Thursday, October 05, 2006

The right stuff

From a Slashdot discussion:

No one has the "right" to do anything. A right can't be taken away, otherwise it is a privilege, and everything
can be taken away, by nature (or God, if you like) if not by man. This
cruel condition is what we as a species were fighting when we got
together and started forming civilization.


So if there are no
inherent rights, where do rights come from, and what do they mean? The
whole concept of rights revolves around society, around other people.
If you were alone in the world, you would no more think of rights than
a fish thinks of water. Alone without society, your power is your only
right. In order to form cooperative societies that benefit all more
than any could benefit himself alone, we all have to give up some of
our rights. I give up my right to hit you in the face or take your
things because you do the same for me.


So all rights are
arbitrary, agreed upon by society because they benefit everyone. And
all rights involve giving up some kind of freedom as well, so the
exchange had better be worth it. In the case of violence, pretty much
everyone can agree. The same goes for personal property. However,
private property is a harder sell. Too many freedoms are lost by too
many people for too little gain by too few.


Most people would
agree that the things a person works for should be their own, and this
is often used to justify private ownership of natural resources.
However, in order to labor on a piece of land and thus call it your
own, you need to keep others off it, and this happens before you have
the justification for doing so.


So private ownership of
resources can not be justified from first principles, only as an
arbitrary privilege granted by society. A privilege granted very
unfairly, I might add, as most resources are owned and controlled by
people who labored very little for the privilege. Therefore, society
has all the justification it needs to impose any kinds of limits or
qualifiers on the ownership of private property, from having to pay
taxes all the way to having to paint your house a certain color. If you
don't like it, you don't have to own property.


The original comment.

Thursday, September 28, 2006

Stuttgart -> Heidelberg

I move to Heidelberg tomorrow, but I'm having a little trouble getting excited about the whole thing. It'll be my first move that isn't international, and the concept of having to travel an hour-and-a-half to pick up something I've forgotten doesn't really provide the necessary impetus to knuckle down and devote my full attention to the task of packing. So in between packing I faff around, play a few rounds of MechAssault on the Xbox, and, you know.. blog :-)

Theoretically, at least, I should be a bit nervous about the move. It takes me from an established network of friends and activities to a place I'm only vaguely familiar with, preparing for an activity that I still don't know an awful lot about. Yet somehow none of this fazes me. I've got somewhere to stay, I know at least one person in Heidelberg outside my family, and Uni.. well, how different can one Uni be from another? Sure, I'll have to borrow the books a different way, class structures and maybe attitudes will vary, but that won't be much problem. I'm quite prepared to treat my first semester as a learning experience – learning about the system, not just through it – and won't get too upset if my marks aren't at the same level as in Australia.

Anyway, I still need to pack all the football stuff I accumulated during the World Cup, and then give my room a good clean before I leave. Where the dickens does all this dust come from?

Wednesday, September 27, 2006

Music Downloads: Pirates—or Customers?

The Harvard Business School has an interesting article about the effect of illegal music downloads on CD sales. The study was restricted to the US market, but the results are most likely broadly applicable in a global context.

The results? That music downloaders have two major groups: teenagers/college kids, and "samplers". The former are "'money-poor but time-rich,' meaning they wouldn't have bought the songs they downloaded. In that sense, the music industry can't claim those downloads as lost record sales." The second group, the "samplers", are generally older folk who are more likely to download music in order to 'trial' it before deciding to purchase it. I'll admit that it's not uncommon for me to check out an album over the 'net before deciding to buy it, but that on the whole I've decided to buy many more albums than I would have otherwise - a personal result that fits in with the trend shown by the study.

It's the article isn't a long read - it summarises the study before doing a quick Q&A with one of the authors - but interesting nonetheless, if not least because it's an objective voice in a debate that's commonly fought between money-grubbing corporations and anonymous freeloaders that chant "information wants to free" as though that mantra atoned for all sins.

Zürich

My mate Paul dropped by on his round trip the other week, on his way to visit his Dad in Zürich. Paul wanted to spend time with me, but he also wanted to see his Dad, so I generously offered to accept the offer of free accommodation and accompany him. Paul stayed long enough to play a game of football with me and my mates - despite a nasty rash on his foot; what a trooper - before we decamped to Switzerland.

Organising the train tickets was an ordeal in itself, since Paul has roughly the same relationship with punctuality and confident decision making as the Italians do with honesty - that is to say: a pretty loose one - and I'm.. well, pretty German. Not to be unfair to Paul: it's these laid-back attributes that make him such a great chap - but trying to book international travel to fit in with plans that don't exist can fray the nerves.

Anyway, we got there in the end. Zürich's only a short trip south from Stuttgart - it's closer than Munich, in fact - and we even managed to squeeze in a little sightseeing in Stuttgart on the morning of the trip. Paul Dad, Ian, met us at the station, and treated us to the local Golden Arches on the way home. The Swiss Franc has roughly the same value as the AUD (100 CHF = 106 AUD), so having to pay close to 10 CHF for a meal was a bit of an eyeopener: Switzerland is an expensive place! Maybe not quite London expensive, but still pretty hefty. All as much concern to me was the apparent inability of the cashier to understand my German - had I suddenly forgot how to speak? I know the Swiss speak a different style of German to the Germans, but it's still the same language!

Ian Dundas has the top 1.5 stories of a very nice house south of the city, from which Paul and I caught a bus and then tram back to the Hauptbahnhof the following day. The interesting sections of the Zürich Hbf lie predominantly underground, with a plethora of shops and other attractions. The above-ground portion isn't bad, either, but nothing special. Unfortunately it was impossible to get a decent shot of it that wasn't spoiled by a cobweb of tram power cables, which wasn't an infrequent occurrence during our sightseeing. The Council has made a concerted effort to rid the CBD of cars, and to a great extent succeeded. I'm quite happy to accept a few more power lines to service the PT grid in return, but it was a little aggravating to be presented with construction works at every twist and turn. Every beautiful view across the river seemed to include a crane or scaffolding, detracting from the otherwise charming vista the city presents. Lake Zürich remains a tremendous view, as does the outlook from the University, and if you wander through the old resedential districts you find some lovely alleys; Stalin even stayed in Zürich not long before leaving to start the revolution (if you're wondering which one, I suggest you don't ask a high school history teacher or they'll get all nihilistic). It's that kind of city.

A useful landmark in Zürich is the river, which runs virtually North-South, so one day Paul and I visited the west side of the city, and on the other, the east. Though I've never really bothered with tours or guidebooks in the past, Ian had one lying in around that we borrowed, and it really did make a difference: it's much more interesting knowing that one fancy building is the guardhouse, another the Town Hall, and being able to look up why some guy was important enough to warrant being immortalised in statue form. There was no mention of what noble deeds his horse did, though. Maybe the statue thing was a package deal.
The other thing I'd strongly recommend is taking advantage of the free bike hire some cities offer. We didn't do it Zürich, and it's a little incompatible with the whole guidebook thing, but if your preference lies less with cosy alleys and more with, I dunno, vans with strange paintjobs, you can get about much more efficaciously on a bicycle.

After a few days in was time to Paul to continue his journey, so I bid farewell to the Dundas' and made my way back to Stuttgart. Condensed impression of Zürich? Clean, attractive, metropolitan, expensive. Not the capital of Switzerland, but the largest city by far and the cultural capital. Still, I wouldn't mind visiting Bern, if just because of that fateful day ;-)

Tuesday, September 26, 2006

Not that he'd link to me, but...

Klaus (no, that's not really him) sent me a link to another page today.

It makes more sense if you understand that my nickname is also "Fargo"*, and that I am/used to be/hope to still occasionally be a roleplayer.

*From "MartinBartinFargo", which in turn comes from "Martin, Bartin & Fargo", a law firm that a chap from High School saw and whose name I became christened with.

/Martin of the sodden cushions

Thursday, September 07, 2006

Thirteeeeen – Niiiiiiil

Tonight was a good night. France beat Italy 3-1 (as it should have been two months ago!), the Czech Republic beat Slovakia (important, because I had said they would, and Seb said they wouldn't - ha!), and Germany waltzed past San Marino with 13:0.

The highlight of the latter match was probably Bernd Schneider scoring only his 3rd goal in 74 appearances, though he threatens to be upstaged by central defender Manuel Friedrich, who now has one goal from three (3) appearances. On a goals per game basis, this makes Friedrich 8 times more threatening than his colleague in midfield :D

On a final matter – whether or not David Odonkor is (on paper, at least) at striker, results have been mixed. ESPN regards him as a forward, while Sky Sports has him as an attacking midfielder. The veracity of Sky Sports position is in some doubt, however, as they seem to have mistaken Gerald Asamoah for a midfielder – and not even an attacking one, at that!

For the record, the DFB (German Football Federation) states that David Odonkor is a midfielder, and Gerald Asamoah. So, I don't know where these other outlets source their information from, but I'm forced to begrudgingly concede to Seb that – on paper – some (altogether daft) people regard Odonkor as a striker.
*throws hands in the air* sports reporters... *sigh*

Wednesday, September 06, 2006

The Martin Prophecies

It occurred to me that I invariably post about things after I've done them, and not before. This would seem like the logical order to follow, but on the hand, sometimes the prospect of what one is about to do is more interesting than ruminating upon past events.


In any case, what I'm leading up to is the announcement that I'm going to Zurich for a few days, from Thursday to Sunday. Why Zurich? Well, Paul has been doing a bus-about trip through Europe these past couple of weeks, and on his way to visit his Dad - who lives in Zurich - he's stopping in here (Stuttgart). Since he flies out of Zurich on Sunday, and wants to maximise time with both his Dad and I, I said I'd go to Zurich with him.

Actually, I just wanted to use the opportunity for free accommodation, but the other formulation sounds much nobler, doesn't it?

So, that's what I'll be doing this week; next week ought hopefully see me attend the Munich Lindy Exchange. Lindy Exchanges are events where swing dancers in a particular city provide accommodation and put on events for out-of-town (often international) dancers for a few days, in the spirit of friendship, hope of reciprocity, and expectation of a killer party. That's probably not their mission statement, but it hits close enough to the mark.
This Lindy Exchange goes from the 14th - 17th (Thurs-Sun), and all I really have to do is arrange accommodation.. but first things first: Zurich, then a few days recovery, then dancing!

After that? Well, I have pencilled in that Tu Linh, a dancing friend of mine from Melbourne, is supposed to visit, but that was a while ago and we haven't spoken about it since. We'll see what happens. The week after that is the last week of September, and sees two moves take place: first, my honorary brother Matze moves back from Hamburg to start finishing his degree; and later in the week, I decamp to Heidelberg! So, for a few days only, Stuttgart will have a double billing: M&M, live and in person.

There it is - this month's calendar, in text format. Now if you'll excuse me, I have to ring the electoral office and check whether I've enrolled as an overseas voter or not. Exciting stuff..

Monday, September 04, 2006

Consider it a practice essay

I read an article in the paper today that posed the question: "Is your life efficient?"

The standpoint of the author, a religious counsellor, was that living your life by the rules of efficiency was bad - or at least, not optimal. She bemoaned companies that abided only by the rules of economics and competition, and wished more people were generous - truly generous, giving for the sake of giving, without expecting anything in return.

Articles like this give me the shits, because they misrepresent the fundamental purpose of economics; economics is NOT about maximising profits, competition, downsizing, streamlining, or any of the other buzzwords that were thrown into the article. No, economics is simply the study of how people deal with limited resources and unlimited wants. That's all. There is no fundamental goal to economics: it does not inherently promote maximum production, or efficiency, or profit-seeking. These are inherent assumptions in the use of economics tools, given - but economics would function just as well without them. While it unlikely that many people who've studied economics will have encountered a model that did not seek to maximise production, that's only because someone, somewhere - probably a politician - decided it was everyone's best interests to do so.
Let me repeat that: someone, somewhere, at a time far in the forgotten past, decided it was better for everyone if the scarce resources were allocated to best satisfy humanity's unlimited wants, and applied economics to that end.

Now, a perfectly valid argument could be made that the goal of best satisfying unlimited wants is so fundamentally tied up with our understanding of economics that it would be, at best, a semantic decision to claim otherwise. Fair enough. But the linking of a goal with the tools used to achieve that goal, until the two become inseparable, is the foot of the precipice to which that argument forms the peak. And it down that very slope that this author is steering her evangelical bobsled.

She argues that it is disturbing when companies hire consulting firms that advocate cutting staff, as no-one carries the responsibility: the company can point at the recommendations and blame the consultants, who are long gone and probably haven't give a second thought to the company. This is a classic case of confusing the tool with the goal: the consultants were hired, no doubt, to make the company more profitable. They did this - end of story.
Oh, but it's bad that people got fired - well, why weren't the consultants given the task of maximising profits without reducing staff. It's that simple.
Well, what about the managers - they were simply acting upon the accepted economic impulse to make more money, weren't they? Rubbish - economics doesn't say that at all. Economics tells them how to get there, but it didn't suggest the target, remember?

"Why is money so often the goal of human endeavour?", is perhaps a relevant question at this juncture. I don't rightly know; or at least, not to the extent that I could present a proper answer. Money is closely linked to goods, certainly, which in turn have always held an association with happiness. Ah, happiness - there we strike the variable that, more than any other, defines economics as a social science. For, if we stand atop our precipice and declare that the goal of economics is to 'best' allocate scare resources to satisfy our unlimited wants, we remain on solid footing if we introduce 'happiness' as the criterion by which we judge what is 'best'.

