This is a response to "Litter or Gift?"
I too have ruminated on this topic, and came to the conclusion that, so long as the paper is left in good condition, I approve of the practice.
Newspapers are a quasi-public good (a club good, to use the Samuelsonian terminology), and once you have "consumed" the information in them it's beneficial to leave them for other people to also "consume", so long as you leave them in a state that doesn't reduce the use of a non-newspaper reader, i.e., torn bits of paper all over the seats.
Interestingly, I can't remember very many instances of up-market papers being left behind. It's usually the free rags (MX, or the London equivalent) or the tabloids (Herald Sun, BILD over here in Germany, I've forgotten what I found in England. Some rubbish). Since it's hardly likely that the readers of these publications have made the connection to social surplus and the readers of, say, the Financial Review haven't, I posit two reasons:
1) It takes longer to read quality papers, so people are unlikely to have finished them by the time they finish their commute.
2) People ascribe some value to their papers above and beyond their information. I.e. although they have read them, they still want to keep them. Hmmm, perhaps it's something to do with the endowment effect (things you possess are automatically worth more than things you don't possess, even if the items are identical).
Perhaps I'll look into this more... after exams!
I too have ruminated on this topic, and came to the conclusion that, so long as the paper is left in good condition, I approve of the practice.
Newspapers are a quasi-public good (a club good, to use the Samuelsonian terminology), and once you have "consumed" the information in them it's beneficial to leave them for other people to also "consume", so long as you leave them in a state that doesn't reduce the use of a non-newspaper reader, i.e., torn bits of paper all over the seats.
Interestingly, I can't remember very many instances of up-market papers being left behind. It's usually the free rags (MX, or the London equivalent) or the tabloids (Herald Sun, BILD over here in Germany, I've forgotten what I found in England. Some rubbish). Since it's hardly likely that the readers of these publications have made the connection to social surplus and the readers of, say, the Financial Review haven't, I posit two reasons:
1) It takes longer to read quality papers, so people are unlikely to have finished them by the time they finish their commute.
2) People ascribe some value to their papers above and beyond their information. I.e. although they have read them, they still want to keep them. Hmmm, perhaps it's something to do with the endowment effect (things you possess are automatically worth more than things you don't possess, even if the items are identical).
Perhaps I'll look into this more... after exams!

No comments:
Post a Comment