Monday, June 06, 2011

Carbon Pricing: it works, bitches!

As I mentioned last Monday, the week just gone was the National Week of Action by the "Say Yes" campaign, culminating on Sunday with rallies across Australia; 10,000 turned out in Melbourne, 8,000 in Sydney, and a whopping (considering its population) 10,000 in Canberra! (I don't have figures for the other capital cities to hand.)

I went to the rally in Sydney on a glorious Sunday morning, sporting a the following placard:
Carbon Pricing: it works, bitches!
On the back, I'd written:
PRO CARBON PRICING
Changing relative prices will
shift consumption so long as
any compensation is not delivered
at the point of purchase.
Pollution is a cost: price it in!

The idea had come earlier in the week, when a tweet shown during the ABC Q&A program questioned the point of a carbon tax when the money was given back as compensation. The twit obviously hadn't done any high school economics or listened to the multiple explanations given over the last five years, so I irately tweeted, "One more time: Changing relative prices will shift consumption so long as any compensation is not delivered at the point of purchase."

The sentiment proved popular, to the extent that one chap suggested putting it on a t-shirt. Fellow economist Matt Cowgill (of "What does the typical Australian earn" fame) opined, "Whack a couple of budget constraints and an indifference curve on the back and it'd be perfect."

So... I did! On Friday, after work, I knocked up a mock-up (below), which was widely retweeted and got several hundred views when I put it up on Twitter.
Click for larger version
Using a cardboard box, old posters, and broken broom handle I'd all grabbed from the recycling centre, I spent a few hours constructing my placard. I think it was worth it – over 40 people took photographs of it at the rally, including a couple of professional photographers. (One was from GetUp!; dunno about the rest.) there was plenty more love from Twitter, one woman did a short video interview with me for her blog (the name of which I've forgotten), and this morning Club Troppo ran a post about it. 
I'm glad I shaved.

A few people asked me to explain the graph to them. It's based on some introductory microeconomics, and isn't incredibly complex, but can take a few minutes to understand. Here's a basic run-down:

The black line represents the maximum combination of polluting and clean goods you can buy. It's your "budget constraint". The budget line is straight because the ratio at which you can exchange those products is fixed by their prices. The black curved line, A, represents a combination of products with which you are equally happy. It's curved because the more you have of one product, the less valuable it becomes, and the ratio at which you are willing to exchange products changes. The "higher" the black line is, the better, and it's highest when you consume at A*. (You can't move the black curve higher, or consume on other points along it, because that's outside what your budget constraint says you can afford.)

A price on pollution means you can buy fewer polluting products, so the black budget line turns into the red line. When you get compensation, you can keep buying A* if you like, so the red line moves across to become the blue line. They are parallel because the ratio of the prices hasn't changed, just the amount of money you have. As you can see, on the blue budget line you can move to the higher curve B, rather than A, which is obviously better. The highest point is at B*, where you consume fewer polluting products, more clean products, and are better off! 

Easy.

No comments: