Saturday, August 19, 2006

Political musings

I try and read quite a bit here - in Germany - firstly to improve my vocabulary, and secondly to fill in gaps in my knowledge about current issues in Germany. This isn't to say I read only newspapers: it's rare that you come across such elegant turns of phrases in them that you feel enriched by the experience - the focus is on the message more than the medium - so good literature is invaluable, but a newspaper is easier to read over breakfast. Plus, it has a sports page.

Anyway, recently I read a lengthy article about the state of the (global) environment, which in today's climate (boom boom) basically means global warming. Between that, and a conversation with Seb about politics (which you can trust was a worthwhile experience, because Seb knows an awful lot about stuff - including politics, which is his major - and I like to argue), I crystalised a relatively simple rationale behind my voting pattern for the foreseeable future.

It goes like this:
Q: What is the greatest threat facing mankind?
A: Climate change. Large carbon emissions from virtually all industrialised nations (both past and present)
=> global warming
=> melting glaciers
=> rising sea levels => loss of land
=> loss of water supply
=> warmer air => carries more water => more extreme rainfall => flooding
=> warmer oceans => greater frequency and severity of storms
=> more severe weather (see above) => droughts => reduction in crop yields => mass migration
=> eco-systems get out of whack
=> dying amazonian rainforest (b/c of lack of water) => release of carbon contained within the trees
=> thawing of permafrost => release of methane

("=>" means "leads to")

So - this stuff isn't short term, but probably shorter term than we'd like it to be. In the last hundred years the earth's average temperature increased by 0.8°C; in the next hundred, an increase of 6°C+ is expected. Bad Stuff (TM) has been happening faster than it was predicted to, so who's to say how accurate even the current worst-case scenarios are?

Now, I'm not just suddenly jumping on any environmental bandwagon here. Remember I'm talking about all of this in the context of choosing a politcal party to vote for. If you accept the assertion that the threats presented by global warming are greater than all others, then it's not hard to guess which party you'd want to vote for, is it? But I want to present a logical reasoning behind the decision anyway, because you can't just leave the ballot booth there.

If you accept that Issue A is the most important issue, you should vote for the party that is most likely to effect motion in the correct direction on this issue. If Issue A is the environment, is this the Green party? Probably. Note: I only say probably. This is because it's not just about having the right stance, but also being able to enforce it. If, to use an Australian example, the Greens suffered a Democratic-like implosion and ceased to be a significant political force, I might be swayed for voting for the larger party with the better political stance. Given the Liberals' position on the Kyoto protocol (I bashed my steering wheel in rage and frustration when I head Howard roll out the arguement that "We don't need to sign the Kyoto Protocol, because we're going to meet its targets anyway - and if we do sign it, countries who don't abide by it.." he meant China, but the US falls into the category, too ".. will steal our jobs by being cheaper"), it's not going to be them.

In Germany, the choice is pretty simple, because not only do the Greens have the 'best' (to my knowledge) position on the evironment, they're also a good chance to form Government (in Coalition). In Australia, like I've said, as long as they're a force I'd vote Greens. I believe it would take quite a significant reduction in the Green party's political capital before I'd consider not voting for them, because the best way to affect the centre parties is to yell loudly for a fringe position and settle for a compromise. Special interest groups do it all the time, and it's very effective.

This simple system of mine, which probably doesn't appear so simple any more after all that explanation, relies on the classification of global warming as the world's biggest threat. What if it weren't? For example, what about wars? Well, the Greens have a pretty good stance on wars (in my opinion), and in Germany are even in favour of peaceful deployment of the army, so I see no problem there. The economy? Mate, what does it matter if our economy is growing at 8% p.a. if we run out of drinkable water or fuel? Growth will die up pretty quickly then, I'll tell you that much. To put it less fatalistically: I can accept lower economic growth if the reason for that reduced growth is to improve, or minimise the damage to, the environment. Subsidies for dual-fuel cars for example, and that sort of guff. Other issues too, I feel, are secondary to climate change - or at least, the difference between 'best practice' and the $BestEnvironmentalParty$'s stance on these issues is not great enough to consider a change. This is a particularly tough argument to believe when healthcare/education/immigration/personal rights issues are on the table, but for the moment I feel certain that all parties have a reasonable enough stance on these that I can use environmental policy as the decider.a
Okay, here's a big problem: what if the climate change is natural? Or: what if the environment can & will correct itself. My answer to both these is: quite aside from a whole bunch of boffins (whom I believe) saying that's not so, the consequences of believing those arguments when they are wrong are much worse than the consequences of ignoring them when they are right.

Should any information come to me that alters any of the fundamental points in my system, I of course reserve the right to alter my position. As a student of economics, after all, I simply act rationally on the best information available to me. Thus, if anyone has any better information - or feels my chain of thought is flawed - I'll happily consider their feedback.

No comments: