I received a slight shock yesterday when I was having dinner with my parents. In the context of whatever discussion we were having I raised the observation that "everyone thinks they're middle class", a less-than-groundbreaking insight I intended merely to lead into some data from 1999 in which people were asked to place themselves into an income class.
What I essentially asked was this: "If you take all income-earning Australians and rank (order) them by the amount of income they earn, then separate them into ten equally sized groups, you get income deciles: the poorest 10%, the next poorest 10% (11-20%), the richest 10% (91-100%), etc. How many people do you think put themselves into the 51-60% decile/group?"
My dad is an engineer and my mum a high-school teacher, and both are intelligent people, so I figured I'd be alright with what was, really, not much more than high-school maths. The point I wanted to make was that, although only 10% of people are in the 51-60% range (by definition), about 26% of people put themselves into that group – 2.6 times as many as are actually in it! When my dad answered "70-80%", though, I was thrown. Did he really think Australians were that delusional about their income ranking?
It turns out dad was thinking of a bell curve (normal) distribution of incomes over the range 0-100% (of people) and was estimating how many people would fall into the middle of that distribution (i.e. where it peaks). What caused me concern, however, is that I wasn't able to shift him from his (engineering) model of the world to one in which you simply order people from poor to rich and put them into equally large groups; he thought terms like the "poorest 10%" or "richest 10%" of people were just not things anyone would want to talk about; couldn't see a use for the concept.
I love my dad and I don't think any less of him as a result of this episode – it's been 40-odd years since he passed his stats class at uni and since then has only had to use a sub-section of that knowledge. But my general assumption that "intelligent people" – broadly, those who went or could have gone to university – are able to understand (what I consider to be) basic statistics was shaken. More critically, I am now unsure to what extent I misjudge the common man and his ability to process information; if one were to print the following graph (from CORE economics.com.au – see link, above) in the newspaper and say that "within the top 30% highest-earning Australians, less than 1/6th think they're that rich", would the lay reader understand it?
I wouldn't really be all too concerned if I were living in a ivory tower – but I'd like to be aware of the fact!


No comments:
Post a Comment