Our position at once becomes nebulous, though, since as yet there is no way to quantitative way to measure happiness. Economics could be used to satisfy Party A's wants (= make them happier), or Party B's wants - but how is it to know which to choose? Even if we take another step along our peak and decide maximising total happiness is now our goal, we still don't know which option that is. Does choosing the least happy person guarantee the greatest net increase? Not necessarily. Note, also, that maximising happiness, given a limited (scarce) set of resources, is a question of efficiency. We'll come back to that.

Let's give roles to our parties: Party A is now a worker, and Party B is now a shareholder sin the company Party A works for. Management could fire the worker, and give the money saved to the shareholder (let's assume, for the sake of simplicity, that the other workers can compensate for their lost comrade without a decrease in their happiness).
Now, the worker is unhappier, and the shareholder is happier. Which change is greater? Not proportionally, but absolutely. The question is unanswerable. Maybe the worker hated the job, was too craven to quit, but now enjoys the free time; maybe the shareholder used the money for an operation to drastically improve the quality of his life; without some quantitative scale, how do you measure something like that? And if it turned out the shareholder's happiness increase was greater than the worker's decrease, would you advocate firing him on that basis? It would certainly be an efficient use of the resources, if you want to look at it that way.

Economics doesn't make those choices. The people using it do. The management that fired those workers the author was complaining about were simply using economics tools to achieve their goals efficiently. The argument that, because the goal is undesirable, efficiency (or economics) is undesirable is ludicrous!
The author's argument that competition is bad, again, hinges upon the assumption that the parties involved are competing on points that undesirable aspects. That they are even competing on those points means that someone doesn't regard the aspects as undesirable, and the author should concentrate her efforts on changing the attitudes of whoever that is.

A succinct rebuttal of the author's points is thus:
Efficiency, in and of itself, is neither good nor bad - even if the purpose for which is it used is. Ditto for Economics, and competition (though the latter requires a more complicated extrapolation, the principle is the same).

Finally, what if her 'truly generous' folk applied the principles of economics and efficiency to their giving: wouldn't their gifts have a much greater effect?

Friday, September 01, 2006

Amazonian Technology

I've been thinking about ways to spend my $500+ Tax Rebate the last few days, and have decided to treat myself to another piece of technology (no great suprises there). This time it's not a flashy gizmo that'll I'll be mooning over for weeks on end like I normally do, but a simple, functional expansion to one of my already existing baubles.


I present: the 4 GB Memory Stick Pro Duo

Why am I writing about this? Firstly, because, at 121 €, this thing cost twice as much as phone I'll be putting it in. Sure, I got the phone cheaper with the plan, but I've still tripled the purchase value of the stuff I carry around in my pocket in one fell swoop. Secondly, I've just upgraded my phone to the equivalent of an iPod nano, at a fraction of the price. Theoretically I could have bought an 8 GB memory stick and made the comparison ridiculous, but I haven't abandoned my spendthrift nature to that extent.. yet.
The capacity upgrade represents for me the satisfaction of a desire for a decent MP3 player, without buying into the pop-phenommenon that is the iPod. As such, I hold it up as an example to all - let convergence be your watchword!

Maybe I should just become militant

In response to my decision to vote for the greens, Seb sent me an essay he'd written on the environmental, political, and economic aspects of international climate protection policy. This constitutes possibly the most informative reader response I've had since Evan added "Beer is a substitute for dinner" to my list of things you learn as a bachelor.


The long and short of his essay is that the actions of individuals are pretty much worthless in the global scale of response required to have any significant impact on global warming, and that the divergent goals of the three areas (environment, politics, economy), not to mention vested country interests, mean an accord like the Kyoto Protocol should be considered a great success.
The Kyoto Protocol - an accord that had the usefulness beaten out of it by a consortium* of some of the biggest polluters, who then didn't ratify it!

Though the points he makes are valid, a perfect counter-argument appeared in the paper today: Governor of California announces plan to reduce emissions by 25% by 2020. Now, while 25% isn't nearly enough to stop global warming, Arnie's decision is a direct response to the wishes of his electorate. Individual votes made a difference.

There is an alternative to voting for Kang, and it's not Kodos!

So I'm voting for the candidate with the best environmental policy - because even they don't win, the fact that there are votes in it makes it more likely the party in power will adopt a (watered-down) version of their stance. And then we (Australia) might even sign the successor to Kyoto; it still won't go far enough, but it'll go further than Kyoto. So at least in that sense - raising the set of standards seen as a baseline for new accords - the Kyoto protocol can be considered a success. Which is why Seb passed, I guess


*That consortium, by the way, included Japan, the USA, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and Switzerland. Yes, Switzerland. Do they have a methane problem from all the cows they need to make chocolate that they don't want to address? What's going on there?