Saturday, August 08, 2009

What economists think about during late-night shopping

Twitter repost:
23:41– Longer retail shopping hours: a zero-sum game with first-mover advantage? Or can part of consumer rent be captured through price? #economics
23:42 – This is a longer queue than I was expecting at 11:40pm

This is a poorly-structured and incompletely thought-out extension of the above rumination. Maybe someday I'll fix it up and turn it into a first-year economics essay.

Let's assume that consumers and suppliers of retail foodstuffs – supermarkets – are in equilibrium, with "normal" opening hours, and that these opening hours are determined exogenously i.e. through government regulation.

Now let the possible range of these opening hours be extended, i.e. through regulatory change. What drives a supermarket to stay open for longer? Previously, customers have chose a supermarket based on a range of factors, two of which are the times it has open and their personal preference for when they shop. The store which most closely matches the time preference of the consumers will, ceteris paribus, receive the most patronage. BUT – this isn't discretionary consumption, it's necessities. So, all consumers visit some supermarket anyway, they would just prefer to do so at some other time: decreased utility.

So, with longer opening hours, the same set of consumers are able to spread their visits to more closely match their preferences. The first store to be open for longer will attract some customers from other chains who value being able to shop late over brand loyalty. However, this advantage vanishes if other stores also lengthen their opening hours – unless the market structure is such that it is only profitable for the first mover to extend their hours (because of the "stolen" customers from other stores), while second and later movers would simply be reclaiming their original customers at a loss.

Let's look at costs: longer opening hours mean higher factor costs (e.g. electricity), probably also in the area of wages: even if only the customer distribution (and not the quantity) changes, staff usually need to be paid more to work later hours.

What's the benefit? If all the stores do it, you're not going to win any customers. So there's two possibilities: either the customers are buying more, or you're charging them more for the same quantity.
Assuming that prices don't suddenly change during "late" hours to be higher than "normal" hours, this surcharge would affect all customers, all the time. Again assuming that all stores do this (so that we can concentrate on a single representative store), increasing prices will throw the market out of equilibrium.

We're left with those consumers who have a higher utility from being able to shop later. Given that the "normal" customer base won't buy or pay more, and no extra customers are being attracted from other stores, the increased costs stores have from staying open later must be covered by existing consumers shifting consumption from "normal" to "late" hours to match their personal preferences and, due to this increased utility, buying more. Hmmm... I like to shop late at night. Do I buy more at 11:30pm than I do at 11:30am? Not really...

However, one data point doth not a statistic make, as Shakespeare would have said if he'd taken econometrics. Whilst I have trouble believing the "it's more convenient for me to do my shopping at 11pm than 11am" crowd buy more simply out of joy at being able to shop when they want, I can well believe that there is an increase in patronage from impulse buying – or at least, buying from consumers who don't plan well enough to shop in advance.


I'm haven't really worked this out to my satisfaction, but my enthusiasm has been on the wane ever since I left the store. Time to call it quits.

No comments: