einer internationalen Firma mit 50 000 Mitarbeitern zu einer Universität wechselt fällt einem als erstes auf, wie langsam alles passiert. So
unglaublich
langsam.

Gut, ist halt ‚ne Uni. Ganz schön groß, so ‚ne Uni, und im Verwaltungsapparat ist man eben nur ein anonymes Teilchen. Aber da CEEM nur um die 20 Mitarbeiter hat sollte man sich nach kurzer Zeit gut kennen, oder? Nein. CEEM ist nämlich ein interdisziplinäres Forschungszentrum, und der Großteil der „Mitarbeiter“ sind Ökonomen, Ingenieure (die zwei größten Gruppen), Soziologen, Geographen, Juristen, usw. die zwar Mitglied des CEEMs sind, aber ihre Büros bei ihren entsprechenden Fakultäten haben. Täglichen Kontakt hab ich nur mit unserer Sekretärin, eine oder zwei Doktorandinnen die bei CEEM schreiben, die vier Mitarbeit des „Asia-Pacific Ubiquitous Health-Care Research Centre“ mit dem wir das Büro teilen, und mein Chef.

Ach, mein Chef. Eigentlich ist er ein total netter Kerl. Kumpelhaft, gut gelaunt, entspannt… fast zu entspannt für meinen Geschmack. ...
Naja. Er ist, wie gesagt, kein schlechter Chef; er ist nicht dumm, und wenn er im Büro ist kann ich ihn auch subtil in den Arsch treten, damit er die Dinge macht die meine Arbeit ermöglichen. Nur kann ich das noch nicht, wenn er nicht im Büro ist. Dann hock ich manchmal dumm ‚rum und schreib Zeitungsartikel (mehr dazu später). Ich merke auch, dass ich von der Kommunikationsfähigkeit meines Chefs bei der SAP verwöhnt war – und dabei meine ich spezifisch die Fähigkeit, analytisch über Kommunikation zu reden und zu sagen, „ Dieser Satz wäre hier besser; diesen Absatz kannst Du streichen; Beispiele klingen im Dreierpack immer besser; usw.“. Vielleicht schreibe ich meinem ex-Chef einen netten Brief um mich dafür zu bedanken – aber nur wenn er verspricht, ihn zu korrigieren und mir zurückzuschicken! Was sagst Du, Torsten? ;-)

Das Leben in Sydney gefällt mir. Ich wohn im inneren Osten, wo auch eine schäbige Einzimmerwohnung $330 (ca. 220€) die Woche kostet, kalt. (Und ich mein richtig schäbig; so schäbig, dass ich ein Schlichtungsverfahren gegen meinen Vermieter einleite, damit er endlich das seit vier Monaten kaputte Garagentorschloss repariert.) Dafür ist die Gegend fantastisch: ich bin umzingelt bin Cafés, Restaurants, Kneipen – sogar einen Deutschen Bäcker gibt’s in meiner Straße. Mit dem Fahrrad bin in 12 Minuten an der Arbeit, 8 in der Innenstadt, 20 bei meinem Bruder, und 25 am Strand. Und die Strände! Ach, einfach herrlich. Fast jede zweite Woche pack ich mein Boogieboard und geh Wellenreiten. Heiß genug dafür ist es, auf jeden Fall. Oft auch recht schwül, was mir gar nicht gefällt (gerade als Fahrradfahrer), aber anscheinend liegt das an La Nina und ist eher untypisch.

Laut Klischee sind Melbourne und Sydney sehr unterschiedlich, auch von den Leuten, aber so richtig ist mir das noch nicht aufgefallen; sehr viel, was mir anders vorkommt, könnte auch nur daran liegen, dass ich nun in der Innenstadt wohne statt in einem Vorort. Wie gesagt, es ist hier schwüler und gibt bessere Strände. Dafür weiß Sydney überhaupt nichts mit Regen anzufangen: sobald es nass wird sind die Straßen lehr. Finde ich sehr merkwürdig. Die öffentlichen Verkehrsmittel sind pünktlicher und besser vernetzt (wenn auch nicht auf Deutschem Niveau), dafür aber kompliziert: es gibt die Eisenbahn, die Stadtbahn, die Schwebebahn, die Fähren und Busse. Fahrkarten für ein Transportmittel sind meistens nicht für die anderen benutzbar (auch zwischen Busse manchmal nicht). Die Straßen sind der Horror, und als Fahrradfahrer muss man sich echt was zutrauen, wenn es keine Fahrradspur gibt.

Ach, das erinnert mich: mein prägendes „die spinnen doch, die Sydneysider“ Erlebnis kam im Dezember, als ich Samstagabend/Sonntagmorgen mit einem Kumpel nach Hause radelte. Wir waren noch in der Innenstadt als ein weißer Mitsubishi Lancer vorbeiraste und uns ein Passagier anbrüllte, entweder weil er besoffen war oder ich kein Helm trug oder beides. Jedenfalls winken wir ihm freundlich nach. An einer roten Ampel etwa 200m hielt das Auto, und der Passagier stieg aus und lief wütend, brüllend und gestikulierend in unsere Fahrbahn. Mit ca. 20-25 Sachen unterwegs hatte ich keine Lust, auf einer von Taxis gut befahrenen Strecke von Spur zu Spur zu wanken oder für einen besoffenen Trottel zu stoppen, und fuhr einfach weiter. Er wich nicht aus, und – patsch! – fuhr ich ihn an. Wir blieben beide noch auf den Füßen, also brüllte er mich noch ein bisschen weiter an während er sein Handy suchte, das auf den Boden gefallen war. Mein Kumpel, mittlerweile, war ein paar Meter hinter uns stehen geblieben und lachte sich erstmals scheckig. Während ich mein Fahrrad nach Schäden inspizierte versuch der Typ mir eine Faust auf den Kopf zu geben, rüffelt aber nur meine Haare, und läuft damit schnell zum wartenden Auto zurück. Ich schau ihn immer noch verdutzt nach als ein Taxi anhält und mich fragt, ob ich denn das Nummernschild hätte und ob alles in Ordnung sei. Eher verwirrt als verletzt winke ich ab; erst später fällt mir eine Beule auf meinem Arm auf, wo mein Bizeps offensichtlich mit dem Gesicht dieses Idioten Bekanntschaft machte.

Ich nehme an, dass so etwas nicht öfters passiert, sonst werde ich wohl öfters einen Helm tragen um mich gegen Faustschläge zu schützen. Vielleicht wollte man mich nur dazu erziehen, wer weiß es? Körperlicher Gefahr fern der Straße bin ich nur auf dem Fußballplatz ausgesetzt, aber als abgehärteter Spieler der unteren Ligen kann ich ja damit umgehen. Sagte ich unteren Ligen? Nein! Hier in Sydney spiele ich in der 1. Liga des Eastern Suburbs Football Association – nach State League und Premier League (plus zweite Mannschaften) ist das die höchste; die ESFA geht bin zu 10. Liga runter. Hier bin ich wieder einer der schlechteren (vom technischen Niveau, nicht vom taktischen oder körperlichen), was mir auch besser gefällt. Ohne Herausforderungen macht das Leben nur halb so viel Spaß.

Um wieder auf Sydney zurückzukommen: mit meinen Verbindungen vom Swingtanzen habe ich mich gut eingelebt hier, und wo die zu kurz kommen da hilft mein Bruder, der vor einem Jahr hier herzog um für eine Bank zu arbeiten. Mit ihm Zeit verbringen zu können schätze ich sehr: seitdem wir beide erwachsen sind haben wir nur wenig Zeit in derselben Stadt verbracht. Ich hab ein paar Lieblingsrestaurants in Chinatown, ein Lieblingsstrand, und sogar eine Lieblingskneipe (letztere hauptsächlich deswegen, weil sie 50m von mir entfernt ist und Sport zeigt). Es geht mir also gut.

Gerne würde ich weitererzählen, aber nach 2 000 Wörtern und mehrere Stunden des Schreibens habe ich das Kontingent an Grammatikfehler, das ich euch in einer Sitzung zumute, wahrscheinlich erschöpft. (Um von holprigen Ausdrucksformen ganz zu schweigen.) Egal. Sei auf jeden Fall versichert, dass ich euch vermisse und gerne besuchen kommen werde, falls ich die Gelegenheit habe. Geschichten aus eurem Leben lese ich natürlich auch gerne, besonders meine ehemaligen Kommilitonen und -innen: Habt ihr Jobs? Seid ihr noch in Heidelberg? Hat man mein geklautes Fahrrad schon gefunden?

Eins muss ich doch noch kurz hinzufügen, weil ich es ein paar von euch versprochen habe: vor ein paar Wochen hat mich ein Kollege mit der Redakteurin einer Online-Zeitung in Verbindung gesetzt, und seitdem schreibe ich ab und an für sie Artikel. Bisher sind zwei veröffentlicht worden: eins zur Australischen Debatte über ein Klimagesetz, und eins über die Unterschiede zwischen einer CO2-Steuer und Emissionshandel. Diese sowie weitere Artikel findet ihr auf meinem Blog. Oder Facebook. Oder Twitter. Ich bin einfach überall. Besonders da, wo ich nicht nützlich bin – das hab ich mir von der Bayern-Abwehr abgeguckt.

Es grüßt euch,
euer Martin
Surry Hills
NSW 2010
Da Unten
 Dies ist eine gekürzte Version des Originals. Schreibfehler bleiben aber unkorrigiert, um das authentische Martin-Erlebnis zu gewährleisten.

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Cross-post: Carbon Pricing 101

New Matilda were very pleased with my first article and the response thereto, and asked me to write a second, a sort of "carbon tax explainer". I think that these sort of explainer pieces are a dime a dozen, but perhaps I'm biased because I've studied and work in this area. In any case, the editor said some very flattering things, so I wrote this for her:

Carbon Tax 101


Confused about the difference between a carbon tax and an emissions trading scheme? Martin Jones explains how the two mechanisms work - and how they differ.
The issue has been on the public agenda for several years but it still seems that the differences between a carbon tax and an emissions trading scheme (ETS) are not fully understood. With too many commentators focussing on the details and neglecting the basics, this is perhaps understandable. So follow me, gentle reader, through some introductory environmental economics as I explain how carbon taxes and ETSs work — and how they differ. (Shane Wright has recently written an excellent overview of other aspects of the issue.)

The primary goals of taxes are usually one or more of the following: to raise revenue; to encourage or discourage certain forms of behaviour; to redistribute income or wealth; or to simplify the tax system. The goal of a carbon tax (or ETS) is primarily to discourage behaviour that generates emissions of carbon dioxide (and other greenhouse gasses (GHGs)) into the atmosphere.

The emission of GHGs is, in economic parlance, an "externality": it’s a cost or benefit resulting from an action that directly affects someone external to (that is, not involved in) the action. When my neighbour, a bakery, bakes a pie, I enjoy its fresh smell from my balcony; when my other neighbour, a restaurant, fries something, I suffer through the fumes. In neither case do my neighbours take my welfare into account when baking or frying things; my costs or benefits are external to their decisions. 

Put another way, when there are external costs (or benefits), the private costs or benefits of those involved in an action are different to the costs or benefits for society as a whole. When private costs equal social costs, what is best for the individual is also best for society. With externalities, that’s not the case. 

GHGs affect society through their contribution to climate change. The costs to society are different — most probably greater — than the costs to the individual causing the emissions: there is therefore an externality. The individual makes decisions that are best for him or her (burning lots of petrol, using lots of coal-fired electricity), but not best for society. 

We can correct this problem by making the private costs equal the social costs again. There are several methods of doing so, one of which is to increase the private costs by taxing the offending behaviour. This is the thinking behind a carbon tax. 

However, it can be difficult to know precisely what the difference between private and social costs is — set the tax too low, and behaviour doesn’t change enough; too high, and it changes too much. Where the desired level of behaviour is better known than the cost difference, it can be easier to create permits — representing the right to engage in the behaviour — and, just like a sharemarket, let people trade permits between each other to determine the price. This is the thinking behind an emissions (permit) trading scheme. 

The fundamental difference between a carbon tax and an ETS is therefore whether you restrict behaviour using prices or quantities, respectively. The same outcome can be achieved using either mechanism, but, depending on the circumstances, one instrument can have advantages over the other. 

In 1974, the well-respected environmental economist Martin Weitzman compared price and quantity instruments (taxes and permit trading) when the costs and benefits are uncertain, and came to the conclusion that price controls for pollution are better when the costs of pollution reduction increase relatively faster than the benefits (and vice versa). 

Whether the costs or benefits of reducing GHG emissions rise faster is, literally, an academic debate, but if the climate has "tipping points" (such massively increasing costs when a certain level of GHGs is reached), then — economically as well intuitively — it would be better to restrict emissions to a level so that this tipping point is not reached, and let the market determine what the appropriate price for that quantity of permits is. (Weitzman wrote a further excellent, if technical piece on the economic uncertainties of climate change in 2007.) 

