Thursday, December 11, 2008

(Musical) ignorance is bliss

Non-native speakers of English sometimes ask me whether I listen to the lyrics of pop songs and, if I do, how on earth I can stand their banality. I do, in fact, listen to the lyrics of songs, and it's one of the reasons I avoid pop and modern r&b products to a great extent. Foreigners and youths, shielded by their lack of understanding and critical comprehension respectively, are perhaps able to cope with the hackneyed texts of Britney Spears or the saccharine thought vacuum of the Pussycat Dolls: I am not.

Foreign music is totally clear. When I'm listening to Camille I have no idea what she's saying, but it doesn't minder my enjoyment of her since one of the characteristic element of Camille's music is the use of her voice as an instrument. Layered and looped, most of what she's singing isn't meaningful in any language except that of rhythm and melody. As for the rest of what she sings: well, I don't speak French, so I have no idea what's going on. It could be aural equivalent of lorem ipsum sit, for all I know.(1) Which might be better that way – my enjoyment of Rammstein's music decreased significantly after I figured out what they were singing about.
So I can totally understand that people find songs attractive just for the music.

What I have trouble with, though, is how someone who understands a language can just totally ignore the text that's being sung. I can't do that. If I can understand what the singer is saying, I pay attention to it – and if it's bollocks, then the song loses value in my eyes. If there's a button that lets people turn off their comprehension, I don't have it.

That was my view until last night, when I was sitting around in my office in the Environmental Economics Institute and felt the urge to listen to some Hot Hot Heat. Youtube obliged, and even threw up some videos that the lyrics in them. HHH are a band I like very much, and their Elevator album is one in which there isn't a single song I skip over or that I would consider to be weaker than the rest. That's not a view I have of many albums, which can most often be easily separated into the "singles" and the "filler". As I was listening to "Dirty Mouth", I realised to my chagrin that I'd never really paid attention to anything being sung except the chorus. The lyrics weren't necessarily bad, but they were sung in such a way that they invited the listener to interpret the vocal track as just another instrument: the diction and timing were just different enough from ordinary speech to require more than idle listening to parse.

So, perhaps that why people can stand to listen to rubbish music day in, day out: they're just lazy. Or alternatively, their demands are... modest.

(1) How awesome would that be?! What's that? Yes, yes I am a geek :-(

----------------
Now playing: Max Greger - Bei mir bist du schön

Tuesday, December 09, 2008

Thursday, December 04, 2008

Check, check your head.

"Hello... Hello..."

My professor interrupts his lecture and stares bemused at the loudspeakers mounted on the walls.

"Hello... test, test, one two, one two."

Ah. My professor doesn't like to use the microphone for this lecture theatre, and some-one else has picked it up by mistake thinking it was for their lecture. No matter, they'll soon realise their mistake and put it back.

"Test... test... tap tap tap tap... HellOOOooo. Hmmm."

Maybe not.

"One.. two.. one, one.. one, two. Why is this so quiet? Do you hear anything?"

That's us, laughing at you.
Alright, that looks to be all. Back to lec-

"taptaptaptaptap helloooo! Try turning that up... anything? It's still quite quiet. Maybe the batteries are dead."

Maybe your brain is dead.
My professor looks tries to turn off the speakers, but instead manages to plunge the room into darkness, giving the continued mutterings in stereo an ethereal feel.
Time to go look for this chump; my professor and several students leave the lecture theatre to try and discover the errant lecturer and inform him of his mistake. The Heidelberger "New University" building has over a dozen lecture theatres, though, and he could be in any of them. Luckily there aren't many lectures on a Friday afternoon, so at least we aren't interrupting lectures en masse. We assemble back at the lecture hall after a few minutes: all reports negative. Oh dear.

Thankfully our disembodied friend has left us in the interim, and we can get back to our lecture. Until the next time it happens, at least.

Will work for food (in worth of >1200€ a month)

As I sat down for my lecture this afternoon, my friend Rosie – who sports a very practical rain-trouser that makes her look like a deep-sea sailor who's mistakenly decided to bike to uni instead of to her cutter – asked me whether I expected my salary to be more or less than 1,200€. Since my response was to stare at her in confusion while struggling out of my raincoat and wishing I, too, had waterproof pants, she elaborated: 1,200€ starting salary in my first job out of uni, net, per month. My brain tried vainly to multiply 1,200 by 12 while simultaneously adjusting for withheld tax to arrive at gross figure that I could compare with other figures – figures it was also searching for – and failed miserably.

Rosie stared at me perplexed. How had I not given the topic any consideration? Wasn't I about to start writing my diploma thesis? Well, yes, I guess I was. I mean, I am. After this semester. Come June or July of next year I'll be done with Uni and will hopefully have a job, and before accepting an offer I should probably make sure it's a decent one. Which means comparing the salary to the respective salaries of other graduates in my area. What's a representative starting salary for economics graduates in Germany? Shit, no idea... wait, let's just convert the Australian equivalent to Euro... alright... and...

"Yes, Rosie. More than 1,200€."
"Sssh Martin, the lecture's started."

*sigh*

Monday, December 01, 2008

A perfect face for radio

I was up in Mainz yesterday evening for a swing dance thing, it was.. well, a curious experience. It was the 9th annual Mainzer Swing and Boogie party; a title that always makes me a bit wary. Events organised by swing dancers are usually just titled as such: "Swing" events. When the word "Boogie" appears in there, it's usually an event organised by a local Boogie Woogie club, with Swing tacked on as an ancillary thing to bump up the numbers a little. On a larger scale that can totally work, but Mainz doesn't have such a huge scene, so it was questionable whether enough swing dancers would show up to make it worthwhile. I was hoping to see at least a handful of good dancers I'd met a few months earlier in Wiesbaden (which is to Mainz as Albury is to Wodonga).

The event was held in one of the old French barracks left behind after the occupation, which had been turned into a cosy little bar with a wood floor, high ceiling and a lighting rig. Old black & white music videos were playing on the wall behind the stage, and it was fascinating seeing what Gene Krupa, Jimmy Dorset and the like streamed out over the airways. Fascinating, and occasionally a little bizzare.

That description quite possibly matches what the visiting tv/radio team thought of us. They were from the Südwestrundfunk (SWR), the public broadcasting service of the southwest (essentially the state of Baden-Württemberg). Given the high proportion of older attendees (boogie dancers, for the most part) I wondered what exactly they were hoping to get. Stock footage?
After a few more swing dancers showed up, however, and the journalists figured out who belonged to which scene, they started doing radio interviews and filming some of the dancing. Swing is apparently the Dance of the Year 2008, which I found out while they were interviewing me. The experience was a little weird; not because I was self-conscious, but because the questions were sometimes so bland and/or leading that a feeling arose that they were missing the point of swing a little: either accidentally or intentionally. I mean, I don't want to put the journalists down: they were very pleasant and friendly people, and conducted themselves quite professionally as far as I could tell. But when they ask if the revival of swing dancing has anything to do with the world financial crisis, and to your answer of, "No.", reply, "Really?", you feel just a little bit like they're trying to steer you into an answer to fit the angle they've got in their head for their story.

Anyway... so they were doing radio interviews, and getting basic wide-angle footage of people dancing, and I figured that would be it. The band – if you can call them that; apparently they'd double-booked themselves, so we got the keyboardist and bass player, whilst the guitarist and drummer did God-knows-what – played a bit of boogie, and the DJ played some swing-ish stuff in the breaks.

Then, they started doing TV interviews. This time they picked out the more photogenic people there: those dresses to the nines, or the younger, attractive crowd. So, me again! The questions were pretty much the same as for the radio, but this time I'd learnt what they wanted and gave them a bit of codswallop about how, yes, perhaps people are flocking to swing to escape the dreary everyday the financial crisis has plunged them into, just as they did in the 20's and 30's. For the record: that statement is complete and utter bollocks, and I don't believe a word of it. But hey, if it gets my mug on the telly... ;-)

While the host was off doing.. something.. the camera operator braved the dance floor and followed us around. Primarily me. I don't want to sound conceited here, but I was dressed up quite dapper, had white shoes on (which makes for a wonderful floor level shot), and was probably the best swing dancer there. Did I mention I'm young and attractive? Okay, maybe a little conceited :-P

Dancing with a camera barely a metre or two away is.. again, odd. Avoiding looking into the camera isn't as hard as you'd think, since if you're dancing properly you'll be either looking around the dancefloor for space or at your partner. Sure, if you're performing a show you want to look at the audience, but the challenge I set myself was to be flashy without being showy. I.e. make it look good, but make it look natural.
What was weirder was the sudden presence of the thought, "What do I look like?" I've not seen much video footage of myself dancing, and the footage probably isn't shot such that I could do any proper analysis of my technique, but every so often I'd catch myself thinking, "Maybe I should stop looking so intense and smile a little. I know this is fun. Other dancers know this is fun. A few seconds ago I told the television audience this is fun. But if I furrow my brow in deep concentration trying to achieve a perfect I'll look like a right twit."

The evening sort of petered out shortly after mid-night, which was a bit of a shame. The boogie dancers started leaving relatively early, and there weren't enough swing dancers to really keep it going. Without the television crew the evening probably would have been pretty lame, but whatever. What was lame was that my train back to Heidelberg was delayed 75 minutes, so that I hung around Mainz station for two hours and only got home shortly after 4am. Then got up at 10am to not be subbed into my football match.

But I'll probably be on TV next Saturday: 19:15, SWR, "Landesschau – KulTour". Which is nice.



[EDIT]
15 months later, I have the footage.


----------------
Now playing: Frenzal Rhomb - 60, Beautiful & Mine

Friday, November 28, 2008

Ahh, Ebonics.


The music at the end is just perfect.

Monday, November 24, 2008

His previous shoes were bright green

I don't hold much of the shoes, but the ad is terrific:


Also:

Friday, November 21, 2008

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

First-mover advantage in BotS with imperfect info and no communication?

Here's a game theory problem I've been struggling with since yesterday. It's been nagging at me, since I was pretty good in game theory but just can't understand the "correct" answer.

This is the classic Battle of the Sexes game with slightly modified payoffs:













Player 2

MoviesBaseball
Player 1Movies2,30,0
Baseball1,13,2


(Apologies for the giant space before the table, dunno what's going on there)

Alright, so there are Nash Equilibria with pure strategies {M, M} and {B, B}. There's also a mixed strategy NE with {(1/4, 3/4), (3/4, 1/4)}, but this problem restricts itself to pure strategies.

Okay, so the situation is: Player 1 gets to choose their strategy first, and this is common knowledge (Player 2 knows that P1 moves first, and P1 knows that P2 knows, etc). The decision, however, is unknown.

The question: what is the Nash Equilibrium?
The (supposed) answer: B,B.
The explanation: Player 1 will choose the option that has the greatest payoff for him, so he will choose Baseball. Player 2, knowing this, will also choose Baseball.

My problem: Baseball does not have, in my opinion, the greatest payoff – that would make it a dominant strategy. It only has the greatest payoff if you assume P2 also chooses Baseball (more precisely if q < 3/4, where q = P(Movies)). With imperfect information and no communication, I can't solve this without bringing beliefs into the picture, which can't be right. Since P2 doesn't know P1's choice it shouldn't matter that P1 gets to move first – the game is exactly the same as if it were a simultaneous game (compare the decision trees for simultaneous and sequential versions of this game if in doubt). That means there are two possible NEs, neither of which can be said to be more likely than the other without further information.

The only relevant article I've been able to find on the subject says:

[E]xperiments strongly suggest that the player who moves first enjoys an advantage ... . These results have usually been ascribed to "positional order" or "presentation" effects that are seen as psychological or behavioral rather than fully rational responses to a change in the extensive form of the game.


Source: Beyond Normal Form Invariance: First Mover Advantage in Two-Stage Games with or without Predictable Cheap Talk – Peter J. Hammond, p.5-6

That article uses the classic form of the BotS game, with 2,1 / 1,2 the payoffs when collaboration occurs and 0,0 otherwise. I'm not sure that makes any difference, though.

It's driving me nuts. This is a problem for first-semesters, and they seem perfectly happy with Baseball, Baseball as the solution... but I'm not!

Any help would be appreciated.

[EDIT]:
Various textbooks and staff members confirm my view: the extensive form of the game (which is basically what the question describes; sequential moves with uncertainty about previous moves) is treated exactly the same as the normal form (with the grid), and in both cases neither Nash Equilibrium can be said to be more likely than the other based simply on the order in which the players move. Win!


----------------
Now playing: Tom Waits - Step Right Up

Sunday, November 16, 2008

Causes of avoidable death among young people








15-24 year-olds
25-29 year-olds
1. Road accidents
Suicide
2. Suicide
Road accidents
3. Poisoning
Poisoning
4. Drowning
Epilepsy
5. Epilepsy
Drowning

"Poisoning" includes drug and alcohol overdoses.

63% of the deaths of people under 75 are classed as "preventable".

SOURCE: VICTORIAN GOVERNMENT (Via The Age)


----------------
Now playing: The Living End - Long Live The Weekend