Showing posts with label Say Yes rally. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Say Yes rally. Show all posts

Friday, July 08, 2011

Carbon Pricing Placard: Missing the Point

Another lengthy analysis of my placard that misses the point, insults my character, and generally engages in strawman argumentation. I don't really think it's worth reading, but I'm posting a copy of my reply here for easy reference should I need it. At least the author was nice enough to email me and ask whether I'd like to respond.
Dear Mr O'Neill,

Thank you for bringing your article to my attention (I am the author of the sign in question).

Your analysis is cogent, coherent, and well written. Indeed, I have no truck with its main argument: that this graph cannot justify the mechanism of pricing a good with a negative externality. However, as I have commented on other analyses of my sign, that was never the point.

My sign was inspired by repeated exposure to people who didn't understand how taxing a good (service) and then returning the revenue in compensation could change behaviour; it is a graphical representation of the principle of changed relative prices – no more, no less. It was tongue in cheek, served as a basis of discussion with other rally attendees, and was a reminder of the role of economics in the carbon pricing debate.

In this context (as a partial equilibrium result), the sign is utterly unremarkable and – unless you wish to challenge basic microeconomics – difficult to dispute. Even libertarian/centre-right economists such as Sinclair Davidson recognise that: http://catallaxyfiles.com/2011/06/07/carbon-compensation-it-works-bitches-in-theory/

Let me repeat: your analysis is correct in its criticism of what you suggest is the purpose of the sign. However, that is not and was not its actual purpose.

Your post has indeed exposed a fallacy, but it has been the fallacy of arguing against a strawman. Your attacks against my intentions and character were uncalled for.

Sincerely,
Martin C. Jones

Friday, June 17, 2011

More "Carbon Pricing Works" pictures

An update on the LOLBolt thing: comments stopped being moderated (and hence published) on Tuesday afternoon, so the count remains at 260-odd. I can only imagine how many more go unpublished. The great Boltian outrage machine has moved on, though – I hope their next target knows to defend themselves.

Other photos from the "Say Yes" rally have popped up on Flickr. The WWF managed to get my sign from the back as well as the front, while another chap cropped me out of the picture entirely:
Say yes sydney rally
(Just imagine what the nutjobs would have made of my "thumb in the pocket" pose.)
Say yes sydney rally

It Works Bitches


There are some nice crowd shots, too:
Sydney Climate Action rally, by Roy Garner

A gorgeous day in the park.

Tuesday, June 07, 2011

LOLBolt vs. Jones

My "carbon pricing works" placard was, as I mentioned yesterday, much-photographed and widely retweeted (over 150 (re)tweets and several thousand views for my photograph). A version posted by @Tadlette made it on to Andrew Bolt's blog – Bolt, if you're unfamiliar with him, is one of Australia's most well-known conservative journalists, climate sceptics, and pin-up boy for the right.
The face that launched two-hundred comments
By the time a friend alerted me the existence of Bolt's post, it had over 200 very nasty comments. I'm going to reproduce some of my favourite ones below, so if you're unsettled by that sort thing please jump down to the bold-text "Response" header (jump):
  • Combet's love child [Greg Combet, Federal Minister for Climate Change]
  • Smug superiority evident on the guy's face
  • My 10 year old daughter has more testosterone than that pathetic dweeb.
  • I wonder if ‘mummy’ also put out his clothes so he can dress himself.  
  • Someone just finished second year economics. No wonder these children are so sure of themselves, they just read a text book. Wait until you have finished third year - you’ll find out more then.  
  • Typical smug know-it-all uni student activist with NO life experience with a theoretical graph to supposedly prove his point  
  • WOW have a look at the smug look on this guy’s face...That’s it the science is settled!! I’M IN!!! And his clothes are more up to date than mine.  
  • Its the way he tilts his head that did it for me. And the grip on that broom handle......he’s done this often......a real pro.  
  • I used to say to my son “Oh to be 19 and know everything” ! 
  • Just another socialist charlatan - this time a microeconomics lackey who thinks plotting imaginary diagrams from his textbook equates to knowing more about the real world than real working Australians do. These tools should all be shipped to Venezuela.  
  • Is that Sheldon? No, he’s super-smart.  
  • Looks to me the homosexual party has hijacked the green party  
  • This reminds me… disturbingly I mite add...of similarities with the hitler youth movement !  Doing as the National Socialists did by brainwashing impressionable fools from a very early age .(climate science taught in schools ) Good to see science graduates could get time off from Mc Donalds to attend.  
  • I bet he’s a lot of fun at dinner parties! 
  • So that’s what stupid looks like 
  • I do like the look of the lad - gormless prat personified. [This is my absolute favourite!]
  • ....it looks like a twit...waddles like a twit....is a twit...ho hum...... 
  • You can tell by his age: all theory, no practice.  
  • Bitches? Who does he think he is? The love child of carbon copy Combet. Or a product of a carbon copy spurn donator..  
  • Ah, yes! The soft smile! The slightly tilted head! The earnest look! The nerdish intensity! The (ho ho ho) graph to ‘prove’ the point! 
  • Must be a Greenie! Or, at least, an undercover member of the GreenHeimeStaatsPolizei!
  • I wounder who’s bitch he is ?  
  • I wonder if this bitch will give the thousands of people out of work a job? I wonder how ‘smart’ he’d look explaining to the families who now have no work, that they are bitches? 
  • He’ll flash his funny sign, jump back into his pollution spluttering Kombi, jump out have a coffee with ‘peers’ who think just like him and tweet his higher state of being using the wireless internet mummy bought him. Then he’ll pay the barista making sure he gets the correct change. After all, when you’re on the dole, you’ve gotta account for every cent.  
  • It’s not even original - http://xkcd.com/54/
  • Hey beta male - got some bad news for you. A sign like that will NOT end your period of abstinence from rumpy pumpy…
There was also a fair bit of repetition of similar points. Several people also attacked the economics of the sign, most poorly, and all missing the point. (There was much better discussion when the Catallaxy Files reposted the image.)

Response 
I couldn't just let all this pass by, of course – no, I had to prod it with a stick:
Dear Bolters,

As the smug, gormless, homosexual (yet unfashionably dressed), know-it-all, nazi, dole-bludging, sexually-frustrated beta-male prat pictured, let me respond:

First of all, thank you all for underestimating my age and experience by up to a decade; it's very flattering to know my thrice-daily moisturising regime (organic products, made from happy plants) has shown such effect, even in the harsh sunlight causing me to squint as I faced one of the multitude of cameras immortalising my courageous attempt to educate the unwashed masses (this was a climate rally, after all).

Secondly, to the (very) few who've picked the economics of the graph with any degree of rigour: by and large, your criticisms are correct. It would be absurd to try and fit a fully-fledged and nuanced economic justification of a multi-instrument response to anthropogenic climate change on a placard, so I didn't even try. Instead, I used a simplistic graph (drawn from memory, rather than a textbook, my pseudo-intellectual superiority complex compels me to note) that would be recognisable to those who understand economics and whose principles could be easily explained to those who hadn't.
Combined with a slogan that slyly references XKCD for all the nerds out there (hold those TI-86s up high!), the phone numbers of impressionable young arts student activists scrawled on the back of my poster in crayon are a testament to my success.

Finally, you're not my target audience, so basically you can all sod off while I cycle (no Kombi; it got trashed at a bush-doof) to my local café and drink chai (much more ethical than coffee) with my socialist, testosterone-free brethren.

But thanks again for saying I look so young!

/MJ
Bolt was good enough to include my comment into his post so it could be seen by all (I say that in seriousness: good on him), and included a link to my Twitter account – I've no idea where he got that, since I didn't include it in my comment (nor supply my full name). As I also tweeted my response, though, it can't have been too difficult to find me.

At that point, I expected a deluge of nasty tweets, but so far that hasn't eventuated. (Well, one economist at the right-wing IPA told me I looked 32, but that's about as intense as the sledging has been so far.) I have received lots of support from more moderate and left-wing tweeters, though, as well as from my friends over Facebook, so that's been nice. Thank you all for that :-)

Where to now? Tadlette objected to Bolt using her photograph in the manner he did, so Bolt removed it from his post with a sarcastic comment. I offered Bolt use of my photo, but so far there's been no response. That post is now one of his "most-commented", though, and because comments on Bolt's blog require moderation there is likely a queue of comments waiting to appear. (Tadlette's photo has almost 4,000 views.) It's pointless to try and engage with his audience, but I'll leave with a few more delightful selections of the messages slung my way (after my response was published):
  • Behold the geek bearing the Tablet of Warmy Wisdom for the multitudes. Bow down and worship Gaia, you unworthy peasants.
  • I think the late Mr Squiggle could have done a more convincing job than this clown. 
  • Martin Jones seems like a good feller even if he is the epitome of your classical greenie nonce with regard to actually having knowledge of anything to do with climate change.
  • He epitomises the sneering, inner city, self-styled progressives who have hijacked the once great Labor Party. [I thought I was a Greenie? But I'm also a fag only there to pick up chicks, so whatever.]
  • Could do with a good steak and an hour in the sun. [Tell me about it.]
  • Being a sceptic, I ponder, could this be the real Martin (looking ten years younger and all), or a non-English speaking backpacker or a wandering art student pulled in as a subterfuge. [All of the above?]
  • Theo (short for Thesaurus as his mate call him) Jones knows that the very best place to pick up chicks is in these gooey “Save the Planet” thingos.

    Monday, June 06, 2011

    Carbon Pricing: it works, bitches!

    As I mentioned last Monday, the week just gone was the National Week of Action by the "Say Yes" campaign, culminating on Sunday with rallies across Australia; 10,000 turned out in Melbourne, 8,000 in Sydney, and a whopping (considering its population) 10,000 in Canberra! (I don't have figures for the other capital cities to hand.)

    I went to the rally in Sydney on a glorious Sunday morning, sporting a the following placard:
    Carbon Pricing: it works, bitches!
    On the back, I'd written:
    PRO CARBON PRICING
    Changing relative prices will
    shift consumption so long as
    any compensation is not delivered
    at the point of purchase.
    Pollution is a cost: price it in!

    The idea had come earlier in the week, when a tweet shown during the ABC Q&A program questioned the point of a carbon tax when the money was given back as compensation. The twit obviously hadn't done any high school economics or listened to the multiple explanations given over the last five years, so I irately tweeted, "One more time: Changing relative prices will shift consumption so long as any compensation is not delivered at the point of purchase."

    The sentiment proved popular, to the extent that one chap suggested putting it on a t-shirt. Fellow economist Matt Cowgill (of "What does the typical Australian earn" fame) opined, "Whack a couple of budget constraints and an indifference curve on the back and it'd be perfect."

    So... I did! On Friday, after work, I knocked up a mock-up (below), which was widely retweeted and got several hundred views when I put it up on Twitter.
    Click for larger version
    Using a cardboard box, old posters, and broken broom handle I'd all grabbed from the recycling centre, I spent a few hours constructing my placard. I think it was worth it – over 40 people took photographs of it at the rally, including a couple of professional photographers. (One was from GetUp!; dunno about the rest.) there was plenty more love from Twitter, one woman did a short video interview with me for her blog (the name of which I've forgotten), and this morning Club Troppo ran a post about it. 
    I'm glad I shaved.

    A few people asked me to explain the graph to them. It's based on some introductory microeconomics, and isn't incredibly complex, but can take a few minutes to understand. Here's a basic run-down:

    The black line represents the maximum combination of polluting and clean goods you can buy. It's your "budget constraint". The budget line is straight because the ratio at which you can exchange those products is fixed by their prices. The black curved line, A, represents a combination of products with which you are equally happy. It's curved because the more you have of one product, the less valuable it becomes, and the ratio at which you are willing to exchange products changes. The "higher" the black line is, the better, and it's highest when you consume at A*. (You can't move the black curve higher, or consume on other points along it, because that's outside what your budget constraint says you can afford.)

    A price on pollution means you can buy fewer polluting products, so the black budget line turns into the red line. When you get compensation, you can keep buying A* if you like, so the red line moves across to become the blue line. They are parallel because the ratio of the prices hasn't changed, just the amount of money you have. As you can see, on the blue budget line you can move to the higher curve B, rather than A, which is obviously better. The highest point is at B*, where you consume fewer polluting products, more clean products, and are better off! 

    Easy.