There are other relative strengths and weaknesses (pdf) of taxes and trading schemes. Taxes can be simpler as well as easier to implement and administer than trading schemes; all companies have established structures for dealing with tax requirements, but few are used to trading permits. Tax levels are generally stable and predictable, while permit prices can be volatile (though well-designed trading schemes avoid this: after initial turbulences, prices in the EU ETS (pdf) have been stable over the past two years). Domestic emissions trading schemes can be linked with foreign schemes to provide international price and quantity harmonisation, which is not possible with a tax. An ETS would also be counter-cyclical, with prices falling in a downturn (as production and demand for permits falls), and rising in an upturn (as production and demand for permits rises); taxes remain constant throughout. 

It’s important to note that choosing either an ETS or tax does not affect decisions about coverage or compensation. Industries can be excluded from either; they can receive free permits, lower tax rates, or tax-free thresholds (like the thresholds in income tax). In both cases the costs will initially fall on businesses, who will choose to absorb them or to pass them on to consumers. Again these choices are independent of the scheme selected. And revenues can be used to compensate those consumers under either scheme — provided permits are sold and not all given away. 

These are all details the Multi-Party Climate Change Committee (MPCCC) has yet to finalise for its carbon pricing framework. Increasing the cost of GHG emissions then compensating consumers for those costs can still change behaviour, since the prices of polluting goods and services will rise relative to the cleaner alternatives and influence consumers’ decisions about which to purchase in favour of the relatively cheaper, cleaner options. 

Both schemes have problems. In each case, they can be solved. It is extremely unlikely that, whichever instrument is chosen, the initial design will be perfect; in the first phase of the EU ETS, the permit price dropped to almost zero, and the Rudd-era Carbon Polluting Reduction Scheme (CPRS) contained far too much compensation for industries. There is quite a bit of learning by doing. 

In that sense, the MPCCC’s hybrid scheme isn’t such a bad idea; after a few years under a simple scheme, during which companies and the Government figure out how this whole carbon pricing thing works with a fixed price (and realise it isn’t the end of the world), we can move to a more complicated, but hopefully more effective ETS.



The article on New Matilda is worth checking out just for the wonderful picture of a contemplative Wayne Swan (our current Treasurer) they've chosen to accompany the piece.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

What am I doing at the moment?

What does an environmental economist do? This will get a little long...

Let me start with what "an economist" does, because it's often (wrongly) understood that we're all about money. Rather, economics is about "utility", which is a concept somewhere between "usefulness" and "happiness", and the metric economists use to measure the value people place on a particular object or activity. We then use this to study the choices people make, in particular (but not exclusively) during the production and consumption of goods and services.
Because utility is fairy difficult to measure – if I ask you and a friend how much something is worth to each of you on a scale of one to ten, your six may not be worth her six, or twice as much as her three, or even twice as much as your three! – economists often use money as an alternative denominator. Why? Because most things are already priced in money, so we don't have to ask people about possibly hypothetical values: we just look at what they do.

Now, the environment is a little different to most of mainstream economics, because people aren't used to paying for the environment (with limited exceptions, e.g. land rights) – until quite recently it's just been there, and you could use it (or not) for free; take stuff out of it, pump stuff into it, change it, neglect it, whatever. But, fairly obviously, the environment HAS value: it absorbs pollution, gives us resources (fresh air, minerals, crops, new medicines), is somewhere we can relax, or can just be something we enjoy knowing exists (most people have never been to Niagara Falls or Ulura, but I'm sure they're "worth" something to us).
So, in the broadest sense, environmental economics is about fitting the environment into the framework used for the rest of economics: putting utility values on it or, if you like, prices. That can be anything from valuing a forest through which a developer wants to build a road to developing a system/price to charge for allowing people (firms) to dispose of their pollution into the environment (e.g. emissions trading scheme).

What is it that I do, precisely? My institution is the Centre for Energy and Environment Markets (CEEM) at the University of New South Wales (UNSW), and at the moment one of the grants we have is from the Australia Research Council on "Robust Policy Mix" for climate change  I don't want to slug you with another long explanation, but basically "robustness" is all about a policy fulfilling its goals under all possible circumstances; under a change of Government, or an economic crises, or whatever. It's got a lot to do with risk and uncertainty; being prepared for changes you can predict and changes you can't predict. The "policy mix" bit refers to the way different policies interact and positively or negatively affect each other.

Another project that I'll soon be starting with a colleague is for the Consumer Advocacy Panel, where we'll run experiments on how (possibly) solve the problem of split incentives for energy efficiency features in rental accommodation: landlords/owners have no incentive to make the properties more energy efficient, since they don't pay the utility bills, but renters who aren't assured of staying in the property long enough to recoup the costs of their investment through lower bills also lack the incentive to improve the efficiency.

When I'm not researching stuff (i.e. looking for and reading articles; I do a LOT of reading), I also do less interesting stuff like proofread papers for colleagues, clean up datasets (spreadsheets), or help organise conferences/seminars/office events. The proofreading isn't always bad; if the paper is good then I'll learn something new, and it's fun to turn on my economic brain and analyse someone else's arguments.

I'm quite enjoying it, which is good, because the job was the reason I moved to Sydney in the first place :-)  I'm in discussions to extend my contract for another year; my bosses are keen to get me into the Ph.D. programme, and have even tempted me with the possibility of spending some of said programme at a foreign institution, but I'm still uncertain – and I know enough to know that you shouldn't do a Ph.D. unless you're certain you want to do it. That's not a vote against doing one, just that I haven't yet decided.

Having also written a few letters to the editor or just expounded on economic topics of interest here on this blog (I won't link; there are plenty of examples), I've also started getting into properly writing stuff for the media. It's early days yet and, to be honest, nowadays you can hardly turn around without bumping into some sort of blogger, but so far it's good fun.
Outside of work and faffing around writing stuff, I've been taking advantage of Sydney's beaches as much as possible. I'm within cycling distance of a whole bunch of different eastern suburbs beaches, and it's a rare fortnight that I don't go down with my boogieboard for a bit of sandy action. Often my brother, Klaus, will come along, too. It's terrific having him up here: most of our adult lives we've lived in different cities or countries, so it's good fun being able to just spontaneously hang out on weekends, wrestle in the backyard (I did some basic Krav Maga training in December, and Klaus does stuff through the Army Reserves), or just kick a ball around.

I've also joined the UNSW football team, playing in the Eastern Suburbs Football Association Division 1. That's the top division after the State League and Premier League (and their reserves), so pretty high up; the ESFA goes down to Div 10. The season hasn't started yet, but  after a summer spent playing pick-up matches in the park I'm really enjoying a team that plays with some structure and tactics. It's a good group of lads and the standard is fairly high; I'll probably be playing as left fullback, and though it's not a new position for me I'm enjoying still being able to learn new things from my teammates, most of whom are older and more experienced that me. (That may surprise, but funnily enough the minority of the team are students.)

So – that's what I'm doing at the moment!

Tuesday, March 08, 2011

Cross-post: Give us something to talk about

In the course of researching the paper I'm currently co-writing at work, I felt that some of the themes – the role of risk and uncertainty in climate change, as well as robust policy responses to them – had not received enough attention in the Australia policy debate and wrote an opinion piece to that effect. It hasn't yet been published – our media office is pitching it to newspapers, who are mulling it over –, but as a result a colleague of mine (@agentdeclan) put me in touch with the editors of New Matilda, who were looking for someone to write a piece on the current (lack of) debate around the newly-released carbon pricing framework and the role of economists in that debate.

Being a little quicker than newspapers they published it today, and I reproduce it, below.

There's plenty of talk about the proposed carbon tax but it's short on substance - and at any rate, details are thin on the ground. Martin Jones on the role of economists in this debate
[The title and teaser are the work of the editors]

If you were hoping for some policy debate in federal politics last week, you were wasting your time. Since the Multi-Party Committee on Climate Change (MPCCC) announced its Carbon Price Framework (CPF) (PDF), the debate in Parliament has gone around in circles, finding its nadir in the literal rotations performed by Senator Mary Jo Fischer.

Where once upon a time Oppositions deconstructed Government proposals in detail, building up sustained and intense critical pressure that occasionally culminated in a motion to censure the Prime Minister (the passing of which would traditionally cause a Government to resign), the current mob have virtually ignored the CPF to focus on whether Julia Gillard broke her pre-election promise to put a price on carbon in some form other than a tax. Indeed, they rolled out the censure motions with such regularity last week that the ABC started running a sweepstakes competition to guess when the suspension of standing orders would be called for.

One problem for the Opposition is that there isn’t very much in the CPF to criticise. The document is five pages long, and lays out a rough timeframe of when the fixed-price period, flexible-price period, and discussions about the latter could occur; what sectors could be covered; and that we couldn’t use international permits during the fixed-price period. That’s pretty much it -- aside from some pleasant language about “economic transformation”, “business certainty”, and “fairness”. As Ben Eltham pointed out last week, this is a much cannier strategy than what the ALP did with the CPRS (or even with the RSPT, which, even though it had the nominal benefit of being a well-constructed piece of policy, still crashed).

With little to criticise and not much to offer as an alternative, the Opposition resorted to hypothetical scenarios about possible food, petrol, and electricity price rises. They were forced to make assumptions about details that haven’t yet been decided, such as what the price of carbon permits will be, the extent to which the sectors will be covered, and what sort of compensation will be offered. Without these crucial details, however, you could assume pretty much anything about the carbon tax – which the Opposition (and Government in response) duly did, as did much of the media and a plethora of special interest groups (with BlueScope Steel delivering a particularly flagrant example). 

The thing is, we’ve been here before: we had the same special interest commentary and pseudo-analysis during the debate about the CPRS, but also plenty of more formal modelling and analysis. Some of these modelling and analysis has been updated since then – Ross Garnaut, for example, is currently half-way through releasing the updates to his Review – and newer studies have been added to the body of knowledge we have. The MPCCC carbon price framework has not changed the validity of any of these studies and so, if you paid attention the first time around, there is very little in the current iteration of the debate worth paying attention to from a policy perspective – as opposed to a political perspective.

More interesting are the frameworks established by these studies, and how the CPF fits into them. These frameworks are the contributions of experts in science, economics, sociology, law, philosophy; each discipline has its own structure, theories, body of knowledge, and a field over which it claims expertise. Sometimes these fields overlap, but more often they are complementary. When communicated well, they enrich public knowledge and enable us to better assess the arguments being put to us.

The strength of my field, economics, in the climate change debate is in evaluating the suitability of different policy instruments to achieve a stated set of (economic) objectives – for example, under which scenarios taxes are better than quantity controls; how firms and consumers will be affected by particular cost increases; weighing up the economic costs and benefits – through the use of models of human behaviour on a large scale, including the examination of secondary, possibly unintended, effects. Stating that economics is best for economic objectives may seem a little tautological, but, well, everyone is guilty of thinking their field can do it all at one point or another.

That we don’t have a consistent stated set of objectives or a climate policy philosophy from any party bar the Greens makes the task of the economist more difficult, of course. But, at the moment, anthropogenic climate change is widely accepted by all sides as a problem and the debate concerns the mechanism of the solution, with the CPF bearing more than a passing resemblance to proposals put forward by the Garnaut Review in 2008.

Any final carbon pricing framework could do much worse than base itself on the Review; it addresses prices, compensation, institutional arrangements, transitions, emissions-intensive trade-exposed industries, enforcement mechanisms, innovation policy, sectoral peculiarities, broad uncertainties, and eventual global agreements, all in the Australian context. A sensible economic analysis of any future climate policy could compare it to the Review’s recommendations (or those of the updated version of the Review, due to be released in May), spot the differences, and question whether they are decisions made within the economic framework or a political framework. Chances are, many of the compensation arrangements we’ll see will not be grounded in economic reasoning – if they are sold as such.

I have colleagues who believe that politicians’ decision-making processes are governed almost exclusively by the desire to win the next election – and sometimes it is difficult to believe otherwise. With the ALP struggling to clearly outline its core ideals and the Opposition functioning as a party of, well, opposition, their medium- and long-term goals for this country are opaque. But if we step away from the content-free zone of Question Time and offer our politicians frameworks and ideas – be they a more powerful social-justice imperative or the need for a mix of instruments in climate policy (PDF) –, perhaps they’ll take some of them up. Then we’d at least have something worth talking about.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Money, meet mouth

So, I work as an environmental economist, right? I vote for The Greens, cycle everywhere, buy organic food, turn all my appliances off when I'm not using them, reuse my shower water, and generally try to follow the reduce/reuse/recycle motto. But, since 2006, I've flown from Australia to Germany (and back), between Germany and London several times, and between Melbourne and Sydney even more often. Oh, and driven Melbourne-Sydney and back. Against all those emissions (particularly the Australia-Germany flights), the marginal changes I've made to my life are paltry.

Last week, I was hunting around for figures on how many carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2-e) emissions Earth could remove from the atmosphere each year, in order to calculate roughly what each person would be able to emit without increasing the concentration of CO2-e in the atmosphere. The answers were a little confusing, as the climate system is ridiculously complicated and there are many higher-order effects1, but roughly speaking the Earth absorbs 12 Gt (gigatonnes; thousand million tonnes) of CO2-e per year, giving us roughly 2 tonnes of CO2-e allowance per person per year.

The current world average closer to 4 t/year, and developed countries are usually much, much higher; Australia's are around 28 tCO2-e/person/year. 

That's not direct emissions, of course: most my share of Australia's average emissions I have little to no control over. My flights, however, are entirely of my own doing. So I followed up an idea I've been toying around with for a few years, which is to purchase carbon offsets. How that works is that other people offer to reduce CO2-e emissions via different projects (renewable energy rather than fossil fuels; reduced fuel usage via efficiency measures; planting trees), these savings are verified/certified to a particular standard, and other people can then "purchase" these savings in a market: basically, I'm paying someone to have (had) lower CO2-e emissions on my behalf, offsetting my own. (I've started with past flights and those currently booked, long car trips, and will offset future travel as it occurs; my day-to-day emissions I'm counting against my "allowance" – I'm almost certainly exceeding it, but right now I have no way of accurately calculating by how much.)

Depending on the type of project, its location, and the standard to which it's certified, the offsets cost more or less money: the cost of one tonne of CO2-e in the EU emissions trading market (1 EUA) has hovered around 15€ for the last two years, while permits generated to slightly less stringent conditions (CERs; often from developing countries where standards aren't quite as high) have hovered around 12€.

Starting with the excellent Victorian Government/RMIT website http://www.carbonoffsetguide.com.au/, I went through a list of companies that offer to sell you carbon offsets, comparing the certification standards they met and the types of projects they offered. Eventually I settled on First Climate (http://www.firstclimate.com), a German company with an Australian offices; I chose First Climate  primarily because they offered Gold Standard Verified Emission Reductions (VERs), which was the level of quality I wanted to buy. Their record of operating internationally, and particularly in Germany, was another reason.

I sent them off an e-mail, and within minutes a charming fellow called me to talk about how much I wanted to offset, and how. Having already used one of the online emissions calculators (see the offset guide website, earlier) and thought about the options, I was able to give him a tonnage and project preference, where-upon he sent me a list of possible projects with different standards and the corresponding prices per tonne.

The end result is that, just now, I have bought and retired 20 tonnes of CO2-e emissions credits (Gold Standard VERs) from the Yuntdag Wind Power Project in Turkey (PDF) (Project Number 22-07-283) at AU$30 per tonne. That's not cheap – but, for me, it's worth it.

[UPDATE I]
One problem I had with First Climate is that they ask you to deposit your money into a non-Australian bank account, which necessitates an international transfer; at my bank, that involved a $22 fee and a minimum transfer of AU$500. I've asked whether there are alternatives, since I would rather purchase fewer carbon offsets at a time in future, but haven't yet received a reply.

[UPDATE II]
First Climate's response:

Unfortunately the reality is that our key focus in the Australian market is at the corporate/wholesale level and as such we are unable to provide alternatives for transactions via our Frankfurt trading desk, which can only be achieved via international bank transfers.  As you highlighted this obviously presents a problem for retail buyers seeking to make purchases of less than $500 which fail to trigger the threshold for most banks.

I believe that it would be best if in these circumstances we refer you directly to our retail channel partner The Carbon Reduction Institute (http://www.noco2.com.au), who is more than capable and willing to assist in this regard.  CRI are recognised as one of the best carbon offset retailer in the Australian market.

I have not had any dealings with the Carbon Reduction Institute, but will try them out the next time I want to purchase carbon offsets and keep you posted.

1 When one thing directly affects another (I push the cup: it moves; the price of something rises; the sun rises: it gets warmer), that's called a first-order effect. When the causal chain has intermediate steps or multiple sources, there are more – higher – "orders" of effect (e.g. the sun-warmed air rises and begins to circulate; the rotation of the earth changes the pattern of circulation; the circulating air absorbs moisture and forms clouds, changing the pattern of heating and therefore further changing the pattern of circulation).