I've been proof-reading a friend's thesis over the past few months (on and off), and he does this thing that really appeals to me: he tells you what he's about to do, or what he's just done. Basically, at the start and/or the end of each of his sections, there'll be a sentence or two saying something like, "Taken together, the aspects described under point X.Y account for the effects experienced by Countries A-F, and lay a theoretical foundation for analysis. Conducting the empirical analysis is the focus of this next section." Essentially he's telling you where you stand in the grand scheme of the paper, so you don't get lost and forget what's going on.
Now, what fascinates me about this approach is that's it's so simple. It really isn't that hard: you know (or should know) the structure of what you're writing about, and – despite your introduction – the reader doesn't know it as well as you, so why not help them out?
My only problem with the whole concept is that it detracts slightly from the flow of the piece somewhat. I guess that's kind of the point of the whole thing: you're taking a step back from the forest and saying, "See that clearing? That's where we are now. Next, we're going to wander down that path on our way to the waterfall I described at the start. Rightio, back into the thicket!" But that same process – by necessity – pulls you out of whatever little world you're in at the time. And it occurs to me that many of the essays I've written tend to have this sort of narrative thread to them, almost as though I'm telling some sort of story. I still have the same structural plan and verbal cues that lead the reader to the next elements, but usually they're contained within the text, pulling you along the road, rather than standing on the median strip wearing a fluorescent vest and giving directions via loudspeaker.
Now I don't know which I prefer. The explicit variation has the definite benefit that even the most obtuse reader will have trouble getting lost, and in the context of a professor marking a pile of essays, where mind-numbing routine can be considered a proxy for obtuseness, helpful fluoro markers are a definite plus. On the other hand, if you can create an essay that doesn't just convey information, but simultaneously captures the reader's interest and puts him in good humour, then his opinion of it will doubtlessly be positive.
I guess it depends on the topic, and perhaps also the length of the piece. Shorter bodies of work are easier to "style", as it were, but in longer essays, in which one also tends to operate on a more detailed level, too much levity would come across being flippant. Factor in the variable nature of what people find interesting, and my mate's version looks to be the far safer. But, in essays as in my pool game, I don't always choose the safe option ;-)
Now, what fascinates me about this approach is that's it's so simple. It really isn't that hard: you know (or should know) the structure of what you're writing about, and – despite your introduction – the reader doesn't know it as well as you, so why not help them out?
My only problem with the whole concept is that it detracts slightly from the flow of the piece somewhat. I guess that's kind of the point of the whole thing: you're taking a step back from the forest and saying, "See that clearing? That's where we are now. Next, we're going to wander down that path on our way to the waterfall I described at the start. Rightio, back into the thicket!" But that same process – by necessity – pulls you out of whatever little world you're in at the time. And it occurs to me that many of the essays I've written tend to have this sort of narrative thread to them, almost as though I'm telling some sort of story. I still have the same structural plan and verbal cues that lead the reader to the next elements, but usually they're contained within the text, pulling you along the road, rather than standing on the median strip wearing a fluorescent vest and giving directions via loudspeaker.
Now I don't know which I prefer. The explicit variation has the definite benefit that even the most obtuse reader will have trouble getting lost, and in the context of a professor marking a pile of essays, where mind-numbing routine can be considered a proxy for obtuseness, helpful fluoro markers are a definite plus. On the other hand, if you can create an essay that doesn't just convey information, but simultaneously captures the reader's interest and puts him in good humour, then his opinion of it will doubtlessly be positive.
I guess it depends on the topic, and perhaps also the length of the piece. Shorter bodies of work are easier to "style", as it were, but in longer essays, in which one also tends to operate on a more detailed level, too much levity would come across being flippant. Factor in the variable nature of what people find interesting, and my mate's version looks to be the far safer. But, in essays as in my pool game, I don't always choose the safe option ;-)

