Friday, September 11, 2009

The sustainability scale

You may have heard the term "sustainability" used with regards to economics or business lately. What you may not know is that there are several different levels of sustainability – a scale, if you will. The key question is what level of substitutability you are willing to accept between different forms of capital.

If we take the widely accepted definition of sustainability of "having the same (consumption) opportunities in the future as we do now",(1) we than have to ask ourselves: what does that mean? Do we want exactly the same opportunities as now, including the same mix of resources? Well, then we'd better not use up any resources that aren't renewable; or, more accurately, only use them up in the amount that they are renewable. This "strict" notion of sustainability implies that, if you have 20 acres of forest now, you should have 20 acres of forest tomorrow. Only the excess can be logged. May sounds alright, until you consider that the current rate of oil renewal is high enough to provide fuel for roughly 10 cars – worldwide.
At the other end of the scale is the attitude that "sustainability" means being able to replace pretty much all natural capital with built capital. For example, using all the oil is fine because by the time we do that we'll have invented cars that run on water and plastics made from algae and whatever. Instead of having trees to absorb carbon dioxide we'll invent giant sponges and shit. So all the bees have died – that's cool, robots will do the pollination and we can synthesise honey from maple syrup.
If that sounds like I'm taking the piss, well, who knows what the future holds... if we can replicate everything from anything like in Star Trek, would we really need an "environment"? Just raw matter would do.

So those are the two extreme ends of the scale. In the middle are positions like "only substitute natural capital stocks with other natural capital stocks e.g. it's alright to log forests because we're increasing the amount of marshland", or "only substitute built capital for natural capital when our basic needs are threatened." The current world attitude seems to be fairly on the weak side (replacing natural capital with man-made capital), but that may change. Or technological progress may save us all. Only time will tell.

(1) I'm paraphrasing the Brundtland Commission, and the definition debate is not one I want to get into.

No comments: