I have a confession to make: I'm a "Grey's Anatomy" junkie.
Now, there's plenty of television shows I like (Lost, Scrubs, Prison Break et al), but,with the notable exception of The West Wing, none has so consistently succeeded in moving me emotionally.
I don't really know how to explain it -- and, for a while, was loath to admit it -- but there's episodes after which I come away with internal conflicts about the situations the characters are in/have gone through. Right now, after watching the finale of Season 3 for the second time, I've got Ingrid Michaelson's Myspace page open and am constantly hitting play on "Keep Breathing", the track that closes the episode.
It's brilliant writing, I've come to admit. It's not the rapid-fire topical genius of The West Wing; not the comic wackiness of Scrubs; not the sheer craftiness of Lost, where you can just take a step back and admire how they play with the audience; not the biting wit of House; not the offbeat, cult comedy stylings of The Fast Show or its ilk. It's simply damn well written and acted drama, and the way episodes like the finale (which I watched without knowing it was the last of the series) just manage to do so much -- with where the characters are, and where they're going -- and do it naturally, just leaves me amazed.
In that sense, I'd compare it to Buffy, since that was also a show whose characters captured me. I'm watching the middle seasons of that at the moment, too, but knowing (roughly) what happens later on significantly reduces the emotional investment this time around.
I'm going to say that Buffy never had this good of a soundtrack, though. Okay: they had live bands, and that goes a long way -- full respect for that. Oh, the musical episode, of course! But Grey's Anatomy consistently uses indie artists on their shows, including -- and this was the point that really cemented the whole thing for me -- "Step it Up" by the Australian deep funk outfit The Bamboos (one of the first few episodes in season 3). Between them, Tegan & Sara, Snow Patrol, 78 Saab (!), KT Tunstall, Ben Lee, Kraak & Smaak, Regina Spektor, and now Ingrid Michaelson, I'm tempted to call Grey's Anatomy the best source of music outside of Triple J *grins*
I said that I watched this was the second time I've watched this episode; I'll probably watch it again. I'm kind of glad I didn't stumble upon the Grey's Anatomy Writers' Blog, or I'd have lost a lot of time to that over the course of the year. On the plus side, it is a great way of spending more time on the show without having to step out of the make-believe TV universe and start reading about fights between cast members, who's gay, who's leaving the show, and rubbish like that. Stuff like that just spoils the enjoyment of the show, in my opinion.
But then, I'm just a medical drama junkie -- what would I know?
