Went on a funny little musical journey last night. I was watching "The Talented Mr. Ripley", and came across this one song that I just felt I /knew/. I mean, the film is full of jazz songs that I recognised -- indeed, identifying background music is a secret little pleasure of mine, that sometimes even helps with plot comprehension: "You don't know what love is" in this film, for example -- but this song made me perk my ears up not because it was a new version of an old song, but (so I thought) a cover of a new song. Specifically the "Four (4x3)' by breakbeat/dance outfit Capoiera Twins.
Since that seemed rather unlikely, I sat intently through the credits to find: Miles Davis - Four (!)
I immediately hopped online to listen to the original, but was rather disappointed by it. Though I'd be a little embarrassed to admit it, it just sounded like a bunch of self indulgent soloing: I couldn't discern any structure at all.
Concerned that my self-view as something of a jazz aficionado had been merely a lie all these years (what's wrong Martin? Is the music too /jazzy/ for you? Can't /handle/ it? Maybe you should stick to your /big band/) I found another version (by Miles). This one had rather better production values, and I warmed to it a little more. Finally, I found the version from the film, by Guy Barker (and a bunch of other people). This version I liked, and you know why? I could hear the rhythm section! That was it! A strong bass, piano, and suddenly all that tootling and flibberdy bibbedybops made sense; had a structure to fit into; was accessible to me again.
So, I definitely learned something last night. Not just about obscure musical linkages (though that's fun, too), but about my own 'conditioning' from modern recordings as regards what I think jazz should sound like.
Now, that's not to defend bad recordings -- if you can't tell the soloist is soloing over /something/ for four minutes then it might as well just be atonal, self-indulgent crap -- but it means I'll know to listen a bit more intensely before dismissing (or rather, giving up on) a track.
See, it's alright if a track of music doesn't meet my standards. But I'd hate to think I didn't meet its.
Since that seemed rather unlikely, I sat intently through the credits to find: Miles Davis - Four (!)
I immediately hopped online to listen to the original, but was rather disappointed by it. Though I'd be a little embarrassed to admit it, it just sounded like a bunch of self indulgent soloing: I couldn't discern any structure at all.
Concerned that my self-view as something of a jazz aficionado had been merely a lie all these years (what's wrong Martin? Is the music too /jazzy/ for you? Can't /handle/ it? Maybe you should stick to your /big band/) I found another version (by Miles). This one had rather better production values, and I warmed to it a little more. Finally, I found the version from the film, by Guy Barker (and a bunch of other people). This version I liked, and you know why? I could hear the rhythm section! That was it! A strong bass, piano, and suddenly all that tootling and flibberdy bibbedybops made sense; had a structure to fit into; was accessible to me again.
So, I definitely learned something last night. Not just about obscure musical linkages (though that's fun, too), but about my own 'conditioning' from modern recordings as regards what I think jazz should sound like.
Now, that's not to defend bad recordings -- if you can't tell the soloist is soloing over /something/ for four minutes then it might as well just be atonal, self-indulgent crap -- but it means I'll know to listen a bit more intensely before dismissing (or rather, giving up on) a track.
See, it's alright if a track of music doesn't meet my standards. But I'd hate to think I didn't meet its.

No comments:
Post a Comment