Friday, September 01, 2006

Maybe I should just become militant

In response to my decision to vote for the greens, Seb sent me an essay he'd written on the environmental, political, and economic aspects of international climate protection policy. This constitutes possibly the most informative reader response I've had since Evan added "Beer is a substitute for dinner" to my list of things you learn as a bachelor.


The long and short of his essay is that the actions of individuals are pretty much worthless in the global scale of response required to have any significant impact on global warming, and that the divergent goals of the three areas (environment, politics, economy), not to mention vested country interests, mean an accord like the Kyoto Protocol should be considered a great success.
The Kyoto Protocol - an accord that had the usefulness beaten out of it by a consortium* of some of the biggest polluters, who then didn't ratify it!

Though the points he makes are valid, a perfect counter-argument appeared in the paper today: Governor of California announces plan to reduce emissions by 25% by 2020. Now, while 25% isn't nearly enough to stop global warming, Arnie's decision is a direct response to the wishes of his electorate. Individual votes made a difference.

There is an alternative to voting for Kang, and it's not Kodos!

So I'm voting for the candidate with the best environmental policy - because even they don't win, the fact that there are votes in it makes it more likely the party in power will adopt a (watered-down) version of their stance. And then we (Australia) might even sign the successor to Kyoto; it still won't go far enough, but it'll go further than Kyoto. So at least in that sense - raising the set of standards seen as a baseline for new accords - the Kyoto protocol can be considered a success. Which is why Seb passed, I guess


*That consortium, by the way, included Japan, the USA, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and Switzerland. Yes, Switzerland. Do they have a methane problem from all the cows they need to make chocolate that they don't want to address? What's going on there?

No comments: